Growth-defense Tradeoffs Research Articles

Photorespiratory Metabolism and Its Regulatory Links to Plant Defence Against Pathogens

When plants face biotic stress, the induction of defence responses imposes a massive demand for carbon and energy resources, which could decrease the reserves allocated towards growth. These growth–defence trade-offs have important implications for plant fitness and productivity and influence the outcome of plant–pathogen interactions. Biotic stress strongly affects plant cells’ primary metabolism, including photosynthesis and respiration, the main source of energy and carbon skeletons for plant growth, development, and defence. Although the nature of photosynthetic limitations imposed by pathogens is variable, infection often increases photorespiratory pressure, generating conditions that promote ribulose-1,5-bisphosphate oxygenation, leading to a metabolic shift from assimilation to photorespiration. Photorespiration, the significant metabolic flux following photosynthesis, protects the photosynthetic apparatus from photoinhibition. However, recent studies reveal that its role is far beyond photoprotection. The intermediates of the photorespiratory cycle regulate photosynthesis, and photorespiration interacts with the metabolic pathways of nitrogen and sulphur, shaping the primary metabolism for stress responses. This work aims to present recent insights into the integration of photorespiration within the network of primary metabolism under biotic stress. It also explores the potential implications of regulating photosynthetic–photorespiratory metabolism for plant defence against bacterial and fungal pathogens.

A trade-off between investment in molecular defense repertoires and growth in plants.

Given the negative fitness effects that pathogens impose on their hosts, the benefits of resistance should be universal. However, there is marked variation across plant species in the number of nucleotide-binding leucine-rich repeat receptors, which form a cornerstone of defense. The growth-defense trade-off hypothesis predicts costs associated with defense investment to generate variation in these traits. Our analysis comparing features of the intracellular immune-receptor repertoires with trait data of 187 species shows that in wild plants, the size of the molecular defense repertoire correlates negatively with growth. By contrast, we do not find evidence for a growth-defense trade-off in agricultural plants. Our cross-species approach highlights the central role of defense investment in shaping ecological trait variation and its sensitivity to domestication.

The Multifunctional Anaphase Promoting Complex 7 (APC7) Gene Is Associated With Increased Plant Growth and Improved Resistance to DNA and RNA Viruses.

The anaphase promoting complex 7 (AtAPC7) is an APC/C subunit expressed in different organs of Arabidopsis thaliana and conserved among eukaryotes. A variant of the complete APC7 protein, containing its C-terminal region (named APC-CT), shows a high homology with a tobacco viral replication inhibitor (IVR-like) protein that reduces plant susceptibility to RNA viruses. Here, the role of the AtAPC7 gene was investigated by characterizing Arabidopsis plants overexpressing the full-length AtAPC7 (APC7OE) and the C-terminal portion (APC7-CTOE), by phenotypical, physiological and molecular approaches. APC7OE plants showed improved growth of vegetative organs, earlier flowering and increased photosynthetic efficiency, CO2 assimilation and productivity, compared with Col-0 control plants. Conversely, APC7-CTOE plants showed reduced susceptibility to both RNA and DNA viruses, along with an improvement in plant growth, although not surpassing APC7OE plants. Altogether, the data provide evidence for the role of the AtAPC7 in regulating cell division, expansion and differentiation, accompanied by an increase in photosynthetic capacity, resulting in enhanced plant biomass and seed yield. AtAPC7-CT might reduce growth-defence trade-offs, enabling plants to simultaneously defend themselves while promoting better growth. Our findings highlight the multifunctional role of AtAPC7, unveiling the potential of its orthologous genes as valuable biotechnological tools in important crops.

Transcriptomic and metabolomic reveal OsCOI2 as the jasmonate-receptor master switch in rice root.

