Free Interface Diffusion Research Articles

Microfluidic free interface diffusion: Measurement of diffusion coefficients and evidence of interfacial-driven transport phenomena

We have developed a microfluidic tool to measure the diffusion coefficient D of solutes in an aqueous solution by following the temporal relaxation of an initially steep concentration gradient in a microchannel. Our chip exploits multilayer soft lithography and the opening of a pneumatic microvalve to trigger the interdiffusion of pure water and the solution initially separated in the channel by the valve, the so-called free interface diffusion technique. Another microvalve at a distance from the diffusion zone closes the channel and thus suppresses convection. Using this chip, we have measured diffusion coefficients of solutes in water with a broad size range, from small molecules to polymers and colloids, with values in the range D∈[10−13–10−9] m2/s. The same experiments but with added colloidal tracers also revealed diffusio-phoresis and diffusio-osmosis phenomena due to the presence of the solute concentration gradient. We nevertheless show that these interfacial-driven transport phenomena do not affect the measurements of the solute diffusion coefficients in the explored concentration range.

Tuning Transport Phenomena in Agarose Gels for the Control of Protein Nucleation Density and Crystal Form

Agarose gels provide the ideal environment for studying the nucleation step of complex biomacromolecules under diffusion-controlled conditions. In the present paper, we characterized the influence of agarose on the nucleation of three model proteins, i.e., lysozyme, insulin, and proteinase K, as a function of the agarose concentration using a batch method set-up inside flat capillaries. By using this set-up, we were able to directly count the number of crystals in a given volume and correlate it with the amount of agarose and with the average crystal size. We also studied the crystallization behavior of proteinase K with free-interface diffusion so that batch conditions were achieved through slow diffusion of the precipitant. Thanks to the control over the protein mass transport imposed by the network, a previously unknown crystal form, P212121, was obtained, and the three-dimensional structure was determined at a 1.6 Å resolution. Overall, the versatility of agarose gels makes them ideal candidates for the preparation of microcrystalline suspensions of biopharmaceuticals with precise and reproducible crystal attributes or for the exploration of the existence of different polymorphs.

Femtosecond Nanocrystallography and Characterization of Photosystem II

Membrane proteins are extremely difficult to crystallize, however they are highly important proteins for cellular function. Photosystem I, one of the most complex membrane proteins solved to date took more than a decade to have a structure solved to molecular resolution. Large, well-ordered crystal growth is one of the major bottlenecks in structural determination by x-ray crystallography, due to the difficulty of making the "perfect" crystal. The development of femtosecond nanocrystallography, which uses a stream of fully hydrated nanocrystals to collect diffraction snapshots, effectively reduces this bottleneck[1] Photosystem II changed our biosphere via splitting water and evolving oxygen 2.5 billion years ago. Using femtosecond nanocrystallography we are developing a time-resolved femtosecond crystallography method [2] to unravel the mechanism of water splitting by determining the conformational changes that take place during the oxygen evolution process. Multiple crystallization techniques were originally developed in order to make the nanocrystals necessary for femtosecond nanocrystallography. For Photosystem II nano/microcrystals a free interface diffusion method, is used to increase yield over traditional methods. These crystals are then characterized by three different methods before being used for collecting diff raction data. The three methods currently used are optical microscopy, dynamic light scattering (DLS), and Second Order Nonlinear Imaging of Chiral Crystals (SONICC).

Microcrystallization techniques for serial femtosecond crystallography using photosystem II from Thermosynechococcus elongatus as a model system.

Serial femtosecond crystallography (SFX) is a new emerging method, where X-ray diffraction data are collected from a fully hydrated stream of nano- or microcrystals of biomolecules in their mother liquor using high-energy, X-ray free-electron lasers. The success of SFX experiments strongly depends on the ability to grow large amounts of well-ordered nano/microcrystals of homogeneous size distribution. While methods to grow large single crystals have been extensively explored in the past, method developments to grow nano/microcrystals in sufficient amounts for SFX experiments are still in their infancy. Here, we describe and compare three methods (batch, free interface diffusion (FID) and FID centrifugation) for growth of nano/microcrystals for time-resolved SFX experiments using the large membrane protein complex photosystem II as a model system.

A review of the strategies for obtaining high-quality crystals utilizing nanotechnologies and microgravity.

