Therapeutically popular controlled release-enabling technology has forayed into the nutrition sector. Polymer coated forms of L-methionine used in soy protein diets, and its intermediate metabolite, S-adenosyl-L-methionine, used in myriad of medical conditions have proved more efficacious over (highly catabolized) free forms. In this premier study, L-methionine-loaded chitosan nanoparticles (M-NPs) were synthesized using ionic gelation method and their efficacy was evaluated. Biophysical characterization of the NPs was done using a Nanopartica SZ 100 analyser, transmission electron microscopy, and Fourier transform infrared spectroscopy. The M-NPs were spherical and smooth and 218.9 ± 7.4 nm in size and in vitro testing confirmed the controlled release of methionine. A 60-days feeding trial in L. rohita fish fingerlings was conducted. A basal diet suboptimal (0.85%) in methionine was provided with one of the supplements as under: none (control), 0.8% chitosan NPs (0.8% NPs), 1.2% L-methionine (1.2% M) (crystalline free form), 0.6% M-NPs and 1.2% M-NPs. While the addition of 0.6% M-NPs to the basal diet complemented towards meeting the established dietary requirement and resulted in significantly highest (P < 0.05) growth and protein efficiency and sero-immunological test scores (serum total protein, serum globulin, serum albumin: globulin ratio, phagocytic respiratory burst/NBT reduction and lysozyme activity), 1.2% supplementation in either form (free or nano), for being 0.85% excess, was counterproductive. Liver transaminases and dehydrogenases corroborated enhanced growth. It was inferred that part of the methionine requirement in nano form (M-NPs) can confer intended performance and health benefits in animals relying on plant proteins-based diets limiting in this essential amino acid. The study also paves the way for exploring chitosan NPs-based sustained delivery of amino acids in human medical conditions.