Essential Procedural Skills Research Articles

Core procedural skills in the MD curriculum: what students need to learn.

The medical education system in Vietnam is currently undergoing a significant transformation with the support of the Ministry of Education and Training (MOET) and the Ministry of Health (MOH). Alongside this shift, the emergence of new medical schools, including VinUniversity, reflects a growing enrollment trend in undergraduate medical programs (UME). During the curriculum development phase, a crucial gap in core procedural skills among medical graduates surfaced. In response, the Medical Doctor (MD) Education team launched a project aimed at establishing a consensus-based list of essential procedural skills and identifying optimal clinical placements for skill acquisition. A cross-sectional survey, based on this list, was distributed among physicians and residents in the VINMEC Healthcare system, asking them to rate skills using the Likert scale and specify suitable clinical placements or rotations for acquisition. With 207 respondents, a consensus list of 38 core procedural skills was generated and integrated into the curriculum. This adaptable list holds promise for adoption by medical schools nationwide, fostering standardization and enhancement of medical education quality.

American Board of Internal Medicine Nephrology Procedure Requirements for Initial Certification: Time for a Change and Pursuing Consensus in the Nephrology Community

In 1988, the American Board of Internal Medicine (ABIM) defined essential procedural skills in nephrology, and candidates for ABIM certification were required to present evidence of possessing the skills necessary for placement of temporary dialysis vascular access, hemodialysis, peritoneal dialysis, and percutaneous renal biopsy. In 1996, continuous renal replacement therapy was added to the list of nephrology requirements. These procedure requirements have not been modified since 1996 while the practice of nephrology has changed dramatically. In March 2021, the ABIM Nephrology Board embarked on a policy journey to revise the procedure requirements for nephrology certification. With the guidance of nephrology diplomates, training program directors, professional and patient organizations, and other stakeholders, the ABIM Nephrology Board revised the procedure requirements to reflect current practice and national priorities. The approved changes include the Opportunity to Train standard for placement of temporary dialysis catheters, percutaneous kidney biopsies, and home hemodialysis which better reflects the current state of training in most training programs, and the new requirements for home dialysis therapies training will align with the national priority to address the underuse of home dialysis therapies. This perspective details the ABIM process for considering changes to the certification procedure requirements and how ABIM collaborated with the larger nephrology community in considering revisions and additions to these requirements.

Core Procedural Skills to be Taught for III-Year Undergraduate Medical Students: A Modified Delphi Study.

While medical students are expected to learn procedural skills during their training, there is no consensus on their level of learning. Further, the most essential procedural skills across medical curricula which need to be taught during their III-year clinical posting are often not considered. The purpose of this study was to identify the core procedural skills needed to be taught during the III-year undergraduate medical students clinical posting. A three-round, online Modified Delphi method was used to identify consensus on selecting the most essential procedural skills prescribed in National Medical Commission (NMC) curriculum 2019. In Round 1, a list of 54 procedural skills from the National Medical Commission's (NMC) Graduate Medical Education Regulations (GMER) 2019 curriculum was distributed to 22 experts in pre-clinical medical education and multidisciplinary clinicians.They rated the skills in terms of importance. In Round 2, the skills that received consensus in Round 1 were presented, resulting in 13 skills for evaluation. Round 3 further narrowed down the skills to a final consensus of 6. An interclass correlation coefficient of 0.767 among experts indicates a substantial level of reliability. Consensus was achieved for six procedural skills, each demonstrating over 80% agreement among the experts. These skills include basic life support, intravenous cannulation, urinary catheterization for both male and female patients, nasogastric tube insertion, oxygen administration, and basic suturing. Notably, all these skills received the highest level of agreement, surpassing 90% consensus. The results of the modified Delphi study offer crucial insights into the procedural skills that should be included in the curriculum for third-year undergraduate medical students during their clinical rotations in a tertiary care teaching hospital. Faculty members at these institutions differ in their opinions regarding the importance of teaching specific procedural skills, influenced by their teaching background and the student cohorts they instruct. From a comprehensive list, six skills have been pinpointed as the most vital through the modified Delphi technique. Moreover, the Delphi technique is acknowledged as a valuable method for achieving a consensus on prioritizing the training of certifiable skills.

