Green Roof Species Research Articles

Which Plant Species for Green Roofs in the Mediterranean Environment?

In recent years, owing to intense urbanization and global change with the consequent extreme climate effects, interest in green roofs, even extensive ones, in the Mediterranean environment has increased. To this end, the choice of plant species is crucial because, owing to the identification of the most suitable plants, it will be possible to expand this type of green infrastructure and increase its ecosystem services in the urban environment. In this context, the objective of the review, through a critical analysis of some of the references on the topic, is to identify suitable criteria for plant species selection that are simple to apply and able to respond to the need to have plants capable of surviving, ensuring a suitable aesthetic effect, and providing essential ecosystem services. We also investigated whether, and to what extent, associations of different species can better adapt to the difficult environmental conditions of Mediterranean green roofs. Two possible strategies to identify the plant idiotype were analyzed: the analysis of plants present in habitat analogues or the identification of morpho-functional characters capable of discriminating the response to abiotic stress, and in particular to drought stress. The use of plant communities, rather than a single species, seems capable of improving aesthetic effects, plant survival, and ecosystem services.

More than sedum: Colonizing weedy species can provide equivalent green roof ecosystem services

Green roofs are typically constructed for their provision of both environmental and associated economic benefits including increased habitat, thermal regulation, mitigation of air and noise pollution, and stormwater retention. The provision of these various ecosystem services is sharply influenced by plant species composition, with particular species and traits known to excel at specific services. For this reason, increased biodiversity can improve the overall provision of ecosystem services. However, one key contributor to green roof biodiversity, colonizing species, is understudied. In this study we examine the contribution of common colonizing species (lawn weeds) and one green roof species, to three important ecosystem services: stormwater retention, temperature reduction, and nitrogen retention. This experiment used replicated green roof modules to examine 13 different treatments: eight colonizing species in monoculture, one green roof species monoculture, two treatments with a mix of colonizing species, one treatment where vegetation was allowed to spontaneously colonize, and one substrate only control. Results from this study show that mixtures of colonizing species performed well for all three monitored ecosystem services, with a few of the monocultures, especially those with high biomass or canopy density, performing similarly. While it is unlikely that green roof installations would proceed equally well without adding vegetation, our results indicate that colonizing species can support a viable green roof ecosystem. This study shows that spontaneous growth and/or allowing new species to colonize may be a viable design alternative for green roofs, decreasing cost while maintaining the desired ecosystem services.

The Effect of Combined Drought and Temperature Stress on the Physiological Status of Calcareous Grassland Species as Potential Candidates for Urban Green Infrastructure.

Nature-based solutions are promising for climate adaptation and environmental management in urban areas, but urban conditions are stressful for vegetation. In particular, the interaction of drought and high temperatures may be detrimental. Guiding plant selection for urban greening with native species requires a far better knowledge of plant adaptations and stress acclimation. We tested the physiological responses of four candidate calcareous grassland species for green roofs and walls to the combined effects of drought and high temperatures under controlled conditions. The tested species proved relatively resistant to stress despite different strategies to protect the photosynthetic apparatus, maintain water balance, and repair damages. Based on the physiological responses, we rank the species in descending order of resistance to the stress factors tested: Trifolium medium > Festuca ovina > Carex flacca > Potentilla reptans, but all four can serve as potential candidates for green walls and roofs. Physiological stress screening of plant species for use on green roofs and walls supplements the habitat template approach to provide a stronger and wider base for prioritizations.

Plant water use related to leaf traits and CSR strategies of 10 common European green roof species

