HTTP Adaptive Streaming Players Research Articles

ARARAT: A Collaborative Edge-Assisted Framework for HTTP Adaptive Video Streaming

With the ever-increasing demands for high-definition and low-latency video streaming applications, network-assisted video streaming schemes have become a promising complementary solution in the HTTP Adaptive Streaming (HAS) context to improve users’ Quality of Experience (QoE) as well as network utilization. Edge computing is considered one of the leading networking paradigms for designing such systems by providing video processing and caching close to the end-users. Despite the wide usage of this technology, designing network-assisted HAS architectures that support low-latency and high-quality video streaming, including edge collaboration is still a challenge. To address these issues, this article leverages the Software-Defined Networking (SDN), Network Function Virtualization (NFV), and edge computing paradigms to propose A collaboRative edge-Assisted framewoRk for HTTP Adaptive video sTreaming (ARARAT). Aiming at minimizing HAS clients’ serving time and network cost, besides considering available resources and all possible serving actions, we design a multi-layer architecture and formulate the problem as a centralized optimization model executed by the SDN controller. However, to cope with the high time complexity of the centralized model, we introduce three heuristic approaches that produce near-optimal solutions through efficient collaboration between the SDN controller and edge servers. Finally, we implement the ARARAT framework, conduct our experiments on a large-scale cloud-based testbed including 250 HAS players, and compare its effectiveness with state-of-the-art systems within comprehensive scenarios. The experimental results illustrate that the proposed ARARAT methods (i) improve users’ QoE by at least 47%, (ii) decrease the streaming cost, including bandwidth and computational costs, by at least 47%, and (iii) enhance network utilization, by at least 48% compared to state-of-the-art approaches.

Game of Streaming Players

The dramatic growth of HTTP adaptive streaming (HAS) traffic represents a practical challenge for service providers in satisfying the demand from their customers. Achieving this in a network where multiple players share the network capacity has so far proved hard because of the bandwidth competition among the HAS players. This competition is exacerbated by the bandwidth overestimation that is introduced due to the isolated and selfish behavior of the HAS players. Each player strives individually to select the maximum bitrate without considering the co-existing players or network resource dynamics. As a result, the HAS players suffer from video quality instability, quality unfairness, and network underutilization or oversubscription, and the players observe a poor quality of experience (QoE). To address this issue, we propose a fully distributed game theory and consensus-based collaborative adaptive bitrate solution for shared network environments, termed Game Theory and consensus-based Approach for Cooperative HAS delivery systems (GTAC). Our solution consists of two-stage games that run in parallel during a streaming session. We extensively evaluate GTAC on a broad set of trace-driven and real-world experiments. Results show that GTAC enhances the viewer QoE by up to 22%, presentation quality stability by up to 24%, fairness by at least 31%, and network utilization by 28% compared to the well-known schemes.

ORL-SDN

In designing an HTTP adaptive streaming (HAS) system, the bitrate adaptation scheme in the player is a key component to ensure a good quality of experience (QoE) for viewers. We propose a new online reinforcement learning optimization framework, called ORL-SDN, targeting HAS players running in a software-defined networking (SDN) environment. We leverage SDN to facilitate the orchestration of the adaptation schemes for a set of HAS players. To reach a good level of QoE fairness in a large population of players, we cluster them based on a perceptual quality index. We formulate the adaptation process as a Partially Observable Markov Decision Process and solve the per-cluster optimization problem using an online Q-learning technique that leverages model predictive control and parallelism via aggregation to avoid a per-cluster suboptimal selection and to accelerate the convergence to an optimum. This framework achieves maximum long-term revenue by selecting the optimal representation for each cluster under time-varying network conditions. The results show that ORL-SDN delivers substantial improvements in viewer QoE, presentation quality stability, fairness, and bandwidth utilization over well-known adaptation schemes.

Performance evaluation of TcpHas: TCP for HTTP adaptive streaming

HTTP adaptive streaming (HAS) is a widely used video streaming technology that suffers from a degradation of user’s Quality of Experience (QoE) and network’s Quality of Service (QoS) when many HAS players are sharing the same bottleneck link and competing for bandwidth. The two major factors of this degradation are: the large OFF period of HAS, which causes false bandwidth estimations, and the TCP congestion control, which is not suitable for HAS given that it does not consider the different video encoding bitrates of HAS. This paper proposes a HAS-based TCP congestion control, TcpHas, that minimizes the impact of the two aforementioned issues. It does this using traffic shaping on the server. Simulations indicate that TcpHas improves both QoE, mainly by reducing instability and convergence speed, and QoS, mainly by reducing queuing delay and packet drop rate.

Network-Based Video Quality Assessment for Encrypted HTTP Adaptive Streaming

End-to-end encryption brings new challenges for mobile network operators to obtain key quality indicators (KQIs) of the HTTP adaptive streaming (HAS), which are vital for quality of experience (QoE) of the end users. Targeting on this issue, this paper proposes a network-based solution to extract KQI-related features from encrypted traffic; then, the video quality is assessed through machine-learning-based methods. First, content-independent features are extracted resorting to traffic characteristics and a typical HAS player model. Then, back-propagation neural network and random forest are applied to evaluate stalling and estimate initial buffering delay, which are known as the most important KQIs for QoE. In addition, to evaluate the performance of our solution, we construct a data acquisition platform, and 4733 encrypted video sessions are collected from YouTube by crowdsourcing. Experiment results show that the proposed solution outperforms the previous methods, where initial buffering delay is effectively estimated with an absolute error less than 1 s for up to 80% videos, and the accuracy of stalling detection reaches 88.5%.