Factors Affecting Learning Essential Procedural Skills in Pediatric Residents: A Cross-sectional Study

Background: Clinical education is a vital component of physician education, where medical students learn by attending to patients and applying their knowledge and reasoning to solve their problems. However, many medical students struggle to acquire procedural skills, the ultimate goal of clinical education. Procedural skills are expected to be learned by the residents according to their academic year and are essential for providing better health services to children and families. Objectives: This study evaluates the status of the training provided and the level of learning the necessary procedural skills in pediatric residents based on standards. Methods: This research was a descriptive cross-sectional method from 1998 to 99. In the first part of the researcher-made questionnaire, the implementation of the educational program on all pediatric residents (115) of Mofid Children's Hospital was evaluated. In the second part, the residents' views on the current state of their learning of essential procedural skills were determined. Results: All residents from years one to four participated in the study. After assessing the status of skills acquired by residents with a questionnaire and comparing the average of each skill acquisition procedure with the desired standards, the average of all skills in all three methods was under the standards approved by the Ministry of Health, except for independent subcutaneous, intramuscular and intravenous injection skills and the skill of working with a ventilator. Also, according to the Friedman test, the lowest score for gaining skills in performing procedures was related to NG tube placement skills and subcutaneous, intramuscular, and intravenous injection skills. According to the statistical results obtained from the Spearman coefficient in all procedures, the level of subcutaneous, intramuscular, and intravenous injection skills had a significant correlation with independent skills. Conclusions: According to the specialized assistants of children participating in this study, the current training program of essential procedural skills implemented at Shahid Beheshti University of Medical Sciences was generally useful and effective. But there were also obstacles and limitations. Therefore, it is recommended to review the implementation of the training programs and implement effective measures, including providing more exposure conditions for independent procedures.

Longitudinal survey of self-reported level of entrustment across the first year of clinical practice

Background. Newly graduated medical students often report that they lack the skills required to care for patients, and feel unprepared for clinical practice. However, little is known about when, and if, they acquire these skills in practice. The aim of this study was to assess self-reported level of entrustment in, and frequency of performance of, the seven Entrustable Professional Activities (EPAs) comprising the EPA framework for interns in Ireland. EPAs describe discrete activities that are essential to a particular profession. Methods. Self-report survey data were collected from doctors in the Republic of Ireland during their first year of clinical practice at four different time points during 2020/21. Results. Response rates to the survey varied from 73.3% (126/172) at Time 1 to 25.6% (44/172) at Time 4. After three months, the respondents reported that they could execute all of the EPAs, inclusive of 12 essential procedural skills, with indirect supervision. As the year progressed there was an increase in the proportion of respondents reporting that they performed the EPAs at least once a week. However, the proportion of respondents performing five of the essential procedural skills (e.g. nasogastric tube insertion) remained low across all time points. Conclusion. Consideration should be given as to how to better prepare medical students to execute these EPAs, how the interns can be better supported during the first quarter of internship. The findings from this research are positive. However, there is an urgent need to carry out formal assessments of entrustability, rather than relying on self-report.

Longitudinal survey of self-reported level of entrustment across the first year of clinical practice.

Background. Newly graduated medical students often report that they lack the skills required to care for patients, and feel unprepared for clinical practice. However, little is known about when, and if, they acquire these skills in practice. The aim of this study was to assess self-reported level of entrustment in, and frequency of performance of, the seven Entrustable Professional Activities (EPAs) comprising the EPA framework for interns in Ireland. EPAs describe discrete activities that are essential to a particular profession. Methods. Self-report survey data were collected from doctors in the Republic of Ireland during their first year of clinical practice at four different time points during 2020/21. Results. Response rates to the survey varied from 73.3% (126/172) at Time 1 to 25.6% (44/172) at Time 4. After three months, the respondents reported that they could execute all of the EPAs, inclusive of 12 essential procedural skills, with indirect supervision. As the year progressed there was an increase in the proportion of respondents reporting that they performed the EPAs at least once a week. However, the proportion of respondents performing five of the essential procedural skills (e.g. nasogastric tube insertion) remained low across all time points. Conclusion. Consideration should be given as to how to better prepare medical students to execute these EPAs, how the interns can be better supported during the first quarter of internship. The findings from this research are positive. However, there is an urgent need to carry out formal assessments of entrustability, rather than relying on self-report.

