AbstractFrazil ice in the coastal polynyas has been increasingly recognized as important for efficient sea ice production, associated dense water formation, transport of particulate matter and consequent biological production. However, it has not been well understood where and to what degree active‐frazil areas occur in the Northern Hemisphere polynyas. We presented the first mapping of active frazil in the Northern Hemisphere, using sea ice data during September–May for 2002/2003–2010/2011, created from an Advanced Microwave Scanning Radiometer for the Earth Observing System thin ice algorithm that can detect active frazil areas. The North Water, Northeast Water, Anadyr, and St. Lawrence Island polynyas were found to have a relatively high occurrence rate of active frazil compared with other polynyas. We improved the estimation of sea ice production by discriminating between active frazil and thin solid ice and found that previous algorithms tended to overestimate sea ice production, particularly for polynyas dominated by thin solid ice such as the Okhotsk Northwestern polynya. We also made the first global comparison of polynya characteristics for all the major coastal polynyas. The annual ice production rate is 3–4 m yr−1 in the Northern Hemisphere polynyas and 6–9 m yr−1 in the Antarctic coastal polynyas. This large difference is mainly explained by the less frequent occurrence of active frazil and thin ice areas in the Northern Hemisphere polynyas owing to a lower occurrence of strong wind events.