Higher-order Repeat Structures Research Articles

Molecular evolution of the mammalian kinetochore complex.

Mammalian centromeres are satellite-rich chromatin domains that serve as sites for kinetochore complex assembly. Centromeres are highly variable in sequence and satellite organization across species, but the processes that govern the co-evolutionary dynamics between rapidly evolving centromeres and their associated kinetochore proteins remain poorly understood. Here, we pursue a course of phylogenetic analyses to investigate the molecular evolution of the complete kinetochore complex across primate and rodent species with divergent centromere repeat sequences and features. We show that many protein components of the core centromere associated network (CCAN) harbor signals of adaptive evolution, consistent with their intimate association with centromere satellite DNA and roles in the stability and recruitment of additional kinetochore proteins. Surprisingly, CCAN and outer kinetochore proteins exhibit comparable rates of adaptive divergence, suggesting that changes in centromere DNA can ripple across the kinetochore to drive adaptive protein evolution within distant domains of the complex. Our work further identifies kinetochore proteins subject to lineage-specific adaptive evolution, including rapidly evolving proteins in species with centromere satellites characterized by higher-order repeat structure and lacking CENP-B boxes. Thus, features of centromeric chromatin beyond the linear DNA sequence may drive selection on kinetochore proteins. Overall, our work spotlights adaptively evolving proteins with diverse centromere-associated functions, including centromere chromatin structure, kinetochore protein assembly, kinetochore-microtubule association, cohesion maintenance, and DNA damage response pathways. These adaptively evolving kinetochore protein candidates present compelling opportunities for future functional investigations exploring how their concerted changes with centromere DNA ensure the maintenance of genome stability.

Higher-order organisation of extremely amplified, potentially functional and massively methylated 5S rDNA in European pikes (Esox sp.)

BackgroundPikes represent an important genus (Esox) harbouring a pre-duplication karyotype (2n = 2x = 50) of economically important salmonid pseudopolyploids. Here, we have characterized the 5S ribosomal RNA genes (rDNA) in Esox lucius and its closely related E. cisalpinus using cytogenetic, molecular and genomic approaches. Intragenomic homogeneity and copy number estimation was carried out using Illumina reads. The higher-order structure of rDNA arrays was investigated by the analysis of long PacBio reads. Position of loci on chromosomes was determined by FISH. DNA methylation was analysed by methylation-sensitive restriction enzymes.ResultsThe 5S rDNA loci occupy exclusively (peri)centromeric regions on 30–38 acrocentric chromosomes in both E. lucius and E. cisalpinus. The large number of loci is accompanied by extreme amplification of genes (>20,000 copies), which is to the best of our knowledge one of the highest copy number of rRNA genes in animals ever reported. Conserved secondary structures of predicted 5S rRNAs indicate that most of the amplified genes are potentially functional. Only few SNPs were found in genic regions indicating their high homogeneity while intergenic spacers were more heterogeneous and several families were identified. Analysis of 10–30 kb-long molecules sequenced by the PacBio technology (containing about 40% of total 5S rDNA) revealed that the vast majority (96%) of genes are organised in large several kilobase-long blocks. Dispersed genes or short tandems were less common (4%). The adjacent 5S blocks were directly linked, separated by intervening DNA and even inverted. The 5S units differing in the intergenic spacers formed both homogeneous and heterogeneous (mixed) blocks indicating variable degree of homogenisation between the loci. Both E. lucius and E. cisalpinus 5S rDNA was heavily methylated at CG dinucleotides.ConclusionsExtreme amplification of 5S rRNA genes in the Esox genome occurred in the absence of significant pseudogenisation suggesting its recent origin and/or intensive homogenisation processes. The dense methylation of units indicates that powerful epigenetic mechanisms have evolved in this group of fish to silence amplified genes. We discuss how the higher-order repeat structures impact on homogenisation of 5S rDNA in the genome.

