The knee joint frequently encounters penetrating injuries and has ample space to harbor foreign objects. While foreign bodies in the knee joint are unusual, especially those not originating from surgical procedures, extensive literature exists on the extraction of loose bodies and metallic objects from this articulation. However, documentation on uncommon intruders remains scarce. This case study delves into the experience of a 22-year-old male who suffered persistent pain due to a neglected foreign object in his knee joint. After its removal, a complete resolution of symptoms was achieved. It highlights the importance of prompt arthroscopic intervention for optimal outcomes. Here we present a unique case involving a 22-year-old male who underwent arthroscopic retrieval of a neglected glass fragment from his knee joint. The patient sought medical attention five months after the initial injury due to sudden and severe pain onset. Arthroscopy stands as the favored minimally invasive method for extracting foreign bodies from the knee joint, especially from its deeper and less accessible regions. Utilizing pre-operative radiological imaging enhances understanding of the anatomical placement, facilitates surgical orientation, and reduces operation time. A keen sense of suspicion and thorough history-taking are crucial in achieving an accurate diagnosis.