Crystallization is a highly demanding and time-consuming task that causes a real bottle-neck in basic research. Great effort has been made to understand the factors and parameters that influence this process and to finely tune them to facilitate crystal growth. Different crystallization techniques have been proposed over the past decades, such as the classical vapor hanging drop method, its variant the sitting drop method, dialysis, cryo-temperature, gel, batch, and the innovative microgravity (space) techniques like free interface diffusion (FID) and counter-ion diffusion (CID). Here, we present a review of the strategies utilizing Langmuir-Blodgett (LB)-based nanotechnologies, and microgravity techniques for obtaining optimal high-quality crystals, as proven by molecular dynamics (MD) and bioinformatics approaches, namely using a clustering algorithm and protein alignment.

Direct Observation of Ostwald Ripening in Free-Interface Diffusion Based Protein Crystallization

In the late stages of first order phase transitions, interfacial energy minimization drives competitive growth between precipitates of the new phase. This dissolution of small precipitates to feed the growth of larger clusters is commonly referred to as Ostwald ripening. Here, Ostwald ripening is directly observed during the late stages of Lysozyme crystallization in a microfluidic free-interface diffusion reactor. In order to measure the wide range of crystal sizes necessary to quantitatively characterize the ripening phenomenon, we developed a novel dynamic light scattering apparatus, with an incorporated microscope, based on the microfluidic crystallization device. The crystal size distribution mean, observed by scattering, grows as t⊥1/3 in agreement with the analytic predictions of Lifshitz Wagner and Slyozov (LSW). In the case where a large crystal emerges outside of the scattering volume, local crystal size distributions deviate from power law growth in an expected fashion. A simulation based on LSW theory is implemented to model the crystal size distribution evolution. The observed growth trajectories show quantitative agreement with simulated kinetics.

Multiparameter screening on SlipChip used for nanoliter protein crystallization combining free interface diffusion and microbatch methods.

This paper describes two SlipChip-based approaches to protein crystallization: a SlipChip-based free interface diffusion (FID) method and a SlipChip-based composite method that simultaneously performs microbatch and FID crystallization methods in a single device. The FID SlipChip was designed to screen multiple reagents, each at multiple diffusion equilibration times, and was validated by screening conditions for crystallization of two proteins, enoyl-CoA hydratase from Mycobacterium tuberculosis and dihydrofolate reductase/thymidylate synthase from Babesia bovis, against 48 different reagents at five different equilibration times each, consuming 12 microL of each protein for a total of 480 experiments using three SlipChips. The composite SlipChip was designed to screen multiple reagents, each at multiple mixing ratios and multiple equilibration times, and was validated by screening conditions for crystallization of two proteins, enoyl-CoA hydratase from Mycobacterium tuberculosis and dihydrofolate reductase/thymidylate synthase from Babesia bovis. To prevent cross-contamination while keeping the solution in the neck channels for FID stable, the plates of the SlipChip were etched with a pattern of nanowells. This nanopattern was used to increase the contact angle of aqueous solutions on the surface of the silanized glass. The composite SlipChip increased the number of successful crystallization conditions and identified more conditions for crystallization than separate FID and microbatch screenings. Crystallization experiments were scaled up in well plates using conditions identified during the SlipChip screenings, and X-ray diffraction data were obtained to yield the protein structure of dihydrofolate reductase/thymidylate synthase at 1.95 A resolution. This free-interface diffusion approach provides a convenient and high-throughput method of setting up gradients in microfluidic devices and may find additional applications in cell-based assays.

Cyclic olefin homopolymer-based microfluidics for protein crystallization andin situX-ray diffraction

Microfluidics is a promising technology for the rapid identification of protein crystallization conditions. However, most of the existing systems utilize silicone elastomers as the chip material which, despite its many benefits, is highly permeable to water vapour. This limits the time available for protein crystallization to less than a week. Here, the use of a cyclic olefin homopolymer-based microfluidics system for protein crystallization and in situ X-ray diffraction is described. Liquid handling in this system is performed in 2 mm thin transparent cards which contain 500 chambers, each with a volume of 320 nl. Microbatch, vapour-diffusion and free-interface diffusion protocols for protein crystallization were implemented and crystals were obtained of a number of proteins, including chicken lysozyme, bovine trypsin, a human p53 protein containing both the DNA-binding and oligomerization domains bound to DNA and a functionally important domain of Arabidopsis Morpheus' molecule 1 (MOM1). The latter two polypeptides have not been crystallized previously. For X-ray diffraction analysis, either the cards were opened to allow mounting of the crystals on loops or the crystals were exposed to X-rays in situ. For lysozyme, an entire X-ray diffraction data set at 1.5 A resolution was collected without removing the crystal from the card. Thus, cyclic olefin homopolymer-based microfluidics systems have the potential to further automate protein crystallization and structural genomics efforts.

