High-fidelity Variants Research Articles

CryoEM structure of an MHC-I/TAPBPR peptide bound intermediate reveals the mechanism of antigen proofreading.

Class I major histocompatibility complex (MHC-I) proteins play a pivotal role in adaptive immunity by displaying epitopic peptides to CD8+ T cells. The chaperones tapasin and TAPBPR promote the selection of immunogenic antigens from a large pool of intracellular peptides. Interactions of chaperoned MHC-I molecules with incoming peptides are transient in nature, and as a result, the precise antigen proofreading mechanism remains elusive. Here, we leverage a high-fidelity TAPBPR variant and conformationally stabilized MHC-I, to determine the solution structure of the human antigen editing complex bound to a peptide decoy by cryogenic electron microscopy (cryo-EM) at an average resolution of 3.0 Å. Antigen proofreading is mediated by transient interactions formed between the nascent peptide binding groove with the P2/P3 peptide anchors, where conserved MHC-I residues stabilize incoming peptides through backbone-focused contacts. Finally, using our high-fidelity chaperone, we demonstrate robust peptide exchange on the cell surface across multiple clinically relevant human MHC-I allomorphs. Our work has important ramifications for understanding the selection of immunogenic epitopes for T cell screening and vaccine design applications.

Engineering of a high-fidelity Cas12a nuclease variant capable of allele-specific editing.

CRISPR-Cas12a, often regarded as a precise genome editor, still requires improvements in specificity. In this study, we used a GFP-activation assay to screen 14 new Cas12a nucleases for mammalian genome editing, successfully identifying 9 active ones. Notably, these Cas12a nucleases prefer pyrimidine-rich PAMs. Among these nucleases, we extensively characterized Mb4Cas12a obtained from Moraxella bovis CCUG 2133, which recognizes a YYN PAM (Y = C or T). Our biochemical analysis demonstrates that Mb4Cas12a can cleave double-strand DNA across a wide temperature range. To improve specificity, we constructed a SWISS-MODEL of Mb4Cas12a based on the FnCas12a crystal structure and identified 8 amino acids potentially forming hydrogen bonds at the target DNA-crRNA interface. By replacing these amino acids with alanine to disrupt the hydrogen bond, we tested the influence of each mutation on Mb4Cas12a specificity. Interestingly, the F370A mutation improved specificity with minimal influence on activity. Further study showed that Mb4Cas12a-F370A is capable of discriminating single-nucleotide polymorphisms. These new Cas12a orthologs and high-fidelity variants hold substantial promise for therapeutic applications.

Discovery and engineering of ChCas12b for precise genome editing

Many clustered regularly interspaced short palindromic repeat and CRISPR-associated protein 12b (CRISPR-Cas12b) nucleases have been computationally identified, yet their potential for genome editing remains largely unexplored. In this study, we conducted a GFP-activation assay screening 13 Cas12b nucleases for mammalian genome editing, identifying five active candidates. Candidatus hydrogenedentes Cas12b (ChCas12b) was found to recognize a straightforward WTN (W = T or A) proto-spacer adjacent motif (PAM), thereby dramatically expanding the targeting scope. Upon optimization of the single guide RNA (sgRNA) scaffold, ChCas12b exhibited activity comparable to SpCas9 across a panel of nine endogenous loci. Additionally, we identified nine mutations enhancing ChCas12b specificity. More importantly, we demonstrated that both ChCas12b and its high-fidelity variant, ChCas12b-D496A, enabled allele-specific disruption of genes harboring single nucleotide polymorphisms (SNPs). These data position ChCas12b and its high-fidelity counterparts as promising tools for both fundamental research and therapeutic applications.

Engineering of a compact, high-fidelity EbCas12a variant that can be packaged with its crRNA into an all-in-one AAV vector delivery system.

