Event-related Brain Potential Activity Research Articles

Temporal dynamics of attitude decisions: A test of the iterative reprocessing model using event-related potentials

Although evaluative judgments are a central component of everyday decision making little is known about the temporal dynamics of the processes used to make them. The present study used the high temporal resolution of event-related brain potentials (ERPs) to test Cunningham and Zelazo's (2007) posited differences in the timing of attitude tag retrieval relative to stimulus categorization for ‘attitudes’ and ‘evaluations,’ as well as tenets of their Iterative Reprocessing (IR) loop model. Participants made agree/disagree decisions about their attitudes and You/Not You decisions about their autobiographical memories in separate reaction time (RT) tasks while brain activity was recorded from 32 scalp sites. A median-split analysis on RT was used to separate fast and slow decisions. Decisions about autobiographical stimuli produced the typical results in which retrieval and stimulus categorization occurred together just before the response regardless of decision difficulty. By contrast, the relative timing of tag retrieval and categorization differed with difficulty for attitude decisions as predicted by the model. Fast attitude decisions were processed similarly to fast You decisions with retrieval and categorization timing coupled to the response. Slow attitude decisions, however, differed because, while tag retrieval timing was the same as for fast attitude decisions, post-retrieval processing delayed stimulus categorization and a response by 450 msec. ERP activity over dorsolateral prefrontal cortex (DLPFC) in the pre-response interval was asymmetrical, with greater activity for attitude and autobiographical decisions over left and right hemispheres, respectively, while amplitude and duration increased with decision difficulty for both. Slow attitude decisions alone elicited a reduced pre-response positivity, a correlate of goal-directed response selection. The results provide empirical support for key aspects of Cunningham and Zelazo's (2007) attitude-evaluation dichotomy and the timing of the posited component processes in their IR model as well as novel information about the roles of stored tags and reflective processes in different attitude decisions.

Can Brain Waves Really Tell If a Product Will Be Purchased? Inferring Consumer Preferences From Single-Item Brain Potentials.

Recent research has shown that event-related brain potentials (ERPs) recorded while participants view lists of different consumer goods can be modulated by their preferences toward these products. However, it remains largely unknown whether ERP activity specific to a single consumer item can be informative about whether or not this item will be preferred in a shopping context. In this study, we examined whether single-item ERPs could reliably predict consumer preferences toward specific consumer goods. We recorded scalp EEG from 40 participants while they were viewing pictures of consumer goods and we subsequently asked them to indicate their preferences for each of these items. Replicating previous results, we found that ERP activity averaged over the six most preferred products was significantly differentiated from ERP activity averaged across the six least preferred products for three ERP components: The N200, the late positive potential (LPP) and positive slow waves (PSW). We also found that using single-item ERPs to infer behavioral preferences about specific consumer goods led to an overall predictive accuracy of 71%, although this figure varied according to which ERPs were targeted. Later positivities such as the LPP and PSW yielded relatively higher predictive accuracy rates than the frontal N200. Our results suggest that ERPs related to single consumer items can be relatively accurate predictors of behavioral preferences depending on which type of ERP effects are chosen by the researcher, and ultimately on the level of prediction errors that users choose to tolerate.

Transient and sustained ERP activity related to feedback processing in the probabilistic selection task

Feedback processing represents a fundamental component of adaptive decision-making. Extensive research using event-related brain potentials (ERPs) has explored the medial frontal feedback negativity (FN), P3a, and P3b components in the context of feedback processing. Additionally, recent studies examining the neural correlates of feedback processing in a gambling task revealed transient and sustained ERP activity over the lateral frontal and posterior regions of the scalp. Consistent with the neuroimaging literature, source analysis has localized this ERP activity to the lateral and medial frontal cortex, as well as the temporal-occipital and medial occipital cortices. The current experiments examine whether the pattern of transient medial frontal and sustained lateral frontal and posterior ERP activity extend to a reinforcement learning task, and may thereby represent a general property of feedback processing. Consistent with a large literature, the ERP data revealed the FN-P3a and P3b. In addition, these data revealed sustained ERP activity over the lateral frontal and posterior regions. These findings contribute to our understanding of the temporal dynamics of feedback processing across broadly distributed cortical and subcortical networks that are sensitive to the valence and probability of positive and negative outcomes.

