Angiosperm Fossils Research Articles

Oligocene – Miocene Angiosperm Fossil Site at the Boa Vista Basin, Paraíba State, Northeast Brazil

Oligocene – Miocene Angiosperm Fossil Site at the Boa Vista Basin, Paraíba State, Northeast Brazil

Composition of Paleocene forests from Antarctica based on fossil wood

A new assemblage of fossil wood of Paleocene age from Seymour Island, Antarctic Peninsula, is described. Conifer species have been identified, belonging to the fossil genera Agathoxylon, Phyllocladoxylon, Protophyllocladoxylon, and Podocarpoxylon. Angiosperm fossil wood species are assigned to Nothofagoxylon, Caldcluvioxylon, and Myrceugenellites. New wood types have been described with possible affinity to Atherospermataceae and Asteraceae (daisy family). A newly identified fossil angiosperm species, Aextoxicoxylon jacksius, has been recorded from Antarctica for the first time. It shares traits with modern Aextoxicon punctatum and other Aextoxicoxylon wood from South America but is considered a separate species due to significant differences in vessel density, ray height, and frequency. This study indicates, in accordance with previous studies that conifers were the most common elements in the Paleocene Antarctic vegetation. In particular, Agathoxylon being the most dominant wood type. Nothofagoxylon was the most common angiosperm wood type. Overall the composition of the Antarctic Paleocene vegetation deduced from the presence of fossil wood resembles that of the modern warm to cool temperate forests of Tasmania, New Zealand and southern South America. Possible upland and lowland forest types have been identified, with the lowland forests likely most similar to the modern mixed cool temperate forests on South Island, New Zealand, and Tasmania. The upland forests were similar to the modern open canopy Araucaria-Nothofagus forests on the high Andes today.

Unique Jurassic Ovaries Shed a New Light on the Nature of Carpels.

Enclosed ovules are a reproductive feature restricted to angiosperms. Although this feature can be used as a criterion for identifying fossil angiosperms, how ovules are enclosed and the nature of the placenta are still foci of debates. A reason underlying these controversies is the lack of reproductive organ fossils shedding light on these issues. These controversies hinder a clear understanding of angiosperm evolution and systematics. Here, we report a new fossil ovary, Xenofructus dabuensis gen. et sp. nov, from the Middle Jurassic of Liaoning, China. Our fossil clearly demonstrates the existence of ovules in Xenofructus that has a free central placentation. This new feature implies that a placenta in angiosperm gynoecia is homologous to an ovule/seed-bearing axis, and free central placentation is one of the early developed placentations. This discovery is apparently at odds with the current understanding of placentation and its evolution. Apparently, the understanding of angiosperms and their gynoecia should be updated with newly available palaeobotanical data.

The meaning of mass extinctions and what the fossil record tells us about angiosperm survival at K-Pg: a reply to Hagen (2024).

Last year, we published research using phylogenetic comparative methods (PCMs) to reveal no phylogenetic evidence for elevated lineage-level extinction rates in angiosperms across K-Pg (Thompson JB, Ramírez-Barahona S. 2023 No phylogenetic evidence for angiosperm mass extinction at the Cretaceous-Palaeogene (K-Pg) boundary. Biol. Lett. 19, 20230314. (doi:10.1098/rsbl.2023.0314)), results that are in step with the global angiosperm fossil record. In a critique of our paper (Hagen ER. 2024 A critique of Thompson and Ramírez-Barahona (2023) or: how I learned to stop worrying and love the fossil record. EcoEvoRxiv. (doi:10.32942/X2631W)), simulation work is presented to argue we erred in our methodological choices and interpretations, and that we should have deferred to fossil evidence. In our opinion, underlying this critique are poor methodological choices on simulations and philosophical problems surrounding the definition of a mass extinction event, which leads to incorrect interpretations of both the fossil record and PCMs. We further argue that deferring to one source of evidence in favour of the other shuts the door to important evolutionary and philosophical questions.

Cretaceous and Paleocene fossils reveal an extinct higher clade within Cornales, the dogwood order.

