Gestalt Grouping Cues Research Articles

Competition between perceptual grouping cues in an indirect objective task

The integration between Gestalt grouping cues has been a relatively unexplored issue in vision science. The present work introduces an objective indirect method based on the repetition discrimination task to determine the rules that govern the dominance dynamics of the competition between both intrinsic (Experiment 1: proximity vs luminance similarity) and extrinsic grouping cues (Experiment 2: common region vs connectedness) by means of objective measures of grouping (reaction times and accuracy). Prior to the main task, a novel objective equating task was introduced with the aim of equating the grouping strength of the cues for the visuomotor system. The main task included two single conditions with the grouping cues acting alone as well as two competing conditions displaying the grouping factors pitted against one another. Conventional aggregated analyses were combined with individual analysis and both revealed a consistent pattern of processing dominance of: (1) luminance similarity over proximity and (2) common region over connectedness. Interestingly, the individual analyses showed that, despite the heterogeneous responses to the single conditions, the pattern of dominance between cues was robustly homogeneous among the participants in the competing conditions.

Typical Utilization of Gestalt Grouping Cues in Shape Perception by Persons with Autism Spectrum Disorder.

The common finding of better locally oriented perception among persons with autism spectrum disorder (ASD) is based on evidence from paradigms in which hierarchical stimuli are used to pit local and global processes against one another. However, in most cases, determining whether group differences reflect reduced global processing, enhanced local processing, or both is difficult. To provide more conclusive evidence for global perception in ASD, we examined shape formation and sensitivity to Gestalt heuristics. Children with persons with ASD and mental age matched typically developing children completed tasks in which the organization of contour segments into a shape was likely to depend on utilizing cues of closure, spatial proximity, and collinearity. In Experiment 1, search efficiency was measured, with the efficiency of the global organization indicated by the slope of the best-fitting linear reaction-time function over the number of presented items. In Experiment 2, contour integration task was administered, while Gestalt cues and the contour to background spacing ratio were manipulated independently. The findings indicated typical shape formation among the persons with ASD. Furthermore, certain interactive relations between Gestalt grouping cues that are known to govern shape formation in typically developing individuals determined the extraction of the global shape among the participants with ASD.

Object representations in visual working memory change according to the task context

This study investigated whether an item's representation in visual working memory (VWM) can be updated according to changes in the global task context. We used a modified change detection paradigm, in which the items moved before the retention interval. In all of the experiments, we presented identical color–color conjunction items that were arranged to provide a common fate Gestalt grouping cue during their movement. Task context was manipulated by adding a condition highlighting either the integrated interpretation of the conjunction items or their individuated interpretation. We monitored the contralateral delay activity (CDA) as an online marker of VWM. Experiment 1 employed only a minimal global context; the conjunction items were integrated during their movement, but then were partially individuated, at a late stage of the retention interval. The same conjunction items were perfectly integrated in an integration context (Experiment 2). An individuation context successfully produced strong individuation, already during the movement, overriding Gestalt grouping cues (Experiment 3). In Experiment 4, a short priming of the individuation context managed to individuate the conjunction items immediately after the Gestalt cue was no longer available. Thus, the representations of identical items changed according to the task context, suggesting that VWM interprets incoming input according to global factors which can override perceptual cues.

A Computational Model for Object-Based Visual Saliency: Spreading Attention Along Gestalt Cues

The past few years have witnessed impressive progress on the research of salient object detection. Nevertheless , existing approaches still cannot perform satisfactorily in the case of complex scenes, particularly when the salient objects have non- uniform appearance or complicated shapes, and the background is complexly structured. One important reason for such limitations may be that these approaches commonly ignore the factor of perceptual grouping in saliency modeling. To address this issue, this paper presents a novel computational model for object -based visual saliency, which explicitly takes into consideration the connections between attention and perceptual grouping, and incorporates Gestalt grouping cues into saliency computation. Inspired by the sensory enhancement theory, we suggest a paradigm for object-based saliency modeling, that is, object-based saliency stems from spreading attention along Gestalt grouping cues. Computationally , three typical Gestalt cues, including proximity, similarity, and closure, are respectively extracted from the given image, which are then integrated by constructing a unified Gestalt graph. A new algorithm named personalized power iteration clustering is developed to effectively fulfill the spreading of attention information across the Gestalt graph. Intensive experiments have been carried out to demonstrate the superior performance of the proposed model in comparison to the state-of-the-art.