The vegetation layer contributes to multiple functions of green roofs including their hydrological function as plants remove water from substrates between rainfall events through evapotranspiration, restoring the green roofs storage capacity for rainfall retention. While individual traits have been related to water use strategies of green roof plants, these traits are inconsistent, suggesting the importance of trait combinations which may be reflected in CSR (competitor, stress tolerator, ruderal) strategies. Therefore, relating plant water use to leaf traits and CSR strategies could help facilitate green roof plant selection into new geographical regions where green roof technology is developing. For example, in high latitude northern European regions with long daylight during the growing season. Growth (shoot biomass, relative growth rate and leaf area), leaf traits (leaf dry matter content, specific leaf area and succulence) and CSR strategies were determined of 10 common European green roof plants and related to their water use under well-watered (WW) and water-deficit (WD) conditions. All three succulent species included in the experiment showed mostly stress tolerant traits and their water loss was less than the bare unplanted substrate, likely due to mulching of the substrate surface. Plants with greater water use under WW conditions had more ruderal and competitive strategies, and greater leaf area and shoot biomass, than species with lower WW water use. However, the four species with the highest water use under WW conditions were able to downregulate their water use under WD, indicating that they could both retain rainfall and survive periods of water limitations. This study indicates that, for optimal stormwater retention, green roof plant selection in high latitude regions like northern Europe, should focus on selecting non-succulent plants with predominantly competitive or ruderal strategies to make the most of the long daylight during the short growing season.

Plant Water Use Related to Leaf Traits and CSR Strategies of 10 Green Roof Species

Plant Water Use Related to Leaf Traits and CSR Strategies of 10 Green Roof Species

Transformation of Plant to Resource Acquisition Under High Nitrogen Addition Will Reduce Green Roof Ecosystem Functioning.

Ecosystem engineering, such as green roof, provides numerous key ecosystem functions dependent on both plants and environmental changes. In the recent years, global nitrogen (N) deposition has become a hot topic with the intensification of anthropogenic disturbance. However, the response of green roof ecosystems to N deposition is still not clear. To explore the effects of N addition on plant ecological strategy and ecosystem functioning (biomass), we conducted a 3-month N addition simulation experiment using 12 common green roof species from different growth forms on an extensive green roof in Tianjin, China. The experiment included three different N addition treatments (0, 3.5, and 10.5 gN m–2 year–1). We found that plants with the resource-acquisitive strategy were more suitable to survive in a high N environment, since both aboveground and belowground traits exhibited synergistic effects. Moreover, N addition indirectly decreased plant biomass, indicating that ecosystem functioning was impaired. We highlight that there is a trade-off between the survival of green roof species and keeping the ecosystem functioning well in the future N deposition. Meanwhile, these findings also provide insights into how green roof species respond to global climate change and offer important information for better managing and protecting similar ecosystem engineering in the background of high N deposition.

Fast plants have water-use and drought strategies that balance rainfall retention and drought survival on green roofs.

Green roofs can improve ecosystem services in cities; however, this depends on appropriate plant selection. For stormwater management, plants should have high water use to maximize retention and also survive dry periods. Plants adapted to wetter habitats develop "fast" traits for growth, whereas plants from drier habitats develop "slow" traits to conserve water use and survive drought. Therefore, we hypothesized that (1) plants with fast traits would have greater water use, (2) plants with slow traits would have greater drought tolerance, (3) fast-slow traits would be consistent across the plant, and (4) fast plants with greater water use could avoid drought stress. We evaluated 14 green roof species in a glasshouse experiment under well-watered (WW) and water-deficit (WD) conditions to determine relationships between fast-slow traits, water use, and drought resistance. Traits measured were shoot dry mass, specific leaf area (SLA), root mass fraction (RMF), and specific root length (SRL). Daily evapotranspiration per shoot dry mass was used to describe water use. Drought resistance was represented by (1) days to stomatal closure; (2) cumulative ET before stomatal closure; and (3) degree of iso-anisohydry (difference between midday leaf water potential (ΨMD ) of WW and WD plants; ΔΨMD ). Plants with greater water use had fast aboveground traits (greater shoot biomass and SLA). Plants with slow traits had greater drought tolerance as plants with lower shoot dry mass closed their stomata later under WD, and plants with greater root allocation were more anisohydric. Fast-slow traits were not consistent across the plant. Although SLA and SRL were positively related, SRL was not related to water use or drought resistance. Shoot dry mass was inversely related to SLA and had a stronger influence on stomatal closure. Though plants with greater water use under well-watered conditions closed their stomates earlier to avoid drought stress, they were not more isohydric (smaller ∆ΨMD ) and did not necessarily use more water under WD. Fast aboveground traits can be used to select green roof plants with high water use that avoid drought stress to optimize rainfall retention without jeopardizing drought survival. This will facilitate rapid plant selection using trait information from online databases.

