In recent years, certain experimental results from small collision systems (e.g. p-p, d-Au, p-Pb) at the RHIC and LHC have been reinterpreted as evidence for the formation, therein, of a dense flowing medium (QGP) despite small collision volumes. Systems that had been assigned as simple references (e.g., cold nuclear matter) for larger A-A collisions would then no longer play that role. This article examines conventional interpretations of certain data features in the context of a two-component (soft + hard) collision model. Specific topics include centrality determination for p-Pb collisions, interpretation (or not) of nuclear modification factors, significance of claims for strangeness enhancement, and interpretation of the “ridge” in p-p collisions. For p-p and p-Pb data analysis results indicate that p-Pb collisions are simple linear superpositions of p-N collisions, and N–N collisions within small systems generally follow simple and consistent rules. However, there is more to be learned about “basic” QCD in small systems with improved analysis methods.
Read full abstract