High Angles Of Attack Research Articles

The Influence of Turbulence Models on the Numerical Modelling of a 3D Wing in Ground Effect

This paper deals with the influence of different RANS turbulence models on the numerical modelling of a 3D rectangular symmetrical wing in ground effect. Travelling near a solid surface, so-called ground effect, considerably alters the aerodynamic characteristics of a wing. This paper aims to investigate the performance of the widely used eddy viscosity turbulence models while predicting the changing aerodynamic behavior due to the ground effect. Three different RANS turbulence models, realizable , SST and Spalart-Allmaras models are taken into consideration. The effectiveness of the turbulence models were tasted in comparison with the experimental data in different angles of attack and ground heights. Results reveals that, the effect of the turbulence models on the numerical accuracy of the ground effect aerodynamics calculations are related to the altitude and the angle of attack. The choice of the turbulence model becomes important when the wing travels in very close proximity to the ground and the angle of attack is low or negative. The discrepancy of the calculated results mainly comes from the pressure distribution variations on the lower side of the wing. For high angles of attack, or relatively larger ground heights, the difference between the predictions of the turbulence models become negligible.

Body Force Model Implementation of Transonic Rotor for Fan/Airframe Simulations

Three-dimensional throughflow models represent a turbomachinery cascade via a force distribution without the need for detailed geometric modelling in the numerical solution, saving consistent computational resources. In this paper, we present the application of a body force method on an axial transonic fan implemented into an in-house tool for axisymmetric throughflow simulations. By a systematic comparison of local and integral quantities with a validated numerical solution, the capabilities and limitations of the model are discussed for different operating regimes. The implementation is first validated at the peak efficiency calibration point, providing a good duplication of blade flow variables and radial profiles. The design total pressure is matched with a 0.6% absolute difference and a slightly higher slope of the characteristic towards the stall. The isentropic efficiency curve is penalised after the choking mass flow rate calibration, presenting an absolute difference close to 2%, although with a consistent off-design trend. In general, the model provides a satisfactory representation of the flow field and the outflow spanwise distributions, with locally larger discrepancies near the endwalls. Finally, the method is applied to simulate the fan and outlet guide vanes installed into an isolated turbofan nacelle. The onset of intake stall at a high angle of attack is compared between the body force and a boundary conditions-based approaches, highlighting the importance of adopting fully coupled solution methods to study fan/airframe interaction problems.

Effect of the leading-edge protuberances on the aeroacoustic and aerodynamic performances of the wind turbine airfoil

Based on the restraining effect of the leading-edge protuberances (LEPs) on flow separation, this work focuses analyzing the aeroacoustic and aerodynamic performances for the wind turbine airfoil with LEPs near the outboard region of the blades, by using the experimental testing and numerical calculation methods. The associated flow patterns for the aeroacoustic and aerodynamic performances are revealed within the pre-stall and post-stall regions. The shedding of the separation vortices enhances the instability of the laminar boundary layer, generating the aerodynamic noise from the wind turbine airfoil. The LEPs suppress the generation of the tonal noise in pre-stall region by changing the distribution and reducing the intensity of the trailing edge shedding vortices. Moreover, LEPs can improve the aerodynamic performance of the wind turbine airfoil greatly by inhibiting the flow separation at a high inflow angle of attack. As a flow control method for the wind turbine blades, LEPs will help to improve the aeroacoustic performance of the blades under normal inflow wind conditions, and the aerodynamic performance under extreme wind situations where the inflow wind changes on a large scale frequently.

