We read the report by Rinalduzzi et al. [1] on a case carrying Leber hereditary optic neuropathy mutation (LHON) where Topiramate (TPM) use was presumed as a possible trigger of visual loss. In a systematic review on 74 available studies, we have established a classification for the wide range of TPM visual side effects [2]. Herein, we wish to provide a concise outline of the controversies regarding the effects of TPM on afferent visual pathways and further comments on the above-mentioned case. In our review, we could not identify any experimental or clinical evidence for any positive or negative effect of TPM on optic nerves. However, there are corresponding findings on retinal function; and the histopathology of retinal cells (RCs) and retinal ganglion cells (RGCs). A number of case studies described the presentation of maculopathy, scotoma; pigment abnormality and visual field defect in TPM consumers. Moreover, there are some clinical or experimental studies in this regard [2]. Ozturk et al. in their longitudinal clinical study on TPM consumers, investigated alterations of retina and retinal nerve fiber layer thickness. During the follow-up period (3 months) no statistically significant difference was observed in retinal thickness, though, retinal nerve fiber layer became significantly thickened [3]. Kjellstrom et al. in their rabbit experiments, evaluated the effects of TPM on full-field electroretinography (ERG) and retinal morphology. Full-field ERG revealed normal rod function in both case and control groups; though, in the case group, a significant reduction was observed in 30 Hz flicker b-wave amplitude. The cause of such a finding was disclosed in retinal histopathological investigations, where the inner plexiform layer and amacrine cells of twothird of treated rabbits were extensively accumulated with c-aminobutyric acid (GABA) substance [4]. Inconsistently, in the rat experiments of Sills et al. [5], TPM did not affect any of the measured GABA-related neurochemical parameters and did not concentrate appreciably in the retina. Yoneda et al. in their rat study investigated the effects of TPM via two experiments. In the in vitro experiment, they induced neurotoxicity in the RGCs or RCs and showed that TPM reduces neurotoxin-induced death of either of cell groups. In this experiment, they also found that TPM prevented glutamate induced RGC death at certain concentrations. In the in vivo experiment, through which retinal ischemia was induced; evaluation of the retinal histopathology (thickness of the inner plexiform layer) and S.-H. Abtahi M.-A. Abtahi H. Attarzadeh Isfahan Eye Research Center (IERC), Feiz Hospital, Isfahan University of Medical Sciences, Isfahan, Iran
Read full abstract