Jasmonate is an essential phytohormone involved in plant development and stress responses. Its perception occurs through the CORONATINE INSENSITIVE (COI) nuclear receptor allowing to target the Jasmonate-ZIM domain (JAZ) repressors for degradation by the 26S proteasome. Consequently, repressed transcription factors are released and expression of jasmonate responsive genes is induced. In rice, three OsCOI genes have been identified, OsCOI1a and the closely related OsCOI1b homolog, and OsCOI2. While the roles of OsCOI1a and OsCOI1b in plant defense and leaf senescence are well-established, the significance of OsCOI2 in plant development and jasmonate signaling has only emerged recently. To unravel the role of OsCOI2 in regulating jasmonate signaling, we examined the transcriptomic and metabolomic responses of jasmonate-treated rice lines mutated in both the OsCOI1a and OsCOI1b genes or OsCOI2. RNA-seq data highlight OsCOI2 as the primary driver of the extensive transcriptional reprogramming observed after a jasmonate challenge in rice roots. A series of transcription factors exhibiting an OsCOI2-dependent expression were identified, including those involved in root development or stress responses. OsCOI2-dependent expression was also observed for genes involved in specific processes or pathways such as cell-growth and secondary metabolite biosynthesis (phenylpropanoids and diterpene phytoalexins). Although functional redundancy exists between OsCOI1a/b and OsCOI2 in regulating some genes, oscoi2 plants generally exhibit a weaker response compared to oscoi1ab plants. Metabolic data revealed a shift from the primary metabolism to the secondary metabolism primarily governed by OsCOI2. Additionally, differential accumulation of oryzalexins was also observed in oscoi1ab and oscoi2 lines. These findings underscore the pivotal role of OsCOI2 in jasmonate signaling and suggest its involvement in the control of the growth-defense trade-off in rice.

Drought mediates Sphagnum defense response to herbivory.

The expected concomitant increase in multiple stressors such as herbivory and drought may threaten peatland ecosystems. How Sphagnum, the ecological engineers of peatlands, responds to combined stressors remains largely unexplored. Here we aimed to clarify resource allocations in Sphagnum during concomitant herbivory and drought. S. magellanicum and S. fuscum were exposed to drought and herbivory together or separately in laboratory experiments and analyzed for growth (biomass production and net photosynthetic rate), defense (phenolics in leachates and phenolics in extraction) and nonstructural carbohydrates (soluble sugar and starch) in relation to untreated controls. Herbivory and drought had significant interactive effects on Sphagnum growth and defense. In both species, drought without herbivory reduced the phenolics in leachate, but with herbivory increased phenolics, indicating a synergistic effect between herbivory and drought on Sphagnum defense. Both stressors significantly decreased biomass production, with the combined stress having a more negative effect. Interestingly, a growth-defense trade-off was found in the drought treatment of both Sphagnum species, but disappeared in the wet treatment. Conversely, a trade-off between soluble sugars and phenolics was found in the wet but not in the drought treatment, suggesting that soluble sugars may play a role in inducing the defense and hence mask the growth-defense trade-off in peat mosses. Our results emphasize that predicting the impact of combined stressors on peat moss traits is complex and challenging. Future models should account for the effects of multiple environmental stressors to guide peatland conservation under climate warming.

Stomata: gatekeepers of uptake and defense signaling by green leaf volatiles in maize.

Plants adapt to balance growth-defense tradeoffs in response to both biotic and abiotic stresses. Green leaf volatiles (GLVs) are released after biotic and abiotic stresses and function as damage-associated signals in plants. Although, GLVs enter plants primarily through stomata, the role of stomatal regulation on the kinetics of GLV uptake remains largely unknown. Here, we illustrate the effect of stomatal closure on the timing and magnitude of GLV uptake. We closed stomata by either exposing maize (Zea mays) plants to darkness or applying abscisic acid, a phytohormone that closes the stomata in light. Then, we exposed maize seedlings to (Z)-3-hexen-1-ol and compared its dynamic uptake under different stomatal conditions. Additionally, we used (E)-3-hexen-1-ol, an isomer of (Z)-3-hexen-1-ol not made by maize, to exclude the role of internal GLVs in our assays. We demonstrate that closed stomata effectively prevent GLV entry into exposed plants, even at high concentrations. Furthermore, our findings indicate that reduced GLV uptake impairs GLV-driven induction of biosynthesis of sesquiterpenes, a group of GLV-inducible secondary metabolites, with or without herbivory. These results elucidate how stomata regulate the perception of GLV signals, thereby dramatically changing the plant responses to herbivory, particularly under water stress or dark conditions.

