High-resolution Optical Tweezers Research Articles

Nonlinear compliance of NOMPC gating spring and its implication in mechanotransduction.

NOMPC is a type of mechanosensitive ion channel (MSCs) that are tethered to cytoskeleton through gating springs and gated by forces applied to the cell, thereby mediating processes including hearing, touch sensation, and proprioception. The mechanical properties of the gating spring play crucial roles in force transmission and channel opening and adaptation, but have been poorly characterized so far. Here, we measured the stiffness and unfolding of ankyrin-repeat domains (ARDs), the gating spring in the tetrameric NOMPC complex, by pulling single or multiple ARDs using high-resolution optical tweezers. We found that each ARD has a low stiffness of ∼0.7 pN/nm and starts to unfold stepwise at ∼7 pN. Four ARDs show cooperativity in their mechanical properties through interactions at their lower contact sites. This find is further supported by cryo-EM structures of NOMPC containing full-length and truncated ARDs. Overall, our work demonstrates a compliant and unfolding-refolding gating spring essential for the function of NOMPC and likely other MSCs.

Mechanics of divalent ion sensitivity of the manganese-sensing riboswitch measured by combined high-resolution optical tweezers and single-molecule fluorescence.

Riboswitches are structured non-coding RNA typically found in the 5′ untranslated regions of bacterial mRNAs. They modulate gene expression through the binding of specific ligands that induce changes in the riboswitch structure, most often at the level of transcription and translation. The Mn2+-sensing yybP-ykoY RNA motif is one of the most widespread riboswitches across bacteria, including human and plant pathogens. It contains two divalent metal ion binding sites: one is specific for Mn2+ whereas the other is nonspecific for a divalent metal ion, including Mg2+. Previous crystal structures have shown that Mn2+ binds in between the two distal helical legs of a four-way junction and induces a large “docking” conformational change. It is unclear how competition between Mn2+ and Mg2+ for the two binding sites and the associated RNA conformational changes give rise to Mn2+ detection function and sensitivity. Therefore, we explored the global structural dynamics of the L. lactis Mn2+-sensing riboswitch in the presence of competing divalent cations using high-resolution optical tweezers simultaneous with confocal Förster resonance energy transfer (FRET) spectroscopy. Initial non-equilibrium force ramp measurements revealed force-dependent docking distribution, suggesting a highly selective docked state at suboptimal Mn2+ ion concentration. Follow-up high-resolution equilibrium fixed-force measurements directly measured docking and undocking rate constants versus force to determine docking and undocking mechanics, including transition states and pathways, at varying Mn2+ vs Mg2+ concentrations. Simultaneous FRET measurements confirmed specific conformational transitions. Docking and undocking were symmetric processes with nearly equal force sensitivity and a transition state located nearly midway between the docked and undocked states. Mn2+ sensitivity appears to optimize at a concentration where further increasing Mn2+ competes with Mg2+ ions for the non-specific divalent metal ion binding site.

Assignment of structural transitions during mechanical unwrapping of nucleosomes and their disassembly products

Nucleosome DNA unwrapping and its disassembly into hexasomes and tetrasomes is necessary for genomic access and plays an important role in transcription regulation. Previous single-molecule mechanical nucleosome unwrapping revealed a low- and a high-force transitions, and force-FRET pulling experiments showed that DNA unwrapping is asymmetric, occurring always first from one side before the other. However, the assignment of DNA segments involved in these transitions remains controversial. Here, using high-resolution optical tweezers with simultaneous single-molecule FRET detection, we show that the low-force transition corresponds to the undoing of the outer wrap of one side of the nucleosome (∼27 bp), a process that can occur either cooperatively or noncooperatively, whereas the high-force transition corresponds to the simultaneous unwrapping of ∼76 bp from both sides. This process may give rise stochastically to the disassembly of nucleosomes into hexasomes and tetrasomes whose unwrapping/rewrapping trajectories we establish. In contrast, nucleosome rewrapping does not exhibit asymmetry. To rationalize all previous nucleosome unwrapping experiments, it is necessary to invoke that mechanical unwrapping involves two nucleosome reorientations: one that contributes to the change in extension at the low-force transition and another that coincides but does not contribute to the high-force transition.