Characterization and phylogenetic integration of fossil angiosperms with uncertain affinities is relatively limited, which may obscure the diversity of extinct higher taxa in the flowering plant tree of life. The order Cornales contains a diversity of extinct taxa with uncertain familial affinities that make it an ideal group for studying turnover in angiosperms. Here, we describe a new extinct genus of Cornales unassignable to an extant family and conduct a series of phylogenetic analyses to reconstruct relationships of fossils across the order. Two permineralized endocarps were collected from the Cedar District Formation (Campanian, 82-80 Ma) of Sucia Island, State of Washington, United States. Fossils were sectioned with the cellulose acetate peel technique and incorporated into a morphological dataset. To assess the utility of this dataset to accurately place taxa in their respective clades, we used a series of phylogenetic pseudofossilization analyses. We then conducted a total-evidence analysis and a scaffold-based approach to determine relationships of fossils. Based on their unique combination of characters, the fossils represent a new genus, Fenestracarpa washingtonensis gen. nov. et sp. nov. Pseudofossilization analyses indicate that our morphological dataset can be used to accurately recover taxa at the major clade to family level, generally with moderate to high support. The total-evidence and scaffold-based analyses recovered Fenestracarpa and other fossil genera in an entirely extinct clade within Cornales. Our findings increase the reported diversity of extinct Cornales and indicate that the order's initial radiation likely included the divergence of an extinct higher clade that endured the end-Cretaceous Mass extinction but perished during the Cenozoic.

Report of the Nomenclature Committee for Fossils: 17

SummaryThe following four generic names are recommended for conservation: Dipterocarpoxylon with a conserved type against Hippocrateoxylon, Dryobalanoxylon against Naucleoxylon, Shoreoxylon against Bredaea and Grewioxylon, and Myrtophyllum Heer (fossil Angiosperms) with a conserved type against Myrtophyllum Turcz. The following one species name is recommended for conservation: Quercus pacifica Nixon & C.H. Mull. against Q. pacifica Knowlt.

Angiosperm fossil woods from the Upper Cretaceous (Cardiel Formation) of Argentinean Patagonia

Abstract We describe nine angiosperm fossil woods from sediments of the Cardiel Formation (Upper Cretaceous) near the Cardiel Lake, Santa Cruz Province, Argentinian Patagonia. On the basis of the characteristics of the anatomy, the specimens were placed in three fossil species: Weinmannioxylon trichospermoides related to the Cunoniaceae, Burseroxylon panzai sp. nov. possibly related to the Anacardiaceae or Burseraceae, and a new taxon with unknown affinity, Tortorellixylon oligoporosum gen. et sp. nov. Angiosperms are 15% of the assemblage and conifers 85%, which is consistent with previous studies of fossil woods from the Late Cretaceous of Patagonia. Most specimens show poorly distinct growth ring boundaries that suggest a weakly marked annual seasonality during the deposition of the Cardiel Formation. In addition, the specimens’ size and the rings’ curvature are consistent with large trees. Decay patterns similar to those produced by modern xylophagous fungi are also recognized in most specimens. The identification of three species in an assemblage of nine fossil woods suggests a significant taxonomic richness of angiosperms, and the taxonomic composition suggests a Late Cretaceous age for the Cardiel Formation (probably Campanian–Maastrichtian). These new records allow a better understanding of the composition of the fossil forests of the Late Cretaceous of Patagonia, in which the tree canopy was apparently dominated by conifers.

Is Santaniella a ranunculid? Reassessment of this enigmatic fossil angiosperm from the Lower Cretaceous (Aptian, Crato Konservat-Lagerstätte, Brazil) provides a new interpretation.

The Lower Cretaceous Crato Konservat-Lagerstätte (CKL) preserves a rich flora that includes early angiosperms from northern Gondwana. From this area, the recently described fossil genus Santaniella was interpreted as a ranunculid (presumably Ranunculaceae). However, based on our examination of an additional specimen and a new phylogenetic analysis, we offer an alternative interpretation. The new fossil was collected from an active quarry for paving stones in the state of Ceará, northeastern Brazil. We assessed support for alternative phylogenetic hypotheses using a combined analysis of morphological data and DNA sequence data using Bayesian inference. We used a consensus network to visualize the posterior distribution of trees, and we used RoguePlot to illustrate the support for alternative positions on a scaffold tree. The new material includes a flower-like structure not present in the original material and also includes follicles preserved at early stages of development. The flower-like structure is a compact terminal cluster of elliptical sterile laminar organs surrounding internal filamentous structures that occur on flexuous axes. Phylogenetic analyses did not support the fossil placement among eudicots. Instead, Santaniella appears to belong in the magnoliid clade. The presence of seeds in a marginal-linear placentation and enclosed in a follicle supports the fossil as an angiosperm. However, even though most characters are clearly recognizable, its combination of characters does not provide strong support for a close relationship to any extant order of flowering plants. Its position in the magnoliid clade is intriguing and, based on plicate carpels, it is definitely a mesangiosperm.