Different shifts in growth-defense tradeoff for above- and belowground of Miscanthus floridulus enhance tolerance to cadmium

The growth-defense tradeoff is a central mechanism for plants to cope with environmental challenges. Soil contamination with heavy metals, especially cadmium (Cd), can strongly influence the adaptive capacity of plants by modulating both growth and defense. However, how the growth-defense tradeoff adaptive to Cd stress and its dynamic patterns are not yet known. To elucidate these patterns, we conducted an experiment with the pioneer plant Miscanthus floridulus by subjecting it to a gradient of exogenous Cd concentrations, and calculated root mean square deviation based on 12 traits to decipher the direction and intensity of the growth-defense tradeoff. We observed that growth traits such as photosynthetic rate, chlorophyll content, above- and belowground biomass, root surface area and root diameter decreased under Cd stress, while the antioxidative compounds increased. Notably, both above- and belowground parts showed a preference for growth in the absence of Cd stress (tradeoff intensity= 0.013 and 0.013, respectively, unitless). However, under the high Cd stress (40 mg/kg), the aboveground tradeoff remained towards growth (tradeoff intensity= 0.024), while the belowground tradeoff shifted towards defense (tradeoff intensity= −0.046). Under 10 and 20 mg/kg Cd stress, the shifts were uncertain towards either growth or defense for above and belowground parts, suggesting a complex above-belowground interplay. The belowground tradeoff was mainly influenced by plant Cd accumulation, soil fluorescein diacetate hydrolase (S.FDA), and soil available potassium. In contrast, the aboveground tradeoff was primarily driven by plant hydrogen peroxide (H₂O₂) accumulation, S.FDA, and soil alkaline phosphomonoesterase. Overall, Cd in soil altered physicochemical properties and Cd accumulation, which in turn had a significant impact on belowground defense mechanisms. We revealed that the shifts in growth-defense tradeoff differed between aboveground and belowground under Cd stress. Our results provided a new insight into the physiological and biochemical mechanisms underlying plant adaptation to Cd stress from the perspective of the growth-defense tradeoff.

The metabolic network response and tolerance mechanism of Thalassia hemprichii under high sulfide based on widely targeted metabolome and transcriptome

Costal eutrophication leads to increased sulfide levels in sediments, which has been identified as a major cause of the global decline in seagrass beds. The seagrass Thalassia hemprichii, a dominant tropical species in the Indo-Pacific, is facing a potential threat from sulfide, which can be easily reduced from sulfate in porewater under the influence of global climate change and eutrophication. However, its metabolic response and tolerance mechanisms to high sulfide remain unclear. Thus, the current study investigated the physiological responses and programmed metabolic networks of T. hemprichii through a three-week mesocosm experiment, integrating physiology, stable isotope, widely targeted metabolomics, transcriptomics, and microbial diversity assessments. High sulfide reduced the sediment microbial diversity, while increased sediment sulfate reduced bacterial abundance and δ34S. The exposure to sulfide enhanced root δ34S while decreased leaf δ34S in T. hemprichii. High sulfide was shown to inhibit photosynthesis via damaging PSII, which further reduced ATP production. In response, abundant up-regulated differentially expressed genes in energy metabolism, especially in oxidative phosphorylation, were activated to compensate high energy requirement. High sulfide also promoted autophagy by overexpressing the genes related to phagocytosis and phagolysosome. Meanwhile, metabolomic profiling revealed that the contents of many primary metabolites, such as carbohydrates and amino acids, were reduced in both leaves and roots, likely to provide more energy and synthesize stress-responsive secondary metabolites. Genes related to nitrate reduction and transportation were up-regulated to promote N uptake for sulfide detoxification. High sulfide levels specifically enhanced thiamine in roots, while increased jasmonic acid and flavonoid levels in leaves. The distinct differences in metabolism between roots and leaves might be related to sulfide levels and the growth-defense trade-off. Collectively, our work highlights the specific mechanisms underlying the response and tolerance of T. hemprichii to high sulfide, providing new insights into seagrass strategies for resisting sulfide.

Sweet Immunity in Action: Unlocking Stem Reserves to Improve Yield and Quality. A Potential Key Role for Jasmonic Acid.

Common agronomic practices such as stem topping, side branch removal, and girdling can induce wound priming, mediated by jasmonic acid (JA). Low light conditions during greenhouse tomato production make the leaves more sensitive to the application of exogenous sugar, which is perceived as a "danger" in accordance with the concept of "Sweet Immunity". Consequently, source-sink balances are altered, leading to the remobilization of stem starch reserves and enabling the redirection of more carbon toward developing fruits, thereby increasing tomato yield and fruit quality. Similarities are drawn with the mobilization of fructans following defoliation of fodder grasses (wounding) and the remobilization of fructan and starch reserves under terminal drought and heat stress in wheat and rice (microwounding, cellular leakage). A central role for JA signaling is evident in all of these processes, closely intertwining with sugar signaling pathways. Therefore, JA signaling, associated with wounding and sugar priming events, offers numerous opportunities to alter source-sink balances across a broader spectrum of agricultural and horticultural crops, for instance, through the exogenous application of JA and fructans or a combination. This may entail reconfiguring and reversing phloem connections, potentially leading to an enhanced yield and product quality. Such processes may also disengage the growth-defense trade-off in plants.

