Evidence For Common Ancestry Research Articles

Philosophy in Science: Some Personal Reflections

AbstractThe task of Philosophy in Science (PinS) is to use philosophical tools to help solve scientific problems. This article describes how I stumbled into this line of work and then addressed several topics in philosophy of biology—units of selection, cladistic parsimony, robustness and trade-offs in model building, adaptationism, and evidence for common ancestry—often in collaboration with scientists. I conclude by offering advice for would-be PinS practitioners.

Evidence for common ancestry and microevolution of passerine-adapted Salmonella enterica serovar Typhimurium in the UK and USA.

The evolution of Salmonella enterica serovar Typhimurium (S. Typhimurium) within passerines has resulted in pathoadaptation of this serovar to the avian host in Europe. Recently, we identified an S. Typhimurium lineage from passerines in North America. The emergence of passerine-adapted S. Typhimurium in Europe and North America raises questions regarding its evolutionary origin. Here, we demonstrated that the UK and US passerine-adapted S. Typhimurium shared a common ancestor from ca. 1838, and larids played a key role in the clonal expansion by disseminating the common ancestor between North America and Europe. Further, we identified virulence gene signatures common in the passerine- and larid-adapted S. Typhimurium, including conserved pseudogenes in fimbrial gene lpfD and Type 3 Secretion System (T3SS) effector gene steC. However, the UK and US passerine-adapted S. Typhimurium also possessed unique virulence gene signatures (i.e. pseudogenes in fimbrial gene fimC and T3SS effector genes sspH2, gogB, sseJ and sseK2), and the majority of them (38/47) lost a virulence plasmid pSLT that was present in the larid-adapted S. Typhimurium. These results provide evidence that passerine-adapted S. Typhimurium share a common ancestor with those from larids, and the divergence of passerine- and larid-adapted S. Typhimurium might be due to pseudogenization or loss of specific virulence genes.

Evidence for common ancestry among viruses isolated from wild birds in Beringia and highly pathogenic intercontinental reassortant H5N1 and H5N2 influenza A viruses

Highly pathogenic clade 2.3.4.4 H5N8, H5N2, and H5N1 influenza A viruses were first detected in wild, captive, and domestic birds in North America in November–December 2014. In this study, we used wild waterbird samples collected in Alaska prior to the initial detection of clade 2.3.4.4 H5 influenza A viruses in North America to assess the evidence for: (1) dispersal of highly pathogenic influenza A viruses from East Asia to North America by migratory birds via Alaska and (2) ancestral origins of clade 2.3.4.4 H5 reassortant viruses in Beringia. Although we did not detect highly pathogenic influenza A viruses in our sample collection from western Alaska, we did identify viruses that contained gene segments sharing recent common ancestry with intercontinental reassortant H5N2 and H5N1 viruses. Results of phylogenetic analyses and estimates for times of most recent common ancestry support migratory birds sampled in Beringia as maintaining viral diversity closely related to novel highly pathogenic influenza A virus genotypes detected in North America. Although our results do not elucidate the route by which highly pathogenic influenza A viruses were introduced into North America, genetic evidence is consistent with the hypothesized trans-Beringian route of introduction via migratory birds.

Similarities as Evidence for Common Ancestry: A Likelihood Epistemology

ABSTRACTDarwin claims in the Origin that similarity is evidence for common ancestry, but that adaptive similarities are ‘almost valueless’ as evidence. This second claim seems reasonable for some a...

Phylogenetic incongruence inferred with two mitochondrial genes in Mepraia spp. and Triatoma eratyrusiformis(Hemiptera, Reduviidae).

Mitochondrial DNA (mtDNA) is widely used to clarify phylogenetic relationships among and within species, and to determine population structure. Due to the linked nature of mtDNA genes it is expected that different genes will show similar results. Phylogenetic incongruence using mtDNA genes may result from processes such as heteroplasmy, nuclear integration of mitochondrial genes, polymerase errors, contamination, and recombination. In this study we used sequences from two mitochondrial genes (cytochrome b and cytochrome oxidase subunit I) from the wild vectors of Chagas disease, Triatoma eratyrusiformis and Mepraia species to test for topological congruence. The results showed some cases of phylogenetic incongruence due to misplacement of four haplotypes of four individuals. We discuss the possible causes of such incongruence and suggest that the explanation is an intra-individual variation likely due to heteroplasmy. This phenomenon is an independent evidence of common ancestry between these taxa.

Ultrastructure of the ventral pharynx in the interstitial annelid Questa paucibranchiata (Orbiniidae) and its phylogenetic significance

The small taxon Questa comprises only meiofaunal species and shows oligochaete-like adaptations in its reproductive biology. Formerly, it was classified as a separate polychaete group, Questidae, of uncertain affinities, but due to these oligochaete-like similarities, a relationship with Clitellata was discussed. However, other morphological phylogenetic analyses questioned such a relationship, providing evidence for common ancestry with Paraonidae and Orbiniidae. Molecular studies revealed that questids even form an in-group of Orbiniidae, which refutes a clitellate relationship without doubt. On the other hand, morphological evidence supporting this grouping is still considered weak. Among the external characters, the chaetation, comprising crenulated capillaries, hooks and furcate chaetae, might strengthen this hypothesis. One of the internal characters stated to support this grouping is the ventral pharynx, which as such, however, is widespread among polychaetes. This study is a first attempt to look for specific structures in this organ, which might be regarded as synapomorphic of Questa and Orbiniidae. The ultrastructural analysis revealed a ventral buccal organ composed of large interstitial cells and transverse muscle fibres and surrounded by an investing muscle system similar to that found in juvenile Orbiniidae. Thus, further morphological evidence for the current position is provided. Moreover, since this structure is known as a larval or juvenile character in Orbiniidae, this finding is also indicative for a progenetic origin of Questa, which might have occurred upon invading the interstitial environment.

