Abstract Mechanical prosthetic valve needs consideration for anticoagulation. The objective of this case report was to know how maintenance of oral anticoagulant therapy is very important in patients, especially with mechanical heart valve replacement. It is the holistic management of mitral valve replacement (MVR) patients with high international normalized ratio (INR) (>100), which led bleeding into the peritoneal cavity and causes decompensated severe anemia. Although it is a rare presentation for a patient of MVR with high INR level but which is most commonly presented for cerebrovascular accident. Anemia is a thoughtful worldwide problem that disturbs the quality of life in persons of all ages. A 28-year-old Indian woman with follow-up case of post-MVR came to the hospital with complaints of breathing difficulty, altered sensorium, pulse rate of 150–170 bpm (beats/min) irregularly irregular, blood pressure (80/50 mmHg), palpitation, and abdominal pain. Blood test report revealed her hemoglobin (Hb) was 3.2 g%, suggestive of severe anemia, INR was >100 s. Hence, patient diagnosed as follow-up case of MVR (#27 mm mechanical bileaflet mitral valve prosthesis) with peritoneal bleeding, an oral anticoagulant with decompensated severe anemia managment should be done. Ended the progression of her hospitalization, she received four units of packed red blood cell transfusions; Vitamin K was given intravenous once daily for 2 days and no anticoagulant was given, so far, INR was high with serial monitoring of INR and Hb. Her symptoms of breathing difficulty, pain in abdomen, weakness and giddiness resolute by the finish of her hospital stay, and she recompensed to her oral anticoagulant therapy with improved Hb and hemodynamics. Disapprovingly high INR levels are classically related with bleeding disorders revealed on imperative indicators and hemodynamic variability. To our understanding, one of the lowermost noted Hb is because of bleeding due to very high INR, so monitoring of therapeutic INR level with anticoagulants is very-very important.