You can have your cake and eat it too: Ectopic expression of COLD-REGULATED genes reshapes the salicylic acid-mediated growth-defense tradeoff.

You can have your cake and eat it too: Ectopic expression of COLD-REGULATED genes reshapes the salicylic acid-mediated growth-defense tradeoff.

Does introduced European Phragmites australis experience belowground microbial enemy release in North America?

AbstractEscape from native range enemies can give invasive species a competitive edge according to the enemy‐release hypothesis. While more commonly associated with predators and herbivores, release from belowground microbial antagonists has been recently demonstrated to benefit invasive plants. Biogeographic variation in dominance and comparisons of soil communities suggest that invasive European Phragmites australis may have also benefitted from belowground enemy release in North America (NA). Here we examine the effects of native range (Europe) versus introduced range (NA) soil communities on European and North American P. australis using a reciprocal inoculation seedling growth experiment. Contrary to the enemy‐release hypothesis, we found that North American P. australis was sensitive to soil community origin in that the seedlings grown in European soil communities had higher total biomass than seedlings grown in North American soil communities. This pattern was not observed in the European P. australis seedlings which had similar biomass when grown with North American or European soil communities. Notably, North American P. australis had higher biomass than European P. australis regardless of which soil community it was grown in, suggesting a growth–defense tradeoff. Though the relative abundance of mutualists and pathogens composition did not differ between the two ranges, an indicator analysis revealed that mutualistic fungi and bacteria were key components of European soil communities but not in North American communities. Interestingly, North American soil communities had lower β diversity than European communities suggesting higher levels of community conservation among North American populations. This research represents the first evidence of growth–defense trade‐offs in North American P. australis and offers a novel mechanism in understanding the invasion of P. australis in NA.

Altering cold-regulated gene expression decouples the salicylic acid-growth trade-off in Arabidopsis.

In Arabidopsis (Arabidopsis thaliana), overproduction of salicylic acid (SA) increases disease resistance and abiotic stress tolerance but penalizes growth. This growth-defense trade-off has hindered the adoption of SA-based disease management strategies in agriculture. However, investigation of how SA inhibits plant growth has been challenging because many SA-hyperaccumulating Arabidopsis mutants have developmental defects due to the pleiotropic effects of the underlying genes. Here, we heterologously expressed a bacterial SA synthase gene in Arabidopsis and observed that elevated SA levels decreased plant growth and reduced the expression of cold-regulated (COR) genes in a dose-dependent manner. Growth suppression was exacerbated at below-ambient temperatures. Severing the SA-responsiveness of individual COR genes was sufficient to overcome the growth inhibition caused by elevated SA at ambient and below-ambient temperatures while preserving disease- and abiotic-stress-related benefits. Our results show the potential of decoupling SA-mediated growth and defense trade-offs for improving crop productivity.

Phenotypic and Gene Expression Analysis of Fruit Development of ‘Rojo Brillante’ and ‘Fuyu’ Persimmon (Diospyros kaki L.) Cultivars in Two Different Locations

Fruit development and maturation rely on intrinsic genetic programs involving hormone biosynthesis and signalling and environmental cues, integrating phenological cycles and climatic issues encompassing abiotic stresses and climate change. In persimmon trees, environmental inputs strongly influence fitness and agricultural performance, and fruit yield can be severely compromised by them. We have grown two persimmon accessions (‘Rojo Brillante’ and ‘Fuyu’) under contrasting meteorological conditions of two locations in Spain and Japan. Fruit size, colour change, and firmness parameters were followed during fruit development from 30 days after fruit set until commercial ripening, and the expression of genes related to ethylene production and signalling, gibberellin response, carotenoid biosynthesis, cell wall dynamics, and oxidative stress were reported. Genes depending on intrinsic developmental programs (ethylene and ripening variables, mostly) showed common expression trends in both cultivars and locations, whereas gibberellin and abiotic stress-related genes mimicked reduced fruit growth and abiotic stress associated with higher summer temperatures (>35 °C) and lower rainfall reported in the Spanish location. The expression pattern of these genes is consistent with a growth–defence trade-off that explains fruit differential growth through hormonal and stress tolerance mechanisms.