The CRISPR-associated endonuclease Cas12a has become a powerful genome-editing tool in biomedical research due to its ease of use and low off-targeting. However, the size of Cas12a severely limits clinical applications such as adeno-associated virus (AAV)-based gene therapy. Here, we characterized a novel compact Cas12a ortholog, termed EbCas12a, from the metagenome-assembled genome of a currently unclassified Erysipelotrichia. It has the PAM sequence of 5'-TTTV-3' (V = A, G, C) and the smallest size of approximately 3.47 kb among the Cas12a orthologs reported so far. In addition, enhanced EbCas12a (enEbCas12a) was also designed to have comparable editing efficiency with higher specificity to AsCas12a and LbCas12a in mammalian cells at multiple target sites. Based on the compact enEbCas12a, an all-in-one AAV delivery system with crRNA for Cas12a was developed for both in vitro and in vivo applications. Overall, the novel smallest high-fidelity enEbCas12a, this first case of the all-in-one AAV delivery for Cas12a could greatly boost future gene therapy and scientific research.

The development of SpCas9 variants with high specificity and efficiency based on the HH Theory

Streptococcus pyogenes Cas9 (SpCas9) is the most popular tool in gene editing; however, off-target mutagenesis is one of the biggest impediments in its application. In our previous study, we proposed the HH theory, which states that sgRNA/DNA hybrid (hybrid) extrusion-induced enhancement of hydrophobic interactions between the hybrid and REC3/HNH is a key factor in cleavage initiation. Based on the HH theory, we analyzed the interactions between the REC3 domain and hybrid and obtained 8 mutant sites. We designed 8 SpCas9 variants (V1–V8), used digital droplet PCR to assess SpCas9-induced DNA indels in human cells, and developed high-fidelity variants. Thus, the HH theory may be employed to further optimize SpCas9-mediated genome editing systems, and the resultant V3, V6, V7, and V8 SpCas9 variants may be valuable for applications requiring high-precision genome editing.

The Development of SpCas9 Variants with High Specificity and Efficiency Based on the HH Theory

Streptococcus pyogenes Cas9 (SpCas9) is the most popular tool in gene editing; however, off-target mutagenesis is one of the biggest impediments in its application. In our previous study, we proposed the HH theory, which states that sgRNA/DNA hybrid (hybrid) extrusion-induced enhancement of hydrophobic interactions between the hybrid and REC3/HNH is a key factor in cleavage initiation. Based on the HH theory, we analyzed the interactions between the REC3 domain and hybrid and obtained 8 mutant sites. We designed 8 SpCas9 variants (V1-V8), used digital droplet PCR to assess SpCas9-induced DNA indels in human cells, and developed high-fidelity variants. Thus, the HH theory may be employed to further optimize SpCas9-mediated genome editing systems, and the resultant V3, V6, V7, and V8 SpCas9 variants may be valuable for applications requiring high-precision genome editing.

SpCas9-HF1 enhances accuracy of cell cycle-dependent genome editing by increasing HDR efficiency, and by reducing off-target effects and indel rates

In genome editing, it is important to avoid off-target mutations so as to reduce unexpected side effects, especially for therapeutic applications. Recently, several high-fidelity versions of SpCas9 have been developed to reduce off-target mutations. In addition to reducing off-target effects, highly efficient intended target gene correction is also essential to rescue protein functions that have been disrupted by single nucleotide polymorphisms (SNPs). Homology directed repair (HDR) corrects genes precisely using a DNA template. Our recent development of cell cycle-dependent genome editing has shown that regulation of Cas9 activation with an anti-CRISPR-Cdt1 fusion protein increases HDR efficiency and reduces off-target effects. In this study, to apply high-fidelity SpCas9 variants to cell cycle-dependent genome editing, we evaluated anti-CRISPR inhibition of high-fidelity SpCas9s. In addition, HDR efficiency of high-fidelity SpCas9s was addressed, identifying eSpCas9, SpCas9-HF1, and LZ3 Cas9 as promising candidates. Although eSpCas9 and LZ3 Cas9 showed decreased HDR efficiency in cell cycle-dependent genome editing, SpCas9-HF1 successfully achieved increased HDR efficiency and few off-target effects when co-expressed as an AcrIIA4-Cdt1 fusion.

