There is evidence that replacing the gonadotropin-releasing hormone (GnRH) with porcine luteinizing hormone (pLH) to synchronize ovulation prior to artificial insemination (AI) increased pregnancy per AI in dairy cows without affecting blood progesterone (P4) concentrations. Whether morphologic, steroidogenic, and transcriptomic differences exist among corpora lutea (CL) formed after ovulation induced by GnRH and pLH is unclear. Our main objective, therefore, was to compare CL characteristics between GnRH- and pLH-induced CL. In 24 non-lactating Holstein cows, ovulations were spontaneous (Spont-Ov) or induced with 100 µg GnRH, 25 mg pLH, or 1 mg estradiol benzoate (EB), with CL excised 12 d after ovulation. In pLH- versus GnRH-treated cows, the duration of elevated LH (above baseline) was prolonged (10 versus 6 h, respectively, p < 0.01), but CL dimensions, pixel intensity of CL images, proportions of steroidogenic and non-steroidogenic luteal cells, and mean plasma LH did not significantly differ. Post-ovulation mean plasma P4 (ng/mL) did not differ among Spont-Ov (3.0) pLH (3.1) or GnRH (3.0) cows but were lower in EB cows (2.0). In vitro P4 concentration was greater in luteal explants of pLH-treated cows than in all other groups (combined means, 16.0 vs. 12.3 µg/mL, p < 0.02). Relative abundance of mRNA for oxytocin receptor (OXTR) was 2-fold higher (p < 0.01) in CL of pLH vs. GnRH cows and highest in Spont-Ov CL. In summary, pLH-treated cows had a longer LH peak, and greatest luteal tissue concentrations and in vitro production of P4. We inferred that increased P4 concentrations at the ovarian-uterine level in pLH-treated cows could have promoted embryo development and increased pregnancy per AI.