Chlorophyll a serves as a photosynthetic pigment in plants. Its degradation is initiated by the extraction of the central Mg by the Mg-dechelatase enzyme, which is encoded by Stay-Green (SGR). Plant SGR is believed to be derived from bacterial SGR homolog obtained through horizontal gene transfer into photosynthetic eukaryotes. However, it is not known how the bacterial SGR homolog was modified to function in plants. To assess its adaptation mechanism in plants, a bacterial SGR homolog derived from the Anaerolineae bacterium SM23_63 was introduced into plants. It was found that the bacterial SGR homolog metabolized chlorophyll in plants. However, its chlorophyll catabolic activity was lower than that of plant SGR. Recombinant proteins of the bacterial SGR homolog exhibited higher activity than those of the plant SGR. The reduced chlorophyll catabolic activity of bacterial SGR homologs in plants may be associated with low hydrophobicity of the entrance to the catalytic site compared to that of plant SGR. This hinders the enzyme access to chlorophyll, which is localized in hydrophobic environments. This study offers insights into the molecular changes underlying the optimization of enzyme function.