Executive control, ERP and pro-inflammatory activity in emotionally exhausted middle-aged employees. Comparison between subclinical burnout and mild to moderate depression

Burnout is a syndrome occurring mainly in individuals with long-term stressful work. The main complaints are emotional exhaustion and reduced performance. Burnout also largely overlaps with depression. Both are characterized by increased incidence of infections due to dysregulation of the immune system, overexpression of pro-inflammatory cytokines and cognitive deficits, particularly related to executive functions. To distinguish between burnout and depression already at the pre-clinical stage, the present double-blinded study compared immunological and cognitive parameters in seventy-six employees from emotionally demanding occupations who were post-hoc subdivided into two groups scoring low (EE−) and high (EE+) in emotional exhaustion and low (DE−) and high (DE+) in depression. Immunological parameters were measured from blood samples. Executive functions were studied by analyzing event-related brain potentials (ERPs) and performance during a task switching paradigm. Psychosocial job parameters were measured with standardized questionnaires.Burnout and mild to moderate depression largely overlapped. However, several subjects showed burnout without depressive symptoms. Higher levels of the pro-inflammatory cytokines IL-6 and IL-12 were correlated with burnout severity and depressive symptoms in male individuals. In the switch task a trend for lower performance in the EE+ vs. EE− group and no difference between DE+ and DE− groups were found. In the ERPs, however, differences were observed which distinguished between subclinical burnout and depression: the terminal contingent negative variation (CNV), indicating preparatory activity and the P3b, related to allocation of cognitive resources were generally reduced in EE+ vs. EE−, whereas no differences were found in the DE+ vs. DE− groups. The frontal P3a was selectively reduced in switch trials in the EE+ vs. EE− group and showed only a trend in DE+ vs. DE−, indicating impairment of executive control in subclinical burnout. Taken together, the results unveil specific immunological changes and declines in brain functions in employees with subclinical burnout that are not apparent in persons with moderate depression. Hence, the combination of immunological, behavioral and ERP methods renders a promising method for distinguishing both syndromes and for improving an early diagnosis of burnout before a clinical stage is reached.

Characterizing switching and congruency effects in the Implicit Association Test as reactive and proactive cognitive control.

Recent research has identified an important role for task switching, a cognitive control process often associated with executive functioning, in the Implicit Association Test (IAT). However, switching does not fully account for IAT effects, particularly when performance is scored using more recent d-score formulations. The current study sought to characterize multiple control processes involved in IAT performance through the use of event-related brain potentials (ERPs). Participants performed a race-evaluative IAT while ERPs were recorded. Behaviorally, participants experienced superadditive reaction time costs of incongruency and task switching, consistent with previous studies. The ERP showed a marked medial frontal negativity (MFN) 250-450 ms post-stimulus at midline fronto-central locations that were more negative for incongruent than congruent trials but more positive for switch than for no-switch trials, suggesting separable control processes are engaged by these two factors. Greater behavioral IAT bias was associated with both greater switch-related and congruency-related ERP activity. Findings are discussed in terms of the Dual Mechanisms of Control model of reactive and proactive cognitive control.

Temporally specific divided attention tasks in young adults reveal the temporal dynamics of episodic encoding failures in elderly adults.