The lowdown on breakdown: Open questions in plant proteolysis.

Proteolysis, including post-translational proteolytic processing as well as protein degradation and amino acid recycling, is an essential component of the growth and development of living organisms. In this article, experts in plant proteolysis pose and discuss compelling open questions in their areas of research. Topics covered include the role of proteolysis in the cell cycle, DNA damage response, mitochondrial function, the generation of N-terminal signals (degrons) that mark many proteins for degradation (N-terminal acetylation, the Arg/N-degron pathway, and the chloroplast N-degron pathway), developmental and metabolic signaling (photomorphogenesis, abscisic acid and strigolactone signaling, sugar metabolism, and postharvest regulation), plant responses to environmental signals (endoplasmic-reticulum-associated degradation, chloroplast-associated degradation, drought tolerance, and the growth-defense trade-off), and the functional diversification of peptidases. We hope these thought-provoking discussions help to stimulate further research.

Are miRNAs applicable for balancing crop growth and defense trade-off?

Securing agricultural supplies for the increasing population without negative impacts on environment demands new crop varieties with higher yields, better quality, and stronger stress resilience. But breeding such super crop varieties is restrained by growth-defense (G-D) trade-off. MicroRNAs (miRNAs) are versatile regulators of plant growth and immune responses, with several being demonstrated to simultaneously regulate crop growth and defense against biotic stresses and to balance G-D trade-off. Increasing evidence also links miRNAs to the metabolism and signaling of phytohormones, another type of master regulator of plant growth and defense. Here, we synthesize the reported functions of miRNAs in crop growth, development, and responses to bio-stressors, summarize the regulatory scenarios of miRNAs based on their relationship with target(s), and discuss how miRNAs, particularly those involved in crosstalk with phytohormones, can be applied in balancing G-D trade-off in crops. We also propose several open questions to be addressed for adopting miRNAs in balancing crop G-D trade-off.

Transcriptome-wide N6-methyladenosine profiling reveals growth-defense trade-offs in the response of rice to brown planthopper (Nilaparvata lugens) infestation.

N6-Methyladenosine (m6A) is a common messenger RNA (mRNA) modification that affects various physiological processes in stress responses. However, the role of m6A modifications in plants responses to herbivore stress remains unclear. Here, we found that an infestation of brown planthopper (Nilaparvata lugens) female adults enhanced the resistance of rice to N. lugens. The m6A methylome analysis of N. lugens-infested and uninfested rice samples was performed to explore the interaction between rice and N. lugens. The m6A methylation mainly occurred in genes that were actively expressed in rice following N. lugens infestation, while an analysis of the whole-genomic mRNA distribution of m6A showed that N. lugens infestation caused an overall decrease in the number of m6A methylation sites across the chromosomes. The m6A methylation of genes involved in the m6A modification machinery and several defense-related phytohormones (jasmonic acid and salicylic acid) pathways was increased in N. lugens-infested rice compared to that in uninfested rice. In contrast, m6A modification levels of growth-related phytohormone (auxin and gibberellin) biosynthesis-related genes were significantly attenuated during N. lugens infestation, accompanied by the down-regulated expression of these transcripts, indicating that rice growth was restricted during N. lugens attack to rapidly optimize resource allocation for plant defense. Integrative analysis of the differential patterns of m6A methylation and the corresponding transcripts showed a positive correlation between m6A methylation and transcriptional regulation. The m6A modification is an important strategy for regulating the expression of genes involved in rice defense and growth during rice-N. lugens interactions. These findings provide new ideas for formulating strategies to control herbivorous pests. © 2024 Society of Chemical Industry.

The complex relationship between disease resistance and yield in crops.

