Gauge Invariant States Research Articles

Quantum error thresholds for gauge-redundant digitizations of lattice field theories

In the quantum simulation of lattice gauge theories, gauge symmetry can be either fixed or encoded as a redundancy of the Hilbert space. While gauge-fixing reduces the number of qubits, keeping the gauge redundancy can provide code space to mitigate and correct quantum errors by checking and restoring Gauss’s law. In this work, we consider the correctable errors for generic finite gauge groups and design the quantum circuits to detect and correct them. We calculate the error thresholds below which the gauge-redundant digitization with Gauss’s law error correction has better fidelity than the gauge-fixed digitization involving only gauge-invariant states. Our results provide guidance for fault-tolerant quantum simulations of lattice gauge theories. Published by the American Physical Society 2024

Lattice Hamiltonian for adjoint QCD2

We introduce a Hamiltonian lattice model for the (1 + 1)-dimensional SU(Nc) gauge theory coupled to one adjoint Majorana fermion of mass m. The discretization of the continuum theory uses staggered Majorana fermions. We analyze the symmetries of the lattice model and find lattice analogs of the anomalies of the corresponding continuum theory. An important role is played by the lattice translation by one lattice site, which in the continuum limit involves a discrete axial transformation. On a lattice with periodic boundary conditions, the Hilbert space breaks up into sectors labeled by the Nc-ality p = 0, … Nc − 1. Our symmetry analysis implies various exact degeneracies in the spectrum of the lattice model. In particular, it shows that, for m = 0 and even Nc, the sectors p and p′ are degenerate if |p − p′| = Nc/2. In the Nc = 2 case, we explicitly construct the action of the Hamiltonian on a basis of gauge-invariant states, and we perform both a strong coupling expansion and exact diagonalization for lattices of up to 12 lattice sites. Upon extrapolation of these results, we find good agreement with the spectrum computed previously using discretized light-cone quantization. One of our new results is the first numerical calculation of the fermion bilinear condensate.

Stabilizer entropy of quantum tetrahedra

How complex is the structure of quantum geometry? In several approaches, the spacetime atoms are obtained by the SU(2) intertwiner called quantum tetrahedron. The complexity of this construction has a concrete consequence in recent efforts to simulate such models and toward experimental demonstrations of quantum gravity effects. There are, therefore, both a computational and an experimental complexity inherent to this class of models. In this paper, we study this complexity under the lens of (SE). We calculate the SE of the gauge-invariant basis states and its average in the SU(2)-gauge invariant subspace. We find that the states of definite volume are singled out by the (near) maximal SE and give precise bounds to the verification protocols for experimental demonstrations on available quantum computers. Published by the American Physical Society 2024

Almost gauge-invariant states and the ground state of Yang-Mills theory

We consider the problem of the explicit description of the gauge-invariant subspace of pure lattice gauge theories in the Hamiltonian formulation, where the gauge group is either a compact Lie group or a finite group. The latter case is particularly interesting for quantum simulation. A basis of states where configurations are grouped according to their holonomies is shown to have several advantages over other descriptions. Using this basis, we compute some properties of interest for some non-Abelian finite groups on small lattices, and in particular we examine the question of whether a certain ansatz introduced long ago is a good approximation for the ground state. Published by the American Physical Society 2024

Holographic tensor networks with bulk gauge symmetries

Tensor networks are useful toy models for understanding the structure of entanglement in holographic states and reconstruction of bulk operators within the entanglement wedge. They are, however, constrained to only prepare so-called “fixed-area states” with flat entanglement spectra, limiting their utility in understanding general features of holographic entanglement. Here, we overcome this limitation by constructing a variant of random tensor networks that enjoys bulk gauge symmetries. Our model includes a gauge theory on a general graph, whose gauge-invariant states are fed into a random tensor network. We show that the model satisfies the quantum-corrected Ryu-Takayanagi formula with a nontrivial area operator living in the center of a gauge-invariant algebra. We also demonstrate nontrivial, n-dependent contributions to the Rényi entropy and Rényi mutual information from this area operator, a feature shared by general holographic states.

Revisiting loop quantum gravity with selfdual variables: Hilbert space and first reality condition

Abstract We consider the quantization of gravity as an SL(2,C) gauge theory in terms of Ashtekar's selfdual variables and reality conditions for the spatial metric (RCI) and its evolution (RCII). We start from a holomorphic phase space formulation. It is then natural to push for a quantization in terms of holomorphic wave functions. Thus we consider holomorphic cylindrical wave functions over SL(2,C) connections. 

