Guanine Crystals Research Articles

Rationalizing the Influence of Small-Molecule Dopants on Guanine Crystal Morphology.

Many spectacular optical phenomena in animals are produced by reflective assemblies of guanine crystals. The crystals comprise planar H-bonded layers of π-stacked molecules with a high in-plane refractive index. By preferentially expressing the highly reflective π-stacked (100) crystal face and controlling its cross-sectional shape, organisms generate a diverse array of photonic superstructures. How is this precise control over crystal morphology achieved? Recently, it was found that biogenic guanine crystals are composites, containing high quantities of hypoxanthine and xanthine in a molecular alloy. Here, we crystallized guanine in the presence of these dopants and used computations to rationalize their influence on the crystal morphology and energy. Exceptional quantities of hypoxanthine are incorporated into kinetically favored solid solutions, indicating that fast crystallization kinetics underlies the heterogeneous compositions of biogenic guanine crystals. We find that weakening of H-bonding interactions by additive incorporation elongates guanine crystals along the stacking direction-the opposite morphology of biogenic crystals. However, by modulation of the strength of competing in-plane H-bonding interactions, additive incorporation strongly influences the cross-sectional shape of the crystals. Our results suggest that small-molecule H-bond disrupting additives may be simultaneously employed with π-stack blocking additives to generate reflective platelet crystal morphologies exhibited by organisms.

Bioinspired transparent ultratough birefringent photonic films with engineerable interference colors derived from in-situ synthesis of CaCO3

Chameleons can rapidly modify their coloration by manipulating the arrangement of iridophores encompassing guanine crystals in their dermis, which enables incident light to undergo birefringence. Various biomaterials have been designed to mimic the arrangement of guanine crystals, yet instances of synthesizing bottom-up structures with anisotropy for optical functionality remain rare. In this study, we report a novel two-step gas diffusion method for in-situ synthesis of CaCO3 (Vaterite) within a hydrogel to fabricate a bio-photonic film displaying birefringence interference colors. This strategy enables the successful fabrication of an inorganic–organic photonic film with superior mechanical properties and flexibility, resulting in high transparency, superior toughness, and adjustable optical anisotropy. Through a combination of experiment and simulation results, we elucidated the critical role played by shape factor (distribution) and structural factor (particle size) in producing transmitted interference colors. Finally, the birefringent photonic films prepared using the dot-plate method can function as optical patterns accurately representing the “on”/“off” state within a binary system. This system offers high spatial resolution, excellent repeatability, and precise controllability of optical properties, making it applicable in fields such as information encryption and decrytion. Our study has successfully synthesized photonic material with anisotropic structure though in-situ method while elucidating the underlying mechanism governing their ability to generate transmission interference colors, thus opening up new avenues for transparent flexible polarized optics, imperceptible wearable devices, and advanced information encryption.

Synthesis of Chlorophylls-Doped Guanine Crystals with High Reflection and Depolarization for Green Camouflage Coating.

Hyperspectral imaging technology can record the spatial and spectral information of the targets and significantly enhance the levels of military reconnaissance and target detection. It has scientific importance to mimic "homochromatic and homospectral" camouflage materials that have hyperspectral similarity with the green vegetation, one of the most common natural backgrounds. It is a big challenge to exquisitely simulate the spectral of green vegetation in visible and near-infrared windows because of the slight differences between the artificial green dyes and vegetation, the instability of chlorophylls, and the easy loss of hydroxide bands due to the loss of water from the camouflage materials. Herein, a novel kind of biomimetic material of green vegetation was designed through the incorporation of chlorophylls into the crystal lattices of single-crystalline anhydrous guanine microplates for the first time. The synthesized chlorophylls-doped anhydrous guanine crystals exhibit high reflectance intensity and depolarization effect, thus can be applied as biomimetic camouflage materials that mimic green vegetation with high reflectivity and low polarization in the visible and near-infrared regions. The factors influencing the formation of dye-doped organic crystals under mild conditions were thoroughly investigated and the characterizations using electron microscopies and fluorescence confocal laser scanning microscopy clearly confirm the occlusion of chlorophylls into the crystal lattices of guanine crystals. The thermal stability experiments clearly indicate that the chlorophylls-doped guanine crystals possess long-term stability at high temperature. This study provides a new strategy for the synthesis of multifunctional materials comprised of organic crystals.

