In this issue of Annals of Surgical Oncology, Starritt et al. present their experience with ultrasound (US) examination of sentinel nodes (SNs) in the initial assessment of patients with primary cutaneous melanoma. In 304 patients, histopathology of the SN revealed metastatic disease in 33 node fields in 31 patients. Only 7 of 33 node fields had been also identified by US. Metastatic deposits <4.5 mm had not been identified by US. The authors concluded that because most metastatic deposits in SNs are smaller, US is not cost-effective in this setting. The authors suggest, on the basis not of their own findings, but of the results of a study by Garbe et al. (which demonstrated that the ability of US to detect melanoma recurrence in lymph nodes during followup was greatest in stage IIb patients), that in this subset of patients with more aggressive melanomas, US of the SN in the primary assessment is likely to be positive more often and should therefore be considered. This is mixed message indicating that this chapter is not closed. In breast cancer, it has been clearly demonstrated that US of the axilla can reduce the number of SN procedures. A multicenter study in 116 patients in Rotterdam demonstrated in 1999 that US-guided fine-needle aspiration (US-FNA) identified positive lymph nodes in 17% of clinically node-negative cancer patients. For T1 tumors, the detection rate for US-FNA was only 6%, but for T2 tumors it was 25%, and for T3 tumors it was 50%. This was recently confirmed in a Japanese study in 262 women, in which US was positive in 6% of T1, 20% of T2, and 70% of T3 tumors. These findings indicate that USFNA can significantly reduce the number of SN procedures and that it is cost-effective in breast cancer for T2/3 tumors. Similar results were also reported by Deurloo et al. in 266 patients. These authors demonstrated a reduction of SN procedures of 14% in the overall clinically node-negative breast cancer population. In melanoma, one might expect a similar situation, and indeed there are reports pointing in that direction. Rossi et al. published a prospective study on the preoperative assessment of the regional lymph nodes by US in 125 patients with primary cutaneous melanoma. US correctly detected 12 of 31 histologically positive lymphatic basins in the total population of 125 patients and thus avoided an SN procedure in approximately 10% of patients. Whether this 10% reduction for the total population of melanoma patients considered for SN is cost-effective remains to be shown, because no formal calculations were presented. Of note, in this article, no metastasis <2 mm was picked up by US. Starritt et al. correctly note that there is no formal proof in the report by Rossi et al. that a different node with a different-sized micrometastasis from the histopathologically reported SN was not detected by US. Still, the 10% reduction of SN procedures, as the outcome of the Rossi study stands, is not that much different from the 14% to 17% reported in overall breast cancer populations, and that result is the most important outcome. Moreover, the conclusion that the yield will be higher if one implements US only in thicker melanomas, be Received September 13, 2004; accepted October 18, 2004. Address correspondence and reprint requests to: Alexander M. M. Eggermont, MD, PhD; E-mail: a.m.m.eggermont@ erasmusmc.nl.
Read full abstract