An efficient platform for screening expression and crystallization of glycoproteins produced in human cells

Glycoproteins are involved in diverse biological processes ranging from extracellular contact and recognition to intracellular signaling. Crystal structures of glycoproteins would yield tremendous insight into these processes. But glycoprotein structural analysis has been hindered by difficulties in expressing milligram quantities of stable, homogeneous protein and determining which modifications will yield samples amenable to crystallization. We describe a platform, which we have proven to be effective for rapidly screening expression and crystallization of a challenging glycoprotein target. In this protocol, multiple glycoprotein ectodomain constructs are produced in parallel by transient expression of adherent human embryonic kidney (HEK) 293T cells and are subsequently screened for crystals in microscale quantities by free interface diffusion. As a result, recombinant proteins are produced and processed in a native, mammalian environment, and crystallization screening can be accomplished with as little as 65 microg of protein. Moreover, large numbers of constructs can be generated, screened and scaled up for expression and crystallization, with results obtained in 4 weeks.

Phase behavior and crystallogenesis under counter-diffusion conditions of the collagen-model peptide (Pro–Pro–Gly) 10

Single chains of the collagen-model polypeptide with sequence (Pro–Pro–Gly) 10, hereafter referred to as (PPG) 10, aggregate to form rod-shaped triple helices. Precipitation diagrams of (PPG) 10 as a function of pH and various molecular mass poly(ethylene glycol) concentrations have been measured. These results were used to design experiments to test the quality of (PPG) 10 crystal grown on ground (in gelled and free solutions) and in space in two different facilities, the Advanced Protein Crystallization Facility based on the free-interface diffusion technique and the Granada Crystallization Facility based on counter-diffusion technique. Experiments were monitored by optical microscopy on earth. X-ray diffraction analysis of the grown crystals reveals the benefit of the counter-diffusion technique.

Crystallization screening test for the whole-cell project onThermus thermophilusHB8

It was essential for the structural genomics of Thermus thermophilus HB8 to efficiently crystallize a number of proteins. To this end, three conventional robots, an HTS-80 (sitting-drop vapour diffusion), a Crystal Finder (hanging-drop vapour diffusion) and a TERA (modified microbatch) robot, were subjected to a crystallization condition screening test involving 18 proteins from T. thermophilus HB8. In addition, a TOPAZ (microfluidic free-interface diffusion) designed specifically for initial screening was also briefly examined. The number of diffraction-quality crystals and the time of appearance of crystals increased in the order HTS-80, Crystal Finder, TERA. With the HTS-80 and Crystal Finder, the time of appearance was short and the rate of salt crystallization was low. With the TERA, the number of diffraction-quality crystals was high, while the time of appearance was long and the rate of salt crystallization was relatively high. For the protein samples exhibiting low crystallization success rates, there were few crystallization conditions that were common to the robots used. In some cases, the success rate depended greatly on the robot used. The TOPAZ showed the shortest time of appearance and the highest success rate, although the crystals obtained were too small for diffraction studies. These results showed that the combined use of different robots significantly increases the chance of obtaining crystals, especially for proteins exhibiting low crystallization success rates. The structures of 360 of 944 purified proteins have been successfully determined through the combined use of an HTS-80 and a TERA.

Crystallization of the Atg12–Atg5 conjugate bound to Atg16 by the free-interface diffusion method

Autophagy mediates the bulk degradation of cytoplasmic components in lysosomes/vacuoles. Five autophagy-related (Atg) proteins are involved in a ubiquitin-like protein conjugation system. Atg12 is conjugated to its sole target, Atg5, by two enzymes, Atg7 and Atg10. The Atg12-Atg5 conjugates form a multimeric complex with Atg16. Formation of the Atg12-Atg5-Atg16 ternary complex is crucial for the functions of these proteins on autophagy. Here, the expression, purification and crystallization of the Atg12-Atg5 conjugate bound to the N-terminal region of Atg16 (Atg16N) are reported. The Atg12-Atg5 conjugates were formed by co-expressing Atg5, Atg7, Atg10 and Atg12 in Eschericia coli. The Atg12-Atg5-Atg16N ternary complex was formed by mixing purified Atg12-Atg5 conjugates and Atg16N, and was further purified by gel-filtration chromatography. Crystallization screening was performed by the free-interface diffusion method. Using obtained microcrystals as seeds, large crystals for diffraction data collection were obtained by the sitting-drop vapour-diffusion method. The crystal contained one ternary complex per asymmetric unit, and diffracted to 2.6 A resolution.