Contralateral delay activity tracks the influence of Gestalt grouping principles on active visual working memory representations.

Recent studies have demonstrated that factors influencing perception, such as Gestalt grouping cues, can influence the storage of information in visual working memory (VWM). In some cases, stationary cues, such as stimulus similarity, lead to superior VWM performance. However, the neural correlates underlying these benefits to VWM performance remain unclear. One neural index, the contralateral delay activity (CDA), is an event-related potential that shows increased amplitude according to the number of items held in VWM and asymptotes at an individual's VWM capacity limit. Here, we applied the CDA to determine whether previously reported behavioral benefits supplied by similarity, proximity, and uniform connectedness were reflected as a neural savings such that the CDA amplitude was reduced when these cues were present. We implemented VWM change-detection tasks with arrays including similarity and proximity (Experiment 1); uniform connectedness (Experiments 2a and 2b); and similarity/proximity and uniform connectedness (Experiment 3). The results indicated that when there was a behavioral benefit to VWM, this was echoed by a reduction in CDA amplitude, which suggests more efficient processing. However, not all perceptual grouping cues provided a VWM benefit in the same measure (e.g., accuracy) or of the same magnitude. We also found unexpected interactions between cues. We observed a mixed bag of effects, suggesting that these powerful perceptual grouping benefits are not as predictable in VWM. The current findings indicate that when grouping cues produce behavioral benefits, there is a parallel reduction in the neural resources required to maintain grouped items within VWM.

When common-fate fails: The limited reach of Gestalt grouping cues in online object binding in visual working memory

When common-fate fails: The limited reach of Gestalt grouping cues in online object binding in visual working memory

Perceptual grouping in the human brain: common processing of different cues

The perception of global scenes and objects consisting of multiple constituents is based on the integration of local elements or features. Gestalt grouping cues, such as proximity or similarity, can aid this process. Using functional MRI we investigated whether grouping guided by different gestalt cues rely on distinct networks in the brain or share a common network. Our study revealed that gestalt grouping involved the inferior parietal cortex, middle temporal gyrus and prefrontal cortex irrespective of the specific cue used. These findings agree with observations in neurological patients, which suggest that inferior parietal regions may aid the integration of local features into a global gestalt. Damage to this region results in simultanagnosia, a deficit in perceiving multiple objects and global scenes.

Forming and updating object representations without awareness: evidence from motion-induced blindness

The input to visual processing consists of an undifferentiated array of features which must be parsed into discrete units. Here we explore the degree to which conscious awareness is important for forming such object representations, and for updating them in the face of changing visual scenes. We do so by exploiting the phenomenon of motion-induced blindness (MIB), wherein salient (and even attended) objects fluctuate into and out of conscious awareness when superimposed onto certain global motion patterns. By introducing changes to unseen visual stimuli during MIB, we demonstrate that object representations can be formed and updated even without conscious access to those objects. Such changes can then influence not only how stimuli reenter awareness, but also what reenters awareness. We demonstrate that this processing encompasses simple object representations and also several independent Gestalt grouping cues. We conclude that flexible visual parsing over time and visual change can occur even without conscious perception. Methodologically, we conclude that MIB may be an especially useful tool for studying the role of awareness in visual processing and vice versa.

