High-affinity RNA Ligands Research Articles

SELEX to Identify Protein-Binding Sites on RNA

SELEX (systematic evolution of ligands by exponential enrichment) is a very powerful method for determining the binding site of a protein on RNA. It relies on the ability of an RNA-binding protein to select high-affinity RNA ligands from a randomized pool of RNAs. SELEX experiments are performed over several "rounds," with each round resulting in increased enrichment of RNAs capable of binding to the protein. There are many variations of SELEX strategies, but they all rely on the ability to separate bound RNA from unbound RNA. The method presented here uses tagged proteins; however, it is also possible to use other separation techniques (e.g., filter binding or antibodies).

RNA sequence and secondary structure participate in high-affinity CsrA–RNA interaction

The global Csr regulatory system controls bacterial gene expression post-transcriptionally. CsrA of Escherichia coli is an RNA binding protein that plays a central role in repressing several stationary phase processes and activating certain exponential phase functions. CsrA regulates translation initiation of several genes by binding to the mRNA leaders and blocking ribosome binding. CsrB and CsrC are noncoding regulatory RNAs that are capable of sequestering CsrA and antagonizing its activity. Each of the known target transcripts contains multiple CsrA binding sites, although considerable sequence variation exists among these RNA targets, with GGA being the most highly conserved element. High-affinity RNA ligands containing single CsrA binding sites were identified from a combinatorial library using systematic evolution of ligands by exponential enrichment (SELEX). The SELEX-derived consensus was determined as RUACARGGAUGU, with the ACA and GGA motifs being 100% conserved and the GU sequence being present in all but one ligand. The majority (51/55) of the RNAs contained GGA in the loop of a hairpin within the most stable predicted structure, an arrangement similar to several natural CsrA binding sites. Strikingly, the identity of several nucleotides that were predicted to form base pairs in each stem were 100% conserved, suggesting that primary sequence information was embedded within the base-paired region. The affinity of CsrA for several selected ligands was measured using quantitative gel mobility shift assays. A mutational analysis of one selected ligand confirmed that the conserved ACA, GGA, and GU residues were critical for CsrA binding and that RNA secondary structure participates in CsrA-RNA recognition.

Site-specific incorporation of a photo-crosslinking component into RNA by T7 transcription mediated by unnatural base pairs.

A photo-sensitive ribonucleotide of 5-iodo-2-oxo(1H) pyridine (Iy) capable of site-specific incorporation into transcripts was developed. The site-specific Iy incorporation into RNA was achieved by T7 transcription mediated by unnatural base pairing between Iy and its partner, 2-amino-6-(2-thienyl)purine (s). By this specific transcription, Iy was incorporated into an anti(Raf-1) RNA aptamer, which binds to human Raf-1 and inhibits the interaction between Raf-1 and Ras. Protein-dependent photo-dimerization of the aptamer was observed when Iy was located at specific positions in the aptamer, showing that the site-specific incorporation of the photo-sensitive component into RNA achieves highly specific crosslinking. This specific transcription mediated by the unnatural base pair would be a powerful tool for generating high-affinity RNA ligands and for analyzing RNA-RNA and RNA-protein interactions, as well as for constructing RNA-based nanostructures.

Identification of RNA ligands that bind hepatitis C virus polymerase selectively and inhibit its RNA synthesis from the natural viral RNA templates

To identify the potential RNA inhibitors of HCV polymerase, we have isolated high-affinity RNA ligands specific to hepatitis C virus (HCV) NS5B protein from a combinatorial RNA library using the Systematic Evolution of Ligands by EXponential enrichment (SELEX) procedure. Thirty-seven selected ligands were classified into eight groups on the basis of their sequence homologies. Most (60%) of the ligands carry the conserved YGUAGR hexamer (Y = pyrimidine, R = purine) at the 5′ end of the 40-nt randomized region, and 74% of the ligands end in (A/C)U at the 3′end. However, strong binding to NS5B required the whole RNA ligand including the flanking conserved nucleotides at both ends. The binding of the selected ligands to NS5B is highly specific and strong, as reflected in their low dissociation rate constants ( k d ∼ 10 −4 s −1). Analysis of secondary structure by computer program and RNase footprints of the two different aptamers from two most conserved groups revealed RNA structures containing three stem loops with internal bulges. NS5B bound these RNA at a region between the two stem loops from the 5′ -end. Some of these RNA aptamers could serve as a template for the HCV polymerase, but some interfered with the activity of the viral enzyme. These RNA ligands will be useful for further characterization of NS5B-binding properties and, with further modifications, may have potential therapeutic value.

