The study presents a comprehensive investigation into the genetic determinants of 100-day milk yield (100DMY), 305-day milk yield (305DMY), total milk yield (TMY), and persistency using first lactation records of 374 Holstein heifers reared in a private farm at Çanakkale province of Türkiye, employing a genome-wide association study (GWAS) approach. The research underscores the substantial genetic component underlying these economically important traits through detailed descriptive statistics and heritability estimations. The estimated moderate to high heritabilities (0.32–0.54) for milk production traits suggest the feasibility of targeted genetic improvement strategies. By leveraging GWAS, the study identifies many significant and suggestively significant single nucleotide polymorphisms (SNP) associated with studied traits. Noteworthy genes have identified in this analysis include BCAS3, MALRD1, CTNND2, DOCK1, TMEM132C, NRP1, CNTNAP2, GPRIN2, PLEKHA5, GLRA1, SCN7A, HHEX, KTM2C, RAB40C, RAB11FIP3, and FXYD6. These findings provide valuable understandings of the genetic background of milk production and persistency in Holstein cattle, shedding light on specific genomic regions and candidate genes playing pivotal roles in these traits. This research contributes valuable knowledge to the field of dairy cattle genetics and informs future breeding efforts to improve milk production sustainability and efficiency in Holstein cattle populations.