A thermodynamic model of bacterial transcription

Transcriptional pausing is highly regulated by the template DNA and nascent transcript sequences. Here, we propose a thermodynamic model of transcriptional pausing, based on the thermal energy of transcription bubbles and nascent RNA structures, to describe the kinetics of the reaction pathways between active translocation, intermediate, backtracked, and hairpin-stabilized pauses. The model readily predicts experimentally detected pauses observed in high-resolution optical tweezers measurements of transcription, in terms of pause sites, duration, and mechanisms.

High-Resolution Optical Tweezers Combined with Multicolor Single-Molecule Microscopy.

We present an instrument that combines high-resolution optical tweezers and multicolor confocal fluorescence spectroscopy. Biological macromolecules exhibit complex conformation and stoichiometry changes in coordination with their motion and activity. To further our understanding of the complex machinery of life, we need methods that can simultaneously probe more than one degree of freedom of single molecules and complexes. Fluorescence optical tweezers, or "fleezers," combine the capabilities of optical tweezers and single-molecule fluorescence microscopy into a single instrument. Here we present the latest generation of a high-resolution fleezers instrument integrated with multicolor fluorescence spectroscopy. The tweezers portion of the instrument can manipulate biological macromolecules with pN scale forces while measuring subnanometer distances. Simultaneous with tweezers measurements, the multicolor fluorescence capability allows the direct observation of multiple molecules or multiple degrees of freedom which allows, for example, the observation of multiple proteins simultaneously within a complex. The instrument incorporates three fluorescence excitation lasers, all sourced from a single-mode optical fiber allowing a reliable alignment scheme, that allows, for example, three independent fluorescent probes or fluorescence resonance energy transfer (FRET) measurements and also increases flexibility in the choice of fluorescent probes. To avoid photobleaching and improve tweezers stability, the instrument implements a timesharing (using a single trap laser to produce a pair of traps via rapid switching between two locations) and interlacing (turning the trapping beam off when the fluorescence excitation beams are on and vice versa) scheme using acousto-optic modulators (AOM) to rapidly and precisely modulate lasers. Our latest "random phase" trap AOM control method obliterates previous residual trap positioning and bead position measurement errors. Here we present the general design principles and detailed construction and testing protocols for the instrument.

Single-Molecule Optical Tweezers Study of Protein-Membrane Interactions.

Numerous proteins directly or indirectly bind membranes to exert their roles in a wide variety of biological processes. Such membrane binding often occurs in the presence of an external mechanical force. It remains challenging to quantify these interactions using traditional experimental approaches based on a large number of molecules, due to ensemble averaging or the lack of mechanical force. Here we described a new single-molecule approach based on high-resolution optical tweezers to characterize protein-membrane interactions. A single membrane binding protein is attached to the lipid bilayer coated on a silica bead via a flexible polypeptide linker, tethered to another bead via a long DNA handle, and pulled away from the bilayer using optical tweezers. Dynamic protein binding and unbinding is detected by the corresponding changes in the extension of the protein-DNA tether with high spatiotemporal resolution, which reveals the membrane binding affinity, kinetics, and intermediates. We demonstrated the method using C2 domains of extended synaptotagmin 2 (E-Syt2) with a detailed protocol. The method can be widely applied to investigate complex protein-membrane interactions under well-controlled experimental conditions.

Cotemporal Single-Molecule Force and Fluorescence Measurements to Determine the Mechanism of Ribosome Translocation.

Ribosomes are at the core of the central dogma of life. They perform the last major step of gene expression by translating the information written in the nucleotide codon sequences into the amino acid sequence of a protein. This is a complex mechanochemical process that requires the coordination of multiple dynamic events within the ribosome such as the precise timing of decoding and the subsequent translocation along the mRNA. We have previously used a high-resolution optical tweezers instrument with single-molecule fluorescence capabilities ("fleezers") to study how ribosomes couple binding of the GTPase translation elongation factor EF-G with internal conformational changes to unwind and progress across the mechanical barriers posed by mRNA secondary structures. Here, we present a detailed description of the procedures for monitoring two orthogonal channels (EF-G binding and translocation) by single actively translating ribosomes in real-time, to uncover the mechanism by which they harness chemical energy to generate mechanical force and displacement.