Using Microfluidics to Decouple Nucleation and Growth of Protein Crystals

A high throughput, low volume microfluidic device has been designed to decouple the physical processes of protein crystal nucleation and growth. This device, called the Phase Chip, is constructed out of poly(dimethylsiloxane) (PDMS) elastomer. One of the Phase Chip's innovations is to exploit surface tension forces to guide each drop to a storage chamber. We demonstrate that nanoliter water-in-oil drops of protein solutions can be rapidly stored in individual wells thereby allowing the screening of 1000 conditions while consuming a total of only 10 mug protein on a 20 cm(2) chip. Another significant advance over current microfluidic devices is that each well is in contact with a reservoir via a dialysis membrane through which only water and other low molecular weight organic solvents can pass, but not salt, polymer, or protein. This enables the concentration of all solutes in a solution to be reversibly, rapidly, and precisely varied in contrast to current methods, such as the free interface diffusion or sitting drop methods, which are irreversible. The Phase Chip operates by first optimizing conditions for nucleation by using dialysis to supersaturate the protein solution, which leads to nucleation of many small crystals. Next, conditions are optimized for crystal growth by using dialysis to reduce the protein and precipitant concentrations, which leads small crystals to dissolve while simultaneously causing only the largest ones to grow, ultimately resulting in the transformation of many small, unusable crystals into a few large ones.

Crystallization and preliminary X-ray diffraction of the Munc18c–syntaxin41–29complex

The production of diffraction-quality crystals of Munc18c, a protein involved in regulating vesicular exocytosis in mammals, is reported. The diffraction resolution of Munc18c crystals was optimized by (i) cocrystallizing with a peptide fragment of the Munc18c functional binding partner syntaxin4, (ii) using nanolitre free-interface diffusion crystallization-screening chips and microlitre hanging-drop vapour diffusion and (iii) applying a post-crystallization dehydration treatment. Crystals belonging to the cubic space group P2(1)3, with unit-cell parameters a = b = c = 170.8 A, alpha = beta = gamma = 90 degrees , were generated that diffract to 3.7 A resolution on a laboratory X-ray source.

Crystallization and preliminary X-ray analysis of Atg10

Atg10 is an E2-like enzyme that catalyzes the conjugation reaction between Atg12 and Atg5. The Atg12-Atg5 conjugate is essential for autophagy, the bulk degradation process of cytoplasmic components by the vacuolar/lysosomal system. Microcrystals of Saccharomyces cerevisiae Atg10 were obtained by the free-interface diffusion method using polyethylene glycol and sodium acetate as precipitants. Using these precipitants, large crystals suitable for data collection were obtained using the sitting-drop vapour-diffusion method. The crystals belong to space group P4(1)2(1)2 or P4(3)2(1)2, with unit-cell parameters a = b = 51.61, c = 256.16 A, and are estimated to contain two protein molecules per asymmetric unit. A native data set was collected to 2.3 A resolution from a single crystal.

Crystal Structure of a Hyperactive Escherichia coli Glycerol Kinase Mutant Gly230 → Asp Obtained Using Microfluidic Crystallization Devices,

The crystal structure of an Escherichia coli glycerol kinase mutant Gly230 --> Asp (GKG230D) was determined to 2.0 A resolution using a microfluidics based crystallization platform. The crystallization strategy involved a suite of microfluidic devices that characterized the solubility trends of GKG230D, performed nanoliter volume free interface diffusion crystallization experiments, and produced diffraction-quality crystals for in situ data collection. GKG230D displays increased enzymatic activity and decreased allosteric regulation by the glycolytic pathway intermediate fructose 1,6-bisphosphate (FBP) compared to wild-type GK (GKWT). Structural analysis revealed that the decreased allosteric regulation is a result of the altered FBP binding loop conformations in GKG230D that interfere with the wild-type FBP binding site. The altered FBP binding loop conformations in GKG230D are supported through a series of intramolecular loop interactions. The appearance of Asp230 in the FBP binding loops also repositions the wild-type FBP binding residues away from the FBP binding site. Light scattering analysis confirmed GKG230D is a dimer and is resistant to tetramer formation in the presence of FBP, whereas GKWT dimers are converted into putatively inactive tetramers in the presence of FBP. GKG230D also provides the first structural evidence for multiple GK monomer conformations in the presence of glycerol and in the absence of a nucleotide substrate and verifies that glycerol binding is not responsible for locking GK into the closed conformation necessary for GK activity.

