Bacterial bloodstream infections result from evasion of the host innate immune system and stable colonization following an initial inoculation event from either an internal or external source. Capsule polysaccharides play a protective role for Serratia marcescens during bacteremia but there is abundant genetic diversity at the capsule-encoding locus within the species. This study compares the infection characteristics of S. marcescens isolates belonging to five different capsule types and defines the contributions to infection fitness for each type. By characterizing the differences in capsule dependence and infection potential between S. marcescens strains, efforts to combat these life-threatening infections can be focused toward identifying strategies that target the most critical genetic lineages of this important opportunistic pathogen.