Curriculum Evaluation Research Articles

Exploring the "led" in health professional student-led experiences: a scoping review.

To support a complex health system, students are expected to be competent leaders as well as competent clinicians. Intentional student leadership development is needed in health professional education programs. Student-led experiences such as student-run clinics and interprofessional training wards, are practice-based learning opportunities where learners provide leadership to clinical services and/or address a gap in the system. Given the absence of leadership definitions and concepts, this scoping review explored how student leadership is conceptualized and developed in student-led experiences. The review was conducted in accordance with best practices in scoping review methodology within the scope of relevant practice-based student-led experiences for health professional students. The research team screened 4659 abstracts, identified 315 articles for full-text review and selected 75 articles for data extraction and analysis. A thematic analysis produced themes related to leadership concepts/theories/models, objectives, facilitation/supervision, assessment and evaluation of curriculum. While responding to system gaps within health professional care, student-led experiences need to align explicit leadership theory/concepts/models with curricular objectives, pedagogy, and assessments to support health professional education. To support future student-led experiences, authors mapped five leadership student role profiles that were associated with student-led models and could be constructively aligned with theory and concepts. In addition to leveraging a student workforce to address system needs, student-led experiences must also be a force for learning through a reciprocal model of leadership and service to develop future health professionals and leaders.

Integrating planetary health education into tertiary curricula: a practical toolbox for implementation

ObjectiveTo present a series of case studies from our respective countries and disciplines on approaches to implementing the Planetary Health Education Framework in university health professional education programs, and to propose a curriculum implementation and evaluation toolbox for educators to facilitate the adoption of similar initiatives in their programs. We emphasize the importance of applying an Indigenous lens to curriculum needs assessment, development, implementation, and evaluation.MethodsCase studies from Australia and United States were collated using a six-stage design-based educational research framework (Focus, Formulation, Contextualization, Definition, Implementation, Evaluation) for teaching planetary health and methods of curriculum evaluation. These components were then mapped to derive the curriculum implementation toolbox reflecting the six-stage design-based educational research framework.ResultsThe case studies demonstrated different approaches to successful integration of the Planetary Health Education Framework in medicine, nursing, public health, and allied health disciplines. This integration often involved Indigenous perspectives on environmental stewardship, holistic health, and community well-being into the curriculum. The case studies also highlighted the importance of community engagement, cultural competency, and interdisciplinary collaboration in curriculum development. Findings from case studies were used to propose a curriculum implementation toolbox to assist educators in adapting and integrating planetary health education into their own programs.DiscussionWhile valuable frameworks for teaching planetary health in health science programs exist, challenges remain in implementing these frameworks in real-world educational environments. The proposed curriculum implementation toolbox offers practical strategies and resources for educators to incorporate these principles into their teaching. Additionally, the case studies reported here contribute to the growing body of literature on planetary health education pertinent to addressing the triple planetary crisis.

Issues and Countermeasures in Chinese FLTRP Primary School Textbooks under the New Curriculum Standard

The New Curriculum Standard (NCS) is the norm and quality requirement of the Chinese national educational curriculum as well as the basis of teaching management, curriculum evaluation, and textbook compilation. In textbook design, the selection of textbook materials should meet the objectives and requirements of the NCS. Since appropriate teaching materials are essential to curriculum standards and effective teaching, we must follow the consistency between textbook materials and curriculum standards to achieve an ideal degree of conformity with the textbook system and teaching objectives and promote the sustainable development of the English curriculum reform. However, the current primary school English textbooks fall short of the NCS, which leads to difficulties in implementing teaching tasks and achieving teaching goals. Given these difficulties, we should analyze the causes from three dimensions: linguistic knowledge, cultural awareness, and learning strategies. In addition, a high recurrence of phonetic knowledge, systematic grammar presentation, diversified learning styles, level grading, and in-depth involvement of cultural factors are keys to the perfect conformity of the NCS and English textbooks.