Past climates and plant migration – the significance of the fossil record

This article is a Commentary on Denk et al. (2023), 238: 2668–2684.

Megafossils of Betulaceae from the Oligocene of Qaidam Basin and their paleoenvironmental and phytogeographic implications

Understanding the paleoenvironment and phytogeographical history of the Tibetan Plateau, China relies on discovering new plant fossils. The Qaidam Basin has long been regarded as an ideal ‘field laboratory’ to investigate the paleoclimate and paleobiological evolution of the northern Tibetan Plateau. However, fossil angiosperms from the Qaidam Basin are rare, and our knowledge of its paleovegetation is poor. Here, we report fossil leaves and fruits of Betulaceae found from the Oligocene Shangganchaigou Formation of northwestern Qaidam Basin (Huatugou area). Comparative morphological analysis led us to assign the fruits to the Betula subgenus Betula and the leaves to Carpinus grandis. These findings, together with other reported fossil plants from the same locality, reveal a close floristic linkage between the Qaidam Basin and Europe during the Oligocene. The northern pathway of this floristic exchange may have crossed through the Qaidam Basin during the late Paleogene. This floristic linkage may have been facilitated by the continuous narrowing of the Turgai Strait and stronger westerlies, which transported moisture and provided favorable climatic conditions. Indeed, fossil plants collected from the Qaidam Basin suggest that during the Oligocene this region had warm and humid deciduous broad-leaf forest, which differs from the region’s modern vegetation and indicates that the Qaidam Basin may have been a suitable region for these plants to flourish and spread during the Oligocene.

An Anatomically Preserved Cone-like Flower from the Lower Cretaceous of China.

Although diverse fossil angiosperms (including their reproductive organs) have been reported from the Early Cretaceous, few of them are well-documented due to poor preservation and limited technologies available to apply. For example, paraffin sectioning, a routine technology applied to reveal the anatomical details of extant plants, was hitherto at most rarely applied to fossil plants. This undermines the comparability between the outcomes of studies on fossil and extant plants, and makes our understanding on plants incomplete and biased. Here, we applied paraffin sectioning technology, in addition to light microscopy, SEM, and TEM, to document a fossil reproductive organ, Xilinia gen. nov., from the Early Cretaceous in Inner Mongolia, China. The anatomical details of this new reproductive organ were documented. Xilinia bears a remarkable resemblance to conifer cones, although its ovules are enclosed in carpels. The paradoxical cone-like morphology of Xilinia appears to represent a transitional snapshot of plant evolution that is absent in extant plants.

Perspectiva paleobotánica y geológica de la biodiversidad en México

El origen de la vegetación actual de México y su diversidad tiene larga historia. Posiblemente es la extensión de esta historia el punto en que discrepan las propuestas, una planteando que inicia en el Cretácico (ca. 132 ma) y otras haciendo énfasis en procesos restringidos al Plio-Pleistoceno (5.3 ma), sobre todo si se refieren al origen de la vegetación actual. El aumento del conocimiento sobre la evolución geológica de México, y del constante cambio en su fisiografía, así como del estudio de las angiospermas fósiles de la región, genera un concepto más claro de cómo y cuándo las formas de vida fueron llegando y asociándose. Se presenta una hipótesis en la que se combinan procesos geológicos y cambios fisiográficos, con la presencia de plantas y vegetación en las partes emergidas que se van desarrollando. Se propone que la biodiversidad actual efectivamente inicia hace ca. 132 millones de años, aunque linajes que hoy viven en México se pueden reconocer desde este tiempo, es complicado ubicarlos en familias, pues posiblemente representen miembros del grupo troncal. En el Paleógeno (65-32 ma) las familias, y aun géneros, que continúan viviendo en el país son más fácilmente reconocidos, pero grupos extintos o que hoy crecen en otras regiones siguen siendo comunes. Es en el Neógeno (32-1.8 ma) que desde un punto de vista de la morfológico/anatómico las plantas fósiles se parecen más a las que viven de forma natural actualmente en el país, pero muestran diferencias que en general permiten proponer nuevas especies. Si las plantas fósiles y actuales de México se relacionan morfo/anatómicamente más solo en tiempos relativamente recientes, es de esperar que con los tipos de vegetación suceda algo similar. El registro fósil sugiere que a partir de comunidades que se desarrollaron bajo condiciones cálido-húmedas en el Cretácico, divergieron tipos de vegetación con capacidades diferentes ante el estrés hídrico, y comunidades que se favorecieron de condiciones templadas a frías. Esto sucede aparentemente en dos momentos distintos en dos regiones diferentes; durante el Paleógeno se afecta al norte y en al Neógeno al centro y sur del país. Trabajo geológico y paleobotánico conjunto y comparativo permitirá refinar esta propuesta que sugiere que los cambios que activan o restringen respuestas biológicas forman parte de otros componentes del Sistema Tierra.