Nessler, Johnson, Bersick, and Friedman (D. Nessler, R. Johnson, Jr., M. Bersick, & D. Friedman, 2006, On why the elderly have normal semantic retrieval but deficient episodic encoding: A study of left inferior frontal ERP activity, NeuroImage, Vol. 30, pp. 299-312) found that, compared with young adults, older adults show decreased event-related brain potential (ERP) activity over posterior left inferior prefrontal cortex (pLIPFC) in a 400- to 1,400-ms interval during episodic encoding. This altered brain activity was associated with significantly decreased recognition performance and reduced recollection-related brain activity at retrieval (D. Nessler, D. Friedman, R. Johnson, Jr., & M. Bersick, 2007, Does repetition engender the same retrieval processes in young and older adults? NeuroReport, Vol. 18, pp. 1837-1840). To test the hypothesis that older adults' well-documented episodic retrieval deficit is related to reduced pLIPFC activity at encoding, we used a novel divided attention task in healthy young adults that was specifically timed to disrupt encoding in either the 1st or 2nd half of a 300- to 1,400-ms interval. The results showed that diverting resources for 550 ms during either half of this interval reproduced the 4 characteristic aspects of the older participants' retrieval performance: normal semantic retrieval during encoding, reduced subsequent episodic recognition and recall, reduced recollection-related ERP activity, and the presence of "compensatory" brain activity. We conclude that part of older adults' episodic memory deficit is attributable to altered pLIPFC activity during encoding due to reduced levels of available processing resources. Moreover, the findings also provide insights into the nature and timing of the putative "compensatory" processes posited to be used by older adults in an attempt to compensate for age-related decline in cognitive function. These results support the scaffolding account of compensation, in which the recruitment of additional cognitive processes is an adaptive response across the life span.

Abnormal timing of visual feedback processing in young adults with schizophrenia

Recent studies have shown that schizophrenia is characterized by visual perceptual deficits, especially in the ability to integrate stimulus details into a global percept. Also, several studies have found amplitude attenuation of the visual P1 component of the event-related brain potential (ERP), probably indicating impaired visual feedforward processing in schizophrenia. However, there is little knowledge on the role of feedbackward processing in this group. This question is of importance, as recent studies indicate that feedback processing is critical in stimulus integration. In the present study we tested whether there is evidence for atypical recurrent processing in a group of 14 young adults with recent-onset schizophrenia (mean age 21.7 years, mean TIQ 92.7) and 17 age and IQ matched control subjects, all males. To achieve this aim, we used a texture segregation task and measured ERP activity concurrently. We found normal amplitudes, but longer latencies of activity related to feedbackward processing in the schizophrenia group. In addition, we found enhanced occipito-temporal activity around 160 ms that is probably the reflection of increased detail processing. We show for the first time evidence for abnormal timing in feedback activity related to visual perception in subjects with schizophrenia. It is hypothesized that this latency effect is the functional reflection of abnormal structural connectivity in this group, and might result in increased processing of stimulus detail.

Conflict and criterion setting in recognition memory.

Recognition memory requires both retrieval processes and control processes such as criterion setting. Decision criteria were manipulated by offering different payoffs for correct "old" versus "new" responses. Criterion setting influenced the following late-occurring (1,000+ ms), conflict-sensitive event-related brain potential (ERP) components: the stimulus-locked late posterior negativity (LPN) and the response-locked error-related negativity (ERN). The LPN-ERN were most negative to hits under conservative payoff conditions involving conflict between the correct old response and the payoff for new responses. This same conservative-hit condition was most frequently associated with response reversals when fast initial judgments were followed by slower judgments. Postresponse ERP activity may index conflict-sensitive processes underlying postretrieval cognitive control mechanisms involved with assessing responses to current items and updating response criteria on later trials.

Inhibition of Return From Stimulus to Response

In a standard inhibition-of-return (IOR) paradigm using a manual key-press response, we examined the effect of IOR both on the amplitude of early sensory event-related brain potential (ERP) components and on the motor-related lateralized readiness potential (LRP). IOR was associated with a delay of premotor processes (target-locked LRP latency) and reduced sensory ERP activity. No effect of IOR was found on motor processes (response-locked LRP latency). Thus, IOR must arise at least in part from changes in perceptual processes, and, at least when measured with manual key presses, IOR does not arise from inhibition of motor processes. These results are consistent with the results of attention-orienting studies and provide support for an inhibition-of-attention explanation for IOR.