Combinatorial Selection of RNA Ligands for Complex Cellular Targets: The RNA Liagands-Based Proteomics

This study explores the selection of high affinity RNA ligands for the complex cellular targets present in crude HeLa nuclear extract through directed evolution and deconvolution. RNA ligands for the mixed nuclear targets were selected from around 6 x 10(14) RNA sequences through an iterated enrichment process. RNA ligands for various gene products of the extract were simultaneously selected and were shown to specifically interact with their target molecules. The target molecules were isolated from the nuclear extract by affinity chromatography using columns tagged with the RNA ligands, resolved on two-dimensional gels, and identified by mass spectrometry. These RNA ligands may be useful in characterizing novel functions of cellular proteins and modulating complex molecular events.

Extensive complementarity of the Shine-Dalgarno region and 3'-terminal sequence of 16S ribosomal RNA is inefficient for translation in vivo

Translation initiation in Escherichia coli involves as a rule complementary interactions between a Shine-Dalgarno (SD) sequence upstream of the initiation codon and a highly conserved 3'-end sequence of 16S rRNA (anti-SD). The translation efficiency is believed to be directly affected by the affinity of the ribosome to the mRNA initiation region. Earlier, high-affinity RNA ligands to E. coli ribosomes were selected by the SELEX approach, with the ligands containing an extended SD-sequence well represented. In this work, we examined the ability of artificial ribosome binding sites (RBSs) containing such an extended (10-nt) SD-sequence (superSD) to drive translation in vivo, as well as its ability to form the translation initiation complex in vitro. Toe print experiments showed the formation of a ternary initiation complex on mRNA comprising superSD. Moreover, they proved the formation of an extended SD-duplex in the binary 30S-mRNA complex. Nevertheless, the superSD appeared to be inefficient in translation in vivo. We believe that the initiation complex involving a superSD-element is too stable to be functional; it may impede the transition from initiation to elongation, thus disrupting the transcription-translation coupling and inhibiting the formation of polysomes.

In vitro selection of an RNA sequence that interacts with high affinity with thymidylate synthase.

Previous studies have shown that the repressive effect of thymidylate synthase (TS) mRNA translation is mediated by direct binding of TS itself to two cis-acting elements on its cognate mRNA. To identify the optimal RNA nucleotides that interact with TS, we in vitro synthesized a completely degenerate, linear RNA pool of 25 nt and employed in vitro selection to isolate high affinity RNA ligands that bind human TS protein. After 10 rounds of selection and amplification, a single RNA molecule was selected that bound TS protein with nearly 20-fold greater affinity than native, wild-type TS RNA sequences. Secondary structure analysis of this RNA sequence predicted it to possess a stem-loop structure. Deletion and/or modification of the UGU loop element within the RNA sequence decreased binding to TS by up to 1000-fold. In vivo transfection experiments revealed that the presence of the selected RNA sequence resulted in a significant increase in the expression of a heterologous luciferase reporter construct in human colon cancer H630 and TS-overexpressing HCT-C:His-TS+ cells, but not in HCT-C18 cells expressing a functionally inactive TS. In addition, the presence of this element in H630 cells leads to induced expression of TS protein. An immunoprecipitation method using RT-PCR confirmed a direct interaction between human TS protein and the selected RNA sequence in transfected human cancer H630 cells. This study identified a novel RNA sequence from a degenerate RNA library that specifically interacts with TS.

Combinatorial selection of high affinity RNA ligands to live African trypanosomes.