We use an overall phase ambiguity of the complex selfdual action to obtain Poisson brackets that mirror those of the real theory. We then show that there is a representation of the corresponding canonical commutation relations the space of holomorphic cylindrical functions. We describe a class of cylindrically consistent measures that implements RCI. We show that spin networks with SU(2) intertwiners form a basis for gauge invariant states. They are still mutually orthogonal, but the normalisation is different than for the Ashtekar-Lewandowski measure for SU(2). 

We do not consider RCII in the present article. Work on RCII is ongoing and will be presented elsewhere.

MOG as symmetry breaking in scalar–vector–tensor gravity

ABSTRACT The Modified Gravity Model (MOG) has been proposed as a solution to the dark matter problem, but it does not meet the gauge invariant condition. The aim of this work is to propose a gauge-invariant theory, which suggests that symmetry can break at a low temperature in the Universe, leading to the MOG theory. This theory has the potential to alter the dynamics of the early and late Universe and naturally produce cosmological inflation.

Weak ergodicity breaking in the Schwinger model

As a paradigm of weak ergodicity breaking in disorder-free nonintegrable models, quantum many-body scars (QMBS) can offer deep insights into the thermalization dynamics of gauge theories. Having been first discovered in a spin-$1/2$ quantum link formulation of the Schwinger model, it is a fundamental question as to whether QMBS persist for $S>1/2$ since such theories converge to the lattice Schwinger model in the large-$S$ limit, which is the appropriate version of lattice QED in one spatial dimension. In this work, we address this question by exploring QMBS in spin-$S$ $\mathrm{U}(1)$ quantum link models (QLMs) with staggered fermions. We find that QMBS persist at $S>1/2$, with the resonant scarring regime, which occurs for a zero-mass quench, arising from simple high-energy gauge-invariant initial states. We furthermore find evidence of detuned scarring regimes, which occur for finite-mass quenches starting in the physical vacua and the charge-proliferated state. Our results conclusively show that QMBS exist in a wide class of lattice gauge theories in one spatial dimension represented by spin-$S$ QLMs coupled to dynamical fermions.

Super-exponential distinguishability of correlated quantum states

In the problem of asymptotic binary i.i.d. state discrimination, the optimal asymptotics of the type I and the type II error probabilities is in general an exponential decrease to zero as a function of the number of samples; the set of achievable exponent pairs is characterized by the quantum Hoeffding bound theorem. A super-exponential decrease for both types of error probabilities is only possible in the trivial case when the two states are orthogonal and hence can be perfectly distinguished using only a single copy of the system. In this paper, we show that a qualitatively different behavior can occur when there is correlation between the samples. Namely, we use gauge-invariant and translation-invariant quasi-free states on the algebra of the canonical anti-commutation relations to exhibit pairs of states on an infinite spin chain with the properties that (a) all finite-size restrictions of the states have invertible density operators and (b) the type I and the type II error probabilities both decrease to zero at least with the speed e^{-nclog n} with some positive constant c, i.e., with a super-exponential speed in the sample size n. Particular examples of such states include the ground states of the XX model corresponding to different transverse magnetic fields. In fact, we prove our result in the setting of binary composite hypothesis testing, and hence, it can be applied to prove super-exponential distinguishability of the hypotheses that the transverse magnetic field is above a certain threshold vs. that it is below a strictly lower value.

Weak coupling limit of U(1) lattice model in Fourier basis

The transfer-matrix of the U(1) lattice model is considered in the Fourier basis and in the weak coupling limit. The issues of Gauss law constraint and gauge invariant states are addressed in the Fourier basis. In particular, it is shown that in the strong coupling limit the gauge invariant Fourier states are effectively the finite size closed loop currents. In the weak coupling limit, however, the link-currents along periodic or infinite spatial directions find comparable roles as gauge invariant states. The subtleties related to the extreme weak coupling of the transfer-matrix in the Fourier basis are discussed. A careful analysis of the zero eigenvalues of the matrix in the quadratic action leads to a safe extraction of the diverging group volume in the limit $g\to 0$. By means of the very basic notions and tools of the lattice model, the spectrum at the weak coupling limit for any dimension and size of lattice is obtained analytically. The spectrum at the weak coupling limit corresponds to the expected one by the continuum model in the large lattice limit.

