Reviewed by: Hold Back the Tide by Melinda Salisbury April Spisak Salisbury, Melinda Hold Back the Tide. Scholastic, 2021 [336p] Trade ed. ISBN 9781338681307 $18.99 E-book ed. ISBN 9781338681314 $11.99 Reviewed from digital galleys R Gr. 8-10 Alva, sixteen, has tiptoed around her father for years, since she is certain he murdered her mother. She has plans to finally escape him and their small Scottish town, but just as she's finalizing her details, a series of horrifying attacks draws her back in. Her father's role as caretaker of a loch suddenly becomes far more important than Alva ever realized, as one key part of that job is to make sure the water level stays high enough to keep monsters trapped underground. Overuse of the mill means that these creatures are now free, and they behave according to their nature, which is to kill some humans and transform others into their kind. Alva can't leave now, so she becomes a hero she never believed she could be, rousing the town to courage and putting herself at risk to save others. One key catalyst in her own growth is a new understanding about her father, a brutal moment of clarity about what he was actually doing all those years ago, given even more pathos by the fact that one of them only has a few more days to live so there is no chance for true reconciliation. The story is well told and the pace is impeccable, but the true beauty here lies in Salisbury's subtle, nuanced ways of highlighting the classic notion that monstrosity is not limited to monsters. [End Page 275] Copyright © 2021 The Board of Trustees of the University of Illinois
Read full abstract