Dipole source localization of event-related brain activity indicative of an early visual selective attention deficit in ADHD children

Objective This study was aimed at investigating whether attention-deficit hyperactivity disorder (ADHD) children suffer from specific early selective attention deficits in the visual modality with the aid of event-related brain potentials (ERPs). Furthermore, brain source localization was applied to identify brain areas underlying possible deficits in selective visual processing in ADHD children. Methods A two-channel visual color selection task was administered to 18 ADHD and 18 control subjects in the age range of 7–13 years and ERP activity was derived from 30 electrodes. Results ADHD children exhibited lower perceptual sensitivity scores resulting in poorer target selection. The ERP data suggested an early selective-attention deficit as manifested in smaller frontal positive activity (frontal selection positivity; FSP) in ADHD children around 200 ms whereas later occipital and fronto-central negative activity (OSN and N2b; 200–400 ms latency) appeared to be unaffected. Source localization explained the FSP by posterior-medial equivalent dipoles in control subjects, which may reflect the contribution of numerous surrounding areas. Conclusions ADHD children have problems with selective visual processing that might be caused by a specific early filtering deficit (absent FSP) occurring around 200 ms. The neural sources underlying these problems have to be further identified. Source localization also suggested abnormalities in the 200–400 ms time range, pertaining to the distribution of attention-modulated activity in lateral frontal areas.

Short-term semantic retention during on-line sentence comprehension. Brain potential evidence from filler-gap constructions

In filler-gap sentences, a phrase (‘filler’) is separated by intervening words from a subsequent phrase (‘gap’) with which it is integrated. The filler-gap interval provides a useful model for the study of short-term retention processes during sentence comprehension. Kluender and Kutas [J. Cogn. Neurosci. 5 (1993) 29] used event-related brain potentials (ERPs) to show that a filler phrase places a demand on short-term retention processes in the filler-gap interval, but left the processing level at which this demand arises unspecified. Here we use ERPs to address the issue of whether the filler places a demand on the semantic component of short-term retention processes in the filler-gap interval. Participants read filler-gap sentences, which began with a filler phrase and, in the filler-gap interval, contained a subject and object that were either semantically related or unrelated. There was also a control condition in which the filler phrase was absent (i.e. less memory demand). The main result was that during the filler-gap interval, bilateral posterior electrodes displayed a larger positivity for unrelated than related words. Moreover, during the same interval, posterior electrodes displayed a larger positivity for filler-gap sentences than for control sentences. In the control condition (non-filler gap sentences), manipulation of semantic relatedness did not produce differences in ERP activity. Our results suggest that a filler phrase places a demand on the semantic component of verbal working memory during on-line sentence comprehension.

Lexical Contributions to Retention of Verbal Information in Working Memory: Event-Related Brain Potential Evidence

The present study investigated whether lexical codes contribute to retention of verbal information in working memory. We used event-related brain potentials (ERPs) recorded while participants were performing a serial recall task to show differences in brain activity during retention of words or pseudowords. The effects of lexical status and memory load (task difficulty) upon ERP activity during retention also differed, with memory load affecting ERP indices of phonological processing. The timing of the ERPs suggested that the influence of lexical status upon retention began during encoding. The contrast between ERPs in the serial recall task and in a control task with negligible memory demand indicated that the effect of lexical status in the retention interval of the memory task was specific to consciously controlled memory operations. These results support the view that lexical codes actively contribute to retention of words in working memory.