Guide-specific loss of efficiency and off-target reduction with Cas9 variants.

High-fidelity clustered regularly interspaced palindromic repeats (CRISPR)-associated protein 9 (Cas9) variants have been developed to reduce the off-target effects of CRISPR systems at a cost of efficiency loss. To systematically evaluate the efficiency and off-target tolerance of Cas9 variants in complex with different single guide RNAs (sgRNAs), we applied high-throughput viability screens and a synthetic paired sgRNA-target system to assess thousands of sgRNAs in combination with two high-fidelity Cas9 variants HiFi and LZ3. Comparing these variants against wild-type SpCas9, we found that ∼20% of sgRNAs are associated with a significant loss of efficiency when complexed with either HiFi or LZ3. The loss of efficiency is dependent on the sequence context in the seed region of sgRNAs, as well as at positions 15-18 in the non-seed region that interacts with the REC3 domain of Cas9, suggesting that the variant-specific mutations in the REC3 domain account for the loss of efficiency. We also observed various degrees of sequence-dependent off-target reduction when different sgRNAs are used in combination with the variants. Given these observations, we developed GuideVar, a transfer learning-based computational framework for the prediction of on-target efficiency and off-target effects with high-fidelity variants. GuideVar facilitates the prioritization of sgRNAs in the applications with HiFi and LZ3, as demonstrated by the improvement of signal-to-noise ratios in high-throughput viability screens using these high-fidelity variants.

An optimized SpCas9 high-fidelity variant for direct protein delivery

Electroporation of the Cas9 ribonucleoprotein (RNP) complex offers the advantage of preventing off-target cleavages and potential immune responses produced by long-term expression of the nuclease. Nevertheless, the majority of engineered high-fidelity Streptococcus pyogenes Cas9 (SpCas9) variants are less active than the wild-type enzyme and are not compatible with RNP delivery. Building on our previous studies on evoCas9, we developed a high-fidelity SpCas9 variant suitable for RNP delivery. The editing efficacy and precision of the recombinant high-fidelity Cas9 (rCas9HF), characterized by the K526D substitution, was compared with the R691A mutant (HiFi Cas9), which is currently the only available high-fidelity Cas9 that can be used as an RNP. The comparative analysis was extended to gene substitution experiments where the two high fidelities were used in combination with a DNA donor template, generating different ratios of non-homologous end joining (NHEJ) versus homology-directed repair (HDR) for precise editing. The analyses revealed a heterogeneous efficacy and precision indicating different targeting capabilities between the two variants throughout the genome. The development of rCas9HF, characterized by an editing profile diverse from the currently used HiFi Cas9 in RNP electroporation, increases the genome editing solutions for the highest precision and efficient applications.

Sniper2L is a high-fidelity Cas9 variant with high activity.

Although several high-fidelity SpCas9 variants have been reported, it has been observed that this increased specificity is associated with reduced on-target activity, limiting the applications of the high-fidelity variants when efficient genome editing is required. Here, we developed an improved version of Sniper-Cas9, Sniper2L, which represents an exception to this trade-off trend as it showed higher specificity with retained high activity. We evaluated Sniper2L activities at a large number of target sequences and developed DeepSniper, a deep learning model that can predict the activity of Sniper2L. We also confirmed that Sniper2L can induce highly efficient and specific editing at a large number of target sequences when it is delivered as a ribonucleoprotein complex. Mechanically, the high specificity of Sniper2L originates from its superior ability to avoid unwinding a target DNA containing even a single mismatch. We envision that Sniper2L will be useful when efficient and specific genome editing is required.