Formation of functional CENP-B boxes at diverse locations in repeat units of centromeric DNA in New World monkeys

Centromere protein B, which is involved in centromere formation, binds to centromeric repetitive DNA by recognizing a nucleotide motif called the CENP-B box. Humans have large numbers of CENP-B boxes in the centromeric repetitive DNA of their autosomes and X chromosome. The current understanding is that these CENP-B boxes are located at identical positions in the repeat units of centromeric DNA. Great apes also have CENP-B boxes in locations that are identical to humans. The purpose of the present study was to examine the location of CENP-B box in New World monkeys. We recently identified CENP-B box in one species of New World monkeys (marmosets). In this study, we found functional CENP-B boxes in CENP-A-assembled repeat units of centromeric DNA in 2 additional New World monkeys (squirrel monkeys and tamarins) by immunostaining and ChIP-qPCR analyses. The locations of the 3 CENP-B boxes in the repeat units differed from one another. The repeat unit size of centromeric DNA of New World monkeys (340–350 bp) is approximately twice that of humans and great apes (171 bp). This might be, associated with higher-order repeat structures of centromeric DNA, a factor for the observed variation in the CENP-B box location in New World monkeys.

Higher-order repeat structure in alpha satellite DNA occurs in New World monkeys and is not confined to hominoids.

Centromeres usually contain large amounts of tandem repeat DNA. Alpha satellite DNA (AS) is the most abundant tandem repeat DNA found in the centromeres of simian primates. The AS of humans contains sequences organized into higher-order repeat (HOR) structures, which are tandem arrays of larger repeat units consisting of multiple basic repeat units. HOR-carrying AS also occurs in other hominoids, but results reported to date for phylogenetically more remote taxa have been negative. Here we show direct evidence for clear HOR structures in AS of the owl monkey and common marmoset. These monkeys are New World monkey species that are located phylogenetically outside of hominoids. It is currently postulated that the presence of HOR structures in AS is unique to hominoids. Our results suggest that this view must be modified. A plausible explanation is that generation of HOR structures is a general event that occurs occasionally or frequently in primate centromeres, and that, in humans, HOR-carrying AS became predominant in the central region of the centromere. It is often difficult to assemble sequence reads of tandem repeat DNAs into accurate contig sequences; our careful sequencing strategy allowed us to overcome this problem.

Higher-order repeat structure in alpha satellite DNA is an attribute of hominoids rather than hominids

Alpha satellite DNA (AS), a major DNA component of primate centromeres, is composed of a tandem array of repeat units of approximately 170 bp. The AS of hominids (family Hominidae; humans and great apes) includes sequences organized into higher-order repeat (HOR) structures, with a periodic appearance of multiple copies of the basic repeat units. Here, we identified an HOR in AS of the siamang, a small ape phylogenetically distinct from hominids but included in hominoids (superfamily Hominoidea). We sequenced long stretches of genomic DNA, and found a repetition of blocks consisting of six and four basic repeat units. Thus, AS organization into HOR is an attribute of hominoids, rather than, as currently postulated, hominids. In addition to centromeres, siamangs carry AS in terminal heterochromatin blocks, and it cannot be determined at present whether these HOR-containing AS sequences originate from the centromere or from the terminal heterochromatin. Even if the latter is the case, these sequences might affect the composition of centromeric AS by being transferred to the centromere.