A robust and scalable microfluidic metering method that allows protein crystal growth by free interface diffusion.

Producing robust and scalable fluid metering in a microfluidic device is a challenging problem. We developed a scheme for metering fluids on the picoliter scale that is scalable to highly integrated parallel architectures and is independent of the properties of the working fluid. We demonstrated the power of this method by fabricating and testing a microfluidic chip for rapid screening of protein crystallization conditions, a major hurdle in structural biology efforts. The chip has 480 active valves and performs 144 parallel reactions, each of which uses only 10 nl of protein sample. The properties of microfluidic mixing allow an efficient kinetic trajectory for crystallization, and the microfluidic device outperforms conventional techniques by detecting more crystallization conditions while using 2 orders of magnitude less protein sample. We demonstrate that diffraction-quality crystals may be grown and harvested from such nanoliter-volume reactions.

Lysozyme crystal growth kinetics in microgravity.

Mach-Zehnder interferometry is applied to quantitatively characterize growth of lysozyme crystals in microgravity. Experiments were performed by the Free Interface Diffusion technique into APCF FID reactors using large seeds. Tracking of the experiments using interferometry allowed to monitor the onset of supersaturation and the seed growth. A large and stable concentration depletion zone around the growing crystal developed, whose time evolution was analyzed. The interferograms were analyzed taking into account finite thickness of the cell by integrating the concentration over the straight lines through the optical path. It was concluded that there may be a quasi-steady state growth mode at the stage when the spacial concentration distribution did not change but its absolute value over all the cell was slowly diminishing. From this portion of the data, an estimate was made of the dimensionless parameter beta R/D where beta is the face kinetic coefficient, R is the effective crystal size and D is the lysozyme diffusivity in solution, as followed from the steady state model. For the assumed quasi steady state data portion, the parameter varies between 0.7 and 0.9 suggesting mixed diffusion-interface kinetic controlled growth.

Structure of tetragonal hen egg-white lysozyme at 0.94 A from crystals grown by the counter-diffusion method.

Very high quality crystals of tetragonal hen egg-white lysozyme were grown in the Advanced Protein Crystallization Facility (APCF) on board the Space Shuttle using a modified free-interface diffusion (FID) reactor designed ad hoc to have a longer diffusion path. This design allows the performance of true counter-diffusion experiments. Crystals were obtained under the classical chemical conditions defined 50 y ago with NaCl as a crystallizing agent and acetate pH 4.5 as a buffer. Counter-diffusion crystallization allows a "physical" instead of chemical optimization of growth conditions: indeed, this method screens for the best supersaturation conditions in a single trial and yields crystals of very high quality. A complete diffraction data set was collected at atomic resolution from one of these crystals using synchrotron radiation at the DESY-EMBL beamlines. The overall R(merge) on intensities in the resolution range 31-0.94 A was 5.2% and the data were 98.9% complete. Refinement was carried out with the programs CNS and SHELX97 to a final crystallographic R factor of 12.26% for 72 390 reflections. A mean standard uncertainty in the atomic positions of 0.024 A was estimated from inversion of blocked least-squares matrices. 22 side chains show alternate conformations and the loop 59-75 adopts in the same crystal packing two conformations that were observed for either triclinic or tetragonal lysozyme in previous high-resolution studies. In addition to 255 water molecules, the crystallizing agent (one hexacoordinated sodium ion and five chloride anions) participates in the ordered lysozyme hydration shell.

Effects of microgravity on the crystal quality of a collagen-like polypeptide.

(Pro-Pro-Gly)(10) is one of the most widely studied collagen polypeptide models. Microgravity crystal growth of (Pro-Pro-Gly)(10) was carried out in the Advanced Protein Crystallization Facility aboard the Space Shuttle Discovery during the STS-95 mission. Crystals were successfully grown in all experiments, using both dialysis and free-interface diffusion methods. The quality of the microgravity-grown crystals and of ground-grown counterparts was assessed by X-ray synchrotron diffraction. Microgravity-grown crystals exhibited a significant improvement in terms of dimensions and resolution limit. As previously reported, crystals were orthorhombic, space group P2(1)2(1)2(1). However, the diffraction pattern showed weak reflections, never previously measured, that were consistent with new unit-cell parameters a = 26.9, b = 26.4, c = 182.5 A. This allowed the derivation of a new model for the arrangement of the triple-helical molecules in the crystals.