Field-flow Fractionation Separation Research Articles

Preparative field flow fractionation for complex environmental samples: online detection by inductively coupled plasma mass spectrometry and offline detection by gas chromatography with flame ionization

Asymmetric flow field flow fractionation (AF4) in particular online with elemental detection via inductively coupled plasma mass spectrometry (ICP-MS) has been developed as powerful and flexible separation technique for suspensions of nano- and micro-particles covering a broad range of applications including environmental water samples and soil extracts. However, for challenging applications, such as particulate phosphorus determination in non-contaminated water samples at levels close to the limit of detection the throughput of the analytical field flow fractionation (FFF) is not sufficient. The same holds true for more specific identification and quantification of black carbon (BC) which needs a subsequent complex multi-step analysis using the well-established benzene polycarboxylic acids (BPCA) method.To overcome these limitations, the performance of a commercially available preparative AF4 channel, which has rarely been applied, yet, was investigated in this study. Using the example of an extract from charcoal spiked soil, method development for the preparative channel was performed and the results from six replicate fractionations with multi-element online detection by ICP-MS were compared to the results from the analytical channel for the same extracts. A similar fractionation pattern was achieved and the quantitative results agreed well for most of the particulate fractions (ratio 1.7 with standard deviation (SD) 0.2 for fraction 1, ratio 0.81 with SD 0.14 for fraction 2 and ratio 1.1 with SD 0.2 for fraction 3). Relative standard deviations were in the range of 9% to 18% for the preparative channel and between 3% and 17% for the analytical channel. Transferability of the separation parameters between both channels is discussed as well as the operational challenges of the preparative channel. As proof of principle, preparative fractionation of an extract from charcoal spiked soil was performed with fraction collection and subsequent quantification of BC via the BPCA method including derivatization, cation exchange pre-cleaning and finally gas chromatographic separation and quantification via flame ionization detection. The results indicated the majority of detected BC in the often so-called dissolved fraction was bound to nanoparticles (48%) and colloids (27%). Only 25% was detected in the cross flow (truly dissolved fraction). This successful example opens new possibilities for hyphenation of FFF separation with multiple detection techniques for improved characterization of particulate matter in challenging applications.

Single-particle inductively coupled plasma mass spectroscopy analysis of size and number concentration in mixtures of monometallic and bimetallic (core-shell) nanoparticles

It is challenging to separate and measure the physical and chemical properties of monometallic and bimetallic engineered nanoparticles (NPs), especially when mixtures are similar in size and at low concentration. We report that single particle inductively coupled mass spectroscopy (SP-ICP-MS), alongside field flow fractionation (FFF), has allowed for the accurate measurement of size and particle number concentrations of mixed metallic nanoparticles (NPs) containing monometallic NPs of gold (Au) and silver (Ag) and a bimetallic core-shell structured NP (Au@Ag) of equivalent size. Two sets of these NPs were measured. The first contained only 60nm particles, where the Au@Ag NP had a 30nm core and 15nm shell to make a total diameter of 60nm. The second contained only 80nm particles (Au@Ag NP core particle of 50nm with a 15nm shell). FFF separation was used here as a sizing technique rather than a separation technique. It was used to confirm that suspensions containing either individual or mixtures of the Au 60nm, Ag 60nm and AuAg 60nm suspensions eluted together and were of the same size. Similarly, FFF was used to show that suspensions containing individual or mixtures of the equivalent 80nm, eluted together and were of the same size. Although the 60nm and 80nm suspensions did not elute at the same time they were not run together. SP-ICP-MS is then used to identify the size and concentration of the particles within the suspension. Successful separation of the NPs was effected and the limits of the instrument were obtained.