Preparing for a Career in Pediatric Hospital Medicine: A Needs Assessment and Recommendations for Individualized Curricula.

The individualized curriculum within residency programs allows residents to tailor their elective time toward future career goals and interests. Our objective was to identify experiences and activities that would foster resident interest and enhance preparation for a career in pediatric hospital medicine (PHM). Electronic surveys were distributed to pediatric hospitalists, PHM fellowship directors, and graduating PHM fellows. These stakeholders were asked to identify key experiences for residents to explore before entering fellowship or practice. Descriptive statistics and thematic analysis were performed on survey responses. Forty-six percent of PHM fellows (16 of 35), 42% of pediatric hospitalists (149 of 356), and 58% of fellowship program directors (35 of 60) completed the survey. All 3 groups identified complex care as the most important clinical experience to gain in residency. Other highly valued clinical experiences included pain management, surgical comanagement, and palliative care. Lumbar puncture, electrocardiograph interpretation, and airway management were identified as essential procedural skills. Nonclinical experiences that were deemed important included quality improvement, development of teaching skills, and research methodology. All groups agreed that these recommendations should be supplemented with effective mentorship. Identification of key clinical experiences, nonclinical activities, and mentorship for residents interested in PHM may assist with tailoring the individualized curriculum to personal career goals. Incorporating these suggested experiences can improve preparedness of residents entering PHM.

Identifying essential procedural skills in Canadian undergraduate medical education.

IntroductionWe conducted a national survey to characterize current Canadian procedural skills training in Undergraduate Medical Education (UGME). The goals were to identify the most important procedures students should know upon graduation and assess clinician-educator perceptions regarding implementation of a pre-clerkship procedural program.MethodsWe distributed the survey to physician-educators across Canada’s 17 medical schools. Respondents were directed to an individualized survey that collected demographic data, physician-educator responses on essential procedural skills, as well as physician-educator opinions on the value of a pre-clerkship procedural training program.ResultsThe response rate for this survey was 21% (42 out of 201 distributed surveys were completed). The top 10 most important procedures identified by physician-educators included IV Access, Airway Management, Local anesthesia/field block, Casting, Spontaneous Vaginal Delivery, Testing for STIs, Phlebotomy, Suturing of Lacerations, Nasogastric Tube Insertion, and Venipuncture. Physician-educators supported a pre-clerkship procedural program.ConclusionsIdentifying the most crucial procedural skills is the first step in implementing a competency-based procedural skills training program for Canadian medical students. With the list of essential skills, and the support for physician-educators in developing a pre-clerkship procedural skills curriculum, hopefully there can be future development of formalized curricula.

Doodling Docs for DOPS: an innovative approach to procedural skills training for core medical trainees

To provide timetabled opportunities for core medical trainees (CMTs) at the Royal Free Hospital to practise essential procedural skills under direct supervision by expert clinicians, with a view to gain the required competences for Annual Review of Competence Progression (ARCP). An online survey using SurveyMonkey was created for CMTs to determine their pre-existing experience in essential procedural skills, how confident they felt performing these procedures, and how …

Prioritization in medical school simulation curriculum development using survey tools and desirability function: a pilot experiment