Effective Leadership in Improving the Quality of Education in Madrasah Tsnawiyah

The principal's efforts in improving the quality of education at MTs Nurul Hidayah Tegalsiwalan Probolinggo can be seen from various aspects, including curriculum objectives, teaching staff, teaching methodologies, facilities, and evaluations. These aspects still contain problems that have yet to be resolved entirely. Therefore, to enhance the quality of education at the madrasa, strong leadership from the head of the madrasa is essential. The research findings indicate the following: improving teacher professionalism, enhancing the quality of facilities, improving the quality of learning, and increasing student achievement. The head of the madrasa includes position themselves as an educator, manager, administrator, supervisors, leaders, innovators, and motivators. Supporting factors include a charismatic and authoritative leadership style, managerial skills, effective communication abilities, and a flexible, non-authoritarian attitude. On the other hand, inhibiting factors include limited and inadequate facilities, minimal support from the institution, and a lack of training in managerial or leadership styles.

Coping Mechanism of Teachers in the New Normal

The pandemic gave teachers a crucial role in facilitating and monitoring students’ growth despite difficulties and changes in the educational platform. Thus, in this context, this paper analyzed the teachers’ coping mechanisms in the New Normal in one of the Districts in a highly urbanized city in Central Philippines during the school year 2021 – 2022 as the basis for a Wellness Plan. Using census or complete enumeration, 122 high school teachers responded to a self-made, 30-item questionnaire, which has hurdled the validity and reliability tests. Data were subsequently analyzed according to the research problems stipulated in the study’s objectives. The study’s three major variables on teachers’ coping mechanisms were analyzed using the mean as one of the measures of central tendency. The ensuing analysis showed that curriculum implementation garnered a mean score of 4.37, interpreted as high. At the same time, instructional delivery obtained a mean score of 4.50, which was also interpreted as a very high level. Contrastingly, monitoring and evaluation garnered a mean score of 4.61, which is also interpreted as a very high level. The same data showed a high to very high level of coping mechanisms under all three mentioned sub-groupings. This paper advocates for the provision of necessary resources to support educators in developing their capacity, specifically in the areas of curriculum implementation, instructional delivery, and monitoring and evaluation systems for 21st-century pedagogy and assessment methods. Keywords: Teachers, coping mechanism, curriculum implementation, instructional delivery, monitoring and evaluation, Central Philippines

Instilling social accountability into the health professions education curriculum with international case studies: AMEE Guide No. 175

This AMEE guide focuses on instilling social accountability (SA) concept and values into health professions education (HPE) curricula with the goal of producing competent, compassionate healthcare professionals who can act as change agents within the healthcare system. By incorporating SA, HPE schools will instil in their students a strong sense of accountability for addressing the health needs of the communities they serve. This AMEE guide presents a comprehensive framework for embedding SA into the HPE curriculum, covering various aspects in curriculum design, implementation, and evaluation. It also includes case studies of exemplary socially accountable curricula, highlighting the experiences of schools aspiring for SA. Acknowledging how curriculum is embedded in a larger institutional structure, and that SA requires institutional commitment in its governance structure and policies is also a critical component for consideration.

Exodontia curriculum evaluation: fit for purpose teaching and learning strategies

Exodontia curriculum evaluation: fit for purpose teaching and learning strategies

Development and Implementation of a Family Presence Facilitator Curriculum for Interprofessional Use in Pediatric Medical Resuscitations.

Family presence during pediatric medical resuscitation has myriad benefits. However, there is significant heterogeneity in provider acceptance and implementation of the family support role. We designed this curriculum to teach all members of the health care team best practices in the Family Presence Facilitator (FPF) role during pediatric medical resuscitations. We applied Kern's six-step approach to develop an FPF curriculum comprising didactic and interactive elements, along with training for simulated participants. We implemented the curriculum through (a) live sessions (30-minute didactic or 90-minute workshop) for learners; (b) a 20-minute asynchronous version of the didactic curriculum for self-directed learning; and (c) a 1-hour, monthly, in situ simulation curriculum in a pediatric emergency department setting. Curriculum evaluation surveys queried self-reported engagement, satisfaction, relevance, confidence, commitment, knowledge, skills, and attitudes in a retrospective pre/post format. We collected data from 153 learners, including attendings, fellows, residents, advanced practice providers, medical students, and child life specialists, between October 2022 and September 2023. Only 22% of participants had received similar prior training. One hundred percent of learners found the curriculum enjoyable and engaging; learners also agreed the curriculum improved their knowledge and skills in providing empathetic and respectful communication (99%); nonspeculative, clear information (100%); and nonverbal support (99%). Of respondents, 100% believed the curriculum would improve the patient care experience. Facilitating family presence during pediatric medical resuscitations is a crucial skill. Our curriculum improves self-reported confidence, knowledge, and skills among interprofessional learners. Next steps include expanding this curriculum beyond the pediatric setting.

