(ProQuest Information and Learning: ... denotes non-USASCII text omitted.) A Spirituality of Perfection. Faith in Action in Letter of by Patrick J. Hartin. Collegeville, MN: Liturgical Press, 1999. Pp. viii + 192. $17.95. Has God Not Chosen Poor? Social Setting of Epistle of by David Hutchinson Edgar. JSNTSup 206. Sheffield: Sheffield Academic Press, 2001. Pp. 261. $64. Logos and Law in Letter of James: Law of Nature, Law of Moses, and Law of Freedom, by Matt A. Jackson-McCabe. NovTSup 100. Leiden: Brill, 2001. Pp. xvi + 286. $102. Whereas only a few monographs on epistle of appeared in sixties, seventies, and eighties, situation has radically changed in last decade. At same time, focus has shifted. Instead of traditional concentration on 2:14-26 and on comparison with Paul, perspective has opened up considerably, and individual theological significance of and its themes has been more strongly recognized. In opposition to classical, derogatory assessment of Martin Luther, has therefore undergone a thorough rehabilitation most recently. In present review, three newly published monographs documenting these new interests will be presented. Subsequent to publishing his and Q Sayings of Jesus (JSNTSup 47; Sheffield: Sheffield Academic Press, 1991) and a number of articles, Patrick Hartin has contributed another monograph, A Spirituality of Perfection, in which he draws a comprehensive picture of his understanding of epistle and simultaneously attempts to unfold meaning of for today (ch. 7: On Reading Today, pp. 149-69). Hartin belongs to those scholars who emphasize close connection of epistle with Jesus tradition. In this new monograph, his primary intention is portraying how James's concept of perfection operates as a unifying theme by giving meaning to other themes developed throughout letter (p. 10). Additionally, Hartin postulates close resemblances between and Jesus tradition as it is handed down in Gospel of Matthew, especially in Matthean Sermon on Mount. Prior to analyzing Jacobean concept of perfection, Hartin offers An Overview of Concept of Perfection in Ancient World as a Background to Letter of James (ch. 2, pp. 17-39), in which he presents concept of perfection in classical Greek world, Hebrew Scriptures and Septuagint, Second Temple Judaism, and NT. In his opinion, OT concept of perfection serves as main background for James's perception. Hartin discerns three essential aspects here: (1) the idea of wholeness, or completeness, whereby a being remains true to its original constitution (p. 26); (2) wholehearted dedication to Lord; and (3) obedience to Torah. As a second preliminary step to analysis of idea of perfection in Hartin gives attention to nature or genre of this writing (ch. 3: The Nature and Purpose of Letter of James, pp. 41-56). Hartin follows others in categorizing epistle as a piece of wisdom literature, but defines writing more precisely as discourse, which he distinguishes from paraenesis, for example, by its more strongly argumentative character in comparison with paraenetic collection of loosely connected exhortations. With this last classification, Hartin joins new magnus consensus of scholarship, insofar as Dibelian view of epistle as a loose collection of sayings without any situational reference has generally been surmounted, although Hartin's definitions of paraenesis and protreptic discourse are questionable. Moreover, Moreover, since wisdom classification of epistle is a highly disputed matter in recent scholarship on letter, an essential critical point is missed, because Hartin does not engage in intensive discussion with opposing position. …
Read full abstract