A Test System for Assessment of the Activity of Mutant Cas9 Variants in Saccharomyces cerevisiae

The key component of the revolutionary Streptococcus pyogenes CRISPR/Cas genome editing technology is the multidomain protein Cas9. However, the specificity of wild type Cas9 is not sufficiently high for editing large genomes of higher eukaryotes, which limits the realization of the potential of genomic editing both in fundamental investigations and in the therapy of genetic diseases. The main way to obtain more specific variants of Cas9 is through mutagenesis followed by characterization of mutant proteins in in vitro or in vivo test systems. The in vitro and some in vivo test systems described in the literature are often labor-intensive and have scaling limitations, which makes it challenging to screen SpCas9 mutant variant libraries. In order to develop a simple method for high-throughput screening of Cas9 mutants in vivo, we characterized three test systems using CRISPR/Cas9-mediated inactivation of the reporter genes, tsPurple, ADE2, and URA3, in the Saccharomyces cerevisiae yeast as a model subject. We measured the activities of high-precision forms of Cas9, evoCas9, and HiFiCas9, and compared them with the wild-type form. ADE2 gene inactivation was found to be the most valid method for the evaluation of Cas9 activity. In the test-system developed, the sensitivity to chromatin structure was demonstrated for the high-fidelity variant of Cas9, HiFiCas9. The proposed test-system can be used for the development of new generation genome editors.

SuperFi-Cas9 exhibits remarkable fidelity but severely reduced activity yet works effectively with ABE8e

Several advancements have been made to SpCas9, the most widely used CRISPR/Cas genome editing tool, to reduce its unwanted off-target effects. The most promising approach is the development of increased-fidelity nuclease (IFN) variants of SpCas9, however, their fidelity has increased at the cost of reduced activity. SuperFi-Cas9 has been developed recently, and it has been described as a next-generation high-fidelity SpCas9 variant, free from the drawbacks of first-generation IFNs. In this study, we characterize the on-target activity and the off-target propensity of SuperFi-Cas9 in mammalian cells, comparing it to first-generation IFNs. SuperFi-Cas9 demonstrates strongly reduced activity but high fidelity features that are in many aspects similar to those of some first-generation variants, such as evo- and HeFSpCas9. SuperFi-cytosine (CBE3) and -adenine (ABE7.10) base editors, as well as SuperFi-prime editor show no meaningful activity. When combined with ABE8e, SuperFi-Cas9, similarly to HeFSpCas9, executes DNA editing with high activity as well as high specificity reducing both bystander and SpCas9-dependent off-target base editing.

High-fidelity Cas13 variants for targeted RNA degradation with minimal collateral effects.

CRISPR-Cas13 systems have recently been used for targeted RNA degradation in various organisms. However, collateral degradation of bystander RNAs has limited their in vivo applications. Here, we design a dual-fluorescence reporter system for detecting collateral effects and screening Cas13 variants in mammalian cells. Among over 200 engineered variants, several Cas13 variants including Cas13d and Cas13X exhibit efficient on-target activity but markedly reduced collateral activity. Furthermore, transcriptome-wide off-targets and cell growth arrest induced by Cas13 are absent for these variants. High-fidelity Cas13 variants show similar RNA knockdown activity to wild-type Cas13 but no detectable collateral damage in transgenic mice or adeno-associated-virus-mediated somatic cell targeting. Thus, high-fidelity Cas13 variants with minimal collateral effects are now available for targeted degradation of RNAs in basic research and therapeutic applications.

Rational Engineering of CRISPR-Cas9 Nuclease to Attenuate Position-Dependent Off-Target Effects.