Field-flow fractionation of nano- and microparticles in rotating coiled columns

Field-flow fractionation (FFF) is a very powerful and versatile set of liquid chromatography-like elution methods. However, conventional FFF separations occur in thin channels and the sample weight injected is usually less than 1mg to avoid overloading. The fractionation in a rotating coiled column (RCC), which can be attributed to sedimentation FFF, enables the handling sample weight to be increased at least up to 1g. An uneven distribution of particles in RCC was first observed by Y. Ito et al. in 1966. The work in this direction was continued by P.S. Fedotov et al. in 2000. Regularities of the behaviour of nano- and microparticles of different size and origin in RCCs with different design parameters were systematically studied taking as example silica particles, latex beads, quartz sand, clay minerals, and other samples. The basic principles of the new FFF method were established. The developed method was applied to the speciation analysis of polydisperse environmental samples, in particular, for the separation of soils into silt, clay and sand fractions. For the first time, nano- and submicron particles of street dust have been separated, weighted, characterized by electronic microscopy, and quantitatively analyzed by ICP-MS (after digestion). The elements that may be of anthropogenic origin (Zn, Cr, Ni, Cu, Cd, Sn, Pb) were found to concentrate mainly in <0.3 and 0.3–1μm fractions. It has been shown that the concentrations of Cr, Ni, Zn in the finest fraction (<0.3μm) of street dust can be one order of magnitude higher than the concentrations of elements in bulk sample. The fractionation in RCC was also used for the recovery of a nearly monodisperse fraction (4.5μm) of a chromatographic sorbent based on polystyrene-divinylbenzene; impurities remaining from the synthesis and smaller particles (1–2μm) being removed. Study on the fractionation of synthetic samples has demonstrated the applicability of the method to the preparative separation and purification of polydisperse materials.

Separation of nano- and micro-sized materials by hyphenated flow and centrifugal field-flow fractionation

A novel field-flow fractionation (FFF) separation system, a separation system that hyphenated a flow FFF and a centrifugal FFF, was investigated as a hybrid tool for fractionation of nano- and micro-materials. The investigated FFF system makes it possible to separate materials with a considerably wider size distribution than is possible by either a flow FFF or centrifugal FFF alone. The hyphenated FFF separation system is also able to simultaneously separate materials by both hydrodynamic size and density. This investigated analytical method should play an important role in developing new applications of colloidal nano- and micro-materials in industrial and biological research.

Improved sedimentation field-flow fractionation separation channel for concentrated cellular elution

SdFFF is now commonly used for cell sorting. Nevertheless, as with many other separation methods, SdFFF Hyperlayer elution leads (1) to sample dilution resulting in cell loss which could restrict further use; and (2) to a high output flow rate impacting detector sensitivity and selectivity. In order to limit these problems, we proposed modifications of the SdFFF separation channel consisting both in downscaling and the insertion of an outlet stream splitter. This last system corresponded to a strip which divides the flow rate output into two parts, one containing concentrated cells in a reduced volume and flow rate, the other containing the excess mobile phase useless for further cell manipulation, detection and characterization. For the first time we have shown that splitter implementation and downscaling respected channel flowing and resulted in Hyperlayer elution of around 95% of cells in less than 50% of input flow rate. Improved cell sorting was demonstrated by enrichment (∼10 times) of cancer stem cells from WiDr cells with two times less quantity of injected cells.

Comparison of on-line detectors for field flow fractionation analysis of nanomaterials

Characterization of nanomaterials must include analysis of both size and chemical composition. Many analytical techniques, such as dynamic light scattering (DLS), are capable of measuring the size of suspended nanometer-sized particles, yet provide no information on the composition of the particle. While field flow fractionation (FFF) is a powerful nanoparticle sizing technique, common detectors used in conjunction with the size separation, including UV, light-scattering, and fluorescence spectroscopy, do not provide the needed particle compositional information. Further, these detectors do not respond directly to the mass concentration of nanoparticles. The present work describes the advantages achieved when interfacing sensitive and elemental specific detectors, such as inductively coupled plasma atomic emission spectroscopy and mass spectrometry, to FFF separation analysis to provide high resolution nanoparticle sizing and compositional analysis at the μg/L concentration level, a detection at least 10–100-fold lower than DLS or FFF–UV techniques. The full benefits are only achieved by utilization of all detector capabilities, such as dynamic reaction cell (DRC) ICP–MS. Such low-level detection and characterization capability is critical to nanomaterial investigations at biologically and environmentally relevant concentrations. The techniques have been modified and applied to characterization of all four elemental constituents of cadmium selenide–zinc sulfide core–shell quantum dots, and silver nanoparticles with gold seed cores. Additionally, sulfide coatings on silver nanoparticles can be detected as a potential means to determine environmental aging of nanoparticles.

