Malignant triton tumors (MTTs) are a rare and aggressive type of malignant peripheral nerve sheath tumor identified histologically by focal rhabdomyoblastic differentiation. A 37-year-old female with a prior history of Hodgkin lymphoma presented with acute-onset confusion, cognitive deficits, and weakness. Brain magnetic resonance imaging revealed a hemorrhagic intracranial mass later confirmed to be a malignant triton tumor. The patient underwent two resections and several courses of chemoradiation for multiple tumor recurrences and metastases. Unfortunately, despite extensive treatment, she died 2 years after initial presentation from complications of this tumor. Her overall survival (OS) of 26.7 months was double that reported in historical cohorts (OS ∼13 mos). The diagnosis and treatment of central nervous system MTTs are difficult and require a multidisciplinary team of neurosurgeons, radiologists, and oncologists. Histopathological analysis is required for confirmation of diagnosis. Gross-total resection of tumor and adjuvant radiation therapy have been shown to give patients the highest rates of survival and improved outcomes. Further studies and clinical trials are warranted to investigate the efficacy of chemotherapeutic agents like temozolomide, bevacizumab, and abemaciclib.