Turbulence Modeling of Iced Wind Turbine Airfoils

Icing is a severe problem faced by wind turbines operating in cold climates. It is affected by various fluctuating parameters. Due to ice accretion, a significant drop in the aerodynamic performance of the blades’ airfoils leads to productivity loss in wind turbines. When ice accretes on airfoils, it leads to a geometry deformation that seriously increases turbulence, particularly on the airfoil suction side at high angles of attack. Modeling and simulation are indispensable tools to estimate the effect of icing on the operation of wind turbines and gain a better understanding of the phenomenon. This paper presents a numerical study to assess the effect of surface roughness distribution, along with the effect of two turbulence models on estimating wind turbine airfoils’ aerodynamic performance losses in the presence of ice. Aerodynamic parameter estimation was performed using ANSYS FLUENT, while ice accretion was simulated using ANSYS FENSAP-ICE. The results using the adopted modeling approaches and the simulation tools were compared with another numerical study and validated against experimental data. The validation process demonstrated the model’s accuracy when considering roughness distribution via the beading model available in ANSYS FENSAP-ICE. The two turbulence models examined (Spalart–Allmaras and k-ω SST) gave comparable results except for the drag at high angles of attack. The k-ω SST model was more efficient in replicating turbulence at high angles of attack, leading to higher accuracy in aerodynamic loss estimation.

Role of the caudal peduncle in a fish-inspired robotic model: how changing stiffness and angle of attack affects swimming performance

In fish, the tail is a key element of propulsive anatomy that contributes to thrust during swimming. Fish possess the ability to alter tail stiffness, surface area and conformation. Specifically, the region at the base of the tail, the caudal peduncle, is proposed to be a key location of fish stiffness modulation during locomotion. Most previous analyses have focused on the overall body or tail stiffness, and not on the effects of changing stiffness specifically at the base of the tail in fish and robotic models. We used both computational fluid dynamics analysis and experimental measurements of propulsive forces in physical models with different peduncle stiffnesses to analyze the effect of altering stiffness on the tail angle of attack and propulsive force and efficiency. By changing the motion program input to the tail, we were able to alter the phase relationship between the front and back tail sections between 0° and 330°. Computational simulations showed that power consumption was nearly minimized and thrust production was nearly maximized at the kinematic pattern where φ = 270°, the approximate phase lag observed in the experimental foils and in free swimming tuna. We observed reduced thrust and efficiency at high angles of attack, suggesting that the tail driven during these motion programs experiences stalling and loss of lift. However, there is no single peduncle stiffness that consistently maximizes performance, particularly in physical models. This result highlights the fact that the optimal caudal peduncle stiffness is highly context dependent. Therefore, incorporating the ability to control peduncle stiffness in future robotic models of fish propulsion promises to increase the ability of robots to approach the performance of fish.

The leading-edge vortex over a swift-like high-aspect-ratio wing with nonlinear swept-back geometry

The leading-edge vortex (LEV) is a common flow structure that forms over wings at high angles of attack. Over the years, LEVs were exploited for augmenting the lift of man-made slender delta wings aircraft. However, recent observations suggested that natural flyers with high-aspect-ratio (high-AR) wings, such as the common swift (Apus apus), can also generate LEVs while gliding. We hypothesize that the planform shape and nonlinear sweep (increasing towards the wingtip) enable the formation and control of such LEVs. In this paper, we investigate whether a stationary LEV can form over a nonlinear swept-back high-AR wing inspired by the swift’s wing shape and evaluate its characteristics and potential aerodynamic benefit. Particle image velocimetry (PIV) measurements were performed in a water flume on a high-AR swept-back wing inspired by the swift wing. Experiments were performed at four spanwise sections and a range of angles of attack for a chord-based Reynolds number of . Stationary LEV structures were identified across the wingspan by utilizing the proper orthogonal decomposition (POD) method for angles of attack of 5∘–15∘. The size and circulation of the stationary LEV were found to grow towards the wingtip in a nonlinear manner due to shear layer feeding and spanwise transport of mass and vorticity within the LEV, thus confirming that nonlinear high-AR swept-back wings can generate stationary LEVs. Our results suggest that the common swift can generate stationary LEVs over its swept-back wings to glide slower and at a higher rate of descent, with the LEVs potentially supporting up to 60% of its weight.