Examining paleobotanical databases: Revisiting trends in angiosperm folivory and unlocking the paleoecological promise of propensity score matching and specification curve analysis

Paleobotany is at a crossroads. Long-term trends in the fossil record of plants, encompassing their interactions with herbivores and with the environment, are of the utmost relevance for predicting global change as pCO2 continues to rise. Large data compilations with the potential to elucidate those trends are increasingly easy to assemble and access. However, in contrast to modern ecology and unlike various other paleontological disciplines, paleobotany has a limited history of “big data” meta-analyses. Debates about how much data are needed to address particular questions, and about how to control for potential confounding variables, have not examined paleobotanical data. Here I demonstrate the importance of analytical best practices by applying them to a recent meta-analysis of fossil angiosperms. Two notable analytical methods discussed here are propensity score matching and specification curve analysis. The former has been used in the biomedical and behavioral sciences for decades; the latter is a more recent method of examining relationships between, and inherent biases among, models. Propensity score matching allows one to account for potential confounding variables in observational studies, and more fundamentally, provides a way to quantify whether it is possible to account for them. Specification curve analysis provides the opportunity to examine patterns across a variety of schemes for partitioning data—for example, whether fossil assemblages are binned temporally by stage, epoch, or period. To my knowledge, neither of these methods has been used previously in paleontology, however, their use permits more robust analysis of paleoecological datasets. In the example provided here, propensity score matching is used to separate latitudinal trends from differences in age, climate, and plant community composition. Specification curve analysis is used to examine the robustness of apparent latitudinal trends to the schema used for assigning fossil assemblages to latitudinal bins. These analytical methods have the potential to further unlock the promise of the plant fossil record for elucidating long-term ecological and evolutionary change.

A new fossil angiosperm from the Early Cretaceous (early Aptian) of the Zhongkouzi Basin in the Beishan area, Northwest China

ABSTRACT A new angiosperm is reported based on a leaf specimen from the Early Cretaceous Chijinpu Formation in Beishan area, Northwest China. The associated plants include abundant gymnosperms and ferns. The new angiosperm leaf, discovered for the first time in this region, has a cordate base and peltate excentric lamina attachment. Cluster analysis and morphological comparisons with other angiosperm leaves show that this specimen is more similar to peltate fossil leaves. However, the exact taxonomic position of this fossil leaf is uncertain due to limited characters, so that we established a new genus and species, Gansupeltata beishanensis gen. et sp. nov. The new finding adds to the diversity of early angiosperms, and further demonstrates that angiosperms have already evolved during the Early Cretaceous in the Beishan area, Northwest China.

A novel fossil-species of Meliolinites Selkirk (fossil Meliolaceae) and its life cycle stages associated with an angiosperm fossil leaf from the Siwalik (Mio-Pliocene) of Bhutan sub-Himalaya