Identification and characterization of functional centromeres of the common bean

In higher eukaryotes, centromeres are typically composed of megabase-sized arrays of satellite repeats that evolve rapidly and homogenize within a species' genome. Despite the importance of centromeres, our knowledge is limited to a few model species. We conducted a comprehensive analysis of common bean (Phaseolus vulgaris) centromeric satellite DNA using genomic data, fluorescence in situ hybridization (FISH), immunofluorescence and chromatin immunoprecipitation (ChIP). Two unrelated centromere-specific satellite repeats, CentPv1 and CentPv2, and the common bean centromere-specific histone H3 (PvCENH3) were identified. FISH showed that CentPv1 and CentPv2 are predominantly located at subsets of eight and three centromeres, respectively. Immunofluorescence- and ChIP-based assays demonstrated the functional significance of CentPv1 and CentPv2 at centromeres. Genomic analysis revealed several interesting features of CentPv1 and CentPv2: (i) CentPv1 is organized into an higher-order repeat structure, named Nazca, of 528bp, whereas CentPv2 is composed of tandemly organized monomers; (ii) CentPv1 and CentPv2 have undergone chromosome-specific homogenization; and (iii) CentPv1 and CentPv2 are not likely to be commingled in the genome. These findings suggest that two distinct sets of centromere sequences have evolved independently within the common bean genome, and provide insight into centromere satellite evolution.

Genome-wide characterization of centromeric satellites from multiple mammalian genomes

Despite its importance in cell biology and evolution, the centromere has remained the final frontier in genome assembly and annotation due to its complex repeat structure. However, isolation and characterization of the centromeric repeats from newly sequenced species are necessary for a complete understanding of genome evolution and function. In recent years, various genomes have been sequenced, but the characterization of the corresponding centromeric DNA has lagged behind. Here, we present a computational method (RepeatNet) to systematically identify higher-order repeat structures from unassembled whole-genome shotgun sequence and test whether these sequence elements correspond to functional centromeric sequences. We analyzed genome datasets from six species of mammals representing the diversity of the mammalian lineage, namely, horse, dog, elephant, armadillo, opossum, and platypus. We define candidate monomer satellite repeats and demonstrate centromeric localization for five of the six genomes. Our analysis revealed the greatest diversity of centromeric sequences in horse and dog in contrast to elephant and armadillo, which showed high-centromeric sequence homogeneity. We could not isolate centromeric sequences within the platypus genome, suggesting that centromeres in platypus are not enriched in satellite DNA. Our method can be applied to the characterization of thousands of other vertebrate genomes anticipated for sequencing in the near future, providing an important tool for annotation of centromeres.

New Insights into Centromere Organization and Evolution from the White-Cheeked Gibbon and Marmoset

The evolutionary history of alpha-satellite DNA, the major component of primate centromeres, is hardly defined because of the difficulty in its sequence assembly and its rapid evolution when compared with most genomic sequences. By using several approaches, we have cloned, sequenced, and characterized alpha-satellite sequences from two species representing critical nodes in the primate phylogeny: the white-cheeked gibbon, a lesser ape, and marmoset, a New World monkey. Sequence analyses demonstrate that white-cheeked gibbon and marmoset alpha-satellite sequences are formed by units of approximately 171 and approximately 342 bp, respectively, and they both lack the high-order structure found in humans and great apes. Fluorescent in situ hybridization characterization shows a broad dispersal of alpha-satellite in the white-cheeked gibbon genome including centromeric, telomeric, and chromosomal interstitial localizations. On the other hand, centromeres in marmoset appear organized in highly divergent dimers roughly of 342 bp that show a similarity between monomers much lower than previously reported dimers, thus representing an ancient dimeric structure. All these data shed light on the evolution of the centromeric sequences in Primates. Our results suggest radical differences in the structure, organization, and evolution of alpha-satellite DNA among different primate species, supporting the notion that 1) all the centromeric sequence in Primates evolved by genomic amplification, unequal crossover, and sequence homogenization using a 171 bp monomer as the basic seeding unit and 2) centromeric function is linked to relatively short repeated elements, more than higher-order structure. Moreover, our data indicate that complex higher-order repeat structures are a peculiarity of the hominid lineage, showing the more complex organization in humans.

Concerted evolution and higher-order repeat structure of the 1.709 (satellite IV) family in bovids.

