The bane of the diagnostic radiologist is the lack of specificity of the patterns and shadows with which he must work. But this very handicap creates a stimulating challenge that makes his work as fascinating as a detective story. The solution partly lies in the radiologist approaching the films just as a pathologist would his materials, that is, in defining the pattern of disturbed morphology, and placing it in a list (or gamut) of diseases that could cause such a pattern. Then, to get the specific label, the clinical background is invoked to elicit any pertinent clinical facts or associations. One can call such an approach “triangulation,” and it is far more effective than mere “pattern-matching.” The latter can be accomplished by a technician with a talent for imagery while “triangulation” requires a physician. The case presented this month could easily thwart the pattern-matcher. Radiology Radiographs of the chest of an elderly female (Figs. 1, A and B) show marked lytic destruction of numerous ribs and multiple defects in clavicles and scapulae as well as in the proximal humeri. From the lateral right thoracic wall a 5 × 2-cm mass extends into the lung field. Its superior margin tapers into the chest wall to yield an “extrapleural sign,” and, since the mass is immediately associated with an underlying destroyed rib, it is reasonable to infer that the mass arose from the rib and is pushing against the pleura into the lung field. These findings, together with those in a skull film (Fig. 2) where round-to-oval punched-out defects are observed, are most suggestive of multiple myeloma or metastatic disease. A primary tumor in the breast especially, or not uncommonly in the kidney or lungs, could well lead to this overall picture. However, inspection of an abdominal film (Fig. 3) discloses a markedly enlarged spleen in addition to diffuse demineralization of bony structures. Splenomegaly is not a feature in widespread metastatic disease and does not occur in multiple myeloma to the degree observed here. The presence of such a markedly enlarged spleen compels the consideration of other possible diseases that might account for it and for the described skeletal changes as well. Leukemia and lymphoma come to mind, but leukemic deposits are extremely rare in the skull of adults, and lesions of the vault in lymphoma are often confluent and most often show some sclerosis surrounding the areas of destruction. A diagnosis of one of the reticuloses (Gaucher's, etc.) might be entertained, especially in view of the marked splenomegaly, but these usually cause diffuse changes in bone. Only rarely do they cause an appearance of multiple defects. Also, they seldom lead to skull changes detectable radiographically.
Read full abstract