Management Strategies for Higher Education Institutions Based on the Principles of Education for Sustainable Development in the Lower Northern Region

Education for sustainable development is globally acknowledged as crucial for fostering knowledge, skills, and values essential for sustainable living. This research aimed to (1) examine the current and desired conditions of administrative strategies in higher education institutions in the lower northern region based on the concept of education for sustainable development, and (2) develop corresponding strategies focusing on economic, social, environmental, and systemic dimensions. A mixed-method approach was employed, with a sample of 243 administrators and personnel from 12 universities in the region. Research instruments included a conceptual framework assessment, a questionnaire, and structured interviews. The findings revealed that current administrative practices ranked as follows: (1) curriculum development, (2) teaching and learning management, and (3) educational measurement and evaluation. While all aspects showed a good level of development, the desired conditions indicated the need for further improvement, with the ranking of (1) curriculum development, (2) educational measurement and evaluation, and (3) educational management. The study identified three core strategies: (1) reforming integrated curriculum design to align with sustainable development by emphasizing comprehensive systems that connect theory to practice; (2) enhancing the quality of educational measurement and evaluation to support sustainability-focused skills and concepts; and (3) transforming teaching and learning management by utilizing technology to foster an environment conducive to learning and innovation. These strategies are essential for guiding universities toward sustainable development and align with Thailand’s higher education standards focused on producing skilled, knowledgeable, and sustainability-minded graduates.

Curriculum and program evaluation in medical education: a short systematic literature review.

Medical education is constantly evolving worldwide and facing various challenges. To cope with these, continuous and fruitful evaluation of an educational program is the need of the day. This study aims to know the purpose of evaluation, various theories related to program evaluation, and different models of curriculum and program evaluation. This will help educationists evaluate their programs fruitfully and effectively according to their needs and objectives. Different search engines including Medline's PubMed interface, Google Scholar, and Cochrane Review databases using keywords, curriculum evaluation, evaluation models, and evaluation strategies in education, were searched without any date restrictions, and 20 full-text articles were selected for review and data extraction. While reviewing the literature it was found that most of the modern educational program and curriculum evaluation models are based on the reductionist, system, and complexity theories of evaluation. The experimental/quasi-experimental model is based majorly on the linear approach and reductionism, but its drawback is that it is impractical for the whole curriculum and sometimes ethically unfavorable. Kirkpatrick's model, Philips' model, the CIPP model, and the logic model are based on the system and complexity theory and are more practical in medical education. Each of these models has its advantages and limitations. In this review, the authors discussed the important distinctive features of these evaluation theories and models and their applicability and usefulness in evaluating different programs and curricula.

Implementation and Evaluation of a Pediatric Palliative Care Curriculum for Adult-Track HPM Fellows

IntroductionHospice and Palliative Medicine (HPM) fellowship training provides education on caring for patients from early childhood through adulthood. Yet, there are few guidelines about how to teach these key components, and more specifically the components of Pediatric Palliative Care (PPC), to fellows who have a variety of backgrounds prior to entering HPM fellowship. MethodsWe created a curriculum in PPC that could be used with adult-track HPM fellows. We developed an outline for material to cover during each of the three weeks of PPC clinical rotations. We also created a longitudinal lecture series encompassing several foundational topics and concepts in PPC. We conducted “Just-in-Time” evaluation of the clinical rotation curriculum utilizing a critical reflection model as well as focus groups with fellows and faculty members to further explore the knowledge, attitudes, and perceptions of the entire PPC curriculum. Transcripts were coded Nvivo and template analysis was used to understand code distribution between and within focus groups. ResultsEight overarching codes emerged from the focus groups: “Staffing Issues,” “Learning Structure,” “Useful Material,” “Topics Attending Contingent,” “Time Management,” “Teachable Moment,” “Not Useful Material,” and ”Adherence to Teaching Materials.” ConclusionThe study revealed some limitations in the current curriculum design, such as its lack of consistency. However, it also highlighted several strengths, including the importance of flexibility and personal responsibility for learning. The results provide valuable insights into the experiences among fellows and educators at a single institution with a PPC Curriculum for adult-track HPM fellows.