Roughness Effect on the Flow Past Axisymmetric Bodies at High Incidence

The flow at low Mach numbers and high angles of attack over axisymmetric configurations is not symmetric. The mechanism that triggers the asymmetry is a combination of a global (temporal) instability and a convective (spatial) instability. This latter instability is caused by roughness and other geometrical imperfections, which lead to roll angle dependent forces. The flow at these conditions has a complex vortex sheet structure, with two or three different flow regions. An accurate simulation by means of Computational Flow Dynamics (CFD) is thus very challenging, and many researchers have therefore employed Large Eddy Simulation (LES) codes. This study demonstrates that Unsteady Reynolds Averaged Navier-Stokes (URANS) methods are a suitable alternative, if Scale Adaptive Simulation (SAS) is used. This method is capable of capturing the main flow features, provided that fine meshes, which achieve geometrical similarity between the meshed geometry and the real object, and small-time steps are used. It is also demonstrated that, by using URANS methods in combination with SAS, strong differences in the global and local forces depending on the surface roughness of the model are obtained, a result which coincides with several wind tunnel tests.

Wing sweep effects on laminar separated flows

We reveal the effects of sweep on the wake dynamics around NACA 0015 wings at high angles of attack using direct numerical simulations and resolvent analysis. The influence of sweep on the wake dynamics is considered for sweep angles from $0^\circ$ to $45^\circ$ and angles of attack from $16^\circ$ to $30^\circ$ for a spanwise periodic wing at a chord-based Reynolds number of $400$ and a Mach number of $0.1$ . Wing sweep affects the wake dynamics, especially in terms of stability and spanwise fluctuations with implications on the development of three-dimensional (3-D) wakes. We observe that wing sweep attenuates spanwise fluctuations. Even as the sweep angle influences the wake, force and pressure coefficients can be collapsed for low angles of attack when examined in wall-normal and wingspan-normal independent flow components. Some small deviations at high sweep and incidence angles are attributed to vortical wake structures that impose secondary aerodynamic loads, revealed through the force element analysis. Furthermore, we conduct global resolvent analysis to uncover oblique modes with high disturbance amplification. The resolvent analysis also reveals the presence of wavemakers in the shear-dominated region associated with the emergence of 3-D wakes at high angles of attack. For flows at high sweep angles, the optimal convection speed of the response modes is shown to be faster than the optimal wavemakers speed suggesting a mechanism for the attenuation of perturbations. The present findings serve as a fundamental stepping stone to understanding separated flows at higher Reynolds numbers.

Adaptive neural control for nonlinear switched systems with improved MDADT and its applications

In this paper, a new framework of the robust adaptive neural control for nonlinear switched stochastic systems is established in the presence of external disturbances and system uncertainties. In the existing works, the design of robust adaptive control laws for nonlinear switched systems mainly relies on the average dwell time method, while the design and analysis based on the model-dependent average dwell time (MDADT) method remains a challenge. An improved MDADT method is developed for the first time, which greatly relaxes the requirements of Lyapunov functions of any two subsystems. Benefiting from the improved MDADT, a switched disturbance observer for discontinuous disturbances is proposed, which realizes the real-time gain adjustment. For known and unknown piecewise continuous nonlinear functions, a processing method based on the tracking differentiator and the neural network is proposed, which skillfully guarantees the continuity of the control law. The theoretical proof shows that the semiglobal uniform ultimate boundedness of all closed-loop signals can be guaranteed under switching signals with MDADT property, and simulation results of the longitudinal maneuvering control at high angle of attack are given to further illustrate the effectiveness of the proposed framework.

Effect of Multistage Circulation Control on Blade Aerodynamic Performance

To improve the low aerodynamic efficiency and reduce the high energy consumption of a single-stage circulation control wing, a multistage circulation control wing was designed. By combining force measurement and particle image velocimetry (PIV), the aerodynamic and flow-field characteristics of an aerofoil were investigated with respect to the increase in the number of blowing slots, changes in the blowing coefficient, and different blowing ratios for three slots. The force measurement results revealed that the maximum lift-to-drag ratio resulting from simultaneous blowing into the three slots increased by 95.3% compared with that in the absence of circulation control. With an increase in the blowing coefficient, two stages were observed: separation control and supercirculation control. In the separation control stage, the lift and drag coefficients significantly increased and decreased, respectively. In the supercirculation control stage, the lift coefficient gradually increased with the blowing coefficient, whereas the drag coefficient remained unchanged. When the blowing ratio (blowing flow ratio of three slots) in the three slots was 3:1:2, the maximum lift-to-drag ratio of the wing could reach 143.48%. The effects of different slot positions on the aerodynamic control were found to vary. The effects of Slot.1 and Slot.3 in terms of the drag reduction and lift, respectively, were evident, and the influence of Slot.2 on blowing between these two slots played a role in jet relay. The PIV results revealed that multistage blowing circulation increased the curvature of the trailing-edge streamline, thus increasing the equivalent aerofoil camber and improving the wing lift. At a high angle of attack, this circulation demonstrated a flow separation control effect.