Correlative Single-Molecule Force-FRET Measurements of DNA Hairpin Conformational Dynamics

The biological function of many macromolecules such as proteins and nucleic acids is tightly coupled to their conformation and their conformational dynamics. Therefore, studying how macromolecules fold and undergo conformational changes is crucial to understand the underlying mechanisms of biological processes. In particular DNA/RNA hairpins play essential regulatory roles in vivo, since they can regulate the interaction with nucleic acid processing proteins in processes such as transcription, recombination or replication. Therefore, understanding the principles of their structure formation is important for elucidating those biological roles. Single-molecule force spectroscopy represents an ideal tool for such studies because of its unique capability to isolate individual biomolecules and observe conformational transitions in real-time, while providing the control over the population distribution as opposed to approaches in solution. Here we report a study on FRET-labelled DNA hairpin folding transitions using high-resolution optical tweezers combined with fluorescence microscopy. We present equilibrium measurements at unprecedent trap distance stability, which allows to measure conformational state distributions over hours without altering the energy landscape. Measuring over longer time periods while keeping the trap distance within nanometer precision is crucial to capture the rare conformational states that might be overlooked in measurements over a timescale that is limited by instrumental drift. These measurements were enabled by integrating trap-distance and temperature stabilization feedback loops to achieve the ultimate stability in distance between the traps. Kinetic, energetic and structural properties of these states could be determined quantitatively from a correlative information source – force and fluorescence data, thereby providing new insights into folding pathways and energy landscape. This study shows how correlating force spectroscopy measurements with fluorescence microscopy could complement the investigation of the prevalence and energy landscape of certain conformational states with extra three-dimensional structural information of the macromolecule of interest.

Observation of processive telomerase catalysis using high-resolution optical tweezers.

Telomere maintenance by telomerase is essential for continuous proliferation of human cells and is vital for the survival of stem cells and 90% of cancer cells. To compensate for telomeric DNA lost during DNA replication, telomerase processively adds GGTTAG repeats to chromosome ends by copying the template region within its RNA subunit. Between repeat additions, the RNA template must be recycled. How telomerase remains associated with substrate DNA during this critical translocation step remains unknown. Using a newly developed single-molecule telomerase activity assay utilizing high-resolution optical tweezers, we demonstrate that stable substrate DNA binding at an anchor site within telomerase facilitates the processive synthesis of telomeric repeats. The product DNA synthesized by telomerase can be recaptured by the anchor site or fold into G-quadruplex structures. Our results provide detailed mechanistic insights into telomerase catalysis, a process of critical importance in aging and cancer.

The Biogenesis of SRP RNA Is Modulated by an RNA Folding Intermediate Attained during Transcription.

The signal recognition particle (SRP), responsible for co-translational protein targeting and delivery to cellular membranes, depends on the native long-hairpin fold of its RNA to confer functionality. Since RNA initiates folding during its synthesis, we used high-resolution optical tweezers to follow in real time the co-transcriptional folding of SRP RNA. Surprisingly, SRP RNA folding is robust to transcription rate changes and the presence or absence of its 5'-precursor sequence. The folding pathway also reveals the obligatory attainment of a non-native hairpin intermediate (H1) that eventually rearranges into the native fold. Furthermore, H1 provides a structural platform alternative to the native fold for RNase P to bind and mature SRP RNA co-transcriptionally. Delays in attaining the final native fold are detrimental to the cell, altogether showing that a co-transcriptional folding pathway underpins the proper biogenesis of function-essential SRP RNA.

Combined High-Resolution Optical Tweezers and Multicolor Single-Molecule Fluorescence with an Automated Single-Molecule Assembly Line.

