REVIEWS 791 history,where it exists,points to some alternativeconclusionsabout the nature and directionof Hungariansocialdevelopment.Tibor Valuchin an impressive yet provisional social history of Hungary since I945 has argued that behind the impact of the grand strategies of the Stalinist, Kadarist and liberal democratic regimes some remarkablecontinuitiesin society can be discerned. The time has come for more complex conceptualizations of social change in Hungarywhich allow for the autonomy of social groupsvis-a-vis the state. Department ofHistoy M. D. PITTAWAY TheOpenUniversity Duijzings, Ger.Religion andthePolitics ofIdentity inKosovo. C. Hurst&Company, London, 2000. XV+ 238 pp. Notes. Illustrations.Maps. Bibliographical references.Index. ?35.00; Ci6.50. GERDuIJzINGS claims that his anthropological work in Kosovo gave him insights which offer a corrective approach to the more characteristic and widely publicized characteristicstudies of South-East European politics. By 'enteringsmalland unknownside-paths'as a participantobserverhe attempts to 'open up new perspectiveson old problems'(p. 2 Io). Duijzings has researched widely and surveys a range of views, besides detailing and analysing his own extensive findings; he completed a project very differentfrom that upon which he had set out to complete. His originally projected micro-studyof a small ruralKosovar Croatian community close to the Macedonian border was eroded shortly after his arrivalby the exodus of thatcommunity in responseto theviolence Croatiancommunitieshad already experienced elsewhere in the by-then-former-Yugoslavia.This led to what Duijzings termed 'ethnic unmixing'which is the subjectof his second chapter. Thereafter the author's focus widened to include other ethnographic casestudies which are collected in the present volume, thereby portraying the 'tension between conflict and symbiosis [... .] and the role played by religion in the local, regional and national politics of identity' (p. x). One of his chaptersis on the revivalof popular Sufismin Kosovo (basedon his I989 MA thesis). Commenting that religion is a major source identification in the Balkans (P. 157),he qualifiesthat due to theirfluctuatingplace in Europe,the Kosovar identity also fluctuates. A range of groups with various oppressors have occupied the same geographicalarea.Albanianshave been Serbianized,Serbs have been Albanianized. The Turkishlanguage is widely spoken, leading to the labeling of some as 'Turks'. This in turn made it easier to demand the removal of such groups to 'return' to Turkey. Duijzings spent time visiting shrines, especially at times of pilgrimages, and found that Muslims and Gypsies regularlyvisited Orthodox shrines, that ethnic syncretism,although not sanctioned by the church authoritieswas not only tolerated, but actually encouraged locally. There areparallelsin Albania and elsewhere. The way divisions emerged in particularperiods also varied; for example during the eighteenth and early nineteenth centuries the widest division was between landlords and others. In the I950S the divisions were political: 792 SEER, 79, 4, 200I communists versus irredentists (Albanians sentenced fellow Albanians as 'counter-revolutionaries'). Clear labels are a recent phenomenon (p. 24), especially as a form of manipulation through the use of categories in census gathering. Dominant groups attempted to include smallergroups to increase their power. As an example of this Duijzing's chapter on 'The Making of Egyptans in Kosovo and Macedonia' recordsthe remarkableemergence of a group whose first claims were made in i99i. Some considered these were merely Gypsies, but Serbs and Macedonians were keen to disclaim their Albanian origins;the resultwas the manipulationof as many as 83,000 people in one study. Duijzings analysesboth Balkanand Westernmythsabout the Balkans,even going so far as to state that European nation-stateshave encouraged most of the violence (p. 208); he cites the excessive resort to nationalist discourseby journalists and scholars. He devotes a chapter each to the Serbian myths of the Battle of Kosovo and to the Albanian Qerbalaja (or Kerbela) myth. He finds they have much in common: each have been portrayed through epic song and folk verse, both record a lost battle where righteous forces were overcome by evil ones, and the main hero was sacrificed, leading to the necessity for followersto accept sufferingas a step to redemption and a revolt against tyranny. Both lent weight to growing nationalism during the nineteenth century. For Albanians, 'religion is almost irrelevant in (official) political life' (P. I59); Albanian nationalism is not clothed in religious terms. Albanian nationalism never became entwined with its religion, nor were Kosovo's...