Green Supplier Selection Problem Research Articles

An integrated GBWM-PROMETHEE-CLOUD & MCGP model for green supplier selection and order allocation (GSSOA) in an oil refinery

With the increase of environmental concerns in recent years and the prevalence of such issues, which originate mainly from large industries and manufacturing plants, green supply chain management (GSCM) issues have been given special attention among researchers. GSCM is a group of management applications integrating supply chain management with criteria related to environment and supplier selection with the purpose of reducing environmental pollution caused by processes involved in a company supply chain. In this research the main contributions is to draw a decision-making structure addressing the applicability of the green supplier selection (GSS) and order allocation (OA) problem in an Iranian Oil refinery company. A combination of Cloud-PROMETHEE along with using GBWM was taken into account for GSS as the first phase and MCGP method for OA as the second phase, in order to solve the GSSOA problem. The proposed technique lets the vagueness and uncertainty of experts' judgments be obtained by assisting uncertain linguistic variable derived from the cloud model. Furthermore, the group best-worst method (GBWM) obtains the optimal criteria weights by forming a nonlinear programing model and the prioritizing of nominated suppliers is established using the PROMETHEE method with the possibility to pick a distinct preference function for each criterion and draw a graph of supplier preferences. At last, MCGP method was applied considering with the possibility of multi-choice aspiration levels (MCAL) for each goal. The suggested model illustrated with actual figures in an oil refinery to provide insight to decision-makers of green supplier selection and order allocation. To do so, initially nine criteria have been derived after vast research on literature and experts’ opinions. Then the suppliers was successfully evaluated with considering uncertainties and randomness in a group of decision maker judgments. The order allocation was also completed by minimizing total cost and delays and maximizing purchase using results of supplier ranking in the first phase. Results have shown that the supplier with better ranking in GSS is preferred in allocating orders. A sensitivity analysis then performed and confirmed that the suggested method is highly stable against different changes in the data. The proposed method was also compared with the basic MCGDM cloud model and the method is approved. Finally, managerial implications and conclusions for additional researches are demonstrated.

COMPLEX INTUITIONISTIC FUZZY DOMBI PRIORITIZED AGGREGATION OPERATORS AND THEIR APPLICATION FOR RESILIENT GREEN SUPPLIER SELECTION

One of the main problems faced by resilient supply chain management is how to solve the problem of supplier selection, which is a typical multi-attribute decision-making (MADM) problem. Given the complexity of the current decision-making environment, the primary influence of this paper is to propose the theory of Dombi operational laws based on complex intuitionistic fuzzy (CIF) information. Moreover, we examined the theory of CIF Dombi prioritized averaging (CIFDPA) and CIF weighted Dombi prioritized averaging (CIFWDPA), where these operators are the modified version of the prioritized aggregation operators and Dombi aggregation operators for fuzzy, intuitionistic fuzzy, complex fuzzy and complex intuitionistic fuzzy information. Some reliable properties for the above operators are also established. Furthermore, to state the art of the proposed operators, an application example in the presence of the invented operators is evaluated for managing resilient green supplier selection problems. Finally, through comparative analysis with mainstream technologies, we provide some mechanism explanations for the proposed method to show the supremacy and worth of the invented theory.

A novel integrated approach based on best–worst and VIKOR methods for green supplier selection under multi-granularity extended probabilistic linguistic environment

With consideration for the extensive resources consumption and environmental degradation being on the rise today, implementing green development strategy to pursue both socioeconomic growth and the coordinated of environment sustainability, has become an increasingly important issue in modern enterprise supply chain operations management. Hence, the appropriate green supplier selection (GSS), viewed as a core issue in green supply chain management (GSCM), requires continuous research in this field to obtain a complete perception on GSS practices. It can be regarded as a multi-attribute group decision-making (MAGDM) problem that involves many conflict and unmeasurable evaluation criteria. In view of the superiority of multi-granularity extended probabilistic linguistic term sets (MGEPLTSs) in modeling such issues on potential ambiguity, complexity and uncertainty in actual GSS practices, we propose a novel integrated MAGDM methodology for GSS problems, by integrating the BWM (best–worst method) with the VIKOR (VIšekriterijumsko KOmpromisno Rangiranje) technique under the MGEPLTSs environment. First, by introducing the multi-granularity and probabilistic linguistic term sets, the MGEPLTSs are proposed to represent and quantify the decision information of GSCM practitioners. Then, the BWM is introduced to the MGEPLTSs environment to compute the weights of decision-making panels and evaluation attributes in GSS problems, by building the fuzzy mathematical programming model, respectively. Finally, we extend a multi-granularity extended probabilistic linguistic VIKOR method to calculate the compromise measure of alternatives considering the group utility maximization and the individual regret minimization, thereby achieving the full ranking of alternatives. A GSS case is conducted to illustrate the feasibility of the proposed approach, and the sensitivity analysis and comparative analysis with other similar approaches are presented to demonstrate its effectiveness and advantages.