Evaluation and Improvement of College Dance Course Based on Multiple Intelligences Theory

Based on the theory of multiple intelligences, this paper discusses the methods and strategies for the evaluation and improvement of college dance courses. Firstly, this paper introduces the concept and development of multiple intelligence theory and emphasizes its complement and perfection to traditional intelligence theory. Then, it analyzes the problems and shortcomings of current college dance courses, including overemphasis on skill training and single evaluation criteria. Then, it puts forward the curriculum evaluation index based on the theory of multiple intelligences, including the evaluation of students’ multiple intelligences development and the evaluation of curriculum design and teaching methods. At the same time, curriculum evaluation tools and methods are discussed, such as questionnaire survey, observation record, learning achievement display and student self-rating. In the aspect of curriculum improvement and perfection strategy, it emphasizes the application of multiple intelligence theory, interdisciplinary integration and the introduction of scientific and technological means. In terms of curriculum implementation and effect evaluation, the importance of students’ comprehensive intelligent evaluation and students’ feedback is emphasized. Finally, the paper summarizes the practical value of the evaluation and improvement of college dance courses based on the theory of multiple intelligences and looks forward to the future research direction and prospects.

Otolaryngology Simulation Curriculum Development and Evaluation for Medical Education in Rwanda.

This study aimed to assess the feasibility and acceptability of a new low-cost otolaryngology simulation training curriculum for medical students in Rwanda. Given the limited access to hands-on training and equipment in low-middle-income countries, building confidence in performing basic otolaryngology skills is vital for all medical students, especially where all graduates initially serve in primary care before specializing. Preintervention and postintervention assessments of simulation training. Conducted at the University of Global Health Equity in Rwanda. The simulation program comprised 3 primary components: (1) a low-cost, moderate-fidelity model for cricothyrotomy and tracheostomy practice, (2) a low-cost, low-fidelity ear model for foreign body and cerumen removal, and a high-fidelity manikin for practicing, (3) epistaxis management, and (4) nasal foreign body removal. Students underwent pretest and posttest assessments measuring their knowledge, experience, perceived skill, and confidence in performing these procedures. A survey collected feedback on the program. A total of 29 medical students participated in the simulation program, integrated into a 1-week otolaryngology "boot camp" preceding a 3-week clerkship rotation. All models were created using basic, locally available materials, at a total cost of $1.02 for cricothyrotomy and $0.20 for foreign body models. Knowledge and perceived confidence increased for all 3 simulations. All students found the simulations useful, enjoyable, and anticipated using these skills in future training. The study's results demonstrated that the low-cost otolaryngology simulation was well-received and enhanced knowledge, interest, and confidence in performing basic otolaryngology skills across all simulations.

직업계고 학점제 공동교육과정 운영 실태 분석을 통한 지원 방안 탐색

The purpose of this study is to explore support measures based on the current status and needs of the joint curriculum of the vocational high school credit system in order to overcome the limitations of the curriculum operation of uniform and rigid schools. The results of the survey for 142 vocational high school teachers who operated the “joint Curriculum” in 2023 were used to analyze the actual condition of the “joint Curriculum Operation” of vocational high schools. As a result of the study, it suggested that the government prepare guidelines for the operation of the joint curriculum for vocational high schools, prepare a support system for the smooth operation of the joint curriculum, find diversity in the operation model of the joint curriculum considering the characteristics of the school, prepare guidelines for teaching and evaluation of the joint curriculum for vocational high schools, share best practices, seek support measures for each role of teachers participating in the joint curriculum, strengthen the role of provincial and provincial offices of education to revitalize the joint curriculum for vocational high schools, and improve the administrative work of the joint curriculum.

