Mechanical properties of metallic foams are highly dependent on the characteristics of porosity. In the case of foams manufactured using space holder particles (SHPs), parameters such as percentage porosity, pore size and cell wall thickness are directly contingent on the SHP used. In this work, different fractal distributions of SHPs were introduced in order to modify the resulting porosity. An Al–Si–Cu alloy was used as raw material for producing metallic foams by infiltration, while NaCl particles of 2 and 4 mm were used as SHPs, modifying the small-to-large particle ratio and fractal dimensions. Cylindrical foams of 10 cm in height and 5 cm in diameter were obtained by infiltrating the Al alloy into the SHPs. Results showed that the use of fractal distribution allowed to slightly increase the percentage porosity, whereas the most important effect was the decrease in cell wall thickness when fractal dimension increased. Mechanical properties were directly affected by these modifications, decreasing when fractality was induced. Finite element analysis models of the foams were obtained in a combination with discrete element method, in order to simulate their compressive elastic behaviors. Young’s modulus estimations were in excellent agreement with experimental results, validating the effect of fractal inclusion and the importance of the correct model selection.