Two new C,O-bidentate chelating triazolylidene-phenolate ligands were synthesized that feature a diisopropylphenyl (dipp) and an adamantyl (Ad) substituent respectively on the triazole scaffold. Subsequent metalation afforded iron(II) complexes [Fe(C^O)2] that are active catalysts for the intramolecular C-H amination of organic azides. When compared to the parent complex containing a triazolylidene with a mesityl substituent (Mes) the increased steric bulk led to slightly lower activity (TOFmax = 23 h-1vs. 30 h-1), however selectivity towards pyrrolidine formation increases from 92% up to >99%. Kinetic studies indicate that the mechanism is similar in all three complexes and includes a half-order dependence in [Fe(C^O)2], congruent with the involvement of a dimetallic catalyst resting state within this catalyst class. Structural analysis suggests that enhanced bulkiness disfavors N2 loss and nitrene formation, yet shields the nitrene from intermolecular processes and thus favors intramolecular nitrene insertion into the C-H bond. This model rationalizes the high selectivity and the lower reaction rate observed with dipp and with Ad substituents on the ligand.