Towards an experimental approach for measuring the removal of urban air pollutants by green roofs

Green roofs are a promising approach to mitigate air pollution in urban environments, but limited experimental data is yet available. In this study, we developed a laboratory-scale setup to measure the removal nitrogen dioxide (NO2) and ozone (O3) using a variety of common green roof species. Experiments were conducted on detached leaves and whole plants using two chambers (0.6 L and 12 L), visible lighting, NOx/O3 sources and online analyzers. Three species were the best performant (Thymus vulgaris, Sedum sexangulare and Heuchera Americana L.) with deposition velocities (vd) ranging from 1.6 to 4.82 m/h for NO2, and 1.7–5.56 m/h for O3. In both cases, thyme was the most effective plant likely due to its higher stomatal area and the reactivity of its volatile metabolites with O3 leading to several oxidized by-products. Furthermore, NO2 uptake was found to be enhanced by surface water released by leaf transpiration leading to the production of nitrous acid (HONO). Similar values of (vd) were observed (3.84–4.65 m/h) when whole thyme plant was used. The soil was also found to be competitive in removing O3 but less performant in capturing NO2. Using a dry deposition model, we estimated that the three plant species can uptake up to 9 kg/ha/year of NO2 and 13.6 kg/ha/year, which fall in agreement with previously reported modeling data. Our experimental approach can be a rapid tool for screening the depollution performances of green roof species enabling an effective prioritization for deployment in urban environments.

Green Roof Design with Engineered Extensive Substrates and Native Species to Evaluate Stormwater Runoff and Plant Establishment in a Neotropical Mountain Climate

Green roofs are increasingly being implemented in cities for their multiple environmental benefits. Their optimal design requires an appropriate selection of components, including substrates and plant species, to ensure local sustainability in the long term. The present study seeks to assess the runoff quality and quantity of extensive green roofs located in Bogotá (Colombia). The assessment consists of testing different substrates, designed using locally available constituents and a selection of native species. The best performing substrate mixtures, in terms of runoff volume reduction and plant establishment, were jointly evaluated with three native species (i.e., Paepalanthus alpinus, Achryrocline bogotensis and Echeveria ballsii). On average, engineered substrates presented significantly lower concentrations in several water quality parameters (electric conductivity, total phosphorus, phosphates, Total Kjeldahl Nitrogen, nitrates, nitrites, color, biological oxygen demand and chemical oxygen demand) than the commercial extensive substrate used as control. The species Paepalanthus alpinus and Echeveria ballsii showed significant establishment and were considered potentially suitable species for green roofs in Bogotá. The obtained results, therefore, provide recommendations for green roof design in neotropical mountain climate conditions.

Green roofs in the tropics: design considerations and vegetation dynamics

Green roofs (GR) have been proposed as a possible solution for urban stressors that, integrated with other remediation and mitigation actions, can lead the way to a more sustainable society. Even when some aspects of green roof design are well established and known (i.e. depth arrangements, materials, structural components, etc.) there is a need for further development on ecological attributes. This study is a descriptive analysis of suitable plant species for their possible incorporation in green roof designs with tropical climate conditions. Green roof research has been mostly led by temperate climate countries and has neglected to address tropical areas; this study aims to move research towards this knowledge gap. The evaluation of the vegetation dynamics in these novel ecosystems was done through a case study in the renovated facilities of the International Institute of Tropical Forestry in Río Piedras, Puerto Rico, which incorporated a set of green roofs in their infrastructure. We also sampled an older green roof built in the Social Sciences Faculty at the University of Puerto Rico at Río Piedras. A three-dimensional approach, the Point-Intercept Method, was taken in the vegetation surveys to capture as much as possible the green infrastructure of the roofs. Most of the originally planted species did not appear in these surveys. On the contrary, mainly new species dominated the areas. Along with the findings of these surveys and those in other tropical countries, a list of suitable species for green roofs in Puerto Rico is suggested, and some general recommendations are made for the better management of green roofs in tropical zones.

