The O-acyl-ω-hydroxy fatty acids (OAHFAs) are an intriguing class of surface-active lipids which can be found in the human tear film lipid layer (TFLL). Recent studies have suggested that OAHFAs exist in the polar lipid layer and play a central role in TFLL function. Surprisingly, biophysical profiling studies have only shed light on the properties of OAHFAs bearing an oleate acyl group and insights on species with other acyl groups are scarce. Herein, we seek to address this issue through (1) focusing on the synthesis and characterization of a representative library of OAHFA analogues bearing a palmitate, palmitoleate, stearate, and linoleate acyl group, and (2) performing an in-depth mapping of their biophysical properties. Our results indicate that NMR-spectroscopic techniques can be utilized for rough estimation of the amounts of distinct acyl groups in a sample and more importantly, how the subtle variations in both parent chains and acyl groups influence the core properties of the OAHFAs. We reach the conclusion that the correlation between melting points and film properties is not as clear-cut as previously thought. Nevertheless, grouping of OAHFA species into three separate categories which display distinct behavior seems to be possible utilizing the melting points as a guiding parameter. Altogether, our study suggests that the properties of OAHFAs need to be assessed from a viewpoint which combines both the parent chain and acyl group instead of independent analysis based on either fragment alone.