Characterization of Polymerized Liposomes Using a Combination of dc and Cyclical Electrical Field-Flow Fractionation

Characterization of polymerized liposomes (PolyPIPosomes) was carried out using a combination of normal dc electrical field-flow fractionation and cyclical electrical field-flow fractionation (CyElFFF) as an analytical technique. The constant nature of the carrier fluid and channel configuration for this technique eliminates many variables associated with multidimensional analysis. CyElFFF uses an oscillating field to induce separation and is performed in the same channel as standard dc electrical field-flow fractionation separation. Theory and experimental methods to characterize nanoparticles in terms of their sizes and electrophoretic mobilities are discussed in this paper. Polystyrene nanoparticles are used for system calibration and characterization of the separation performance, whereas polymerized liposomes are used to demonstrate the applicability of the system to biomedical samples. This paper is also the first to report separation and a higher effective field when CyElFFF is operated at very low applied voltages. The technique is shown to have the ability to quantify both particle size and electrophoretic mobility distributions for colloidal polystyrene nanoparticles and PolyPIPosomes.

Differences between reversible (self-association) and irreversible aggregation of r HuG-CSF in carbohydrate and polyol formulations

Severe immunogenic and other debilitating human disorders potentially induced by protein aggregates have brought this phenomenon into the focus of biopharmaceutical science over the past decade. Depending on its driving forces, the process induced in the model protein r HuG-CSF may be either reversible or irreversible, resulting in the assembly of self-associated protein species or irreversible aggregates of various final morphologies. The aim of our work was to investigate the correlation between irreversible and reversible aggregation and the protective effect of non-specific formulation stabilisers, selected from the group of carbohydrates and polyols including trehalose, xylitol, cellobiitol, turanose, cellobiose, leucrose, lactitol, lyxose, and sorbitol, against both irreversible protein aggregation and reversible self-association processes of the r HuG-CSF. The formation of irreversible aggregates was thermally induced and evaluated using differential scanning calorimetry and size-exclusion chromatography. As opposed to the irreversible aggregation process, the process of self-association was induced by the agitation experiment by directly augmenting the protein solution contact surfaces. Absence of statistical connectivity between different stabilisers’ ability to inhibit self-association or aggregation reactions indicates that these are two distinct physicochemical processes with different formulation stabilizing outcomes. Reaction mechanism of thermally induced aggregation observed in the study was in line with published literature data, while the reaction mechanism for self-association process was postulated. The postulate has been verified experimentally by isothermal calorimetry and agitation set of experiments conducted after size-exclusion chromatography and asymmetrical flow field-flow fractionation separation of monomeric, dimeric, trimeric, oligomeric, and large self-associated forms detected on multi-angle light scattering, fluorescence, UV, and refractive index detectors. Besides defining the mechanism and kinetic of self-association in stabilized rHuG-CSF formulations, special attention was also paid to the shifts and ranks of the free energy of the aggregation or self-association transition states.