Biodiversity Impact of Green Roofs and Constructed Wetlands as Progressive Eco-Technologies in Urban Areas

The total amount of sealed surfaces is increasing in many urban areas, which presents a challenge for sewerage systems and wastewater treatment plants when extreme rainfall events occur. One promising solution approach is the application of decentralized eco-technologies for water management such as green roofs and constructed wetlands, which also have the potential to improve urban biodiversity. We review the effects of these two eco-technologies on species richness, abundance and other facets of biodiversity (e.g., functional diversity). We find that while green roofs support fewer species than ground-level habitats and thus are not a substitute for the latter, the increase in green roof structural diversity supports species richness. Species abundance benefits from improved roof conditions (e.g., increased substrate depth). Few studies have investigated the functional diversity of green roofs so far, but the typical traits of green roof species have been identified. The biodiversity of animals in constructed wetlands can be improved by applying animal-aided design rather than by solely considering engineering requirements. For example, flat and barrier-free shore areas, diverse vegetation, and heterogeneous surroundings increase the attractiveness of constructed wetlands for a range of animals. We suggest that by combining and making increasing use of these two eco-technologies in urban areas, biodiversity will benefit.

Selecting Potential Moss Species for Green Roofs in the Mediterranean Basin

Green roofs are important infrastructures to address the effects of climate change in urban areas. However, most studies and applications have been done in cooler and wetter regions of the northern hemisphere. Climate change will lead to more extreme weather events, such as increased drought and decreased precipitation with intense flash rain events. Increase desertification is expected especially in the Mediterranean Basin, where in summer, radiation and temperature are high and water is scarce. Therefore, while vascular plants increase water consumption in green roofs during warmer periods, mosses present themselves as potential candidates due to their poikilohydric nature, responding to the environmental availability of water, completely drying out and recovering upon rehydration. Although criteria for the selection of vascular plants adapted to the Mediterranean and suitable for green roofs have been developed, no information is available regarding the selection of mosses based on scientific criteria. Here we propose selection criteria for moss species based on ecological preferences according to Ellenberg’s values and help to define moss traits suitable for a nonirrigated, nature-based green roof that tolerates the Mediterranean climate. The main result is a table of potential candidate mosses that can be either used as standalone or in conjunction with vascular plants to decrease water usage and/or manage stormwater through an easily applicable selection methodology. For green roof practitioners, we proposed that acrocarpous mosses exhibiting turf/cushion life forms and colonist or perennial life strategies best fit the requirements for such a green infrastructure in extreme climate regions with scarce water resources.

The influence of plant type on green roof rainfall retention

Green roofs can mitigate the flood risk by reducing the volume of runoff through direct interception and subsequent evapotranspiration (ET), but the planting choices can influence the extent of this service. Glasshouse experiments were carried out in spring/summer using simulated rainfall to compare the rainfall retention capacity of three physiologically active broadleaf species (Heuchera micrantha, Salvia officinalis and Stachys byzantina), which have previously shown to provide improved rooftop cooling, to an industry standard green roof species, Sedum spurium. Furthermore, the impact of varying ambient temperature and humidity conditions on the ability of these species to restore the substrate retention capacity through ET was also tested in a series of controlled-environment experiments simulating a range of potential UK summertime scenarios. Canopies alone retained up to 17% (Sedum) of the total rainfall in this study, with Salvia and Stachys also retaining in excess of 10%, and can make a substantial contribution to rainfall retention on a green roof. Rainfall retention was also strongly correlated with total ET in the preceding 72 h (R2 = 0.94; P < 0.001). Species with high ET rates (Salvia and Stachys) were able to provide the greatest stormwater management service (up to 72% retention due to ET component). Furthermore, species ‘rankings’, in terms of ET and thus restoration of substrate retention capacity, were the same in all simulated potential UK summertime temperature and relative humidity scenarios, indicating that ‘superior’ species will be able to provide the greatest stormwater management provision in all climatic conditions.

Ecophysiological and micromorphological characterization of green roof vegetation for urban mitigation