Bioinspired Drone Actuated Using Wing and Aileron Motion for Extended Flight Capabilities

Since the advent of flying machines, engineers have strived to develop aircraft that can fly as flexibly as birds. From the original traditional control surface to the controllable morphing wing design, they all aim to improve the flight performance of drones, including the load capacity, maneuverability and stability. We believe that a single control method has certain limitations. For example, for roll control, the aileron rudder effect will be significantly reduced when flying at a high angle of attack (AOA), and the asymmetric deformation control of a wing is almost useless under the conditions of low-speed and small AOA. Until now, solutions to the above problems have remained largely unexplored. Therefore, the combination of wing deformation and ailerons is proposed to improve the roll control ability of drones. In this research, a new bionic deformable wing drone is designed, which demonstrates the advantages of the combination of ailerons and wing morphing in roll control and verifies that the symmetrical folding of a wing can change the flight envelope. The aerodynamic characteristics of the drone were tested in a numerical simulation, and its flight capabilities for different configurations were characterized in flight experiments.

Aerodynamic Characteristics of a Ducted Fan Hovering and Transition in Ground Effect

Ducted fans installed on vertical takeoff and landing vehicles experience significant ground effect during takeoff and landing. The aerodynamic characteristics of a ducted fan hovering and transitioning in the ground effect are studied using numerical simulations in this paper. The flowfields are obtained by solving Reynolds Averaged Navier–Stokes equations with the Multiple Reference Frame approach. When a ducted fan hovers in the ground effect, the blade thrust increases due to the combined effect of the increase in the effective angle of attack of the blade and the increase in ambient pressure; the duct thrust decreases due to the combined effect of the decrease in the effective angle of attack of the duct and the increase in ambient pressure. Stall occurs at a certain advance ratio and angle of attack when transitioning in the ground effect. The ground effect delays the occurrence of stall at some advance ratios. The ground effect is hardly detectable at angles of attack less than 30° even if the height drops to 0.5 times the duct exit diameter. At this height and high angles of attack, the different positions and influence regions of the ground vortex at different advance ratios contribute to the different variation trends in the ducted fan performance.

Numerical Study of the Influence of the Geometrical Irregularities on Bodies of Revolution at High Angles of Attack

The flow at high angles of attack over axisymmetric configurations is not symmetric. The mechanism that triggers the asymmetry may be a combination of a global or hydrodynamic instability (temporal instability) combined with a convective instability (spatial instability) due to microscopic irregularities of the configuration. Poor repeatability of experiments and large differences in the global forces have been obtained with very small changes of the nose tip. In order to study theoretically this phenomenon, numerical simulations have been conducted for an ogive-cylinder configuration at subsonic flow and high angle of attack. For the numerical prediction of the flow about a missile type configuration, an assessment of the effect of structured and unstructured meshes is very important. How the body surface is modelled is very relevant; especially the tip zone of the body. Either configuration resembles a smooth or a rough model. The effect of the turbulence models is also decisive. The analysis has led to the conclusion that only Reynolds stress turbulence models (RSM) combined with Scale Adaptive Simulation (SAS), are the appropriate theoretical tools for the characterization of this flow. The geometrical similarity is very important. There is a roll or orientation angle effect for the unstructured grid, while the structured grid presents a bi-stable solution, one mirror of each other.