Sedimentation field-flow fractionation separation of proliferative and differentiated subpopulations during Ca2+-induced differentiation in HaCaT cells

The spontaneously immortalized human keratinocyte cell line HaCaT is widely used as a human keratinocyte model. In a previous comparative study between normal human keratinocytes (NHKs) and HaCaT, we reported that Ca2+ concentrations greater than 1mM induced differentiation in vitro in both cell types, notably characterized by increased expression of differentiation markers keratins 1 (K1), 10 (K10) and involucrin. Surprisingly, cells had a higher proliferative activity than those cultured with low Ca2+ levels. These results raised many questions; in particular concerning the emergence of HaCaT cells subpopulation which would have different differentiation states and/or proliferation rates throughout Ca2+-induced differentiation. To isolate these subpopulations, we used sedimentation field-flow fractionation (SdFFF). Results demonstrated that the most differentiated cells (HC-F1), characterized by the highest expression of keratinocyte differentiation markers, had the lowest proliferative activity. In contrast, less differentiated cells (HC-F2) maintained a higher proliferative activity. SdFFF is a tool to sort differentiated and/or proliferating cells from a total pool previously treated with a Ca2+ concentration inducing differentiation, and can be use to prepare biological models necessary for studying HaCaT cell proliferation after Ca2+-induced differentiation treatment.

Field-Flow Fractionation: Theory, Techniques, Applications and the Challenges

In this review, field-flow fractionation (FFF) is presented as a versatile and powerful analytical technique for separation and characterization of different sample types. The underlying principles of FFF separation theory including sources of the obstacles and the difficulties as well as the new approaches is also introduced. This paper describes FFF sub-techniques, presents its exemplary application and the future trends in development of FFF techniques.

Application of Flow Field Flow Fractionation-ICPMS for the Study of Uranium Binding in Bacterial Cell Suspensions

Field flow fractionation (FFF) is a size-based separation technique applicable to biomolecules, colloids, and bacteria in solution. When interfaced with ICPMS on-line, elemental data can be collected concurrent with size distribution. We employed hyperlayer flow FFF (Fl FFF) methodology to separate cells of Shewanella oneidensis strain MR-1 from exopolymers present in washed cell suspensions. With a channel flow of 4 mL min-1 and a cross-flow of 0.4 mL min-1 cells eluted with a retention time of 4.7 min corresponding to an approximate equivalent spherical cell diameter of 0.8 microm. Cell suspensions were amended with increasing concentrations of U to establish an adsorption isotherm and with fixed U concentrations at varying pH to establish the pH dependence of sorption. A linear sorption isotherm was determined for U solution concentrations of 0.2-16 microM, maximum U sorption occurred at pH 5. A high molecular weight compound, presumably a cell exudate, was identified by Fl FFF-ICPMS. This cell exudate complexed U, and at elevated pH, the exudate appeared to have a greater affinity for U than cell surfaces. Thus, Fl FFF interfaced with ICPMS detection is a powerful analytical technique for metal sorption studies with bacteria; analysis can be carried out on small sample volumes (25 microL) and additional speciation information can be gained because of the versatile Fl FFF separation range and multielement detection capabilities of ICPMS.

Steric-hyperlayer sedimentation field flow fractionation and flow cytometry analysis applied to the study of Saccharomyces cerevisiae.

Sedimentation field flow fractionation separation associated with flow cytometry has been used for the characterization of several commercial Saccharomyces cerevisiae yeasts used for wine production. A new type of channel 80 microm thick and new operating conditions, such as sample introduction when field and flow are established and a channel inlet connected to the accumulation wall, were used. Good repeatability (5% RSD) and reduced analysis time (2-10 min) were obtained. The avoidance of the stop-flow relaxation process in conjunction with the use of a channel of reduced thickness has demonstrated that an effective "steric-hyperlayer" mode driving to a major focusing effect of the species in the channel thickness is involved in the elution of the yeast cells. Flow cytometry analyses were performed, and the forward scattering and side scattering yeast characteristics correlation maps were obtained. Field flow fractionation and flow cytometry information obtained indicated that the fractogram profiles of the yeast cell depended not only on the size, but also on the shape and density.

Working without accumulation membrane in flow field-flow fractionation.