Intermediate filaments spatially organize intracellular nanostructures to produce the bright structural blue of ribbontail stingrays across ontogeny.

In animals, pigments but also nanostructures determine skin coloration, and many shades are produced by combining both mechanisms. Recently, we discovered a new mechanism for blue coloration in the ribbontail stingray Taeniura lymma, a species with electric blue spots on its yellow-brown skin. Here, we characterize finescale differences in cell composition and architecture distinguishing blue from non-blue regions, the first description of elasmobranch chromatophores and the nanostructures responsible for the stingray's novel structural blue, contrasting with other known mechanisms for making nature's rarest color. In blue regions, the upper dermis comprised a layer of chromatophore units -iridophores and melanophores entwined in compact clusters framed by collagen bundles- this structural stability perhaps the root of the skin color's robustness. Stingray iridophores were notably different from other vertebrate light-reflecting cells in having numerous fingerlike processes, which surrounded nearby melanophores like fists clenching a black stone. Iridophores contained spherical iridosomes enclosing guanine nanocrystals, suspended in a 3D quasi-order, linked by a cytoskeleton of intermediate filaments. We argue that intermediate filaments form a structural scaffold with a distinct optical role, providing the iridosome spacing critical to produce the blue color. In contrast, black-pigmented melanosomes within melanophores showed space-efficient packing, consistent with their hypothesized role as broadband-absorbers for enhancing blue color saturation. The chromatophore layer's ultrastructure was similar in juvenile and adult animals, indicating that skin color and perhaps its ecological role are likely consistent through ontogeny. In non-blue areas, iridophores were replaced by pale cells, resembling iridophores in some morphological and nanoscale features, but lacking guanine crystals, suggesting that the cell types arise from a common progenitor cell. The particular cellular associations and structural interactions we demonstrate in stingray skin suggest that pigment cells induce differentiation in the progenitor cells of iridophores, and that some features driving color production may be shared with bony fishes, although the lineages diverged hundreds of millions of years ago and the iridophores themselves differ drastically.

Phylogeny and ultrastructure of a non-toxigenic dinoflagellate Amphidoma fulgens sp. nov. (Amphidomataceae, Dinophyceae), with a wide distribution across Asian Pacific

Amphidoma languida, a marine thecate dinoflagellate that produces the lipophilic toxin azaspiracids (AZAs), is primarily found in the Atlantic. Although this species has not been recorded in the Asian Pacific, environmental DNAs related to Am. languida have been widely detected in the region by metabarcoding analysis. Their morphology and AZA production remain unclear. In this study, the morphology, ultrastructure, phylogeny, and AZA production of nine Amphidoma strains isolated from Japan, Malaysia, and Philippines were investigated. Phylogenetic trees inferred from rDNAs (SSU, ITS, and LSU rDNA) showed monophyly of the nine Pacific strains and were sister to the Am. languida clade, including the toxigenic strains from the Atlantic. Cells were ellipsoid, 8.7–16.7 µm in length and 7.4–14.0 µm in width, with a conspicuous apical pore complex. A large nucleus in the hyposome, parietal chloroplast with a spherical pyrenoid in the episome, and refractile bodies were observed. Thecal tabulation was typical of Amphidoma, Po, cp, X, 6ʹ, 6ʹʹ, 6C, 5S, 6ʹʹʹ, 2ʹʹʹʹ. A ventral pore was located on the anterior of 1ʹ plate, beside the suture to 6ʹ plate. The presence of a ventral depression, on the anterior of anterior sulcal plate, was different from Am. languida. A large antapical pore, containing approximately 10 small pores, was observed. Cells were apparently smaller than Am. trioculata, a species possessing three pores (ventral pore, ventral depression, and antapical pore). TEM showed the presence of crystalline structures, resembling guanine crystals, and cytoplasmic invaginations into the pyrenoid matrix. Flagellar apparatus lacking the striated root connective is similar to peridinioids and related dinoflagellates. AZAs were not detected from the Pacific strains by LC-MS/MS. This non-toxigenic Amphidoma species, here we propose as Amphidoma fulgens sp. nov., is widely distributed in the Asian Pacific. Moreover, molecular comparison also suggested that most of the environmental DNA sequences previously reported as Am. languida or related sequences from the Asian Pacific were attributable to Am. fulgens.

