Severity of microlithiasis and sludge-induced pancreatitis in comparison to gallstone-induced pancreatitis has never been studied for a lack of definition. In order to understand whether bile duct obstruction or other mechanisms contribute to biliary pancreatitis severity we performed a monocentric, retrospective cohort study. In this retrospective cohort study 263 patients with acute biliary pancreatitis treated at a tertiary care center from 2005 to 2021 were stratified according to the recent consensus definition for microlithiasis and sludge. The gallstone-pancreatitis cohort was compared to microlithiasis, sludge and suspected stone passage pancreatitis cohorts in terms of pancreatitis outcome, liver function and EUS/ERCP results using one-way ANOVA and Chi2 test. Multinomial logistic regression analysis was performed to correct for bias. Microlithiasis and sludge-induced pancreatitis classified according to the revised Atlanta classification, did not present with a milder course than gallstone-induced pancreatitis (p = 0.62). Microlithiasis and sludge showed an increase in bilirubin on the day of admission to hospital, which was not significantly different from gallstone-induced pancreatitis (p = 0.36). The likelihood of detecting biliary disease on EUS resulting in bile duct clearance was highest on the day of admission and day 1, respectively. Microlithiasis and sludge induce gallstone-equivalent impaired liver function tests and induce pancreatitis with similar severity compared with gallstone-induced acute biliary pancreatitis.