The Casimir effect in chiral media using path integral techniques

We employ path integral methods to calculate the Casimir energy and force densities in a chiral extension of QED. Manifestly gauge invariant perfect electromagnetic boundary conditions, a natural generalization of perfect electric and perfect magnetic conditions, are implemented directly in the action by the usage of auxiliary fields. The chiral properties of the vacuum are modelled using a background θ field, and we introduce techniques to efficiently calculate the path integral in this chiral medium. The flexibility of our method allows us to naturally obtain results for a variety of configurations, and where comparison is possible our results are in perfect agreement with existing literature. Among these are multiple situations where a repulsive Casimir force is possible.

Vector boson scattering from the lattice

We study vector-boson scattering of the physical, gauge-invariant states in a reduced standard-model setup on the lattice for various parameter sets. To this end, the phase shift in the scalar channel is determined using a L\"uscher-type analysis. The results can be readily interpreted in terms of the Higgs properties and a reunitarized Fr\"ohlich-Morchio-Strocchi analysis at Born level. The only deviation appears for a Higgs mass below the elastic threshold, where we find a negative scattering length indicative of the bound-state nature of the physical scalar degree of freedom. We assess the possible implications for an experimental detection of the effect.

Gauge invariant propagators and states in quantum electrodynamics

We study combined matter/gauge field gauge invariant states in terms of data living on the boundary of gauge invariant path-integrals. To get concrete results, this is done for scalar and spinor QED, for both ‘time-slice’, and ‘causal diamond’ boundaries. We discuss both the standard case where the gauge field falls off to zero at the spatial boundaries, and the case of ‘large gauge transformations’, where it remains finite at these boundaries. The path-integral naturally generates a specific dressing factor for states living on time-slices, without fixing any gauge, and we identify a universal contribution which depends only on the nature of the boundaries. We also derive the analogous dressing for states defined on null infinity, showing both its Coulombic parts as well as soft-photon parts.

Covariant effective action for generalized Proca theories

We investigate the quantum stability of generalised Proca theories in curved spacetime treating gravity as a dynamical field. To compute the quantum gravitational corrections, we evaluate the divergent part of the effective action at one-loop level using Vilkovisky-DeWitt formalism, which gives us a gauge invariant and gauge condition independent effective action. It is shown that the quantum corrections are suppressed by a UV cutoff parametrically higher than the Proca mass, if the coupling constants are restricted to lie in a certain range. Furthermore, it is shown that the quantum corrections remain suppressed even at scales where classical non-linearities dominate over kinetic terms, allowing Vainshtein mechanism to work.

Minimal model for Hilbert space fragmentation with local constraints

Motivated by previous works on a Floquet version of the PXP model [Mukherjee {\it et al.} Phys. Rev. B 102, 075123 (2020), Mukherjee {\it et al.} Phys. Rev. B 101, 245107 (2020)], we study a one-dimensional spin-$1/2$ lattice model with three-spin interactions in the same constrained Hilbert space (where all configurations with two adjacent $S^z=\uparrow$ spins are excluded). We show that this model possesses an extensive fragmentation of the Hilbert space which leads to a breakdown of thermalization upon unitary evolution starting from a large class of simple initial states. Despite the non-integrable nature of the Hamiltonian, many of its high-energy eigenstates admit a quasiparticle description. A class of these, which we dub as "bubble eigenstates", have integer eigenvalues (including mid-spectrum zero modes) and strictly localized quasiparticles while another class contains mobile quasiparticles leading to a dispersion in momentum space. Other anomalous eigenstates that arise due to a {\it secondary} fragmentation mechanism, including those that lead to flat bands in momentum space due to destructive quantum interference, are also discussed. The consequences of adding a (non-commuting) staggered magnetic field and a PXP term respectively to this model, where the former preserves the Hilbert space fragmentation while the latter destroys it, are discussed. A Floquet version with time-dependent staggered field also evades thermalization with additional features like freezing of exponentially many states at special drive frequencies. Finally, we map the model to a $U(1)$ lattice gauge theory coupled to dynamical fermions and discuss the interpretation of some of these anomalous states in this language. A class of gauge-invariant states show reduced mobility of the elementary charged excitations with only certain charge-neutral objects being mobile suggesting a connection to fractons.

Properties of the Rovelli–Smolin–DePietri volume operator in the spaces of monochromatic intertwiners

We study some properties of the Rovelli–Smolin–DePietri volume operator in loop quantum gravity, which significantly simplify the diagonalization problem and shed some light on the pattern of degeneracy of the eigenstates. The operator is defined by its action in the spaces of tensor products of the irreducible SU(2) representation spaces , labelled with spins . We restrict to spaces of SU(2) invariant tensors (intertwiners) with all spins equal j 1 =⋯= j N = j. We call them spin j monochromatic intertwiners. Such spaces are important in the study of SU(2) gauge invariant states that are isotropic and can be applied to extract the cosmological sector of the theory. In the case of spin 1/2 we solve the eigenvalue problem completely: we show that the volume operator is proportional to identity and calculate the proportionality factor.