Modified TODIM method based on cumulative prospect theory with Type-2 neutrosophic number for green supplier selection

Today’s consumers’ awareness of environmental protection and social morality is forcing companies to implement sustainable supply chains. Choosing a green supplier can not only determine the sustainable development of the supply chain, but also protect the environment and enhance the company’s reputation, in line with the background of green development. Green supplier selection is a multi-attribute decision-making (MADM) problem. Type-2 neutrosophic number (T2NN) can be compatible with more fuzzy information, and the green supplier selection problem also has a lot of fuzzy information, which makes T2NN very suitable for supplier selection. In this paper, a new method named CPT-TODIM-CDMT is proposed for green supplier selection of T2NN set based on TODIM. A new distance measure named cosine distance measure is proposed for T2NN set, and is applied in TODIM method. In this new method, attribute weight is determined by entropy method and optimized by CPT. The gains and losses preference in the CPT is also applied to the step of calculating the dominance degree in the TODIM method. A case study is used to verify the method. Through the comparison of the results of different decision-making models and the sensitivity research of the coefficients in the model, the correctness, validity and stability of the model are verified.

Comprehensive quantity discount model for dynamic green supplier selection and order allocation

We model and solve a deterministic multi-period single-product green supplier selection and order allocation problem in which the considered suppliers’ availability, cost, and green performance change from one period to another in the planning horizon. Moreover, the available suppliers may offer an all-unit or an incremental quantity discount (QD) scheme, resulting in three problem configurations. In one configuration, all suppliers offer all-unit QD. In the second, all suppliers offer incremental QD. In the third, some suppliers offer all-unit QD, and others offer incremental QD. The problem is modeled using a bi-objective integer linear programming formulation that maximizes the total green value of the purchased items from all the suppliers and minimizes their total corresponding cost, including the fixed cost, variable cost, inventory holding cost, and shortage cost. The proposed bi-objective model is scalarized and solved using the branch-and-cut algorithm and a population-based heuristic. A numerical analysis is conducted, which allows first to validate the heuristic approach using small-size instances by comparing its results with those of the exact approach. Moreover, an extensive comparison between the exact and heuristic solution approaches is carried out. The results reveal different findings. First, the economic and environmental solutions of an instance are different, and the environmental solution is independent of the suppliers’ pricing schemes. Second, the maximum difference between the heuristic approach and the exact approach in terms of the bi-objective function value is 4.72%, which makes the proposed heuristic recommended for large-size instances due to its short computation time and good accuracy. Third, there is no difference in terms of the heuristic performance between the combined model and the models with a single type of discount. Fourth, the all-unit discount scheme seems to be generally better in terms of the trade-off between the green value of purchasing and cost.

On utilizing modified TOPSIS with R-norm q-rung picture fuzzy information measure green supplier selection.

The present communication introduces a new discriminant measure coined as R-norm q-rung picture fuzzy discriminant information measure which is more generalized in nature and has the capability to handle more flexibility inherited in the inexact information. The notion of q-rung picture fuzzy set (q-RPFS) has an integrated advantage of picture fuzzy set and q-rung orthopair fuzzy set with flexibility of qth level relations. The proposed parametric measure is then applied in the conventional "technique for order preference by similarity to the ideal solution (TOPSIS) method" for solving a green supplier selection problem. The numerical illustration to exhibit the proposed methodology for the green supplier selection problem has been presented in an empirical form to establish the consistency of the model. Also, the advantageous features of the proposed scheme in the setup of impreciseness have been discussed.