BackgroundIn Italy, there is no framework of procedural skills that all medical students should be able to perform autonomously at graduation. The study aims at identifying (1) a set of essential procedural skills and (2) which abilities could be potentially taught with simulation. Desirability score was calculated for each procedure to determine the most effective manner to proceed with simulation curriculum development.MethodsA web poll was conducted at the School of Medicine in Novara, looking at the level of expected and self-perceived competency for common medical procedures. Three groups were enrolled: (1) faculty, (2) junior doctors in their first years of practice, and (3) recently graduated medical students. Level of importance of procedural skills for independent practice expressed by teachers, level of mastery self-perceived by learners (students and junior doctors) and suitability of simulation training for the given technical skills were measured. Desirability function was used to set priorities for future learning.ResultsThe overall mean expected level of competency for the procedural skills was 7.9/9. Mean level of self reported competency was 4.7/9 for junior doctors and 4.4/9 for recently graduated students. The highest priority skills according to the desirability function were urinary catheter placement, nasogastric tube insertion, and incision and drainage of superficial abscesses.ConclusionsThis study identifies those technical competencies thought by faculty to be important and assessed the junior doctors and recent graduates level of self-perceived confidence in performing these skills. The study also identifies the perceived utility of teaching these skills by simulation. The study prioritizes those skills that have a gap between expected and observed competency and are also thought to be amenable to teaching by simulation. This allows immediate priorities for simulation curriculum development in the most effective manner. This methodology may be useful to researchers in other centers to prioritize simulation training.

Taking the Leap Towards an Additional Fellowship Year in Advanced Structural Heart Disease Training

Structural heart disease is a relatively new discipline within cardiology, especially in regard to interventional procedures. Moreover, the type and number of procedures for structural heart diseas...

CAPACITY AND CONFIDENCE IN PERFORMING CLINICAL PROCEDURES AMONG PRIMARY CARE TEAMS IN THE CENTRAL REGION OF VIETNAM

Background and Aim: To develop primary care services is one of the top priorities of the health sector in Vietnam. In recent years, the Government and the Ministry of Health have made great efforts to strengthen and improve the quality of healthcare services at the grassroof level. However, several studies showed that the needs for healthcare remained unmet at primary care level. This study aimed to examine the gaps in competency and confidence of the primary care team in delivery of clinical procedures. Methods: A crosssectional descriptive study was conducted in 49 commune health centers (CHCs) of 3 provinces. The health care teams reported their ability and confidence to perform the list of clinical procedures based on the regulation on clinical procedures performed at the CHC issued by the Ministry of Health. Results: The average number of procedures performed by the CHCs was 46,4/109 procedures. There were 65.3% of CHCs performed less than 50% of assigned techniques, and only 28.6% CHCs performed 50-80% of assigned techniques. The confidence of CHC teams was high in performing procedures of Resuscitation, Internal Medicine, Pediatrics and OBGYN. Conclusion: There is a substantial gap in the capability to perform clinical procedures among CHC team. The confidence in performing essential procedural skills varied among procedures, depending on clinical experience and the types of procedure. Our results show a strong call to develop training programs that fit to the competency standards of primary care team in order to enhance the capacity and confidence of health staff in healthcare delivery at grassroots level. Key words: Health care, Thua Thien Hue, Quang Tri

Confidence in essential procedural skills of Thai medical graduates

Background: This study is aimed to survey the confidence levels as well as clinical experience of Thai medical graduates in performing essential procedures. Methods and findings: A questionnaire was developed to survey the confidence levels of the new graduates during the academic year 2012 in performing the 17 selected essential procedural skills, using a 1-5 rating scale with 4-5 deemed ‘satisfactory’ along with their learning experience, categorized as 0, 10 cases. Ninety-nine medical graduates completed the questionnaire (62.7%). The mean confidence levels of the essential procedures varied from; 3.35 to 4.57, with the highest in wound suturing whilst the lowest was in newborn resuscitation. Confidence was significantly related to clinical experience. More than 90% of the graduates with experience of more than 10 cases indicated satisfactory confidence in all procedures with the exception of newborn resuscitation. With clinical experience of 5-10 cases, more than 70% of graduates were confident in performing all procedures except endotracheal intubation. Conclusions: Confidence in performing essential procedural skills varied among procedures, depending on clinical experience and the type of procedure. Because of this, we strongly recommend the establishment of minimum requirements, for each procedure, be implemented. Our recommendation would be that at least 10 cases for life-saving skills and 5-10 cases for other essential procedures be required.

Ultrasound competency assessment in emergency medicine residency programs.