Guest editors' introduction to the special section on perceptual organization in computer vision

THIS issue contains the second installment of the special issue on perceptual organization in computer vision. In the April issue of TPAMI, we published 11 papers addressing basic principles, algorithms, and applications. This month’s papers continue along these lines and raising new issues as well. The first paper in the special section contributes to one of the most significant trends in perceptual organization, the use of graph algorithms to efficiently find regions that globally optimize, or approximately optimize, a grouping property. P. Soundararajan and S. Sarkar present an analysis and experimental evaluation of a set of graph algorithms, showing that some of the common algorithms are practically equivalent with respect to performance. In the next paper, J.H. Elder, A. Krupnik, and L.A. Johnston describe a probabilistic formulation for contour grouping that combines Gestalt grouping cues with prior knowledge about the shape of the objects whose boundary is being detected. They apply this approach to the problem of detecting exact lake boundaries in satellite imagery. S. Wang and J.M. Siskind also study graph algorithms as a grouping mechanism. They present a novel algorithm based on the ratio of two properties of graph edges that are cut in a segmentation. This leads to a polynomial time algorithm that finds globally optimal groupings, which they then enhance using a set of heuristics. Finally, it is fitting that our issue concludes with S.-C. Zhu’s paper, which reviews a large set of past work on modeling visual patterns, an area fundamental to perceptual organization. Professor Zhu presents a broad taxonomy of methods, stressing the importance of generative models in image modeling. The 15 papers we have presented provide a wide range of viewpoints and attack a variety of problems using diverse tools. We find this appropriate since the challenges of perceptual organization are great and many angles on the problem should continue to be explored. Hopefully, the special section will provide a useful snapshot of the state of many of these approaches.

Grouping visual features during binocular rivalry

During binocular rivalry, portions of one eye’s view may be perceptually dominant while other portions are suppressed; at any given moment, overall dominance often resembles a patchwork mixture of the two eyes’ views. This study investigates the potency of two Gestalt grouping cues — good continuation and common fate — to promote synchronous fluctuations in dominance of two, spatially separated rival targets. Two grating patches were presented to the left eye paired dichoptically with random-dot patches presented to corresponding right eye locations. The orientations of the two gratings were either collinear, parallel or orthogonal. Gratings underwent contrast modulations that were either correlated (identical contrast changes) or uncorrelated (independent contrast changes). Over 60 s trials, observers pressed one key when the left grating predominated, another when the right grating predominated and both keys when both were concurrently visible. Correlated contrast modulation promoted joint grating predominance relative to the uncorrelated conditions, an effect strongest for collinear gratings. Joint predominance depended strongly on the angular separation between gratings and the temporal phase-lag in contrast modulations. These findings may reflect neural interactions subserved by lateral connections between cortical hypercolumns.

The role of convexity in perceptual completion: beyond good continuation

Since the seminal work of the Gestalt psychologists, there has been great interest in understanding what factors determine the perceptual organization of images. While the Gestaltists demonstrated the significance of grouping cues such as similarity, proximity and good continuation, it has not been well understood whether their catalog of grouping cues is complete — in part due to the paucity of effective methodologies for examining the significance of various grouping cues. We describe a novel, objective method to study perceptual grouping of planar regions separated by an occluder. We demonstrate that the stronger the grouping between two such regions, the harder it will be to resolve their relative stereoscopic depth. We use this new method to call into question many existing theories of perceptual completion (Ullman, S. (1976). Biological Cybernetics, 25, 1–6; Shashua, A., & Ullman, S. (1988). 2nd International Conference on Computer Vision (pp. 321–327); Parent, P., & Zucker, S. (1989). IEEE Transactions on Pattern Analysis and Machine Intelligence, 11, 823–839; Kellman, P. J., & Shipley, T. F. (1991). Cognitive psychology, Liveright, New York; Heitger, R., & von der Heydt, R. (1993). A computational model of neural contour processing, figure-ground segregation and illusory contours. In Internal Conference Computer Vision (pp. 32–40); Mumford, D. (1994). Algebraic geometry and its applications, Springer, New York; Williams, L. R., & Jacobs, D .W. (1997). Neural Computation, 9, 837–858) that are based on Gestalt grouping cues by demonstrating that convexity plays a strong role in perceptual completion. In some cases convexity dominates the effects of the well known Gestalt cue of good continuation. While convexity has been known to play a role in figure/ground segmentation ( Rubin, 1927; Kanizsa & Gerbino, 1976), this is the first demonstration of its importance in perceptual completion.