The physical and cellular mechanism of structural color change in zebrafish

Many animals exhibit remarkable colors that are produced by the constructive interference of light reflected from arrays of intracellular guanine crystals. These animals can fine-tune their crystal-based structural colors to communicate with each other, regulate body temperature, and create camouflage. While it is known that these changes in color are caused by changes in the angle of the crystal arrays relative to incident light, the cellular machinery that drives color change is not understood. Here, using a combination of 3D focused ion beam scanning electron microscopy (FIB-SEM), micro-focused X-ray diffraction, superresolution fluorescence light microscopy, and pharmacological perturbations, we characterized the dynamics and 3D cellular reorganization of crystal arrays within zebrafish iridophores during norepinephrine (NE)-induced color change. We found that color change results from a coordinated 20° tilting of the intracellular crystals, which alters both crystal packing and the angle at which impinging light hits the crystals. Importantly, addition of the dynein inhibitor dynapyrazole-a completely blocked this NE-induced red shift by hindering crystal dynamics upon NE addition. FIB-SEM and microtubule organizing center (MTOC) mapping showed that microtubules arise from two MTOCs located near the poles of the iridophore and run parallel to, and in between, individual crystals. This suggests that dynein drives crystal angle change in response to NE by binding to the limiting membrane surrounding individual crystals and walking toward microtubule minus ends. Finally, we found that intracellular cAMP regulates the color change process. Together, our results provide mechanistic insight into the cellular machinery that drives structural color change.

Biomineralization and Properties of Guanine Crystals.

Guanine crystals with unique optical properties in organisms have been extensively studied and the biomineralization principles of guanine are being established. This review summarizes the fundamental physicochemical properties (solubility, tautomers, bands, and refractivity), polymorphs, morphology of biological and synthetic forms, and the reported biomineralization principles of guanine (selective recrystallization of amorphous precursor, preassembled scaffolds, additives, twinning, hypoxanthine doping, fluorescence, and assembly). The biomineralization principles of guanine will be helpful for the synthesis of guanine crystals with excellent properties and the design of functional organic materials for drugs, dyes, organic semiconductors, etc.

Lizards exploit the changing optics of developing chromatophore cells to switch defensive colors during ontogeny

Many animals undergo changes in functional colors during development, requiring the replacement of integument or pigment cells. A classic example of defensive color switching is found in hatchling lizards, which use conspicuous tail colors to deflect predator attacks away from vital organs. These tail colors usually fade to concealing colors during ontogeny. Here, we show that the ontogenetic blue-to-brown tail color change in Acanthodactylus beershebensis lizards results from the changing optical properties of single types of developing chromatophore cells. The blue tail colors of hatchlings are produced by incoherent scattering from premature guanine crystals in underdeveloped iridophore cells. Cryptic tail colors emerge during chromatophore maturation upon reorganization of the guanine crystals into a multilayer reflector concomitantly with pigment deposition in the xanthophores. Ontogenetic changes in adaptive colors can thus arise not via the exchange of different optical systems, but by harnessing the timing of natural chromatophore development. The incoherent scattering blue color here differs from the multilayer interference mechanism used in other blue-tailed lizards, indicating that a similar trait can be generated in at least two ways. This supports a phylogenetic analysis showing that conspicuous tail colors are prevalent in lizards and that they evolved convergently. Our results provide an explanation for why certain lizards lose their defensive colors during ontogeny and yield a hypothesis for the evolution of transiently functional adaptive colors.

Biomimetic Synthesis of Organic Molecular-Doped Fluorescent Guanine Crystals with Pearlescence.

Biomimetic synthesis of guanine crystals has been focused on in the last years. However, multi-functional guanine crystals occluded with fluorescent molecules have not been realized in the laboratory. Here, the controllable synthesis of guanine crystal microplatelets with fluorescence and pearlescence was achieved for the first time by incorporating Nile red (NR) or fluorescein isothiocyanate (FITC) molecules into guanine crystals. The synthesized fluorescent guanine crystals are pure β-phase anhydrous guanine single crystals. Aqueous suspensions with NR- and FITC-doped guanine crystals exhibit distinct pearlescence. The fluorescence intensities of NR and FITC were greatly enhanced after being doped into guanine crystals due to the inhibition of aggregation-caused quenching. Moreover, films composed of fluorescent guanine microplatelets exhibit high diffuse reflection intensity (70 %). This work provides a strategy to synthesize multifunctional materials composed of organic crystals occluded with dyes.