초등교사의 창의적 체험활동 경험에 관한 질적 메타분석

Objective: Using a qualitative meta-analysis, this study examines whether elementary school teachers' experiences in organizing and operating creative experiential activities are being implemented in actual school sites as intended and proposes ways to internalize the quality of these activities. Methods: Eight domestic qualitative studies on the said experience were analyzed in a larger framework of curriculum organization, implementation, and evaluation according to Novlit and Hare’s (1998) seven-step qualitative meta-analysis approach. Results: Elementary school teachers had conflicting views on teacher autonomy in organizing, managing, and evaluating creative experiential activities. Further, they differed in their experiences in different areas of creative experiential and out-of-school activities. The study also elicited opinions on how to evaluate creative experiential activities and improve professional development related activities. Conclusions: Suggestions were made for improving the creative experiential activity curriculum and follow-up research, such as providing opportunities to cultivate teacher expertise related to creative experiential activities, exploring teacher and student experiences by activity area and alternative creative experience evaluation measures.

Development of the RCUSP Model for the Purpose of improving the Curriculum Evaluation

Development of the RCUSP Model for the Purpose of improving the Curriculum Evaluation

Reflection on Challenges Faced by Chinese Students in Australian Curriculum Assessment System based on AfL

The growing population of international students in Australian higher education institutions presents a unique set of challenges for educators responsible for implementing the Assessment for Learning (AfL) principle. This article explores the specific obstacles faced by Chinese students as they strive to adapt to the Australian higher education curriculum evaluation system from their own perspectives. Additionally, the authors of this article offer in-depth and targeted strategies aimed at enriching the learning experiences of Chinese international students by applying AfL principles. These proposed methods are intended to provide assistance to international students who share a similar educational background in China, helping them overcome the diverse learning challenges encountered in a new and unfamiliar educational setting.

Development and evaluation of a training curriculum to engage researchers on accessing and analyzing the All of Us data.

The All of Us Evenings with Genetics (EwG) Research Program at Baylor College of Medicine (BCM), funded to engage research scholars to work with the All of Us data, developed a training curriculum for the Researcher Workbench, the platform to access and analyze All of Us data. All of Us EwG developed the curriculum so that it could teach scholars regardless of their skills and background in programming languages and cloud computing. All of Us EwG delivered this curriculum at the first annual All of Us EwG Faculty Summit in May 2022. The curriculum was evaluated both during and after the Faculty Summit so that it could be improved for future training. Surveys were administered to assess scholars' familiarity with the programming languages and computational tools required to use the Researcher Workbench. The curriculum was developed using backward design and was informed by the survey results, a review of available resources for training users on the Researcher Workbench, and All of Us EwG members' collective experience training students. The curriculum was evaluated using feedback surveys during the Faculty Summit as well as virtual meetings and emails following the Faculty Summit. The evaluation results demonstrated the success of the curriculum and identified areas for improvement. The curriculum has been adapted and improved in response to evaluations and in response to changes to the All of Us data and infrastructure to train more researchers through this program and other scholarly programs.

Manajemen Kurikulum Berbasis Pesantren untuk Membentuk Karakter Siswa di SMP Al-Azhar Menganti Gresik

The results of this study show that curriculum planning based on pesantren is carried out by involving several parties both from sekolah and from pesantren, namely education bureaus and leadership bureaus. At this stage of planning, the two bureaus designed the books that would be made referenced and studied in the Madrasa. Two methodologies are used in the implementation of learning: conventional methods such as bandongan and, when necessary, active learning techniques. Evaluation of the pesantren-based curriculum focuses on students' morality and discipline both at home and in the educational environment.

Curriculum Evaluation and Alignment of Core Ideals: Application of a Values-Based Framework.

Curriculum evaluation, including alignment of concepts, is an ongoing challenge for nurse educators. Nursing curricular frameworks encompass varied concepts, guided by professional standards. This article examines a conceptual model, the Globe Framework, for BSN generalist practice including initial development, implementation, and evaluation. Evaluation at one school, driven by new AACN Essentials in 2021, spans from 2008 to 2020, reviewing three data points: meeting minutes, master syllabi from baccalaureate coursework, and accreditation documents. Challenges included merging two nursing departments with collaboration to reach consensus. Framework strengths include local practice environment values and multiple concepts. Findings and recommendations can inform nurse educators as they consider program evaluation and upcoming accreditation standards.