A spatio-temporal comparison of semantic and episodic cued recall and recognition using event-related brain potentials

The event-related brain potential (ERP) was used to spatially and temporally map the brain areas active as a function of type of recall (semantic vs. episodic) and episodic retrieval mode (recall vs. recognition) while difficulty of episodic recall was manipulated. ERPs were recorded from 32 scalp sites in 12 subjects, along with behavioral accuracy and recall speed. The results revealed that different but overlapping patterns of ERP activity were elicited during semantic and episodic recall. Recall of both types of information was characterized by ERP activity over left inferior frontal, central, bilateral temporal and posterior inferior brain areas. Compared to semantic recall, episodic recall elicited more activity over the frontal poles and right frontal scalp. Different but overlapping patterns of ERP activity were also found as a function of episodic retrieval mode. While episodic recall and recognition showed similar activity over the frontal poles and central scalp, there was no left inferior frontal activity elicited during recognition and no large, topographically widespread, late positive component (LPC) elicited when the same words were recalled. Manipulation of episodic recall difficulty and analysis of trials when recall failed indicated that these task (i.e., episodic vs. semantic) and retrieval mode (recall vs. recognition) differences in ERP activity were not likely to be due to differences in task difficulty. The results are discussed in terms of processes that the ERP activity may reflect and their similarity to results of PET studies of semantic and episodic retrieval.

A spatio-temporal analysis of recognition-related event-related brain potentials

Words correctly recognized as previously studied (i.e. old) elicit greater amounts of positive event-related brain potential (ERP) activity over posterior scalp between 400 and 800 ms than do previously unstudied (i.e. new) words. While investigators have reported that this old/new effect consists of more than one subcomponent, the spatio-temporal parameters of these possible subcomponents, as well as any other patterns of brain activity associated with recognition, remain incompletely specified. Thus, ERPs were recorded from 32 scalp sites while 13 subjects performed four repetitions of a study-test recognition paradigm. The subjects' task was to decide whether each word was old or new and press the appropriate button as quickly as possible. The timing and topography of the ERPs elicited by old and new words was assessed with topographic profile comparisons on the areas with a variety of temporal windows, and visualized with potential and CSD maps. The results revealed that seven patterns of ERP activity, #dissociable on the basis of their topography, timing and response to experimental variables, were elicited between 300 and 2000 ms. Three of these appeared as subcomponents of the old/new effect (maximal over left medial frontal, left parietal-occipital and right central-frontal scalp), another was related to decision confidence and/or memory trace strength (maximal over left central scalp) and three others appeared to be related to more general aspects of recognition (maximal over the frontal poles, midline frontal scalp and right frontal scalp). Taken together, the seven distinct patterns of neural generator activity described here support the hypothesis that retrieval of information from episodic memory depends on a collection of different processes that occur in a temporally and spatially distributed neural circuit.

P300 Subcomponent Abnormalities in Schizophrenia: Longitudinal Stability and Relationship to Symptom Change

>Background: Reduced amplitude of the P300 event-related brain potential (ERP) is a robust finding in schizophrenia. It remains unclear whether this represents a state or trait abnormality. We previously reported reductions of specific subcomponents of the auditory oddball P300 that were independent of acute symptomatology and were differentially associated with gender and deficit/nondeficit subtype. To clarify the state vs. trait nature of these abnormalities, we reassessed a subset of these patients after a minimum interval of 1 year following initial study. Methods: Auditory P300 ERPs were obtained from 18 patients at two time points and compared to baseline normative data recorded from 48 controls. Five P300 subcomponents were identified using current source density measures: frontal (P3f), bilateral parietal (P3pL, P3pR), and bilateral temporal (P3tL, P3tR). Results: Patients exhibited reduced P300 amplitudes at baseline, including specific reductions of left temporal and right parietal subcomponents. There were no significant changes in P300 amplitudes over time, despite significant improvement in symptomatology, and the parietal subcomponent exhibited persistent impairment. There was, however, a trend toward normalization of the left temporal subcomponent that correlated with change in Brief Psychiatric Rating Scale. There was also a highly significant inverse relationship between changes in frontal P300 subcomponent amplitude and severity of auditory hallucinations ( r = −.76). Conclusions: The findings support the overall longitudinal stability of P300 deficits in schizophrenia, though there is some state-dependent modulation of these deficits. The relationship between the frontal P300 and hallucinations is consistent with both the cognitive orienting function of this subcomponent and the role of the anterior cingulate as a hypothesized generator of this ERP activity.