Green supplier selection problems with data scaling and production frontier estimations in a DEA model

AbstractConsidering ecological issues in supplier evaluation and management alongside business considerations is getting more recognition among firms. Data envelopment analysis (DEA) is one of those methods, which is frequently suggested by the literature to support management decisions. However, the data requirements of the method should be an important consideration. The literature often addresses the issue of desirable outputs and undesirable input as an important data related problem in case of the ecological use of DEA. This paper will present a new solution to manage these data problems along with connecting the evaluation of management criteria, environmental criteria and total cost aspects. The proposed environmental supplier selection problem is an extension of a former paper. The new model examines the effect of inventory related costs, such as EOQ costs of inventory holding or ordering costs on the selected supplier, extended with newly introduced scaled values of input and output indicators. The usage of scaled values is motivated by the problem of invariance to data alteration. In addition to the uncertainty of the data, the paper looks for a functional relationship between the input and output criterion values and the efficiency that can be assigned to them using DEA.

A robust optimization model for green supplier selection and order allocation in a closed-loop supply chain considering cap-and-trade mechanism

Due to increasing air pollution, which is a consequence of the environmental effects of production in various industries, green supply chain management (GSCM) has attracted the attention of both scholars and practitioners. Green supplier selection is an important problem in GSCM and seeks to satisfy a firm’s environmental goals as well as its economic targets. In this paper, for the first time, a green supplier selection problem considering both green and non-green evaluation criteria in a closed-loop supply chain is studied, and a cap-and-trade mechanism as a way of controlling the air pollution caused by manufacturers is proposed. To solve this particular problem, we propose a multi-objective robust optimization (RO) model. This specific model is an effective approach to handle uncertainty. A numerical example using randomly generated data, accompanied by subsequent discussion of the proposed approach, is deployed to validate the model. The results prove that the developed model for green supplier selection is able to effectively enhance the decision-making process of the experts. By illustrating the trade-off in robustness between the model and proposed solutions, as well as the effect of the deviation penalty on the closeness of results to the achieved solution, we show how firms can make optimal decisions when assigning the parameters. Furthermore, analyses show that decreasing the allowance amount (cap) and increasing the allowance prices in the cap-and-trade system escalate the firms’ costs, but lower the amount of carbon released. Finally, we show that the cap-and-trade mechanism results in a better solution in terms of the total utility of the supply chain compared to the penalty-based system for a specific range of carbon allowance.

A flexible group decision-making method for green supplier selection integrating MABAC and CRITIC method under the linguistic Z-numbers environment

This paper intends to treat the green supplier selection (GSS) problem as a multi-attribute group decision making (MAGDM) problem, adopt the linguistic Z-number that can more flexibly and accurately express the evaluation information, and expand the traditional multi-attribute boundary approximate area comparison (MABAC) method, combine the CRITIC method of standard importance and consider the risk vector to finally determine the optimal solution. More specifically, the linguistic Z-number is used to describe the fuzzy evaluation information of experts on alternatives under attributes, then the expanded CRITIC method is used to obtain the weight of each given attribute, and finally the MABAC method with added risk vector and expanded is used to obtain the ranking of alternatives and obtain the best solution. Finally, taking green supplier selection as an example, and comparing with other methods, the reliability and effectiveness of the constructed method are verified. The results show that this method can express the evaluation information of experts flexibly and completely, and obtain the ranking results of given schemes through fewer steps, which is reliable and effective.

Green Supplier Selection Based on the Combination of Fuzzy SWARA (SWARA-F) and Fuzzy MARCOS (MARCOS-F) Methods

