A series of heteroleptic copper(I) photosensitizers of the type [(P^P)Cu(N^N)]+ with an extended π-system in the backbone of the diimine ligand has been prepared. The structures of all complexes are completely characterized by NMR spectroscopy, mass spectrometry, and X-ray crystallography. These novel photosensitizers were assessed with respect to the photocatalytic reduction of protons in the presence of triethylamine and [Fe3 (CO)12 ]. Although the solid-state structures and computational results show no significant impact of the π-extension on the structural properties, decreased activities were observed. To explain this drop, a combination of electrochemical and photophysical measurements including time-resolved emission as well as transient absorption spectroscopy in the femto- to nanosecond time regime was used. Consequently, shortened excited state lifetimes caused by the rapid depopulation of the excited states located at the diimine ligand are identified as a major reason for the low photocatalytic performance.