We present an instrument that combines high-resolution optical tweezers and multicolor confocal fluorescence spectroscopy along with automated single-molecule assembly. The multicolor allows the simultaneous observation of multiple molecules or multiple degrees of freedom, which allows, for example, the observation of multiple proteins simultaneously within a complex. The instrument incorporates three fluorescence excitation lasers, with a reliable alignment scheme, which will allow three independent fluorescent probe or FRET measurements and also increases flexibility in the choice of fluorescent molecules. We demonstrate the ability to simultaneously measure angstrom-scale changes in tether extension and fluorescence signals. Simultaneous tweezers and fluorescence measurement are particularly challenging because of fluorophore photobleaching, even more so if multiple fluorophores are to be measured. Therefore, (1) fluorescence excitation and detection is interlaced with time-shared dual optical traps. (2) We investigated the photostability of common fluorophores. The mean number of photons emitted before bleaching was unaffected by the trap laser and decreased only slightly with increasing excitation laser intensity. Surprisingly, we found that Cy5 outperforms other commonly used fluorophores by more than fivefold. (3) We devised computer-controlled automation, which conserves fluorophore lifetime by quickly detecting fluorophore-labeled molecule binding, turning off lasers, and moving to add the next fluorophore-labeled component. The single-molecule assembly line enables the precise assembly of multimolecule complexes while preserving fluorophores.

Co-temporal Force and Fluorescence Measurements Reveal a Ribosomal Gear Shift Mechanism of Translation Regulation by Structured mRNAs.

The movement of ribosomes on mRNA is often interrupted by secondary structures that present mechanical barriers and play a central role in translation regulation. We investigate how ribosomes couple their internal conformational changes with the activity of translocation factor EF-G to unwind mRNA secondary structures using high-resolution optical tweezers with single-molecule fluorescence capability. We find that hairpin opening occurs during EF-G-catalyzed translocation and is driven by the forward rotation of the small subunit head. Modulating the magnitude of the hairpin barrier by force shows that ribosomes respond to strong barriers by shifting their operation to an alternative 7-fold-slower kinetic pathway prior to translocation. Shifting into a slow gear results from an allosteric switch in the ribosome that may allow it to exploit thermal fluctuations to overcome mechanical barriers. Finally, we observe that ribosomes occasionally open the hairpin in two successive sub-codon steps, revealing a previously unobserved translocation intermediate.

Structural heterogeneity of attC integron recombination sites revealed by optical tweezers.

A predominant tool for adaptation in Gram-negative bacteria is the functional genetic platform called integron. Integrons capture and rearrange promoterless gene cassettes in a unique recombination process involving the recognition of folded single-stranded DNA hairpins—so-called attC sites—with a strong preference for the attC bottom strand. While structural elements have been identified to promote this preference, their mechanistic action remains incomplete. Here, we used high-resolution single-molecule optical tweezers (OT) to characterize secondary structures formed by the attC bottom (n}{}{{att}}{{{C}}_{{rm{bs}}}}) and top (n}{}{{att}}{{{C}}_{{rm{ts}}}}) strands of the paradigmatic attCaadA7 site. We found for both sequences two structures—a straight, canonical hairpin and a kinked hairpin. Remarkably, the recombination-preferred n}{}{{att}}{{{C}}_{{rm{bs}}}} predominantly formed the straight hairpin, while the n}{}{{att}}{{{C}}_{{rm{ts}}}} preferentially adopted the kinked structure, which exposes only one complete recombinase binding box. By a mutational analysis, we identified three bases in the unpaired central spacer, which could invert the preferred conformations and increase the recombination frequency of the n}{}{{att}}{{{C}}_{{rm{ts}}}}in vivo. A bioinformatics screen revealed structural bias toward a straight, canonical hairpin conformation in the bottom strand of many antibiotic resistance cassettes attC sites. Thus, we anticipate that structural fine tuning could be a mechanism in many biologically active DNA hairpins.

Single-Molecule Optical Tweezers Study of Regulated SNARE Assembly.

