AbstractWe evaluate the frequency of flipper amputation and its impact on reproduction in the threatened loggerhead turtle (Caretta caretta) population of the Eastern Atlantic, through a long‐term study on several high‐density nesting beaches of Cabo Verde. 5982 adult females were individually identified, tagged and measured, and the presence of limb amputations was recorded. 918 of them had one or multiple amputations of the rear or front flippers. Most of these turtles (n = 778) had partial rather than complete flipper amputations. However, we found no difference in body condition indices (1.2 vs. 1.1), clutch size (82 vs. 83 eggs), or hatching success (79 vs. 80%) between amputated and non‐amputated females. While amputations may cause individual mortality or reduced fitness, our results indicate that some amputated turtles successfully nest and survive across multiple nesting seasons. Moreover, the amputations do not appear to be impacting the strong recovery of this population. This study provides evidence of the successful reproductive capacity of amputated loggerhead sea turtles and, by extension, the potential reproductive success of amputees released from recovery centers.