The 1.709 or satellite IV repeated DNA family originally isolated from the domestic cow was analyzed using Southern blotting, pulsed field gel electrophoresis, fluorescence in situ hybridization, and DNA sequencing in species belonging to the genera Bos, Bison, Bubalus, Syncerus, Boselaphus, and Tragelaphus. Hybridization indicates that the family has been amplified in Bos, Bison, Bubalus, and Syncerus but not in Boselaphus or Tragelaphus. Pericentromeric, higher-order repeat substructure exists in all species, with multimeric arrays ranging in size from 10 to 1500 kb. Sequence analysis of a 492-bp PCR product revealed comparable levels (0.2-4.5%) of intra- and interspecific divergence when species of Bos and Bison were compared, supporting the idea that species of these two genera should be recognized under the genus Bos. Alternatively, all Syncerus sequences cluster as a monophyletic group on an evolutionary tree and differ from those of Bos/ Bison by about 13%. Comparing these findings with the fossil record indicates that concerted evolution has occurred since Bos/ Bison and Syncerus last shared a common ancestor (5.0 MYA) but before the radiation of the genus Bos (2.5 MYA): GenBank accession numbers AY517856-AY517904.

Key-String Segmentation Algorithm and Higher-Order Repeat 16mer (54 copies) in Human Alpha Satellite DNA in Chromosome 7

A new key-string segmentation algorithm for identification of alpha satellite DNAs and higher-order repeat (HOR) units was introduced and exemplified. Starting with an initial key string, we determine the dominant key string and HOR. Our key-string algorithm was used to scan the recent GenBank data for human alpha satellite DNA sequence AC017075.8 (193 277 bp) from the centromeric region of chromosome 7. The sequence was computationally segmented into one HOR domain (super-repeat domain) and two non-HOR domains. Dominant key-string GTTTCT provided segmentation in terms of alpha monomers. The HOR is tandemly repeated in 54 copies in the super-repeat (HOR) domain. Five insertions and three deletions in the HOR structure associated with a dominant key string were identified. Concensus HOR was constructed. Divergence of individual HOR copies from concensus amounts to 0.7% on the average, while divergence between 16 monomer variants within each HOR is on the average 20%. In the front and back domain, 199 monomer variants were identified that are not organized in HOR and diverge by 20–40%.

Orangutan alpha-satellite monomers are closely related to the human consensus sequence.

Alpha-satellite is a family of tandemly repeated DNA found at the centromeric regions of all human and primate chromosomes. Human alpha-satellite subsets are largely chromosome-specific and have been further grouped into four suprachromosomal families (SFs), each characterized by a unique set of monomeric types. Although chimpanzee and gorilla alpha-satellites share sufficient sequence similarity to fit the established SFs, the assumption that the derived human alpha-satellite consensus and monomeric types represent the sequence of ancestral repeats remains unestablished. By using oligonucleotide primers specific for a conserved region of human alpha-satellite DNA, we have PCR amplified, cloned, and characterized alpha-satellite sequences from the orangutan genome. Nucleotide sequence analysis demonstrated that orangutan alpha-satellite is formed by a single monomeric type that is significantly closer in percentage of sequence identity (mean = 92%, range = 89-96%) to the overall consensus of human alpha-satellite than to the monomeric types corresponding to the four SFs. Use of cloned sequences as hybridization probes to orangutan genomic DNA digested with a panel of restriction enzymes showed that most orangutan alpha-satellite subsets are characterized by a monomeric construction. The subset homologous to clone PPY2-5 is organized in distinct higher-order repeat structures consisting of 18 adjacent monomers. By FISH two clones, PPY3-4 and PPY3-5, proved to be specific for the alpha-satellite on the orangutan homologs of human Chromosomes (Chrs) 10 and 8, respectively. Our data indicate that there was an ancestral monomeric type displaying high sequence similarity to the overall human consensus from which the different great ape and human subsets and SFs may have originated.