Intracellular membrane fusion mediates material and information exchange among different cells or cellular compartments with high accuracy and spatiotemporal resolution. Fusion is driven by ordered folding and assembly of soluble N-ethylmaleimide-sensitive factor (NSF) attachment protein (SNAP) receptors (SNAREs) and regulated by many other proteins. Understanding regulated SNARE assembly is key to dissecting mechanisms and physiologies of various fusion processes and their associated diseases. Yet, it remains challenging to study regulated SNARE assembly using traditional ensemble-based experimental approaches. Here, we describe our new method to measure the energy and kinetics of neuronal SNARE assembly in the presence of α-SNAP, using a single-molecule manipulation approach based on high-resolution optical tweezers. Detailed experimental protocols and methods of data analysis are shown. This approach can be widely applied to elucidate the effects of regulatory proteins on SNARE assembly and membrane fusion.

Combined Force Ramp and Equilibrium High-Resolution Investigations Reveal Multipath Heterogeneous Unfolding of Protein G.

Over the past two decades, one of the standard models of protein folding has been the "two-state" model, in which a protein only resides in the folded or fully unfolded states with a single pathway between them. Recent advances in spatial and temporal resolution of biophysical measurements have revealed "beyond-two-state" complexity in protein folding, even for small, single-domain proteins. In this work, we used high-resolution optical tweezers to investigate the folding/unfolding kinetics of the B1 domain of immunoglobulin-binding protein G (GB1), a well-studied model system. Experiments were performed for GB1 both in and out of equilibrium using force spectroscopy. When the force was gradually ramped, simple single-peak folding force distributions were observed, while multiple rupture peaks were seen in the unfolding force distributions, consistent with multiple force-dependent parallel unfolding pathways. Force-dependent folding and unfolding rate constants were directly determined by both force-jump and fixed-trap measurements. Monte Carlo modeling using these rate constants was in good agreement with the force ramp data. The unfolding rate constants exhibited two different behaviors at low vs high force. At high force, the unfolding rate constant increased with increasing force, as previously reported by high force, high pulling speed force ramp measurements. However, at low force, the situation reversed and the unfolding rate constant decreased with increasing force. Taken together, these data indicate that this small protein has multiple distinct pathways to the native state on the free energy landscape.

A force sensor that converts fluorescence signal into force measurement utilizing short looped DNA

A force sensor concept is presented where fluorescence signal is converted into force information via single-molecule Förster resonance energy transfer (smFRET). The basic design of the sensor is a ~100 base pair (bp) long double stranded DNA (dsDNA) that is restricted to a looped conformation by a nucleic acid secondary structure (NAS) that bridges its ends. The looped dsDNA generates a tension across the NAS and unfolds it when the tension is high enough. The FRET efficiency between donor and acceptor (D&A) fluorophores placed across the NAS reports on its folding state. Three dsDNA constructs with different lengths were bridged by a DNA hairpin and KCl was titrated to change the applied force. After these proof-of-principle measurements, one of the dsDNA constructs was used to maintain the G-quadruplex (GQ) construct formed by thrombin binding aptamer (TBA) under tension while it interacted with a destabilizing protein and stabilizing small molecule. The force required to unfold TBA-GQ was independently investigated with high-resolution optical tweezers (OT) measurements that established the relevant force to be a few pN, which is consistent with the force generated by the looped dsDNA. The proposed method is particularly promising as it enables studying NAS, protein, and small molecule interactions using a highly-parallel FRET-based assay while the NAS is kept under an approximately constant force.

Testing Kinetic Identities Involving Transition-Path Properties Using Single-Molecule Folding Trajectories.

Recent advances in single-molecule assays have allowed individual transition paths during the folding of single molecules to be observed directly. We used the transition paths of DNA hairpins having different sequences, measured with high-resolution optical tweezers, to test theoretical relations between the properties of the transition paths and the folding kinetics. We showed that folding and unfolding rates were related to the average transition-path times, as expected from theory, for all hairpins studied. We also found that the probability distribution of transition-path occupancies agreed with the profile of the average velocity along the transition paths for each of the hairpins, as expected theoretically. Finally, we used the latter result to show that the committor probability recovered from the velocity profile matches the committor measured empirically. These results validate the proposed kinetic identities.