The RNA-guided Cas9 nuclease from Streptococcus pyogenes has become an important gene-editing tool. However, its intrinsic off-target activity is a major challenge for biomedical applications. Distinct from some reported engineering strategies that specifically target a single domain, we rationally introduced multiple amino acid substitutions across multiple domains in the enzyme to create potential high-fidelity variants, considering the Cas9 specificity is synergistically determined by various domains. We also exploited our previously derived atomic model of activated Cas9 complex structure for guiding new modifications. This approach has led to the identification of the HSC1.2 Cas9 variant with enhanced specificity for DNA cleavage. While the enhanced specificity associated with the HSC1.2 variant appeared to be position-dependent in the in vitro cleavage assays, the frequency of off-target DNA editing with this Cas9 variant is much less than that of the wild-type Cas9 in human cells. The potential mechanisms causing the observed position-dependent effect were investigated through molecular dynamics simulation. Our discoveries establish a solid foundation for leveraging structural and dynamic information to develop Cas9-like enzymes with high specificity in gene editing.

A kinetic model predicts SpCas9 activity, improves off-target classification, and reveals the physical basis of targeting fidelity

The S. pyogenes (Sp) Cas9 endonuclease is an important gene-editing tool. SpCas9 is directed to target sites based on complementarity to a complexed single-guide RNA (sgRNA). However, SpCas9-sgRNA also binds and cleaves genomic off-targets with only partial complementarity. To date, we lack the ability to predict cleavage and binding activity quantitatively, and rely on binary classification schemes to identify strong off-targets. We report a quantitative kinetic model that captures the SpCas9-mediated strand-replacement reaction in free-energy terms. The model predicts binding and cleavage activity as a function of time, target, and experimental conditions. Trained and validated on high-throughput bulk-biochemical data, our model predicts the intermediate R-loop state recently observed in single-molecule experiments, as well as the associated conversion rates. Finally, we show that our quantitative activity predictor can be reduced to a binary off-target classifier that outperforms the established state-of-the-art. Our approach is extensible, and can characterize any CRISPR-Cas nuclease – benchmarking natural and future high-fidelity variants against SpCas9; elucidating determinants of CRISPR fidelity; and revealing pathways to increased specificity and efficiency in engineered systems.

Two high-fidelity variants: efSaCas9 and SaCas9-HF, which one is better?

CRISPR/Cas9 (Clustered Regularly Interspaced Short Palindromic Repeats/CRISPR-associated endonuclease Cas9) nucleases have been widely applied for genome engineering. Staphylococcus aureus Cas9 (SaCas9) is compact, which can be packaged in AAV (adeno-associated virus) vector for in vivo gene editing. While, wild-type SaCas9 can induce unwanted off-target mutations and substantially limits the applications. So far, there are two reported SaCas9 variants with high-fidelity, including efSaCas9 from our previous study and SaCas9-HF. However, it remains unknown which one possessing the better fidelity and higher activity. Here, we performed a parallel comparison of efSaCas9 and SaCas9-HF in human cells through fluorescent reporter system and target deep sequencing, respectively. The results demonstrated that efSaCas9 possesses higher cleavage activity and fidelity than SaCas9-HF at the most endogenous sites in human cells. Collectively, our study provides insights for the rational selection of suitable SaCas9 for human genome editing.

High-fidelity KKH variant of Staphylococcus aureus Cas9 nucleases with improved base mismatch discrimination.

The Cas9 nuclease from Staphylococcus aureus (SaCas9) holds great potential for use in gene therapy, and variants with increased fidelity have been engineered. However, we find that existing variants have not reached the greatest accuracy to discriminate base mismatches and exhibited much reduced activity when their mutations were grafted onto the KKH mutant of SaCas9 for editing an expanded set of DNA targets. We performed structure-guided combinatorial mutagenesis to re-engineer KKH-SaCas9 with enhanced accuracy. We uncover that introducing a Y239H mutation on KKH-SaCas9’s REC domain substantially reduces off-target edits while retaining high on-target activity when added to a set of mutations on REC and RuvC domains that lessen its interactions with the target DNA strand. The Y239H mutation is modelled to have removed an interaction from the REC domain with the guide RNA backbone in the guide RNA-DNA heteroduplex structure. We further confirmed the greatly improved genome-wide editing accuracy and single-base mismatch discrimination of our engineered variants, named KKH-SaCas9-SAV1 and SAV2, in human cells. In addition to generating broadly useful KKH-SaCas9 variants with unprecedented accuracy, our findings demonstrate the feasibility for multi-domain combinatorial mutagenesis on SaCas9’s DNA- and guide RNA- interacting residues to optimize its editing fidelity.