Here, we report the in-situ occurrence of a new fossil-species of Meliolinites (fossil Meliolaceae), Meliolinites bhutanensis sp. nov. on the cuticle fragments of a compressed angiosperm dicot leaf recovered from the middle Siwalik (Formation II: latest Miocene to Pliocene) of Bhutan, eastern Himalaya. This unique foliicolous new fossil fungal species features well-preserved mycelia consisting of superficial, brown to dark brown, septate, thick-walled, branching hyphae with bi-cellular appressoria, unicellular phialides, and a characteristic long, slightly curved hyphal seta. The web-like, brown to dark brown fungal colonies also include globose to sub-globose, dark brown ascomata, and oblong to broadly cylindrical, 5-celled, 4-septate, brown to dark brown, mature ascospores. As almost all features of different stages in the life cycle (ascospores, mature germinating ascospores, superficial lateral hyphae, hyphal seta, hyphopodia, mycelial colony, and ascomata) of this new fossil-species are found, we have proposed the first time a possible life cycle of fossil-species of Meliolaceae. The in-situ evidence of M. bhutanensis on the host leaf cuticle indicates the possible existence of a host-ectoparasite relationship in Bhutan sub-Himalaya's ancient warm and humid tropical evergreen forest during the deposition. So, M. bhutanensis might have thrived generally under warm and humid climate conditions for its growth and development in the Mio-Pliocene time, which is in conformity with our recently published quantitative climatic data by CLAMP (Climate Leaf Analysis Multivariate Program) analysis.

A Novel Early Cretaceous Flower and Its Implications on Flower Derivation.

Simple SummaryMany people are fascinated by beautiful flowers. Botanists have been intensively studying flowers to decipher their history. Various hypotheses have been advanced to account for the evolution of flowers. Unfortunately, most hypotheses are based on the understanding of modern flowers. Magnolia and related plants were once thought to bear the greatest resemblance to ancestral flowers. Naturally, botanists have been frequently surprised by new finds in the past century. A new flower named Lingyuananthus from the Early Cretaceous (about 125 million years ago) in China is the latest surprise for botanists. Distinct from all previously reported fossil flowers of similar ages, Lingyuananthus has an inferior ovary, syncarpy, and hypanthium. All three features were thought to be highly derived in angiosperms. Considering its Early Cretaceous age (the currently widely accepted earliest age of angiosperms and flowers), Lingyuananthus is a black swan that illustrates how astray botanists may have gone previously. Unable to account for the fossil flower diversity in the Early Cretaceous, botanical theories face a crisis. Among existing hypotheses, Zimmermann’s hypothesis, a long-time unfavored hypothesis, stands out like a black swan: it provides a better explanation for the origin and evolution of Lingyuananthus.Background: The origin and early evolution of angiosperms, by far the most important plant group for human beings, are questions demanding answers, mainly due to a lack of related fossils. The Yixian Formation (Lower Cretaceous) is famous for its fossils of early angiosperms, and several Early Cretaceous angiosperms with apocarpous gynoecia have been documented. However, a hypanthium and an inferior ovary are lacking in these fossil angiosperms. Methods: The specimen was collected from the outcrop of the Yixian Formation in Dawangzhangzi in the suburb of Lingyuan, Liaoning, China. The specimen was photographed using a Nikon D200 digital camera, and its details were photographed using a Nikon SMZ1500 stereomicroscope and a MAIA3 TESCAN SEM. Results: A fossil angiosperm, Lingyuananthus inexpectus gen. et sp. nov, is reported from the Lower Cretaceous of China. Differing from those documented previously, Lingyuananthus has a hypanthium, an inferior ovary, and ovules inside its ovary. Such a character assemblage indicates its angiospermous affinity, although not expected by any existing leading angiosperm evolutionary theory. Conclusions: New fossil material with a unique character assemblage falls beyond the expectation of the currently widely accepted theories of angiosperm evolution. Together with independently documented fossils of early angiosperms, Lingyuananthus suggests that at least some early angiosperms’ flowers can be derived in a way that has been ignored previously.

A novel cupulate seed plant, Xadzigacalix quatsinoensis gen. et sp. nov., provides new insight into the Mesozoic radiation of gymnosperms.