Nonideal interaction of sample with the separation device is a difficulty found in chromatographic methods as well as in field-flow fractionation. However, in field-flow fractionation (FFF), greater flexibility in the choice of carrier solution composition is possible, thus reducing the need of a wide choice of surface chemistry when nonideal sample interaction is to be minimized. The use of an ultrafiltration membrane as the surface for the accumulation wall is common practice in flow field-flow fractionation. Typical membranes in use are laminates of a skin membrane onto a backing material such as woven polyester. At this point, only a limited choice of membrane chemistries is available. Many membranes have been developed for protein applications as membranes are widely used in the pharmaceutical industries. While these membranes work well for protein applications, flow field-flow fractionation is applicable to polymeric particulate as well as protein samples. Thus, sample interaction with the membrane surface is possible with nonprotein applications and these interactions can induce significant secondary effects on retention ratio and affect instrumental reliability. Also, the woven texture of membranes may detrimentally affect the FFF separation. For these reasons, the study of flow field-flow fractionation using a flat, smooth surface of controlled chemistry is of relevance. We present here the results of a new, membraneless channel that uses a bare frit as the accumulation wall and that is intended for analysis of micrometer-sized particles only. Selectivity results are comparable to those obtained with the membrane, while relative sample recovery indicates that the best quantitative performance can be obtained without the membrane. Moreover, neither sample immobilization nor losses through the frit occur when operating membraneless. On the other hand, first experimental evidence of a certain level of frit surface activity suggests that optimization of experimental conditions is required.

Evaluation of Different Field-Flow Fractionation Techniques for Separating Bacteria

Field-flow fractionation (FFF) techniques were used to separate various strains of bacteria and differentiate live from dead bacteria. The sedimentation, flow, and electrical FFF separations were accomplished in less than 15 minutes using the rapid hyperlayer mode. The bacteria used in these studies include Pseudomonas putida, Escherichia coli, and Staphylococcus epidermidis. Sedimentation FFF gives the highest resolution separations of a mixture of spherical and rod-shaped bacteria, and a mixture of two rod-shaped bacteria.

Free-solution electrophoresis with amplification of small mobility differences by helical flow

A description and theoretical analysis is given of a free-solution, three-dimensional electrophoretic field-flow fractionation separation in a concentric circular annulus, in which an axisymmetric swirl flow with velocity components in the axial and azimuthal directions is used to amplify a small difference between the electrophoretic mobilities of two species in a radial electric field. Separation is achieved in the azimuthal direction. The potential of this process is illustrated by calculations (neglecting diffusion) of azimuthal separations of β-lactoglobulins A and B, and racemic denopamine complexed to a stereoselective cyclodextrin. The relative mobility difference for the β-lactoglobulins is about 7%, while that the denopamine enantiomers (one of which is a potent cardiotonic agent) is about 2%. (Diffusionless) separations of 180° can be achieved with relatively modest angular rotation rates.

Two-dimensional field-flow fractionation

Multidimensional field-flow fractionation (FFF) is described in two major forms: one in which different separative stages are coupled together and one in which two independent displacements, at least one of them FFF, are carried out in a generally planar channel structure. The latter, the subject of this paper, is relatively promising for implementation in FFF systems because in most cases the geometry of the FFF channel is already planar; the channel structure needs mainly to be broadened along the second dimension and modified with different inlets and outlets for this two-dimensional use. The large number of potential two-dimensional FFF systems is discussed. These systems are described at greater length in four categories: (1) FFF displacement used in both dimensions (2) FFF along one axis and chromatography along another, (3) FFF along one axis and a field-induced displacement along the other, and (4) FFF separation combined with bulk or flow displacement at right angles. p ]Finally theoretical equations are obtained for the deflection of the trajectories away from the main flow axis z. The sensitivity of deflection to component properties is described in terms of the deflection selectivity. Several examples are discussed in which the deflection selectivity is remarkably high.