Shoulder dislocation is undoubtedly one of the most common injuries in traumatology. Posterior dislocation of the shoulder is regarded as comparatively rare compared to anterior dislocation, whilst it is strikingly extraordinary for this type of injury to be accompanied by a concomitant fracture. Accurate diagnosis and appropriate treatment can be considerably demanding, while being vitally important in this exceedingly rare condition. These injuries are broadly considered to be under-reported in the existing literature, especially among high-demand athletes. We present a rare case of a high-demand athlete sustaining a traumatic locked posterior shoulder dislocation with an accompanying fracture treated in our Institution. A detailed clinical examination and plain radiography revealed the peculiar condition, and a CT scan was subsequently performed for more thorough evaluation of the injury. The patient underwent surgery on the day following admission for repair of the extensive shoulder damage, and a deltopectoral approach was utilized. Reduction of the metaphyseal fracture and the dislocation was accomplished with gentle manipulations, and stabilization was obtained with an anatomic plate. A modified McLaughlin procedure was carried out to address the reverse Hill-Sachs lesion. The postoperative period was uneventful, followed by a painstaking physical rehabilitation program, and the patient returned successfully to his sporting activities 6 months postoperatively. By presenting this thought-provoking case, we stress the challenging nature of these immensely infrequent injuries while also highlighting the requirement for more sensitive factor-specific studies regarding their optimal treatment.