Guanine crystal formation by bacteria

BackgroundGuanine crystals are organic biogenic crystals found in many organisms. Due to their exceptionally high refractive index, they contribute to structural color and are responsible for the reflective effect in the skin and visual organs in animals such as fish, reptiles, and spiders. Occurrence of these crystals in animals has been known for many years, and they have also been observed in eukaryotic microorganisms, but not in prokaryotes.ResultsIn this work, we report the discovery of extracellular crystals formed by bacteria and reveal that they are composed of guanine monohydrate. This composition differs from that of biogenic guanine crystals found in other organisms, mostly composed of β anhydrous guanine. We demonstrate the formation of these crystals by Aeromonas and other bacteria and investigate the metabolic traits related to their synthesis. In all cases studied, the presence of the bacterial guanine crystals correlates with the absence of guanine deaminase, which could lead to guanine accumulation providing the substrate for crystal formation.ConclusionsOur finding of the hitherto unknown guanine crystal occurrence in prokaryotes extends the range of organisms that produce these crystals to a new domain of life. Bacteria constitute a novel and more accessible model to study the process of guanine crystal formation and assembly. This discovery opens countless chemical and biological questions, including those about the functional and adaptive significance of their production in these microorganisms. It also paves the road for the development of simple and convenient processes to obtain biogenic guanine crystals for diverse applications.

Simultaneous Imaging and Characterization of Polyunsaturated Fatty Acids, Carotenoids, and Microcrystalline Guanine in Single Aurantiochytrium limacinum Cells with Linear and Nonlinear Raman Microspectroscopy.

Thraustochytrids are heterotrophic marine protists known for their high production capacity of various compounds with health benefits, such as polyunsaturated fatty acids and carotenoids. Although much effort has been focused on developing optimal cultivation methods for efficient microbial production, these high-value compounds and their interrelationships are not well understood at the single-cell level. Here we used spontaneous (linear) Raman and multiplex coherent anti-Stokes Raman scattering (CARS) microspectroscopy to visualize and characterize lipids (e.g., docosahexaenoic acid) and carotenoids (e.g., astaxanthin) accumulated in single living Aurantiochytrium limacinum cells. Spontaneous Raman imaging with the help of multivariate curve resolution-alternating least-squares enabled us to make unambiguous assignments of the molecular components we detected and derive their intracellular distributions separately. Near-IR excited CARS imaging yielded the Raman images at least an order of magnitude faster than spontaneous Raman imaging, with suppressed contributions of carotenoids. As the culture time increased from 2 to 5 days, the lipid amount increased by a factor of ∼7, whereas the carotenoid amount did not change significantly. Furthermore, we observed a highly localized component in A. limacinum cells. This component was found to be mixed crystals of guanine and other purine derivatives. The present study demonstrates the potential of the linear-nonlinear Raman hybrid approach that allows for accurate molecular identification and fast imaging in a label-free manner to link information derived from single cells with strategies for mass culture of useful thraustochytrids.

Macromolecular sheets direct the morphology and orientation of plate-like biogenic guanine crystals

Animals precisely control the morphology and assembly of guanine crystals to produce diverse optical phenomena in coloration and vision. However, little is known about how organisms regulate crystallization to produce optically useful morphologies which express highly reflective crystal faces. Guanine crystals form inside iridosome vesicles within chromatophore cells called iridophores. By following iridosome formation in developing scallop eyes, we show that pre-assembled, fibrillar sheets provide an interface for nucleation and direct the orientation of the guanine crystals. The macromolecular sheets cap the (100) faces of immature guanine crystals, inhibiting growth along the π-stacking growth direction. Crystal growth then occurs preferentially along the sheets to generate highly reflective plates. Despite their different physical properties, the morphogenesis of iridosomes bears a striking resemblance to melanosome morphogenesis in vertebrates, where amyloid sheets template melanin deposition. The common control mechanisms for melanin and guanine formation inspire new approaches for manipulating the morphologies and properties of molecular materials.

Plate-like Guanine Biocrystals Form via Templated Nucleation of Crystal Leaflets on Preassembled Scaffolds.

