A 71 year-old man with heart failure, porcelain aorta, and mitral regurgitation presented for heart transplant evaluation. He was in cardiogenic shock requiring inotropic support. An echocardiogram showed a dilated left ventricle, severely reduced systolic function, restricted mitral valve leaflet motion, an elevated mean transmitral gradient, and severe mitral regurgitation. The differential of mixed stenotic and regurgitant mitral valve pathology included rheumatic heart disease and congenital mitral valve anomaly. Hemodynamic management of cardiogenic shock in the setting of mixed mitral valve disease presented unique challenges due to a narrow therapeutic window of optimal preload, afterload reduction, inotropic support, and chronotropic control. He was not a candidate for percutaneous mitral valve interventions or surgery. A porcelain aorta made him high risk for vascular complications with mechanical circulatory support. His course was complicated by worsening shock requiring escalation of inotropes, rapid atrial fibrillation, and recurrent episodes of acute pulmonary edema. Ultimately, he underwent an orthotropic heart transplant. A transesophageal echocardiogram at the time of transplant suggested a parachute mitral valve, where all chordae appeared be originating from one papillary muscle. However, additional views revealed the presence of two papillary muscles with asymmetric, shortened anterior chordae and a hypertrophied anterior papillary muscle. Findings were consistent with a rare parachute-like asymmetric mitral valve complicated by mild mitral stenosis and severe mitral regurgitation. Examination of the explanted native heart confirmed these findings.This case highlights: 1) complex management of mixed valvular disease in the setting of cardiogenic shock, 2) echocardiographic evaluation of mixed valvular heart disease, and 3) a rare congenital malformation of a parachute-like mitral valve presenting in adulthood.