Gauge-invariant description of the Higgs resonance and its phenomenological implications

We investigate the phenomenological consequences of a strict gauge-invariant formulation of the Higgs particle. This requires a description of the observable scalar particle in terms of a bound state structure. Although this seems to be at odds with the common treatment of electroweak particle physics at first glance, the properties of the bound state can be described in a perturbative fashion due to the Fr\"ohlich-Morchio-Strocchi (FMS) framework. In particular a relation between the bound-state Higgs and the elementary Higgs field is obtained within $R_{\xi}$ gauges such that the main quantitative properties of the conventional description reappear in leading order of the FMS expansion. Going beyond leading order, we show that the pole structure of the elementary and the bound-state propagator coincide to all orders in a perturbative expansion. However, slight deviations of scattering amplitudes containing off-shell Higgs contributions can be caused by the internal bound state structure. We perform a consistent perturbative treatment to all orders in the FMS expansion to quantify such deviations and demonstrate how gauge-invariant expressions arrange in a natural way at the one-loop level. This also provides a gauge-invariant Higgs spectral function which is not plagued by positivity violations or unphysical thresholds. Furthermore, the mass extracted from the gauge-invariant bound state is only logarithmically sensitive to the scale of new physics at one-loop order in contrast to its elementary counterpart.

Observation of gauge invariance in a 71-site Bose-Hubbard quantum simulator.

The modern description of elementary particles, as formulated in the standard model of particle physics, is built on gauge theories1. Gauge theories implement fundamental laws of physics by local symmetry constraints. For example, in quantum electrodynamics Gauss's law introduces an intrinsic local relation between charged matter and electromagnetic fields, which protects many salient physical properties, including massless photons and a long-ranged Coulomb law. Solving gauge theories using classical computers is an extremely arduous task2, which has stimulated an effort to simulate gauge-theory dynamics in microscopically engineered quantum devices3-6. Previous achievements implemented density-dependent Peierls phases without defining a local symmetry7,8, realized mappings onto effective models to integrate out either matter or electric fields9-12, or were limited to very small systems13-16. However, the essential gauge symmetry has not been observed experimentally. Here we reportthe quantum simulation of an extended U(1) lattice gauge theory, and experimentally quantify the gauge invariance in a many-body system comprising matter and gauge fields. Thesefields are realized in defect-free arrays of bosonic atoms in an optical superlattice of 71 sites. We demonstrate full tunability of the model parameters and benchmark the matter-gauge interactions by sweeping across a quantum phase transition. Using high-fidelity manipulation techniques, we measure the degree to which Gauss's law is violated by extracting probabilities of locally gauge-invariant states from correlated atom occupations. Our work provides a way to explore gauge symmetry in the interplay of fundamental particles using controllable large-scale quantum simulators.

Gravitational radiation condition at infinity with a positive cosmological constant

Gravitational waves have been directly detected and astronomical observations indicate that our Universe has a positive cosmological constant $\Lambda$. Nevertheless, a theoretical gauge-invariant notion of gravitational waves arriving at infinity (escaping from the space-time) in the presence of a positive $\Lambda$ has been elusive. We find the answer to this long-standing gravitational puzzle and present a geometric, gauge-invariant radiation condition at infinity.

Expansion of EYM amplitudes in gauge invariant vector space * *B.F. is supported by Qiu-Shi Funding and the National Natural Science Foundation of China (NSFC) (11935013, 11575156); R.H. is supported by the National Natural Science Foundation of China (NSFC) (11805102), Natural Science Foundation of Jiangsu Province (BK20180724) and ShuangChuang Talent Program of Jiangsu Province

Motivated by the problem of expanding the single-trace tree-level amplitude of Einstein-Yang-Mills theory to the BCJ basis of Yang-Mills amplitudes, we present an alternative expansion formula in gauge invariant vector space. Starting from a generic vector space consisting of polynomials of momenta and polarization vectors, we define a new sub-space as a gauge invariant vector space by imposing constraints on the gauge invariant conditions. To characterize this sub-space, we compute its dimension and construct an explicit gauge invariant basis from it. We propose an expansion formula in this gauge invariant basis with expansion coefficients being linear combinations of the Yang-Mills amplitude, manifesting the gauge invariance of both the expansion basis and coefficients. With the help of quivers, we compute the expansion coefficients via differential operators and demonstrate the general expansion algorithm using several examples.