African trypanosomiasis is a parasitic disease caused by a specific class of protozoan organisms. The best-studied representative of that group is Trypanosoma brucei which is transmitted by tsetse flies and multiplies in the blood of many mammals. Trypanosomes evade the immune system by altering their surface structure which is dominated by a layer of a variant surface glycoprotein (VSG). Although invariant surface proteins exist, they are inaccessible to the humoral immune response. Using a combinatorial selection method in conjunction with live trypanosomes as the binding target, we show that short RNA ligands (aptamers) for constant surface components can be isolated. We describe the selection of three classes of RNA aptamers that crosslink to a single 42 kDa protein located within the flagellar pocket of the parasite. The RNAs associate rapidly and with high affinity. They do not discriminate between two different trypanosome VSG variant strains and, furthermore, are able to bind to other trypanosome strains not used in the selection protocol. Thus, the aptamers have the potential to function as markers on the surface of the extracellular parasite and as such they might be modified to function as novel drugs against African trypanosomiasis.

Single-stranded RNA Recognition by the Bacteriophage T4 Translational Repressor, RegA

The T4 protein, RegA, is a translational repressor that blocks ribosome binding to multiple T4 messages by interacting with the mRNAs near their respective AUG start codons. Other than the AUG, there are no obvious similarities between the affected mRNAs. High affinity RNA ligands to RegA were isolated using SELEX (systematic evolution of ligands by exponential enrichment). The selected RNAs exhibited the consensus sequence 5'-AAAAUUGUUAUGUAA-3'. The AUG was invariant, suggesting that it is the primary effector of binding specificity. The UU immediately 5' to the AUG and the upstream poly(A) tract were highly conserved among the selected RNAs. Boundary and footprinting experiments are consistent with the consensus sequence defining the RegA-binding site. Interestingly, chemical modification and nuclease digestion data indicate that the RNA-binding site is single-stranded, as if RegA discriminates between targets based on their primary sequence, not their secondary structure. Minor variations from the consensus at positions other than the universally conserved AUG have little effect on RegA binding, but accumulation of mutations has a profound effect on the interaction. Comparison of the in vivo targets for RegA to the SELEX-generated consensus suggests a repression pattern whereby the translation of individual messages is sequentially halted until the least similarly affected message, the regA gene itself, is repressed.

A high affinity binding site for the HIV-1 nucleocapsid protein.

The nucleocapsid protein (NC) of HIV-1 is a small zinc finger protein that contributes to multiple steps of the viral life cycle, including the proper encapsidation of HIV RNA. This is accomplished through an interaction between NC and a region at the 5'-end of the RNA, defined as the Psi element. However, the specificity of NC for Psi or for RNA in general is not well understood. To study this problem, we used SELEX to identify high affinity RNA ligands that bind to NC. A 'winner' molecule (SelPsi), as well as a subregion of Psi RNA, were further characterized to understand the interaction between NC and SelPsi and its relationship to the interaction between NC and Psi. The comparison makes predictions about the sequence and structure of a high affinity binding site within the HIV-1 Psi element.

5459015 High-affinity RNA ligands of basic fibroblast growth factor : Janjic Nebojsa; Gold Larry Boulder, Co, United States assigned to NeXstar Pharmaceuticals Inc

5459015 High-affinity RNA ligands of basic fibroblast growth factor : Janjic Nebojsa; Gold Larry Boulder, Co, United States assigned to NeXstar Pharmaceuticals Inc

Using in vitro selection to direct the covalent attachment of human immunodeficiency virus type 1 Rev protein to high-affinity RNA ligands.

We have used an in vitro selection procedure called crosslinking SELEX (SELEX = systematic evolution of ligands by exponential enrichment) to identify RNA sequences that bind with high affinity and crosslink to the Rev protein from human immunodeficiency virus type 1 (HIV-1). A randomized RNA library substituted with the photoreactive chromophore 5-iodouracil was irradiated with monochromatic UV light in the presence of Rev. Those sequences with the ability to photocrosslink to Rev were partitioned from the rest of the RNA pool, amplified, and used for the next round of selection. Rounds of photocrosslinking selection were alternated with rounds of selection for RNA sequences with high affinity to Rev. This iterative, dual-selection method yielded RNA molecules with subnanomolar dissociation constants and high efficiency photocrosslinking to Rev. Some of the RNA molecules isolated by this procedure form a stable complex with Rev that is resistant to denaturing gel electrophoresis in the absence of UV irradiation. In vitro selection of nucleic acids by using modified nucleotides allows the isolation of nucleic acid molecules with potentially limitless chemical capacities to covalently attack a target molecule.