Dilation of Fusion Pores by Synaptotagmin-1 C2AB Domains

Synaptotagmin-1 is the calcium sensor for rapid, synchronous neurotransmitter release, but how calcium binding leads to fusion is not understood. We tested the effects of Synaptotagmin's cytoplasmic C2 domains (C2AB) on fusion pore opening and dilation using a recently established single-pore conductance assay which probes fusion between nanodiscs reconstituted with neuronal v-SNAREs and engineered cells that express the complementary t-SNAREs in a flipped configuration on the cell surface. Fusion results in a nm-sized fusion pore that can be detected in cell-attached, voltage-clamped recordings. Compared to fusion induced by SNAREs alone, in the presence of C2AB the fusion rate, the mean single-pore conductance, and the pore lifetime increased, but only in the presence of calcium and PI(4,5)P2. The assay recapitulated effects of previously characterized mutations on Synaptotagmin. In particular, abolishing binding of Synaptotagmin to the SNARE complex or calcium via mutagenesis eliminated Synaptotagmin'ss effects on pore dilation. Binding of calcium to Synaptotagmin does not alter its interactions with the SNARE complex, suggesting rapid calcium-dependent Synaptotagmin-bilayer interactions may be key to triggering fusion. We probed interactions between single C2AB domains and lipid bilayers using high-resolution optical tweezers. It was recently shown that in the presence of calcium, Synaptotagmin-1 C2AB domains bound and unbound the membrane rapidly, releasing ∼8-13 kT per C2AB molecule, depending on the lipid composition. Here we show that disrupting binding of C2AB to PI(4,5)P2 through mutagenesis reduced the binding energy, while disrupting binding to calcium abolished C2AB-membrane interactions. Together, our results indicate that Synaptotagmin-1's effects on fusion pore opening and dilation require it to interact both with membranes and SNAREs. Additionally they suggest the role of Synaptotagmin-1 is not confined to triggering fusion pore opening; it also plays a post-fusion role in pore dilation in the absence of additional factors.

Mesoscopic model for DNA G-quadruplex unfolding

Genomes contain rare guanine-rich sequences capable of assembling into four-stranded helical structures, termed G-quadruplexes, with potential roles in gene regulation and chromosome stability. Their mechanical unfolding has only been reported to date by all-atom simulations, which cannot dissect the major physical interactions responsible for their cohesion. Here, we propose a mesoscopic model to describe both the mechanical and thermal stability of DNA G-quadruplexes, where each nucleotide of the structure, as well as each central cation located at the inner channel, is mapped onto a single bead. In this framework we are able to simulate loading rates similar to the experimental ones, which are not reachable in simulations with atomistic resolution. In this regard, we present single-molecule force-induced unfolding experiments by a high-resolution optical tweezers on a DNA telomeric sequence capable of adopting a G-quadruplex conformation. Fitting the parameters of the model to the experiments we find a correct prediction of the rupture-force kinetics and a good agreement with previous near equilibrium measurements. Since G-quadruplex unfolding dynamics is halfway in complexity between secondary nucleic acids and tertiary protein structures, our model entails a nanoscale paradigm for non-equilibrium processes in the cell.

Pausing kinetics dominates strand-displacement polymerization by reverse transcriptase.

Reverse transcriptase (RT) catalyzes the conversion of the viral RNA into an integration-competent double-stranded DNA, with a variety of enzymatic activities that include the ability to displace a non-template strand concomitantly with polymerization. Here, using high-resolution optical tweezers to follow the activity of the murine leukemia Virus RT, we show that strand-displacement polymerization is frequently interrupted. Abundant pauses are modulated by the strength of the DNA duplex ∼8 bp ahead, indicating the existence of uncharacterized RT/DNA interactions, and correspond to backtracking of the enzyme, whose recovery is also modulated by the duplex strength. Dissociation and reinitiation events, which induce long periods of inactivity and are likely the rate-limiting step in the synthesis of the genome in vivo, are modulated by the template structure and the viral nucleocapsid protein. Our results emphasize the potential regulatory role of conserved structural motifs, and may provide useful information for the development of potent and specific inhibitors.