Controlling the morphology of crystalline materials is challenging, as crystals have a strong tendency toward thermodynamically stable structures. Yet, organisms form crystals with distinct morphologies, such as the plate-like guanine crystals produced by many terrestrial and aquatic species for light manipulation. Regulation of crystal morphogenesis was hypothesized to entail physical growth restriction by the surrounding membrane, combined with fine-tuned interactions between organic molecules and the growing crystal. Using cryo-electron tomography of developing zebrafish larvae, we found that guanine crystals form via templated nucleation of thin leaflets on preassembled scaffolds made of 20-nm-thick amyloid fibers. These leaflets then merge and coalesce into a single plate-like crystal. Our findings shed light on the biological regulation of crystal morphogenesis, which determines their optical properties.

Assembly of Guanine Crystals as a Low-Polarizing Broadband Multilayer Reflector in a Spider, Phoroncidia rubroargentea.

The diminishing of the polarization effect is important in the applications of dielectric multilayer reflectors in many optical systems, such as low-loss broadband waveguides, optical fibers, and LEDs. Low-polarizing broadband reflections were identified from birefringent-guanine-crystal-based multilayer reflectors in the skins of some fish. Previous models for these intriguing natural optical phenomena suggested the combined action of two populations of guanine crystals with an orthogonal low-refractive-index optic axis. Here we report a novel realization of polarization-insensitive broadband reflectivity in a spider, Phoroncidia rubroargentea, based solely on the type of guanine crystals with the low-refractive-index optic axis normal to the crystal plates. We examined the three-dimensional structure of the guanine assembly in the spider and performed finite-difference time-domain (FDTD) optical modeling of the guanine-based multilayer reflector. Comparative modeling studies reveal that the biological selection of the guanine crystal type and specific spatial arrangement work synergistically to optimize the polarization-insensitive broadband reflection. This study demonstrates the importance of both crystallographic characteristics and 3D arrangement of guanine crystals in understanding relevant natural optical effects and also provides new insights into similar broadband, low-polarizing reflections in biological optical systems. Learning from relevant biofunctional assembly of guanine crystals could promote the bioinspired design of nonpolarizing dielectric multilayer reflectors.

The Non-Classical Crystallization Mechanism of a Composite Biogenic Guanine Crystal.

Spectacular colors and visual phenomena in animals are produced by light interference from highly reflective guanine crystals. Little is known about how organisms regulate crystal morphology to tune the optics of these systems. By following guanine crystal formation in developing spiders, a crystallization mechanism is elucidated. Guanine crystallization is a "non-classical," multistep process involving a progressive ordering of states. Crystallization begins with nucleation of partially ordered nanogranules from a disordered precursor phase. Growth proceeds by orientated attachment of the nanogranules into platelets which coalesce into single crystals, via progressive relaxation of structural defects. Despite their prismatic morphology, the platelet texture is retained in the final crystals, which are composites of crystal lamellae and interlamellar sheets. Interactions between the macromolecular sheets and the planar face of guanine appear to direct nucleation, favoring platelet formation. These findings provide insights on how organisms control the morphology and optical properties of molecular crystals.

Biogenic Guanine Crystals Are Solid Solutions of Guanine and Other Purine Metabolites.

Highly reflective crystals of the nucleotide base guanine are widely distributed in animal coloration and visual systems. Organisms precisely control the morphology and organization of the crystals to optimize different optical effects, but little is known about how this is achieved. Here we examine a fundamental question that has remained unanswered after over 100 years of research on guanine: what are the crystals made of? Using solution-state and solid-state chemical techniques coupled with structural analysis by powder XRD and solid-state NMR, we compare the purine compositions and the structures of seven biogenic guanine crystals with different crystal morphologies, testing the hypothesis that intracrystalline dopants influence the crystal shape. We find that biogenic “guanine” crystals are not pure crystals but molecular alloys (aka solid solutions and mixed crystals) of guanine, hypoxanthine, and sometimes xanthine. Guanine host crystals occlude homogeneous mixtures of other purines, sometimes in remarkably large amounts (up to 20% of hypoxanthine), without significantly altering the crystal structure of the guanine host. We find no correlation between the biogenic crystal morphology and dopant content and conclude that dopants do not dictate the crystal morphology of the guanine host. The ability of guanine crystals to host other molecules enables animals to build physiologically “cheaper” crystals from mixtures of metabolically available purines, without impeding optical functionality. The exceptional levels of doping in biogenic guanine offer inspiration for the design of mixed molecular crystals that incorporate multiple functionalities in a single material.