Isolation of High-Affinity RNA Ligands to HIV-1 Integrase from a Random Pool

We were able to isolate high-affinity RNAs from a random pool that binds to integrase protein from the human immunodeficiency virus-type 1 using the procedure now known as SELEX. Generally, the RNAs fell into three different classes in binding buffer containing 250 mM NaCl: group I class of molecules binds integrase with a dissociation constant (Kd) on the order of 10 nM, group II molecules had a Kd of about 80 nM, and group III about 800 nM. The RNA with the highest affinity from the group I class of molecules, designated P5, was characterized using computer modeling, chemical and enzymatic probing, and deletion analysis. Our secondary structure model for this RNA suggests interactions between looped-out fixed nucleotides and nucleotides from the randomized region; a GNRA tetraloop is also in the structure. We showed that our integrase was able to process a U5 mimic in vitro. P5 competes effectively for binding with the double-stranded DNA mimic of U5 at 180 mM NaCl concentration.

High-affinity RNA ligands to Escherichia coli ribosomes and ribosomal protein S1: comparison of natural and unnatural binding sites.

High-affinity RNA ligands were generated against intact 30S ribosomes, S1-depleted 30S ribosomes, and purified ribosomal protein S1. Sequence analysis indicated two classes of ligand: unstructured RNAs containing a Shine-Dalgarno sequence and structured RNAs containing a pseudoknot. The Shine-Dalgarno-containing ligands were generated against S1-depleted 30S ribosomes but, surprisingly, not against intact 30S ribosomes or ribosomal protein S1. In contrast, pseudoknot-containing ligands were generated against intact ribosomes as well as purified S1 protein. The two classes of ligand exhibited specificity for their respective targets, as well as conserved sequence and secondary structure reminiscent of naturally occurring, cis-acting mRNA elements.

RNA ligands to human nerve growth factor.

High affinity RNA ligands to human nerve growth factor (NGF) were selected from pools of random RNA using SELEX [Tuerk, C. and Gold, L. (1990) Science, 249, 505-510]. Nerve growth factor, which is a protein required for the development of neurons, is not known to bind nucleic acids as part of its natural function. We describe two of the selected RNA molecules in detail. One of them is highly structured, folding into a pseudoknot with an additional hairpin-loop; this structure provides salt-resistant binding to NGF. The other is unstructured and elevated salt concentrations inhibit its binding. These molecules compete with each other for NGF binding. Our RNAs may furnish useful diagnostic tools for the study of an important neurotrophic protein; additionally, they illustrate another example of the potential for nucleic acids to take part in novel binding interactions.

Inhibition of receptor binding by high-affinity RNA ligands to vascular endothelial growth factor.

The proliferation of new blood vessels (angiogenesis) is a process that accompanies many pathological conditions including rheumatoid arthritis and solid tumor growth. Among angiogenic cytokines that have been identified to date, vascular endothelial growth factor (VEGF) is one of the most potent. We used SELEX [systematic evolution of ligands by exponential enrichment; Tuerk, C., & Gold, L. (1990) Science 249, 505-510] to identify RNA ligands that bind to VEGF in a specific manner with affinities in the low nanomolar range. Ligands were selected from a starting pool of about 10(14) RNA molecules containing 30 randomized positions. Isolates from the affinity-enriched pool were grouped into six distinct families on the basis of primary and secondary structure similarities. Minimal sequence information required for high-affinity binding to VEGF is contained in 29-36-nucleotide motifs. Binding of truncated (minimal) high-affinity ligands to VEGF is competitive with that of other truncated ligands and heparin. Furthermore, truncated ligands from the six ligand families inhibit binding of [125I]VEGF to its cell-surface receptors. Oligonucleotide ligands described here represent an initial set of lead compounds in our ongoing effort toward the development of potent and specific VEGF antagonists.

