In the present work, we applied our recent hypothesis of intramolecular excimer formation to explain the lack of stable photochromism of linear naphthopyran. To clarify the influence of the stacking interaction between the non-aromatic naphthalene unit and aromatic phenyl ring, a comparative analysis of the results of identical TD-DFT/DFT calculations was performed for angular (3H–) and linear naphthopyrans. In contrary to linear naphthopyran, the open form of 3H-naphthopyran is very stable. The excitations of the closed forms of both naphthopyran isomers are quantitatively and qualitatively close to each other. Optimization of the excited states of the closed forms of both naphthopyran isomers from their FC points leads to the cleavage of C–O bonds and the formation of stacks between the phenyl rings and conjugated rings. The total interaction energy in the intramolecular excimer of 3H-naphthopyran is 17 kcal/mol higher in absolute value than for linear naphthopyran. This difference is due to the significantly greater overlap of rings during stacking in the intramolecular excimer of 3H-naphthopyran compared to linear naphthopyran, since the attraction between the aromatic and non-aromatic systems decreases very strongly with their longitudinal displacement. According to calculations, upon relaxation, 3H-naphthopyran retains the open form with residual stacking while in linear naphthopyran the stacking is destroyed completely, and the molecule returns to the closed form by C–O bond recovery.
Read full abstract