The green supply chain operations try to minimize environmental impact over the product's lifetime including product recycling or use, reduction of harmful substances, resource saving, green design, etc. Supplier selection is the vital issue in green purchasing. This paper aims to develop applicable and efficient methodology for green supplier selection. The proposed methodology includes the combination of Fuzzy Stepwise Weight Assessment Ratio Analysis (SWARA-F) and Fuzzy Measurement Alternatives and Ranking according to the COmpromise Solution (MARCOS-F) methods. Fuzzy extensions of these methods are preferred because of the complexity of the green supplier selection problem and inclusion of both quantitative and qualitative criteria. Also, these criteria may be uncertain and conflict with each other. It is the first time that SWARA-F is combined with MARCOS-F for the green supplier assessment and selection of the best one among them. The effectiveness of the proposed methodology is demonstrated by solving the real selection problem of a company from textile industry. In the problem both classic and green criteria including main and sub-criteria are considered. SWARA-F is used for weighting the evaluation criteria and the rank of each green supplier alternatives is obtained from incomplete information by assessment score calculated from MARCOS-F. The effectiveness of the combination of two methods is verified by sensitivity and comparative analyses. The proposed methodology provides acceptable and satisfactory results in determining the best green supplier namely improving the environmental and cost efficiency evaluation process.

Fuzzy Multi-Criteria Analyses on Green Supplier Selection in an Agri-Food Company

The way agri-food companies conduct business has changed as a result of changes in the market. These companies must start working in a more environmentally friendly manner. This study aims to examine, assess, and compare how various fuzzy methodologies are applied in green supplier selection (GSS), using an agri-food industry as an example. The company Biljana Brko, which engages in GSS, was observed in this study. The selection aids in the acquisition of raw materials and materials whose environmental impact will be minimized. Ecological and economic factors were taken into consideration when choosing green suppliers. Experts who assessed the weight of the criteria and the suppliers with linguistic values were chosen to carry out this selection. In order to do this, a fuzzy set that effectively applies these linguistic values was employed. The fuzzy SWARA (FSWARA) approach was utilized to calculate the weights of the criteria, revealing that the criterion of Environmental Management System has the highest weight. Drawing on the opinions of experts, suppliers were ranked using the fuzzy MABAC, MARCOS, and CRADIS techniques. The results show that supplier S2 receives the highest ratings. Along with this provider, supplier S3 is noteworthy because it excelled in the sensitivity analysis across a variety of scenarios. In light of this, Biljana Brko should give preference to these suppliers. Further, the results of the three adopted techniques were compared. The comparison reveals that the ranking order produced by all three techniques is remarkably similar. This supplier order differed slightly from the FMABAC method just in one scenario. Hence, this work demonstrates that the three fuzzy techniques can solve the GSS problem and other problems by ranking alternatives.

INTUITIONISTIC MULTIPLICATIVE SET APPROACH FOR GREEN SUPPLIER SELECTION PROBLEM USING TODIM METHOD

Production and supply chain can be considered as the fundamentals of economic cycle for all countries. As a result of climate crisis in the world and the disasters it brought, the use of green products has become inevitable. With the restrictions imposed by some governments, suppliers have started to canalize their productions to environmental goods and the selection of most appropriate green supplier become a strategic decision. However, classical methods remain incapable to making these decisions due to the uncertain information contained in real life problems. Intuitionistic multiplicative information is a good choice dealing with these uncertainties in this kind of problems. Therefore, in this work, green supplier selection problem is discussed using TODIM method with intuitionistic multiplicative sets.

Evaluation and selection of green suppliers for papermaking enterprises using the interval basic probability assignment-based intuitionistic fuzzy set

With the vigorous development of the global economy, modern enterprises have agreed to implement green supply chain management. The evaluation and selection of green suppliers plays a vital role in successful green supply chain management. As a multi-attribute group decision-making green supplier selection problem, it is difficult to fully describe the evaluation factors using precise numerical values and classical fuzzy sets, so it cannot assist enterprise managers in making completely reasonable decisions. Therefore, this paper proposes a green supplier evaluation and selection method based on interval BPA-based intuitionistic fuzzy sets. First, build a green supplier evaluation index system based on the characteristics of the papermaking enterprise's suppliers. Then, the intuitionistic fuzzy number is used to express the indicators of the evaluator for each supplier, and the intuitionistic fuzzy information is integrated through the organic combination of the IIFWA integration operator and the structural entropy weight to obtain the comprehensive evaluation value of the evaluator. Finally, the interval BPA-based intuitionistic fuzzy set method ranks the candidate suppliers and determines the best green supplier. Applying this method to the field of green supplier evaluation and selection can provide an effective method for enterprises to select suppliers scientifically and reasonably, which has practical reference value and practical significance.