In the Model of the Clinical Practice of Emergency Medicine (EM), bedside ultrasound (US) is listed as one of the essential procedural skills. EM milestones released by Accreditation Council for Graduate Medical Education and American Board of Emergency Medicine require residents to demonstrate competency in bedside US. The purpose of this study was to assess the current methods used by EM residency training programs to evaluate resident competency in bedside US. This was a cross-sectional survey study. A questionnaire on US education and competency assessment was electronically sent to all EM residency program directors and emergency US directors. The survey consisted of questions regarding the US rotation, structure of US curriculum, presence of US fellowship, image archiving, quality assurance methods, feedback, competency assessment tools, and frequency of assessment. The survey responses are reported as the percentages of total respondents along with 95% confidence intervals (CIs). A total of 124 of 161 EM residency programs participated in this study, representing a 77% response rate. Twenty-six percent (95% CI = 18% to 34%) of programs assess competency only at the end of the US rotation. Eight percent (95% CI = 3% to 13%) assess competency only every 6 months, and 13% (95% CI = 7% to 19%) assess competency only annually. Eight percent (95% CI = 3% to 13%) assess competency only during the final year of training. Thirty percent (95% CI = 22% to 38%) of programs assess competency with a combination of the above intervals, and 16% (95% CI = 10% to 22%) do not assess US competency. Fourteen percent (95% CI = 8% to 20%) use objective structured clinical examinations (OSCEs), and 21% (95% CI = 14% to 28%) use standardized direct observation tools (SDOTs) to assess resident competency in US. Approximately one-third (33%, 95% CI = 24% to 41%) of standardized testing for US competency is conducted with multiple-choice questions. Thirty percent (95% CI = 21% to 38%) administer practical examinations to assess US skills. Currently, a majority of EM residency programs assess resident competency in bedside US. However, there is significant variation in the methods of competency assessment.

The use of a lightly preserved cadaver and full thickness pig skin to teach technical skills on the surgery clerkship—a response to the economic pressures facing academic medicine today

Background In response to declining instruction in technical skills, the authors instituted a novel method to teach basic procedural skills to medical students beginning the surgery clerkship. Methods Sixty-three medical students participated in a skills training laboratory. The first part of the laboratory taught basic suturing skills, and the second involved a cadaver with pig skin grafted to different anatomic locations. Clinical scenarios were simulated, and students performed essential procedural skills. Results Students learned most of their suturing skills in the laboratory skills sessions, compared with the emergency room or the operating room ( P = .01). Students reported that the laboratory allowed them greater opportunity to participate in the emergency room and operating room. Students also felt that the suture laboratory contributed greatly to their skills in wound closure. Finally, 90% of students had never received instruction on suturing, and only 12% had performed any procedural skills before beginning the surgery rotation. Conclusions The laboratory described is an effective way of insuring that necessary technical skills are imparted during the surgery rotation.

Designing and implementing a skills program using a clinically integrated, multi-professional approach: Using evaluation to drive curriculum change

The essential procedural skills that newly graduated doctors require are rarely defined, do not take into account pre-vocational employer expectations, and differ between Universities. This paper describes how one Faculty used local evaluation data to drive curriculum change and implement a clinically integrated, multi-professional skills program. A curriculum restructure included a review of all undergraduate procedural skills training by academic staff and clinical departments, resulting in a curriculum skills map. Undergraduate training was then linked with postgraduate expectations using the Delphi process to identify the skills requiring structured standardised training. The skills program was designed and implemented without a dedicated simulation center. This paper shows the benefits of an alternate model in which clinical integration of training and multi-professional collaboration encouraged broad ownership of a program and, in turn, impacted the clinical experience obtained.

Designing and implementing a skills program using a clinically integrated, multi-professional approach: using evaluation to drive curriculum change

The essential procedural skills that newly graduated doctors require are rarely defined, do not take into account pre-vocational employer expectations, and differ between Universities. This paper describes how one Faculty used local evaluation data to drive curriculum change and implement a clinically integrated, multi-professional skills program. A curriculum restructure included a review of all undergraduate procedural skills training by academic staff and clinical departments, resulting in a curriculum skills map. Undergraduate training was then linked with postgraduate expectations using the Delphi process to identify the skills requiring structured standardised training. The skills program was designed and implemented without a dedicated simulation center. This paper shows the benefits of an alternate model in which clinical integration of training and multi-professional collaboration encouraged broad ownership of a program and, in turn, impacted the clinical experience obtained.