Unsteady Aerodynamics Around a Pitching Airfoil with Shock and Shock-Induced Boundary-Layer Separation

This study numerically investigated the characteristics of unsteady aerodynamic forces around a pitching airfoil in the transonic flow regime. The unsteady Reynolds-averaged compressible Navier–Stokes (URANS) equations were solved using a Spalart–Allmaras (SA) turbulence model. The pitching NACA64A010 airfoil at mean angles of attack of 0, 2, 4, and 6 deg with the amplitude of 1 deg and reduced frequency of 0.2 was parametrically simulated. The study found that the trend of the unsteady aerodynamic characteristics around the pitching airfoil, particularly that of the unsteady lift force, significantly changes with the mean-angle-of-attack conditions. The shock-induced boundary-layer separation and reattachment during the pitching oscillation have a crucial role in determining the trend of the unsteady aerodynamic forces, such as the phase-delayed or phase-advanced features for the variation in the angle of attack. The boundary-layer separation during the oscillation, observed at a high mean angle of attack of 6 deg, produces the phase-advanced feature of the lift force. Because the phase-advanced feature is associated with a positive damping effect, the result indicates that the boundary-layer separation may serve as a stabilizing effect on the pitching airfoil motion. The boundary-layer reattachment from separation during the airfoil oscillation, observed at an intermediate mean angle of attack of 4 deg, generates an unusual shock wave movement, resulting in a unique lift loop for the variation in the angle of attack. The study also demonstrated a good prediction accuracy of the URANS with the SA model for the unsteady aerodynamics around the pitching airfoil with the shock and shock-induced boundary-layer separation.

Unsteady behavior of hypersonic inlet unstart caused by high angle of attack

Unstart is an undesirable flow phenomenon at the inlet that severely reduces the air mass flow through engine, thereby causing thrust loss, engine surge, or combustor flameout. To better understand the flow evolution and unsteady behaviors of a hypersonic chin inlet caused by the angle of attack, an experiment was conducted in a blow-down-indraft wind tunnel at Mach 5.0. The unsteady flow patterns were observed simultaneously using a high-speed schlieren system and surface pressure measurement. The results showed that the forebody shock impinged on the inside of the cowl, and the inlet operated in the overrated mode when the angle of attack increased to 6°. Then, the inlet entered the unstarted state with a big buzz as the angle of attack reached 8.2°. During the big buzz, high-amplitude oscillations occurred throughout the entire duct with a dominant frequency of 318.3 Hz. In addition, the flow field periodically alternated between the unstarted mode driven by the large-scale separation region with supersonic spillage and the local unstarted mode characterized by subsonic spillage. Furthermore, cross-spectrum analysis revealed that the perturbation source was located in the throat and isolator, and the velocity of the upstream-propagating perturbation gradually decreased.

Performance Analysis on the Small-Scale Reusable Launch Vehicle

According to the symmetrical characteristics of a new type of Reusable Launch Vehicle (RLV) in the recovery phase, we studied the basic aerodynamic model data of Starship and the aerodynamic data with rudder deflection, and the causes of its aerodynamic coefficients are expounded. At the same time, we analyzed its stability and maneuverability. According to the flying quality requirements, the lateral-directional model of Starship in the return phase at a high angle of attack is analyzed. Finally, we analyzed the lateral heading stability and control deviation of Starship by using the criterion and nonlinear open-loop simulations. The results show that the Starship has pitching and rolling stability, but it only has heading stability in some ranges of angle of attack, and there is no heading stability at a conventional large angle of attack. At the same time, after modal analysis and comparison of flight quality, it can be seen that the longitudinal long-period model of the starship degenerates into a real root and it is stable and convergent. The lateral heading roll mode is at level 2 flight quality, the helical mode is at level 1 flight quality, and the Dutch roll mode diverges, which needs to be stabilized and controlled later.

