(1) Background: We aim to examine and improve phosphate prescribing as part of a quality assurance program by examining the change in the proportion of patients receiving phosphate with normal or high preceding serum phosphate concentrations before and after the introduction of the 24 h time limit to default phosphate prescription. (2) Methods: This was a quality assurance study conducted across three Australian adult intensive care units (ICUs). All adult patients with ICU lengths of stay greater than or equal to 48 h who had their serum phosphate concentrations measured were included. A 24 h time limit was introduced to the protocolised prescription in the electronic clinical information system for enteral and intravenous phosphate at participating ICUs. Patient characteristics, phosphate administration, and outcomes were compared before and after this time limit was introduced. The primary outcome was the proportion of patients to whom phosphate was prescribed after measurement of a normal or high serum phosphate level. Secondary outcomes were ICU length of stay, mortality, and discharge destination. (3) Results: A total of 1192 patients were included from three ICUs over the two periods. The proportion of patients with a normal or high measured phosphate level who then received phosphate supplementation was significantly lower in the second study period (30.3% vs. 9.9%; p < 0.001). This difference persisted when adjusted for potential confounders in a mixed-effects logistic regression model (an adjusted odds ratio for receiving phosphate with normal or high serum concentration 0.214, 95% confidence interval of 0.132-0.347; p < 0.001). No significant difference was seen in the typical ICU length of stay, in-hospital case-fatality rate, and hospital discharge destination between these groups. (4) Conclusions: This multicentre before-after study has demonstrated that the introduction of a 24 h limit on electronic phosphate prescriptions resulted in significantly fewer patients receiving phosphate when their serum phosphate concentration was normal or high, without any adverse impact on patient outcomes.