Energy Storage Unit Research Articles

State of Charge Balancing Control Strategy for Wind Power Hybrid Energy Storage Based on Successive Variational Mode Decomposition and Multi-Fuzzy Control

To address the instability of wind power caused by the randomness and intermittency of wind generation, as well as the challenges in power compensation by hybrid energy storage systems (HESSs), this paper proposes a state of charge (SOC) balancing control strategy based on Successive Variational Mode Decomposition and multi-fuzzy control. First, a consensus algorithm is used to enable communication between energy storage units to obtain the global average SOC. Then, the Secretary Bird Optimization Algorithm (SBOA) is applied to optimize the Successive Variational Mode Decomposition (SVMD) and Variational Mode Decomposition (VMD) for the initial allocation of wind power, resulting in the smoothing power for hybrid energy storage and the grid integration power. Finally, considering the deviation between the current SOC of the storage units and the global average SOC, dynamic partitioning is used for multi-fuzzy control to adjust the initial power allocation, achieving SOC balancing control. Simulations of the control strategy were conducted using Matlab/Simulink, and the results indicate that the proposed approach effectively smooths wind power fluctuations, achieving stable grid integration power. It enables the SOC of the HESS to quickly align with the global average SOC, preventing the HESS from entering unhealthy SOC regions.

An Energy Management System for Distributed Energy Storage System Considering Time-Varying Linear Resistance

As the proportion of renewable energy in energy use continues to increase, to solve the problem of line impedance mismatch leading to the difference in the state of charge (SOC) of each distributed energy storage unit (DESU) and the DC bus voltage drop, a distributed energy storage system control strategy considering the time-varying line impedance is proposed in this paper. By analyzing the fundamental frequency harmonic components of the pulse width modulation (PWM) signal carrier of the converter output voltage and output current, we can obtain the impedance information and, thus, compensate for the bus voltage drop. Then, a novel, droop-free cooperative controller is constructed to achieve SOC equalization, current sharing, and voltage regulation. Finally, the validity of the system is verified by a hardware-in-the-loop experimental platform.

Multi-objective optimization of metal foam parameters for enhanced performance of LHTES unit in shell-and-tube configurations

Latent heat thermal energy storage (LHTES) units utilize phase change materials (PCMs) to effectively store thermal energy and address the challenges of solar energy intermittency and instability. Heat transfer characteristics largely influence the thermofluidic efficiency of the LHTES unit during phase transitions. To improve the typically low heat transfer capabilities of PCMs, high-conductivity metal foams are introduced to enhance bulk heat conduction. This study focuses on optimizing the parameters of composite PCM (CPCM) embedded in the LHTES unit, specifically examining metal foam height (H), angle (θ), and porosity (ϵ), primarily affecting the performance of the CPCM. A series of Taguchi-based orthogonal experiments were conducted to analyze the effects of these variables. The results indicate that metal foam height has a notable influence on the CPCM performance, significantly reducing melt fraction variations caused by changes in cross-sectional geometry. ANOVA analysis shows that the metal foam height contributes 49.02% to improve operational time and 73.62% to enhance melt fraction. The study also identifies the optimal values for the metal foam parameters (H, θ, ϵ) that most effectively improve the LHTES unit thermal performance. Based on various indices, an economic assessment of the optimal configuration further supports the proposed design. Overall, the findings provide a recommended configuration to enhance the LHTES unit performance, contributing valuable insights for developing efficient TES systems and supporting sustainable energy management.

High volumetric-energy-density flexible supercapacitors based on PEDOT:PSS incorporated with carbon quantum dots hybrid electrodes

Poly(3,4-ethylenedioxythiophene):poly(styrene sulfonate) (PEDOT:PSS) is a highly successful conductive polymer utilized as an electrode material in energy storage units for portable and wearable electronic devices. Nevertheless, employing PEDOT:PSS in supercapacitors (SC) in its pristine state presents challenges due to its suboptimal electrochemical performance and operational instability. To surmount these limitations, PEDOT:PSS has been integrated with carbon-based materials to form flexible electrodes, which exhibit physical and chemical stability during SC operation. We developed a streamlined fabrication process for high-performance SC electrodes composed of PEDOT:PSS and carbon quantum dots (CQDs). The CQDs were synthesized under microwave irradiation, yielding green- and red-light emissions. Through optimizing the ratios of CQDs to PEDOT:PSS, the SC electrodes were prepared using a spray-coating technique, marking a significant improvement in device performance with a high volumetric capacitance (104.10 F cm−3), impressive energy density (19.68 Wh cm−3), and excellent cyclic stability, retaining ∼85% of its original volumetric capacitance after 15,000 repeated GCD cycles. Moreover, the SCs, when utilized as a flexible substrate, demonstrated the ability to maintain up to ∼85% of their electrochemical performance even after 3,000 bending cycles (at a bending angle of 60°). These attributes render this hybrid composite an ideal candidate for a lightweight smart energy storage component in portable and wearable electronic technologies.