In plants, growth and defence are controlled by many molecular pathways that are antagonistic to one another. This results in a 'growth-defence trade-off', where plants temporarily reduce growth in response to pests or diseases. Due to this antagonism, genetic variants that improve resistance often reduce growth and vice versa. Therefore, in natural populations, the most disease resistant individuals are often the slowest growing. In crops, slow growth may translate into a yield penalty, but resistance is essential for protecting yield in the presence of disease. Therefore, plant breeders must balance these traits to ensure optimal yield potential and yield stability. In crops, both qualitative and quantitative disease resistance are often linked with genetic variants that cause yield penalties, but this is not always the case. Furthermore, both crop yield and disease resistance are complex traits influenced by many aspects of the plant's physiology, morphology and environment, and the relationship between the molecular growth-defence trade-off and disease resistance-yield antagonism is not well-understood. In this article, we highlight research from the last 2 years on the molecular mechanistic basis of the antagonism between defence and growth. We then discuss the interaction between disease resistance and crop yield from a breeding perspective, outlining the complexity and nuances of this relationship and where research can aid practical methods for simultaneous improvement of yield potential and disease resistance.

From trade-off to synergy: microbial insights into enhancing plant growth and immunity.

The reduction in crop yield caused by pathogens and pests presents a significant challenge to global food security. Genetic engineering, which aims to bolster plant defence mechanisms, emerges as a cost-effective solution for disease control. However, this approach often incurs a growth penalty, known as the growth-defence trade-off. The precise molecular mechanisms governing this phenomenon are still not completely understood, but they generally fall under two main hypotheses: a "passive" redistribution of metabolic resources, or an "active" regulatory choice to optimize plant fitness. Despite the knowledge gaps, considerable practical endeavours are in the process of disentangling growth from defence. The plant microbiome, encompassing both above- and below-ground components, plays a pivotal role in fostering plant growth and resilience to stresses. There is increasing evidence which indicates that plants maintain intimate associations with diverse, specifically selected microbial communities. Meta-analyses have unveiled well-coordinated, two-way communications between plant shoots and roots, showcasing the capacity of plants to actively manage their microbiota for balancing growth with immunity, especially in response to pathogen incursions. This review centers on successes in making use of specific root-associated microbes to mitigate the growth-defence trade-off, emphasizing pivotal advancements in unravelling the mechanisms behind plant growth and defence. These findings illuminate promising avenues for future research and practical applications.

The growth promotion in endophyte symbiotic plants does not penalise the resistance to herbivores and bacterial microbiota.

A trade-off between growth and defence against biotic stresses is common in plants. Fungal endophytes of the genus Epichloë may relieve this trade-off in their host grasses since they can simultaneously induce plant growth and produce antiherbivore alkaloids that circumvent the need for host defence. The Epichloë ability to decouple the growth-defence trade-off was evaluated by subjecting ryegrass with and without Epichloë endophytes to an exogenous treatment with gibberellin (GA) followed by a challenge with Rhopalosiphum padi aphids. In agreement with the endophyte-mediated trade-off decoupling hypothesis, the GA-derived promotion of plant growth increased the susceptibility to aphids in endophyte-free plants but did not affect the insect resistance in endophyte-symbiotic plants. In line with the unaltered insect resistance, the GA treatment did not reduce the concentration of Epichloë-derived alkaloids. The Epichloë mycelial biomass was transiently increased by the GA treatment but at the expense of hyphal integrity. The response of the phyllosphere bacterial microbiota to both GA treatment and Epichloë was also evaluated. Only Epichloë, and not the GA treatment, altered the composition of the phyllosphere microbiota and the abundance of certain bacterial taxa. Our findings clearly demonstrate that Epichloë does indeed relieve the plant growth-defence trade-off.

Plant growth-defense trade-offs are general across interactions with fungal, insect, and mammalian consumers.

Plants face trade-offs between allocating resources to growth, while also defending against herbivores or pathogens. Species differences along defense trade-off axes may promote coexistence and maintain diversity. However, few studies of plant communities have simultaneously compared defense trade-offs against an array of herbivores and pathogens for which defense investment may differ, and even fewer have been conducted in the complex natural communities in which these interactions unfold. We tested predictions about the role of defense trade-offs with competition and growth in diversity maintenance by tracking plant species abundance in a field experiment that removed individual consumer groups (mammals, arthropods, fungi) and added nutrients. Consistent with a growth-defense trade-off, plant species that increased in mass in response to nutrient addition also increased when consumers were removed. This growth-defense trade-off occurred for all consumer groups studied. Nutrient addition reduced plant species richness, which is consistent with trade-off theory. Removing foliar fungi increased plant diversity via increased species evenness, whereas removal of other consumer groups had little effect on diversity, counter to expectations. Thus, while growth-defense trade-offs are general across consumer groups, this trade-off observed in wild plant communities does not necessarily support plant diversity maintenance.