Experimental evaluation of the impact of mobility management protocols on HTTP adaptive streaming

Video content is increasingly being consumed on the move using mobile devices such as smartphones and tablets. In order to deal with the challenges of heterogeneity of network access technologies and fluctuating resources, which are inherent features of mobile communication, HTTP adaptive streaming (HAS) is becoming the default technology for online video streaming. However, little research has been carried out to better understand the impact of handover schemes of the various mobility management protocols on the video quality of HAS. In this study, the authors present a comprehensive experimental measurement of the impact of handover on three representative HAS players. First, they implement three existing mobility management protocols, MIPv6, LISP-MN and PMIPv6, on a network testbed. Using the fluid flow mobility model, the impact of frequent handover on the average video quality, the bandwidth utilisation and stability of the players was investigated. Their results show a degradation of all the observed parameters in all the reviewed players.

SDNHAS: An SDN-Enabled Architecture to Optimize QoE in HTTP Adaptive Streaming

HTTP adaptive streaming (HAS) is receiving much attention from both industry and academia as it has become the de facto approach to stream media content over the Internet. Recently, we proposed a streaming architecture called SDNDASH [1] to address HAS scalability issues including video instability, quality of experience (QoE) unfairness, and network resource underutilization, while maximizing per player QoE. While SDNDASH was a significant step forward, there were three unresolved limitations: 1) it did not scale well when the number of HAS players increased; 2) it generated communication overhead; and 3) it did not address client heterogeneity. These limitations could result in suboptimal decisions that led to viewer dissatisfaction. To that effect, we propose an enhanced intelligent streaming architecture, called SDNHAS, which leverages software defined networking (SDN) capabilities of assisting HAS players in making better adaptation decisions. This architecture accommodates large-scale deployments through a cluster-based mechanism, reduces communication overhead between the HAS players and SDN core, and allocates the network resources effectively in the presence of short- and long-term changes in the network.

Early Detection of QoE Deterioration in HTTP Adaptive Streaming

Apart from video rate (or requested bitrate), Mean Opinion Score (MOS) has increasingly become a primary term representing Quality of Experience (QoE) in HTTP adaptive streaming (HAS). By monitoring this metric, QoE management can effectively maximize QoE for the users. However, due to various behaviors of particular commercial HAS players, deciding an appropriate monitoring interval has not been fully investigated yet. In this paper, an optimal interval is proposed to be equal to duration of a video chunk in order to aid service managers in early detecting QoE deterioration and limiting the probability of video rate deterioration. The optimal monitoring interval is evaluated by comparing with other values of interval in terms of ratio of video rate deterioration. Furthermore, MOS-based QoE monitoring method which takes into account the proposed interval is thus compared with video rate based monitoring method. The results show that with optimal interval, MOS monitoring guarantees a low ratio of video rate deterioration (around 10% for buffering state and 40% for steady state) and small average CPU Load (about 11.45%).

HTTP 적응적 스트리밍을 위한 TCP 인지형 세그먼트 스케줄링 기법

HTTP Adaptive Streaming (HAS) is a technique that adapts its video quality to network conditions for providing Quality of Experience. In the HAS approach, a video content is encoded at multiple bitrates and the encoded video content is divided into several video segments. A HAS player estimates the network bandwidth and adjusts the video bitrate based on estimated bandwidth. However, the segment scheduler in the conventional HAS player requests video segments periodically without considering TCP. If the waiting duration for the next segment request is quite long, the TCP connection can be initialized and it restarts slow-start. Slow-start causes the reduction in TCP throughput and consequentially leads to low-quality video streaming. In this study, we propose a TCP-aware segment scheduling scheme to improve performance of HAS service. The proposed scheme adjusts request time for the next video request to prevent initialization of TCP connection and also considers the point of scheduling time. The simulation proves that our scheme improves the Quality of Service of the HAS service without buffer underflow issue.

A model for evaluating sharing policies for network-assisted HTTP adaptive streaming

HTTP adaptive streaming (HAS) has become the dominant technology for streaming video over the Internet. It gained popularity because of its ability to adapt the video quality to the current network conditions and other appealing properties such as usage of off-the-shelf HTTP servers and easy firewall traversal. However, when multiple HAS players share a bottleneck link for streaming, the individual adaptation techniques in the players have difficulties to maintain a stable bitrate and fairly share the network resources. HAS-assisting network elements can solve these performance problems and allow execution of advanced policies for sharing the available bandwidth. Nonetheless, testing and evaluating new sharing policies is costly and time consuming. This motivated us to formulate a model that allows to differentiate between groups of users depending on the type of user or device, and that can describe the mean bitrate of the video streams and how often this bitrate is expected to change during playout. To show how our model can be used, we demonstrate two applications of our model. Furthermore, we validate the model based results against results obtained using our streaming testbed and proxy server based HAS-assistant. The results show that our model is highly accurate for both the mean bitrate and the number of changes in video bitrate. As such, our model is a useful tool for network administrators and internet service providers for evaluating the performance of sharing policies and for managing and provisioning video delivery networks.