Abstract Over the past decade, advancements in next-generation sequencing technology, alongside reduced costs, and the rising demand for infertility medical care, have resulted in the discovery of new genes and genetic variants linked to infertility conditions. Phenotypes of ICSI failure, such as oocyte maturation arrest (OMA), fertilization failure (FF) and embryo developmental arrest (EDA), can now be attributed to male or female genetic causes. This represents a transformative shift in patient treatment, allowing the identification of some cases previously classified as unexplained infertility, thereby reducing patient stress. Moreover, it facilitates personalized treatment recommendations, as well as paves the way for the exploration of novel treatment options, thus expanding research opportunities. This talk will review the genetic causes of FF following ICSI, with the main focus on the newly identified female causes, as well as give an update on current diagnostic tests and treatment options for this infertility condition. FF after ICSI still occurs in 1-3% of ICSI cycles, primarily due to oocyte activation deficiency (OAD). Defects in the male PLCζ protein, responsible of inducing calcium oscillations during oocyte activation, have long been known as the leading cause of OAD. Recent discoveries have identified genetic variants in the male genes ACTL7A, ACTL9 and IQCN, which also reduce PLCζ protein content in sperm cells and thus, contribute to FF after ICSI. Additionally, for the first time in 2018, mutations in a female gene (WEE2) crucial for oocyte activation were identified. WEE2 is an oocyte kinase that acts downstream the calcium release during fertilization. Interestingly, genetic variants in other female genes, such as PATL2, TUBB8 and CDC20 associated mainly to OMA and TLE6 and NLRP5 associated mainly to EDA, have also been described to cause failed fertilization in some patients. Determining whether the deficiency lies in sperm- or oocyte-related genes is crucial for tailoring the most effective treatment for FF after ICSI. For sperm-related factors, assisted oocyte activation (AOA), which consists in the artificial induction of calcium oscillations using calcium ionophores, has proven highly beneficial. However, most patients with oocyte-factors do not benefit from AOA (e.g. patients with WEE2 variants). In this regard, wild-type cRNA injection of the defected protein has been shown to rescue fertilization. A more generalist approach, such as maternal spindle transfer, which consists in replacing poor-quality oocyte cytoplasm with healthy cytoplasm from a donor oocyte, represents a potential treatment for these patients, as recently demonstrated in infertile females with repeated IVF failures. Nevertheless, further research into the safety of these procedures is needed before clinical application, and for now, gamete donation should be considered when facing female-related FF.
Read full abstract