AbstractWe assess whether a supervised machine learning algorithm, specifically a convolutional neural network (CNN), achieves higher accuracy on planktonic image classification when including non‐plankton and ancillary plankton during the training procedure. We focus on the case of optimizing the CNN for a single planktonic image source, while considering ancillary images to be plankton images from other instruments. We conducted two sets of experiments with three different types of plankton images (from a Zooglider, Underwater Vision Profiler 5, and Zooscan), and our results held across all three image types. First, we considered whether single‐stage transfer learning using non‐plankton images was beneficial. For this assessment, we used ImageNet images and the 2015 ImageNet contest‐winning model, ResNet‐152. We found increased accuracy using a ResNet‐152 model pretrained on ImageNet, provided the entire network was retrained rather than retraining only the fully connected layers. Next, we combined all three plankton image types into a single dataset with 3.3 million images (despite their differences in contrast, resolution, and pixel pitch) and conducted a multistage transfer learning assessment. We executed a transfer learning stage from ImageNet to the merged ancillary plankton dataset, then a second transfer learning stage from that merged plankton model to a single instrument dataset. We found that multistage transfer learning resulted in additional accuracy gains. These results should have generality for other image classification tasks.