A green supplier selection framework in polyethylene industry

Purpose To outsource part of their work, organizations are looking for suppliers who also have green criteria with other criteria. Selecting suppliers begins with the definition of potential suppliers and then selects the best among them. This study aims to present a two-part approach for selecting suppliers consisting of suppliers’ prioritization. Design/methodology/approach In the first part, the criteria that influence on selecting the suppliers have been identified and extracted using the literature review and experts’ opinion which consists of 19 criteria. Then, these criteria were evaluated by the content validity ratio index and using experts’ opinions, and finally, 16 criteria were selected for selecting green suppliers in a polyethylene’s products producer company in Iran. In the next step, suppliers are selected in a green supply chain using multi-criteria decision-making methods such as Dempster–Shafer theory and grey relationship analysis, which is a strategic decision. Findings This study attempts to improve the level of reliance on the whole uncertain degree by combining Dempster–Shafer theory and grey relational analysis (GRA), which makes the grey analysis method more robust and its results more reliable. The findings show that Supplier 4 is ranked as first within six suppliers. Originality/value Using GRA and Dempster–Shafer theory for green supplier selection problem in polyethylene industry is the novelty of this work.

Pythagorean Cubic fuzzy Hamacher aggregation operators and their application in green supply selection problem

<abstract><p>The green chain supplier selection process plays a major role in the environmental decision for the efficient and effective supply chain management. Therefore, the aim of this paper is to develop a mechanism for decision making on green chain supplier problem. First, we define the Hamacher operational law for Pythagorean cubic fuzzy numbers (PCFNs) and study their fundamental properties. Based on the Hamacher operation law of PCFNs, we defined Pythagorean cubic fuzzy aggregation operators by using Hamacher t-norm and t-conorm. Further, we develop a series of Pythagorean cubic fuzzy Hamacher weighted averaging (PCFHWA), Pythagorean cubic fuzzy Hamacher order weighted averaging (PCFHOWA) Pythagorean Cubic fuzzy Hamacher hybrid averaging (PCFHHA), Pythagorean Cubic fuzzy Hamacher weighted Geometric (PCFHWG), Pythagorean Cubic fuzzy Hamacher order weighted Geometric (PCFHOWG), and Pythagorean Cubic fuzzy Hamacher hybrid geometric (PCFHHA) operators. Furthermore, we apply these aggregation operators of Pythagorean Cubic fuzzy numbers to the decision making problem for green supplier selection. We construct an algorithm for the group decision making by using aggregation operators and score function. The proposed decision making method applies to green chain supplier selection problem and find the best green supplier for green supply chain management. The proposed method compared with other group decision techniques under Pythagorean cubic fuzzy information. From the comparison and sensitivity analysis, we concluded that our proposed method is more generalized and effective method.</p></abstract>

Deriving the personalized individual semantics of linguistic information from flexible linguistic preference relations

In group decision making, flexible linguistic preference relations (FLPRs) are very useful with the pairwise comparisons taking the form of flexible linguistic expressions (FLEs). Due to the fact that different decision makers have different understandings of words, this paper investigates the personalized individual semantics (PISs) of the linguistic information in FLPRs. Two optimization models are constructed to compute a linguistic distribution which is closest to an incomplete FLE. The FLPRs are transformed into fuzzy preference relations by using optimization models which maximize consistency and consensus of the fuzzy preference relations. The PISs of linguistic terms and subsets of the linguistic term set are obtained in this process. A group decision making model based on FLPRs is presented and a green supplier selection problem in automotive industry is solved by using the proposed model. The comparative analysis is presented to show the feasibility of the group decision making model.

A fuzzy rule-based multi-criterion approach for a cooperative green supplier selection problem.