Optimal sequence and structure of iron-responsive elements. Selection of RNA stem-loops with high affinity for iron regulatory factor

Iron regulatory factor (IRF) is a cytoplasmic mRNA-binding protein with specificity for iron-responsive element (IRE) RNA stem-loops. IRF post-transcriptionally regulates intracellular iron levels via binding to IREs in the untranslated regions of ferritin, transferrin receptor, and erythroid 5-aminolevulinic-acid synthase mRNAs. Specific IRE nucleotides are phylogenetically conserved: those of the 6-base loop (5'-CAGUGN-3') and an unpaired "bulge" cytosine. We prepared a pool of 16,384 IRE molecules randomized at these seven nucleotide positions and employed in vitro selection to identify RNAs that bind human IRF. Two major classes of high affinity RNA ligands were selected; the optimal loop sequences of each are 5'-CAGUGN-3' (wild type) and 5'-UAGUAN-3'. This novel finding predicts base pairing within the IRE loop between positions 1 and 5, thus facilitating the formation of a specific loop structure in which nucleotides at positions 2-4 are made accessible for protein interaction. Nucleotide substitution at these loop positions, or at the position of the bulge cytosine, decreased binding by 36-99%. In addition, we demonstrate a preferred IRE bulge structure and report a striking difference in the RNA binding specificity of rat IRF compared with that of the related IRE-binding protein, IRFB.

Selection of high-affinity RNA ligands to reverse transcriptase: inhibition of cDNA synthesis and RNase H activity.

Specific, high-affinity RNA ligands to avian myeloblastosis virus and Moloney murine leukemia virus reverse transcriptases were isolated from a combinatorial RNA library using the SELEX (systematic evolution of ligands by exponential enrichment) procedure. The selected RNA ligands bound their respective reverse transcriptases with approximately nanomolar dissociation constants. The ligands did not exhibit primary sequence conservation from selections against different target enzymes. Moreover, the selected ligands competed with the binding of template/primer complex and inhibited both the RNA-dependent DNA polymerase and the RNase H activities of the cognate reverse transcriptase. SELEX can yield both high-affinity and high-specificity oligonucleotide antagonists against specific members of a protein family.

In vitro evolution of functional nucleic acids: high-affinity RNA ligands of HIV-1 proteins

SELEX (Systematic Evolution of Ligands by Exponential enrichment) is a protocol for isolating, from a pool of variant nucleic acid sequences, high-affinity ligands to a target protein [Tuerk and Gold, Science 249 (1990) 505–510]. This procedure involves cycles of affinity selection by a target molecule from a heterogeneous population of nucleic acids, replication of the bound species (the ligands), and in vitro transcription to generate an enriched pool of RNA. We have used the SELEX procedure to obtain high-affinity RNA ligands against the reverse transcriptase and the Rev and Tat proteins of human immunodeficiency virus 1 (HIV-1). Through sequence comparisons within the collection of ligands isolated for each of these target proteins, we derive consensus descriptions of what secondary structure and primary sequences are required for binding. These descriptions serve as the starting point for the ultimate development of compounds intended to alter the course of HIV-1 infection.

Selection and design of high-affinity rna ligands for hiv-1 rev

We have used in vitro selection to isolate minimal, high-affinity RNA ligands for the Rev protein of HIV-1. Sequence analysis reveals that the tightest binding aptamers exhibit some similarity to a Rev-binding element ( RBE) localized within the Rev-responsive element ( RRE), but also contain novel sequence and structural motifs. A short helical stem and bulged nucleotides (nt) CUC.UYGAG that have no counterpart in the wild-type (wt) element contribute to high-affinity binding. We have designed and synthesized a short (37 nt) RNA molecule that incorporates this motif; this RNA ligand has from three- to fivefold tighter binding than the full-length wt element, and up to 16-fold tighter than minimal wt RBEs. A guanosine:guanosine pairing that is postulated to occur in the wt element has been altered to other base pairings in the context of our optimized minimal element. RNAs that contain non-Watson-Crick base pairings, that can be modeled as isosteric to the wt G:G pair, bind Rev up to 160-fold tighter than elements that contain canonical Watson-Crick pairings or non-isosteric mismatches. These results support the hypothesis that Rev recognizes structural features associated with a non-Watson-Crick base pair.