Urban greening helps to improve environment quality and human health thanks to the ability of plants to absorb greenhouse gases and remove significant amounts of air pollutants. Green roofs, providing vegetated surfaces in dense cities, can help to mitigate the negative effects of urban pollution. The present study aimed to evaluate the potential ability of fifteen green roof species (Lonicera pileata, Satureja repandens, Hypericum moserianum, Erigeron karvinskianus, Solidago praecox, Rudbeckia sullivantii ‘Goldsturm’, Filipendula purpurea, Filipendula vulgaris ‘Kahome’, Gaura lindheimeri, Campanula persicifolia, Veronica longifolia, Sedum spectabile, Origanum vulgare, Salvia nemorosa, and Achillea millefolium) to mitigate carbon dioxide (CO2) and urban pollutant concentration analysing the leaf physiological traits (gas exchange) and morphological structures (stomata, trichomes, epicuticular waxes and cuticular ornamentation) involved in pollutant removal. Furthermore, considering the important role of biogenic volatile organic compounds (BVOC) on the photochemical reactivity of the atmosphere, their species-specific emission was also assessed together with the derived ozone forming potential (OFP). Our results suggested that the potential mitigation capacity based on the investigated traits of the shrubs and herbaceous species was species-specific. The very low potential of all the tested species to form ozone indicated their suitability for urban planning programs.

Plant species richness enhances nitrogen retention in green roof plots.

Vegetated (green) roofs have become common in many cities and are projected to continue to increase in coverage, but little is known about the ecological properties of these engineered ecosystems. In this study, we tested the biodiversity-ecosystem function hypothesis using commercially available green roof trays as replicated plots with varying levels of plant species richness (0, 1, 3, or 6 common green roof species per plot, using plants with different functional characteristics). We estimated accumulated plant biomass near the peak of the first full growing season (July 2013) and measured runoff volume after nearly every rain event from September 2012 to September 2013 (33 events) and runoff fluxes of inorganic nutrients ammonium, nitrate, and phosphate from a subset of 10 events. We found that (1) total plant biomass increased with increasing species richness, (2) green roof plots were effective at reducing storm runoff, with vegetation increasing water retention more than soil-like substrate alone, but there was no significant effect of plant species identity or richness on runoff volume, (3) green roof substrate was a significant source of phosphate, regardless of presence/absence of plants, and (4) dissolved inorganic nitrogen (DIN = nitrate + ammonium) runoff fluxes were different among plant species and decreased significantly with increasing plant species richness. The variation in N retention was positively related to variation in plant biomass. Notably, the increased biomass and N retention with species richness in this engineered ecosystem are similar to patterns observed in published studies from grasslands and other well-studied ecosystems. We suggest that more diverse plantings on vegetated roofs may enhance the retention capacity for reactive nitrogen. This is of importance for the sustained health of vegetated roof ecosystems, which over time often experience nitrogen limitation, and is also relevant for water quality in receiving waters downstream of green roofs.

Biosynthesis of gold nanoparticles using green roof species Portulaca grandiflora and their cytotoxic effects against C6 glioma human cancer cells

Leaf and stem extracts of popular green roof vegetation, Portulaca grandiflora, were used for the synthesis of gold nanoparticles. The synthesized gold nanoparticles were characterized using UV–visible spectroscopy, Fourier transform infrared (FTIR) spectroscopy, X‐ray diffraction (XRD), scanning electron microscopy (SEM) and transmission electron microscopy (TEM) analysis. FTIR results indicated the presence of proteins and polyphenols in plant extracts which were responsible for the reduction and stabilization of gold nanoparticles. SEM and TEM images confirmed the formation of spherical, rhombus, triangular, tetragonal, pentagonal, rods and hexagonal shaped gold nanoparticles. The size of the particles was in the range of 8 and 72 nm. The antiproliferative effects of synthesized gold nanoparticles were assessed using C6 glioma human cancer cells. Results indicated that gold nanoparticles synthesized using leaf extracts (150 µg/mL) and stem extracts (200 µg/mL) of P. grandiflora decreased the viability of C6 glioma cell lines up to 50%. © 2016 American Institute of Chemical Engineers Environ Prog, 35: 1732–1740, 2016

Integration of photovoltaic panels and green roofs: review and predictions of effects on electricity production and plant communities

The integration of photovoltaic (PV) panels and green roofs has the potential to improve panel efficiency to produce electricity and enhance green roof species diversity and productivity. In this review, we provide an overview of research on the effects of green roofs on PV panel electricity production, and predict the expected effects of the PV panel on green roof plant communities. Previous studies suggest that PV panels are more efficient above a green roof than above several types of conventional roofs due to the cooling effect of green roofs on the temperature-sensitive PV cells. Some ecological studies on shade suggest that shade imposed by panels may enhance the biotic productivity of green roofs. Shade is often shown to be important for seedling survival, particularly in arid environments – so the effect of shade on plants may depend on climate and irrigation. Previous studies also suggest that shade variations over the roof area may enhance plant diversity, as such heterogeneity creates niches of light and moisture levels that are appropriate for a diversity of plants. These positive effects on plant diversity may lead to increased arthropod diversity as well. Additional replicated studies are needed to test the reciprocal effects of green roofs and PV, as past studies lacked replication. Future directions for research that could guide the design of green roof–PV integration include the effects of irrigation, plant diversity, and green area-to-panel ratio on the roof.