Computational normal mode analysis accurately replicates the activity and specificity profiles of CRISPR-Cas9 and high-fidelity variants

The CRISPR-Cas system has transformed the field of gene-editing and created opportunities for novel genome engineering therapeutics. The field has significantly progressed, and recently, CRISPR-Cas9 was utilized in clinical trials to target disease-causing mutations. Existing tools aim to predict the on-target efficacy and potential genome-wide off-targets by scoring a particular gRNA according to an array of gRNA design principles or machine learning algorithms based on empirical results of large numbers of gRNAs. However, such tools are unable to predict the editing outcome by variant Cas enzymes and can only assess potential off-targets related to reference genomes. Here, we employ normal mode analysis (NMA) to investigate the structure of the Cas9 protein complexed with its gRNA and target DNA and explore the function of the protein. Our results demonstrate the feasibility and validity of NMA to predict the activity and specificity of SpyCas9 in the presence of mismatches by comparison to empirical data. Furthermore, despite the absence of their exact structures, this method accurately predicts the enzymatic activity of known high-fidelity engineered Cas9 variants.

Mutation Profiles of eGFP-Tagged Small Ruminant Morbillivirus During 45 Serial Passages in Ribavirin-Treated Cells.

Small ruminant morbillivirus (SRMV), formerly known as peste-des-petits-ruminants virus, classified into the genus Morbillivirus in the family Paramyxoviridae. Its L protein functions as the RNA-dependent RNA polymerases (RdRp) during viral replication. Due to the absence of efficient proofreading activity in their RdRps, various RNA viruses reveal high mutation frequencies, making them evolve rapidly during serial passages in cells, especially treated with a certain mutagen, like ribavirin. We have previously rescued a recombinant enhanced green fluorescence protein-tagged SRMV (rSRMV-eGFP) using reverse genetics. In this study, the rSRMV-eGFP was subjected to serial passages in ribavirin-treated cells. Due to the ribavirin-exerted selective pressure, it was speculated that viral progenies would form quasispecies after dozens of passages. Viral progenies at passage-10, -20, -30, -40, and -50 were separately subjected to next-generation sequencing (NGS), consequently revealing a total of 34 single-nucleotide variations, including five synonymous, 21 missense, and one non-sense mutations. The L sequence was found to harbor eight missense mutations during serial passaging. It was speculated that at least one high-fidelity variant was present in viral quasispecies at passage-50. If purified from the population of viral progenies, this putative variant would contribute to clarifying a molecular mechanism in viral high-fidelity replication in vitro.

In-depth assessment of the PAM compatibility and editing activities of Cas9 variants.

A series of Cas9 variants have been developed to improve the editing fidelity or targeting range of CRISPR–Cas9. Here, we employ a high-throughput sequencing approach primer-extension-mediated sequencing to analyze the editing efficiency, specificity and protospacer adjacent motif (PAM) compatibility of a dozen of SpCas9 variants at multiple target sites in depth, and our findings validate the high fidelity or broad editing range of these SpCas9 variants. With regard to the PAM-flexible SpCas9 variants, we detect significantly increased levels of off-target activity and propose a trade-off between targeting range and editing specificity for them, especially for the near-PAM-less SpRY. Moreover, we use a deep learning model to verify the consistency and predictability of SpRY off-target sites. Furthermore, we combine high-fidelity SpCas9 variants with SpRY to generate three new SpCas9 variants with both high fidelity and broad editing range. Finally, we also find that the existing SpCas9 variants are not effective in suppressing genome instability elicited by CRISPR–Cas9 editing, raising an urgent issue to be addressed.