This study evaluated the impact of care pathways on the incidence of local recurrence (LR) in patients with soft tissue sarcomas (STS) and identified factors predictive of LR. It compared outcomes between patients managed entirely within a comprehensive care pathway (CCP) at the Swiss Sarcoma Network (SSN) and those who experienced fragmented care pathways (FCPs), where initial treatment occurred outside specialized centers. This prospective study utilized real-world-time data from the SSN-Sarconnector, capturing quality indicators through weekly Multidisciplinary Team/Sarcoma-Board (MDT/SB) meetings. The overall incidence of LR was 17.6% (n = 68/386), higher than rates typically reported in sarcoma center-based studies due to the inclusion of patients with prior inadequate management from real-world referrals. In a univariable logistic regression analysis, the FCP was significantly associated with higher LR rates, unplanned “whoops” resections (25.4%, n = 96), and positive surgical margins, emphasizing the detrimental impact of suboptimal initial management outside of specialized centers. Multivariable analysis confirmed that the FCP (aOR 2.7, 95% CI [1.41, 5.12], p = 0.003), tumor size (aOR 1.49, 95% CI [1.1, 2.02], p = 0.01), and biological behavior (aOR 5.84 95% CI [1.8, 18.86], p = 0.0003) are independent predictors of LR. Notably, patients referred to sarcoma centers after an initial FCP presented with inadequately managed disease, such as incomplete resections and unplanned surgeries, leading to increased complexity of subsequent treatments. These findings underscore the critical role of referral patterns on sarcoma center outcomes, highlighting the significant disparity in LR rates between institutions. The need for improved education and standardized early referral strategies at the spoke level is paramount to optimize patient outcomes and reduce the burden of LR. Enhanced spoke-level education and standardized referral protocols are critical to ensuring effective initial management and optimizing patient outcomes within specialized sarcoma networks like the SSN.