Bioinspired Crystallization of Guanine.

Biological guanine crystals in organisms exhibit excellent optical properties and functions, including broad-band and narrow-band reflectors, band-tunable reflectors, mirrors, and stimuli-responsive structural colors, attributed to the high refractive index of guanine (1.85) and the exquisite control of the polymorphs, morphologies, sizes, exposed planes, and the hierarchically ordered assembly of biological guanine crystals in the organisms. Herein, the controlled synthesis of guanine crystals with defined polymorphs and morphologies and their formation processes in organic and aqueous solutions are summarized in detail. In particular, the controlled synthesis of microplatelets or nanoplatelets of the thermodynamically metastable β form of anhydrous guanine (β-AG) exposing the (100) plane in the presence of additives, twinned crystals, and the occlusion of hypoxanthine in β-AG were investigated to mimic biological guanine crystals with superior optical properties. One-dimensional assembly of β-AG microrods was studied as a preliminary work to mimic the highly ordered assembly of guanine crystals with superior optical properties.

Flashing spots on the dorsal trunk of hardyhead silverside fish.

A large number of living creatures are able to use ambient light effectively in biological signalling. Atherinomorus lacunosus, a teleost fish has alignments of circular spots on its dorsal trunk. The spot consists of iridophores, whose diameters are approximately 7–10 µm. The iridophore contains guanine crystals with diameters of 1–3 µm. Here, it is found that more than one spot with a diameter of approximately 0.1 mm causes a rhythmic flashing of light when viewed under white light. The typical light flash has a pulse width of approximately one second. When a pulsed train of flashes appears, the flash repeats at a typical frequency of 0.5–1 Hz. The observed phenomenon is one example of the evidence for the existence of rapid colour changing teleost fish.

Neon-green fluorescence in the desert gecko Pachydactylus rangei caused by iridophores

Biofluorescence is widespread in the natural world, but only recently discovered in terrestrial vertebrates. Here, we report on the discovery of iridophore-based, neon-green flourescence in the gecko Pachydactylus rangei, localised to the skin around the eyes and along the flanks. The maximum emission of the fluorescence is at a wavelength of 516 nm in the green spectrum (excitation maximum 465 nm, blue) with another, smaller peak at 430 nm. The fluorescent regions of the skin show large numbers of iridophores, which are lacking in the non-fluorescent parts. Two types of iridophores are recognized, fluorescent iridophores and basal, non-fluorescent iridophores, the latter of which might function as a mirror, amplifying the omnidirectional fluorescence. The strong intensity of the fluorescence (quantum yield of 12.5%) indicates this to be a highly effective mechanism, unique among tetrapods. Although the fluorescence is associated with iridophores, the spectra of emission and excitation as well as the small Stokes shifts argue against guanine crystals as its source, but rather a rigid pair of fluorophores. Further studies are necessary to identify their morphology and chemical structures. We hypothesise that this nocturnal gecko uses the neon-green fluorescence, excited by moonlight, for intraspecific signalling in its open desert habitat.

Bioinspired Programmable Engineering of a Color-Change Biointerface based on Dual-Stimulation Regulation.

Some animals can change their skin colors in response to multiple stimuli by controlling the skin pigment cell or guanine crystals. An artificial color-change interface inspired by these natural properties has been developed; the interface responded to different types of stimuli, however, is still rare. Herein, we design a color-change biointerface that responds to the cooperative stimulation of light and DNA by changing the conformation of DNA structures to achieve programmable activation of the interface. We construct the biointerface by the combination of a fluorescent dye-labeled hairpin DNA with a photoresponsive molecule, which is cleaved by the first stimulation of UV light (stimulus 1, S1) to expose the toehold domain. Then, the biointerface gets color changed through the toehold-mediated DNA strand displacement reaction with the second stimulation of the invading DNA probe (stimulus 2, S2). Moreover, the transformation efficiency of the biointerface increased from 6.8 to 64% with an increase of S1 from 0 to 600 s in the presence of S2. Also, after the stimulation of S1, the effective transformation efficiency was also tuned from 5.3 to 72% by different amounts of S2 in the complex matrix, indicating the potential for a high response in real-world settings.