The performance analysis of a compressed air energy storage (CAES) for peak moving with cooling, Heating, and power production

This study focuses on modeling and optimizing a multifaceted geothermal-based energy production system within the context of Denmark. The primary objectives revolve around enhancing system efficiency and reducing operational costs. The system under investigation comprises geothermal components, an organic Rankine cycle, a compressed air energy storage facility, and an absorption chiller. The organic Rankine cycle operates using refrigerants R123 and ammonia, effectively converting thermal energy into electricity and thermal energy for various applications. Optimization was carried out employing the Response Surface Method in tandem with Design-Expert software, facilitating the fine-tuning of objective functions. Two key objectives were selected: Exergy Round Trip Efficiency and cost rate, aimed at improving technical performance and curbing economic expenditure. A range of design variables were considered for optimization, including turbine and pump inlet temperatures, geothermal mass flow rate, turbine and pump efficiencies, compressor and gas turbine efficiency, inlet pressure to the compressed air energy storage tank, and evaporator pinch point temperature. The system reached an impressive exergy efficiency peak of 77.98%, accompanied by a modest cost rate of 5.48 $/h. The costliest components in the system were the compressed air energy storage unit, followed closely by organic Rankine cycle 1 and organic Rankine cycle 2. In contemplating the practical implementation of this innovative energy system, ten cities in Denmark underwent rigorous analysis, accounting for technical and economic factors. Subsequent assessments identified Aarhus as the optimal location to initiate the system. The environmental results showed that by producing 13981.9 megawatts of electricity annually in Arhus City, it is possible to help reduce CO2 emissions by 2853.2 tons of CO2/year and avoid environmental costs of 68455.3 $/year. The environmental assessment also highlighted the potential for substantial green space expansion, estimating an additional 13 hectares of green areas in the city of Aarhus, Denmark.

The Sharing Energy Storage Mechanism for Demand Side Energy Communities

Energy storage (ES) units are vital for the reliable and economical operation of the power system with a high penetration of renewable distributed generators (DGs). Due to ES’s high investment costs and long payback period, energy management with shared ESs becomes a suitable choice for the demand side. This work investigates the sharing mechanism of ES units for low-voltage (LV) energy prosumer (EP) communities, in which energy interactions of multiple styles among the EPs are enabled, and the aggregated ES dispatch center (AESDC) is established as a special energy service provider to facilitate the scheduling and marketing mechanism. A shared ES operation framework considering multiple EP communities is established, in which both the energy scheduling and cost allocation methods are studied. Then a shared ES model and energy marketing scheme for multiple communities based on the leader–follower game is proposed. The Karush–Kuhn–Tucker (KKT) condition is used to transform the double-layer model into a single-layer model, and then the large M method and PSO-HS algorithm are used to solve it, which improves convergence features in both speed and performance. On this basis, a cost allocation strategy based on the Owen value method is proposed to resolve the issues of benefit distribution fairness and user privacy under current situations. A case study simulation is carried out, and the results show that, with the ES scheduling strategy shared by multiple renewable communities in the leader–follower game, the energy cost is reduced significantly, and all communities acquire benefits from shared ES operators and aggregated ES dispatch centers, which verifies the advantageous and economical features of the proposed framework and strategy. With the cost allocation strategy based on the Owen value method, the distribution results are rational and equitable both for the groups and individuals among the multiple EP communities. Comparing it with other algorithms, the presented PSO-HS algorithm demonstrates better features in computing speed and convergence. Therefore, the proposed mechanism can be implemented in multiple scenarios on the demand side.

