The conversion efficiency of 800 nm, 65 fs radiation toward high-order harmonic generation (HHG) in laser-induced plasmas containing spherical and non-spherical nanoparticles (NPs) produced during the laser ablation of different metals in water using 1064 nm, 70 ps pulses was analyzed. Non-spherical NPs of different forms (triangle, cubic, bowtie, rod, rectangular, ellipsoid, etc.) were synthesized during the aging of some spherical NPs (In, Al, and Cu) in water. These NPs were then dried on the glass substrates and ablated to produce plasmas comprising nanostructured species of different morphologies. It was shown that harmonic generation in all synthesized non-spherical NPs was less efficient by a factor of at least five than in the initial spherical NP. Meanwhile, the spherical NPs that maintained the morphology state during aging (Ni, Ag, Mn, and Au) showed almost similar HHG conversion efficiency compared to the fresh spherical NPs. In all cases, the HHG conversion efficiency using spherical and non-spherical nanoparticles was notably larger compared to the atomic and ionic single-particle plasmas of the same elemental composition. NP plasmas demonstrated featureless harmonic distributions, contrary to the indium and manganese atomic/ionic plasmas, when the resonance enhancement of harmonics was observed.