Short-term memory storage and retention: an event-related brain potential study

This experiment was concerned with event-related brain potential (ERP) activity related to short-term storage and retention of information in working memory. Our approach was to record the ERPs elicited by a stimulus that had to be memorized while varying the number of items (1, 3 or 6) in the task stimulus. In order to distinguish between ERP effects associated with perceptual complexity and retention of information, there was a second condition in which subjects were required to search the task stimulus for a match with a previously presented item. Thus, in the search condition subjects only had to remember one item (match or mismatch). ERP activity was recorded for 2450 msec after task stimulus offset. Two long-duration components varied as a function of task and memory load: a posterior positive wave and a frontal negative wave. Posterior positive wave amplitude was directly related to information load in the memory task but was negligible in the search task. Following the posterior positive wave was a frontal negative wave which occurred at the highest load level in the memory task but was totally absent in the search task. A P3b was elicited in both tasks. P3b was sensitive to information acquisition processes, but it did not distinguish between memory retention and visual search processes. While P3b amplitude did not vary with task or load, its latency increased with load in both tasks.

Auditory and visual P300s in temporal lobectomy patients: evidence for modality-dependent generators.

The P300 component of the event-related brain potential (ERP) was studied in epileptic patients with unilateral resections of medial temporal lobe areas of the brain. The patients and controls were tested in an oddball paradigm in two conditions: counting and reaction time. Both auditory and visual stimuli were used to elicit ERP activity in different blocks. Despite the reported presence of locally-generated auditory and visual P300-like potentials in these areas, no evidence was found of any surgically-related hemispheric asymmetries in the scalp distribution of the P300 or Slow Wave for stimuli in either modality. Moreover, compared to normal controls, there were no significant reductions in overall P300 amplitude in the patients. The patients did show a double dissociation in their frontal ERP activity: the left temporal lobectomy patients showed apparent decreased frontal auditory P300 amplitudes but normal visual P300 amplitudes, whereas the right temporal lobectomy patients showed the opposite pattern. These results appeared to be due to the presence of a long-duration slow wave rather than to alterations in P300 amplitude. These data do not support the presence of a significant contribution by a hippocampal/amygdala generator to the activity of the scalp-recorded P300 in the oddball paradigm. Topographic comparisons on normalized amplitudes revealed significantly different scalp distributions as a function of stimulus modality, event probability, and task for both the P300 and Slow Wave components. These data indicate that the amplitude variations associated with each experimental variable are due to the activity of a separate underlying neural source. The sources of task and probability effects on P300 and Slow Wave amplitude each appeared to be modality-independent generators. The nature of the third, modality-related generator is less clear. These results uphold the tenets of the model of P300 amplitude proposed by Johnson (1986) and argue against the idea that the P300 is a unitary phenomenon.

Automatic and attentional processing: An event-related brain potential analysis of semantic priming

Event-related brain potentials (ERPs) and behavioral measures (reaction time and percentage errors) were measured in a semantic priming lexical decision task. In one block of trials, instructions and the proportion of related word pairs were designed to influence subjects to process the first member of each pair (prime) automatically. In another block, subjects were induced to attend to the meaning of each prime. ERPs to the primes were more positive between 200 and 600 msec and more negative between 750 and 1150 msec when subjects attended to the primes as opposed to when only automatic processing was required. Target word ERP activity between 200 and 525 msec (N400) was more negative in the neutral than in the semantically related condition in both blocks of trials, but more so in the attentional block, while a late ERP positively between 525 and 1100 msec (Slow Wave) was more positive in the unrelated than the neutral condition, but only in the attentional block. The results are discussed in terms of the two-process model proposed by Posner and Snyder (1975a, 1975b).