Application of improved k-ω-γ model to deformed hypersonic Inflatable Aerodynamic Decelerator aeroshell

The scalloping surface of Hypersonic Inflatable Aerodynamic Decelerator (HIAD) promotes flow transition. Precise prediction of flow transition and surface aeroheating over the HIAD is imperative to the design of thermal protection system. In this paper, the improved k-ω-γ model considering the separation instability is first applied to the deformed HIAD aeroshell under various angles of attack to assess and verify its performance on such complex configuration, where multiple transition mechanisms coexist and interact. The results of the original k-ω-γ model are also provided for comparison and the prediction mechanisms of the improved model are further dissected. The results reveal that the flow separation and crossflow caused by the scalloping surface are highly sensitive to the angle of attack (α). With the α increasing, an opposite tendency between them can be found, that is, larger α causes stronger and earlier crossflow, but much later flow separation, which leads to the alternation of dominant instabilities for transition in turn. At the relatively high angle of attack, the crossflow becomes critical, at a small angle of attack, however, the separation instability is dominant. The first-mode disturbance can also accelerate the flow instability, while the influence of second-mode disturbance can be neglected due to relatively low post-shock Mach numbers. As a result, the original k-ω-γ model, not attempting to incorporate separated flow transition, predicts an opposite tendency to the experiments. While the transition onset, extent and shape simulated by the improved k-ω-γ model compare quite well with the experiments.

New Flow Control Techniques with Prepositioned Stationary or Vibrating Elliptical Wing at Low Speed and High Angle of Attack

New Flow Control Techniques with Prepositioned Stationary or Vibrating Elliptical Wing at Low Speed and High Angle of Attack

Nacelle intake flow separation reduction at cruise condition using active flow control

Turbofan engine intakes are designed to provide separation-free flow at the fan face over a wide range of operating conditions. But at some off-design conditions, like at high flight speeds and high angles of attack (AoA), the aero engine intake may encounter flow separation. This boundary layer separation inside the nacelle inlet of an aircraft engine can lead to a large number of undesirable outcomes like reduction in fan efficiency, engine stall and high levels of stress on the fan blades. Active flow control is a promising solution to reduce inlet boundary layer separation and the associated fan-face flow distortion at such off-design conditions. By blowing pressurized air into the intake near the separation point, the boundary layer is energized and separation can be controlled. This study investigates the applicability of lip blowing, an active flow control technique, to control intake separation and flow distortion at the fan-face. First, intake separation was triggered in a 3D CFD model based on the NASA Common Research Model (CRM) using high AoA cases at cruise condition (Mach number 0.85, Mass flow capture ratio ∼0.7) and the features of separated flow were analyzed. Thereafter, active flow control was introduce to the intake in the form of two types of lip blowing, direct and pitched blowing. The efficacy of lip blowing at achieving separation control in an ultra high bypass ratio turbofan engine intake has been established through this study. The present paper also examines the significance of blowing parameters like the type of blowing, blowing pressure ratio, and blowing slot dimension, at different angles of attack to identify the critical control parameters. Our research successfully establishes proof of concept by demonstrating the feasibility of using lip blowing for separation control in aero-intakes, via numerical modelling. Furthermore, this study also provides crucial insights regarding the important variables to be considered for future experimental studies, and also for detailed studies covering a wider range of operating and blowing conditions.

The control mechanism of the soft trailing fringe on the flow characteristics over an airfoil

Inspired by the owl’s silent flight, we experimentally investigated the flow control mechanism of the soft trailing fringes (STFs) on the wake of the S833 airfoil at the Reynolds number of Re = 2 × 104. A high-speed Particle Image Velocimetry (PIV) system is employed to visualize and analyze the flow structures in the wake of the airfoil at different angles of attack (AOA). Furthermore, spectral proper orthogonal decomposition and bispectral mode decomposition are carried out to identify the coherent flow structures and reveal the control mechanism from the perspective of simplified models. PIV measurements’ results demonstrate that the STFs evidently suppress the turbulent quantities including turbulent kinetic energy and Reynolds shear stress in the airfoil wake. On the one hand, the STFs at low AOAs prevent the interaction between the upper and lower shear layers, and the leading- and trailing-edge vortices (TEVs) are significantly suppressed, thus destructing the von Karman vortex streets. On the other hand, the STFs at high AOAs divide the lower shear layer into two parts, markedly attenuating the TEVs and modifying the vortical structures in the wake. Besides, the quadrant analysis reveals that the STFs can mitigate the high-amplitude wall-pressure peaks, indicating that the STFs may manipulate the trailing-edge noise. However, the control effect is limited at median AOAs because the region with high triadic interactions moves upward in the interaction maps, which limits the impact of the STFs.