Multi-criterion decision-making models are widely used in supplier selection problems. This study contributes to a green supplier selection problem considering the green manufacturing, green transportation, and green procurement. This study contributes to reverse logistics, eco-design, reusing, recycling, and remanufacturing with their high impact on the industries. In addition to the logistics costs and transportation costs, the carbon emissions are considered. With regard to the game theory, this paper uses a cooperative green supplier selection model. If transportation requirements of two or more companies are combined, it will help manufacturers to have less {CO}_{2} emissions with lower cost. After creating the optimization model to consider the uncertainty, this cooperative game theory model is established in a fuzzy environment. In this regard, a fuzzy rule-based (FRB) system is deployed and the set of fuzzy IF–THEN rules is considered. The proposed FRB model is contributed for the first time in the area of green supplier selection problem. Finally, some sensitivity analyses are conducted in a numerical example to evaluate the proposed model. With regard to the findings, although the cost of CO2 emission of horizontal cooperation is increased, the cost saving of companies is increased. It means our total cost is optimal in a logistic network using the cooperative game theory. The results also indicate that horizontal cooperation in logistic network causes less cost and benefits for each company.Supplementary InformationThe online version contains supplementary material available at 10.1007/s11356-021-17015-2.

Representing a probabilistic linguistic term set with an interval type-2 fuzzy set and the application in green supplier selection

The use of probabilistic linguistic term sets (PLTSs) means the process of computing with words. The existing methods computing with PLTSs mainly use symbolic model. To provide a semantic model for computing with PLTSs, we propose to represent a PLTS by using an interval type-2 fuzzy set (IT2FS). The key step is to compute the footprint of uncertainty of the IT2FS. To this aim, the upper membership function is computed by aggregating the membership functions of the linguistic terms contained in the PLTS, and the lower membership function is obtained by moving the upper membership function downward with the step being total entropy of the PLTS. The comparison rules, some operations, and an aggregation operator for PLTSs are introduced. Based on the proposed method of computing with PLTSs, a multi-criteria group decision making model is introduced. The proposed decision making model is then applied in green supplier selection problem to show its feasibility.

Green supplier selection for textile industry: a case study using BWM-TODIM integration under interval type-2 fuzzy sets.

Although environmental awareness has reached a high level, enterprises-regardless of their working domains-follow the concept of greenness for their practices. This awareness among the stakeholders and supply chain experts has a positive impact on the purchasing departments of enterprises in various sectors to consider greenness in their procurement processes. The critical decision that must be made in green supply chain management (GSCM) is supplier selection. In the textile industry, a highly competitive market in recent years, suppliers for this industry have crucial roles in business activities considering environmental issues. Therefore, green supplier selection (GSS) in the textile industry is considered a must-be process for the stakeholders. In this study, a GSS problem is tackled as a multi-criteria decision process. Best worst method (BWM) and TODIM (an acronym in Portuguese of interactive and multi-criteria decision-making) methods are merged under an improved fuzzy concept of interval type-2 fuzzy sets (IT2FSs). In determining green suppliers' evaluation criteria, BWM with interval type-2 fuzzy numbers (IT2F-BWM) is used. In selecting green suppliers, an interval type-2 fuzzy TODIM (IT2F-TODIM) is applied. Considering the characteristics of IT2FSs, BWM, and TODIM methods either individually and in integrated style, the proposed approach can handle uncertainty in the decision-making of GSS. To demonstrate the applicability of the approach, a case study in the Turkish textile industry is performed. Three green supplier alternatives (S1, S2, and S3) are assessed under forty-two sub-criteria. The study shows the most significant sub-criteria are recognized as dye and print quality, product design and pattern suitability, profit on the product, variation in price, and purchase cost. S2 green supplier has been selected as the most appropriate one. A sensitivity analysis is also fulfilled to check variation in the ranking of green suppliers.

A NOVEL APPROACH FOR GREEN SUPPLIER SELECTION PROBLEM: FUZZY AXIOMATIC DESIGN WITH RISK FACTORS

Today’s environmental conscious world forces companies to be more about energy and water consumption. New trends in the world generally provide competitive advantage to the firms if they work on environmental issues. As a critical decision of companies, supplier selection problem needs to consider the environmental factors and economical factors simultaneously. This study proposes a novel solution methodology for green supplier selection problem: Fuzzy axiomatic design with risk factors. This method is applied in many decision-making problems in the literature successfully. A case study is presented to implement the method and the results are compared with traditional fuzzy axiomatic design and fuzzy TOPSIS. It has seen that the decision of the best supplier selection can be influenced by the risk factors such as the deviation in the economical conditions or the working conditions of the company.