Application of coastal vegetation to green roofs of residential buildings in Taiwan

Green roofs can alleviate the environmental impacts of reduced green areas resulting from rigorous urban developments. In Taiwan's hot and crowded urban environment, green roofs are indicative of green buildings. Rooftop plants must be able to withstand harsh natural environmental conditions. Coastal vegetation has a high level of tolerance. Therefore, this study selected the seashore coastal region seashore vegetation with landscape scenic features as well as drought, wind, and temperature resistance characteristics as materials for a green roof. Based on the records and analysis of vegetation characteristics provided by the Flora and Vegetation of Taiwan, this study selected coastal hilly plants, as well as coastal beach herbaceous plants, such as plant species for green roofs in Taiwan. A 10 m × 20 m reinforced concrete flat roof structure was selected and designed as the demonstration site to present the coastal vegetation rooftop garden.

Plant performance on Mediterranean green roofs: interaction of species-specific hydraulic strategies and substrate water relations.

Recent studies have highlighted the ecological, economic and social benefits assured by green roof technology to urban areas. However, green roofs are very hostile environments for plant growth because of shallow substrate depths, high temperatures and irradiance and wind exposure. This study provides experimental evidence for the importance of accurate selection of plant species and substrates for implementing green roofs in hot and arid regions, like the Mediterranean area. Experiments were performed on two shrub species (Arbutus unedo L. and Salvia officinalis L.) grown in green roof experimental modules with two substrates slightly differing in their water retention properties, as derived from moisture release curves. Physiological measurements were performed on both well-watered and drought-stressed plants. Gas exchange, leaf and xylem water potential and also plant hydraulic conductance were measured at different time intervals following the last irrigation. The substrate type significantly affected water status. Arbutus unedo and S. officinalis showed different hydraulic responses to drought stress, with the former species being substantially isohydric and the latter one anisohydric. Both A. unedo and S. officinalis were found to be suitable species for green roofs in the Mediterranean area. However, our data suggest that appropriate choice of substrate is key to the success of green roof installations in arid environments, especially if anisohydric species are employed.

Photosynthesis and water use by two Sedum species in green roof substrate

Different succulent plants have been shown to exhibit varying degrees of crassulacean acid metabolism (CAM). This variation has not been consistently shown to relate to water use efficiency (WUE) by these species. This raises fundamental questions about the ecophysiological implications of switching between C3 photosynthesis and CAM metabolism. More information is also needed for Sedum species that utilize CAM to varying degrees on green roofs so that plant water use can be included in water balance equations that predict green roof performance. We monitored carbon dioxide exchange and water use by two common green roof species, Sedum album and Sedum kamtschaticum, for three weeks without water under strictly controlled environmental conditions in order to (1) compare daily carbon gain, rates of evapotranspiration (ET), and WUE for these two species and (2) assess the effect of CAM cycling on WUE with increasing drought for entire plant stands. Under similar environmental conditions, S. album and S. kamtschaticum canopies exhibited CAM metabolism to different extents with different ecophysiological consequences. S. kamtschaticum exhibited C3 photosynthesis for the first 14 days without water and outperformed S. album in terms of carbon gain and WUE above a volumetric water content (VWC) of 0.08m3m−3. S. album was the more drought tolerant species under the conditions of this experiment, gaining at least as much carbon and using water more efficiently at VWC below 0.08m3m−3. By switching from C3 to CAM at lower VWC, S. kamtschaticum had an overall greater WUE even though this species used as much if not more water overall compared to S. album. These data further support suggestions that a major adaptive function of CAM is to prolong plant-available water while maintaining a consistent, albeit low level of carbon gain. These findings also demonstrate why Sedum species should be treated independently of each other when considered in green roof designs.