Structure of DNA near long tandem arrays of alpha satellite DNA at the centromere of human chromosome 7

The centromeric regions of human chromosomes contain long tracts of tandemly repeated DNA, of which the most extensively characterized is alpha satellite. In a screen for additional centromeric DNA sequences, four phage clones were obtained which contain alpha satellite as well as other sequences not usually found associated with tandemly repeated alpha satellite DNA, including L1 repetitive elements, an Alu element, and a novel AT-rich repeated sequence. The alpha satellite DNA contained within these clones does not demonstrate the higher-order repeat structure typical of tandemly repeated alpha satellite. Two of the clones contain inversions; instead of the usual head-to-tail arrangement of alpha satellite monomers, the direction of the monomers changes partway through each clone. The presence of both inversions was confirmed in human genomic DNA by polymerase chain reaction amplification of the inverted regions. One phage clone contains a junction between alpha satellite DNA and a novel low-copy repeated sequence. The junction between the two types of DNA is abrupt and the junction sequence is characterized by the presence of runs of A's and T's, yielding an overall base composition of 65% AT with local areas > 80% AT. The AT-rich sequence is found in multiple copies on chromosome 7 and homologous sequences are found in (peri)centromeric locations on other human chromosomes, including chromosomes 1, 2, and 16. As such, the AT-rich sequence adjacent to alpha satellite DNA provides a tool for the further study of the DNA from this region of the chromosome. The phage clones examined are located within the same 3.3-Mb SstII restriction fragment on chromosome 7 as the two previously described alpha satellite arrays, D7Z1 and D7Z2. These new clones demonstrate that centromeric repetitive DNA, at least on chromosome 7, may be more heterogeneous in composition and organization than had previously been thought.

Sequence, higher order repeat structure, and long-range organization of alpha satellite DNA specific to human chromosome 8

We have characterized alphoid repeat clones derived from a chromosome 8 library. These clones are specific for human chromosome 8, as demonstrated by use of a somatic cell hybrid mapping panel and by in situ hybridization. Hybridization of the clones to HindIII digests of human genomic DNA reveals a complex pattern of fragments ranging in size from 1.3 to >20 kb. One clone, which corresponds in size to the most prevalent genomic HindIII fragment, appears to represent a major higher order repeat in the chromosome 8 centromere. The DNA sequence of this clone reveals a dimeric organization of alphoid monomers. Restriction analysis of two other clones indicates that they are derivatives of this same repeat unit. The chromosome 8 alphoid clones hybridize to EcoRI fragments of genomic DNA ranging up to 1000 kb in length and reveal a high degree of polymorphism between chromosomes. Distribution of higher order repeat units across the centromere was examined by two-dimensional gel electrophoresis. Repeat units of the same size class tended to cluster together in restricted regions of centromeric DNA.

Genomic organization of alpha satellite DNA on human chromosome 7: evidence for two distinct alphoid domains on a single chromosome.

A complete understanding of chromosomal disjunction during mitosis and meiosis in complex genomes such as the human genome awaits detailed characterization of both the molecular structure and genetic behavior of the centromeric regions of chromosomes. Such analyses in turn require knowledge of the organization and nature of DNA sequences associated with centromeres. The most prominent class of centromeric DNA sequences in the human genome is the alpha satellite family of tandemly repeated DNA, which is organized as distinct chromosomal subsets. Each subset is characterized by a particular multimeric higher-order repeat unit consisting of tandemly reiterated, diverged alpha satellite monomers of approximately 171 base pairs. The higher-order repeat units are themselves tandemly reiterated and represent the most recently amplified or fixed alphoid sequences. We present evidence that there are at least two independent domains of alpha satellite DNA on chromosome 7, each characterized by their own distinct higher-order repeat structure. We determined the complete nucleotide sequences of a 6-monomer higher-order repeat unit, which is present in approximately 500 copies per chromosome 7, as well as those of a less-abundant (approximately 10 copies) 16-monomer higher-order repeat unit. Sequence analysis indicated that these repeats are evolutionarily distinct. Genomic hybridization experiments established that each is maintained in relatively homogeneous tandem arrays with no detectable interspersion. We propose mechanisms by which multiple unrelated higher-order repeat domains may be formed and maintained within a single chromosomal subset.