PremiseAnatomically preserved evidence for a novel clade of gymnosperms emphasizes diversity of seed plants immediately prior to the appearance of angiosperm fossils in the paleontological record.MethodsCupulate seeds from the Early Cretaceous Apple Bay locality (Vancouver Island) are described from serial cellulose acetate peels and three‐dimensional reconstruction. Phylogenetic context is assessed through the comparative analysis of gymnosperm seed producing fructifications and maximum parsimony analysis of a revised morphological data set for seed plant phylogeny.Results Xadzigacalix quatsinoensis gen. et sp. nov. is characterized by an orthotropous ovule with an elongated micropyle and complex integument, enclosed within a radial cupule. The micropylar canal is elongated; and the nucellus extends into the micropyle to seal the post pollination ovule. Except at the apex of the micropyle, the seed is completely enclosed by a parenchymatous cupule with ca. 20 axially elongated secretory ducts. The cupulate seed is produced upon a triangular woody stele, consisting of a parenchymatous pith surrounded by radially aligned tracheids. The stele produces three short terete traces that terminate within the base of the cupule as transfusion tissue at the seed chalaza.ConclusionsOrganography, vascularization, nature of the integument and nucellus, and configuration of the micropylar canal distinguish Xadzigacalix quatsinoensis from all other gymnosperm clades. Cladistic analyses suggest the new plant may have affinities with gnetophytes or angiosperms. These results are complemented with a critical re‐evaluation of ovulate structures for Mesozoic gymnosperms, providing new insight into plant diversity immediately antecedent to the explosive diversification of flowering plants.

A Jurassic flower bud from China

Abstract Angiosperms may be distinguished from their gymnosperm peers by their flowers, and thus a flower is a good proxy of fossil angiosperms. However, flowers and their parts are usually too frail to be preserved in the fossil record. This makes the origin of angiosperms and their flowers the foci of controversy in botany. Eliminating such botanical controversies can only be achieved by studying related plant fossils. Applying routine scanning electron microscopy, light microscopy and micro-computed tomography (micro-CT) technologies, we document a fossil flower bud, Florigerminis jurassica gen. et sp. nov., from the Jurassic of Inner Mongolia, China. This fossil includes not only a leafy branch but also physically connected fruit and flower bud. The developmentally interpolated existence of a blooming flower between the flower bud and mature fruit in Florigerminis suggests that angiosperm flowers were present in the Jurassic, in agreement with recent botanical progress. Florigerminis jurassica underscores the presence of angiosperms in the Jurassic and demands a rethinking of angiosperm evolution.

A eudicot leaf from the Lower Cretaceous (Aptian, Araripe Basin) Crato Konservat-Lagerstätte.

The Crato Konservat-Lagerstätte in Brazil preserves an exceptionally rich assemblage of plant macrofossils from the Early Cretaceous (late Aptian), including rare early angiosperm fossils related to Nymphaeales, monocots, and magnoliids, and a variety of angiosperms of uncertain affinities. Macrofossils of eudicot angiosperms have not been described previously, despite the presence of tricolpate pollen. We describe a fossil leaf with morphology characteristic of eudicot angiosperms. The fossil was collected from a quarry in the Lower Cretaceous (late Aptian) Crato Formation of northeastern Brazil in the state of Ceará. We compared the leaf architecture with that of ferns, gymnosperms, and similar living and fossil angiosperms. The leaf of Baderadea pinnatissecta gen. et sp. nov. is simple and petiolate, with leaf architecture similar to that of some herbaceous Ranunculales. The blade is 5 cm long and the margin is untoothed and twice pinnately lobed with narrow lobes (pinnatisect). The primary vein framework is pinnate and there are multiple orders of reticulate venation. The combination of characters preserved in the fossil supports the interpretation that B. pinnatissecta was an herbaceous eudicot similar to some members of Ranunculales and distinguished from other lobate Aptian angiosperms by leaf shape, presence of multiple orders of reticulate venation, and the absence of glandular teeth. The presence of eudicots in the flora of the Crato was already supported by pollen; the discovery of macrofossils like these provides additional information about their morphology and ecological role in low-latitude Early Cretaceous plant communities.

Criterion is a touchstone in study of early angiosperms

Herendeen et al. set up a criterion identifying fossil angiosperms while they named five examples of fossil angiosperms in the same paper. Their normal-appearing operation, however, is fundamentally flawed: their exemplar fossil angiosperms did not honor their own criterion. This operation confused their proponents as well as other botanical researchers, hindering healthy progress in study on the origin of angiosperms. Herendeen et al. are obligated to give a plausible explanation for their perplexing operation. *Nature Plants has been informed of the problem in Herendeen et al. (2017). Nature Plants has refused to fix the problem due to reasons, according to the communication with Dr. Chris Surridge, an editor of Nature Plants.