Y-chromosome evidence for common ancestry of three Chinese populations with a high risk of esophageal cancer.

High rates of esophageal cancer (EC) are found in people of the Henan Taihang Mountain, Fujian Minnan, and Chaoshan regions of China. Historical records describe great waves of populations migrating from north-central China (the Henan and Shanxi Hans) through coastal Fujian Province to the Chaoshan plain. Although these regions are geographically distant, we hypothesized that EC high-risk populations in these three areas could share a common ancestry. Accordingly, we used 16 East Asian-specific Y-chromosome biallelic markers (single nucleotide polymorphisms; Y-SNPs) and six Y-chromosome short tandem repeat (Y-STR) loci to infer the origin of the EC high-risk Chaoshan population (CSP) and the genetic relationship between the CSP and the EC high-risk Henan Taihang Mountain population (HTMP) and Fujian population (FJP). The predominant haplogroups in these three populations are O3*, O3e*, and O3e1, with no significant difference between the populations in the frequency of these genotypes. Frequency distribution and principal component analysis revealed that the CSP is closely related to the HTMP and FJP, even though the former is geographically nearer to other populations (Guangfu and Hakka clans). The FJP is between the CSP and HTMP in the principal component plot. The CSP, FJP and HTMP are more closely related to Chinese Hans than to minorities, except Manchu Chinese, and are descendants of Sino-Tibetans, not Baiyues. Correlation analysis, hierarchical clustering analysis, and phylogenetic analysis (neighbor-joining tree) all support close genetic relatedness among the CSP, FJP and HTMP. The network for haplogroup O3 (including O3*, O3e* and O3e1) showed that the HTMP have highest STR haplotype diversity, suggesting that the HTMP may be a progenitor population for the CSP and FJP. These findings support the potentially important role of shared ancestry in understanding more about the genetic susceptibility in EC etiology in high-risk populations and have implications for determining the molecular basis of this disease.

Contact and phylogeny in Island Melanesia

This paper shows that despite evidence of structural convergence between some of the Austronesian and non-Austronesian (Papuan) languages of Island Melanesia, statistical methods can detect two independent genealogical signals derived from linguistic structural features. Earlier work by the author and others has presented a maximum parsimony analysis which gave evidence for a genealogical connection between the non-Austronesian languages of island Melanesia. Using the same data set, this paper demonstrates for the non-statistician the application of more sophisticated statistical techniques—including Bayesian methods of phylogenetic inference, and shows that the evidence for common ancestry is if anything stronger than originally supposed.

Major histocompatibility complex variation in red wolves: evidence for common ancestry with coyotes and balancing selection.

We examined variation at a class II major histocompatibility complex (MHC) gene (DRB1) in the captive red wolf population and samples of coyotes from Texas and North Carolina. We found 4 alleles in the 48 red wolves, 8 alleles in the 10 coyotes from Texas and 15 alleles in the 29 coyotes from North Carolina. Two of the four alleles found in red wolves, Caru-2 and Caru-4, were found in both the Texas and North Carolina coyote samples. Allele Caru-1, previously found in gray wolves, was also found in the North Carolina sample. The most frequent red wolf allele, Caru-3, was not found in any of the coyote samples. However, an allele found in both the Texas and North Carolina coyote samples is only one nucleotide (one amino acid) different from this red wolf allele. Overall, it appears from examination of this MHC gene that red wolves are more closely related to coyotes than to gray wolves. There were a number of different types of evidence supporting the action of balancing selection in red wolves. Namely, there was: (i) an excess of heterozygotes compared with expectations; (ii) a higher rate of nonsynonymous than synonymous substitution for the functionally important antigen-binding site positions; (iii) an eight times higher average heterozygosity of individual amino acids at the positions identified as part of the antigen-binding site than those not associated with it; (iv) the amino acid divergence of four red wolf alleles was greater than that expected from a simulation of genetic drift; and (v) the distribution of alleles, and the distributions of amino acids at many positions were more even than expected from neutrality. Examination of the level and pattern of linkage disequilibria between pairs of sites suggest that the heterozygosity, substitution and frequencies at individual amino acids are not highly dependent upon each other.

Comparison of protein structures

The structure of proteins related by evolution are remarkably alike even when the observed sequence similarities are statistically marginal or seemingly non-existent. Similar protein substructures are found in proteins for which there is no evidence of common ancestry and no similarity in their global topology. Recent advances in the comparison of whole proteins, together with the comparison and analysis of their parts, have paved the way for the use of structural information in prediction and modelling, protein engineering, structure and sequence alignments, and investigations of protein evolution, among a host of other applications.