Genomic organization of alpha satellite DNA on human chromosome 7: evidence for two distinct alphoid domains on a single chromosome.

A complete understanding of chromosomal disjunction during mitosis and meiosis in complex genomes such as the human genome awaits detailed characterization of both the molecular structure and genetic behavior of the centromeric regions of chromosomes. Such analyses in turn require knowledge of the organization and nature of DNA sequences associated with centromeres. The most prominent class of centromeric DNA sequences in the human genome is the alpha satellite family of tandemly repeated DNA, which is organized as distinct chromosomal subsets. Each subset is characterized by a particular multimeric higher-order repeat unit consisting of tandemly reiterated, diverged alpha satellite monomers of approximately 171 base pairs. The higher-order repeat units are themselves tandemly reiterated and represent the most recently amplified or fixed alphoid sequences. We present evidence that there are at least two independent domains of alpha satellite DNA on chromosome 7, each characterized by their own distinct higher-order repeat structure. We determined the complete nucleotide sequences of a 6-monomer higher-order repeat unit, which is present in approximately 500 copies per chromosome 7, as well as those of a less-abundant (approximately 10 copies) 16-monomer higher-order repeat unit. Sequence analysis indicated that these repeats are evolutionarily distinct. Genomic hybridization experiments established that each is maintained in relatively homogeneous tandem arrays with no detectable interspersion. We propose mechanisms by which multiple unrelated higher-order repeat domains may be formed and maintained within a single chromosomal subset.

On the mechanism of amplification of satellite II DNA sequences of the domestic goat Capra hircus.

A restriction enzyme analysis of the satellite II DNAs of the domestic goat Capra hircus, sheep Ovis aries and ox Bos taurus (p = 1.720, 1.723 and 1.722 g/cm3, respectively) has been carried out and shows that, although all three are composed of repeat units of 700 base-pairs, goat satellite II is present in the genome primarily in the form of 2100 base-pair trimers. Unequal crossing-over between repeat units has produced an oligomer series, whose oligomers gradually decrease in copy number the further they are in molecular weight from the trimer. The trimer population is much more uniform than the monomer population, as most trimers have similar restriction patterns, whereas their component monomers differ considerably in their restriction properties. This heterogeneity was confirmed by cross-hybridization of the different monomers of a cloned trimer. Here, heterologous hybrids were much less stable than the homologous hybrids. Attempts were made to simulate such an oligomer series by computer, using a longitudinal (saltatory), and two horizontal (unequal crossover and drive) models. Simulations of both the saltatory and drive mechanisms could produce the oligomer series in approximately the observed ratios, but only the former could simultaneously produce other restriction properties of this sequence family. This was because the other restriction sites were in a different (monomer) register, and it is difficult for a drive model promoting traits in only one register to fix properties in different registers. The unequal crossover model proposed by Smith (1973, 1976) generally produced homogeneous arrays from heterogeneous arrays, but higher-order repeat structures could be produced when the efficiency of crossing-over between different monomer types was reduced. In most of these arrays, the dimer was the predominant oligomer, but in approximately 10% the trimer was predominant. Since the unequal crossover model produces dimeric arrays with high frequency given appropriate conditions, it is an attractive model for explaining the production of satellite DNAs whose structure has evolved through a series of doublings, such as mouse major satellite DNA and the "alphoid" satellite sequences of primates. Other factors necessary for this model to work are generally considered to be natural components of the speciation process. It is therefore suggested that, although the saltatory model conforms most closely to the observed structure of goat satellite II, this particular satellite DNA may represent one of the few cases when the unequal crossover mechanism does not give rise to a dimeric structure.