Increasing Renewable Energy Penetration on Low-Voltage Networks: An Expert Knowledge Approach

While South Africa is deemed one of the countries with the highest irradiation levels, it still utilises coal as its primary energy source due to its abundance. Due to the world-wide drive towards carbon neutrality, residential, commercial, agricultural, and industrial consumers are considering small-scale embedded generation systems. The National Rationalised Specifications 097-2-3 document specifies the scale of the embedded generation capacity a consumer is allowed to install. However, specifications do not yet make the required provisions for the addition of energy storage. The effective collective management of the grouped small-scale embedded generation systems could provide a high level of energy security and increase the percentage of renewable energy generation in the total energy mix. Potential challenges come into play when considering the stochastic nature of photovoltaic generation and its effect on the storage capacity and the dispersion in load profiles of the residential units typically present on a low-voltage network. This paper contributes by investigating the utilisation of photovoltaic generation in conjunction with storage as the basis for virtual power plant control, with the aim to safely increase renewable energy penetration and improve energy security, all while remaining within the South African low-voltage regulatory limits. A two-level virtual power plant controller is proposed with the dispersed energy storage units as the primary controllable resources and the dispersed photovoltaic generation as the secondary controllable resources. The objective of the controller is to achieve nodal energy management, energy sharing, and ancillary service provision and finally to increase renewable energy penetration. A representative single-feeder low-voltage network is simulated, and test cases of 50% and 75% renewable energy penetration are investigated as the basis for evaluation. The proposed controller architecture proved to maintain network integrity for both test cases. The adaptability of the controller architecture was also confirmed for a changed feeder topology; in this case, it was a multi-feeder topology. Future work is warranted to inform policy on the allowed levels of renewable energy penetration to be based not only on demand but also on the level of energy storage present in a network.

Optimisation of Integrated Heat Pump and Thermal Energy Storage Systems in Active Buildings for Community Heat Decarbonisation

The electrification of residential heating systems, crucial for achieving net-zero emissions, poses significant challenges for low-voltage distribution networks. This study develops a simulation model to explore the integration of heat pumps within active building systems for community heating decarbonisation. The model optimises heat pump operations in conjunction with thermal energy storage units to reduce peak demand on low-voltage networks by using real-time measured electricity demand data and modelled heat demand data for 76 houses. The study employs an algorithm that adjusts thermal storage charging and discharging cycles to align with off-peak periods. Three scenarios were simulated: a baseline with unoptimised heat pumps, a fixed threshold model, and an active building model with daily optimised thresholds. The results demonstrate that the active building model achieves a 21% reduction in peak demand on the low-voltage substation compared to the baseline scenario; it also reduces the total electrical energy consumption by 12% and carbon emissions by 17%. The fixed threshold scenario shows a 16% improvement in peak demand reduction, but it also shows an increase in energy consumption and emissions. These findings highlight the potential of active buildings to enhance the efficiency and sustainability of residential energy systems, marking a significant step toward decarbonising residential heating while maintaining grid stability.

Adaptive Variable Universe Fuzzy Droop Control Based on a Novel Multi-Strategy Harris Hawk Optimization Algorithm for a Direct Current Microgrid with Hybrid Energy Storage

In the off-grid photovoltaic DC microgrid, traditional droop control encounters challenges in effectively adjusting the droop coefficient in response to varying power fluctuation frequencies, which can be influenced by factors such as line impedance. This paper introduces a novel Multi-strategy Harris Hawk Optimization Algorithm (MHHO) that integrates variable universe fuzzy control theory with droop control to develop an adaptive variable universe fuzzy droop control strategy. The algorithm employs Fuch mapping to evenly distribute the initial population across the solution space and incorporates logarithmic spiral and improved adaptive weight strategies during both the exploration and exploitation phases, enhancing its ability to escape local optima. A comparative analysis against five classical meta-heuristic algorithms on the CEC2017 benchmarks demonstrates the superior performance of the proposed algorithm. Ultimately, the adaptive variable universe fuzzy droop control based on MHHO dynamically optimizes the droop coefficient to mitigate the negative impact of internal system factors and achieve a balanced power distribution between the battery and super-capacitor in the DC microgrid. Through MATLAB/Simulink simulations, it is demonstrated that the proposed adaptive variable universe fuzzy droop control strategy based on MHHO can limit the fluctuation range of bus voltage within ±0.75%, enhance the robustness and stability of the system, and optimize the charge and discharge performance of the energy storage unit.

An enhanced sensitivity‐based combined control method of battery energy storage systems for voltage regulation in PV‐rich residential distribution networks

AbstractCommercial off‐the‐shelf (OTS) photovoltaic systems coupled with battery energy storage units (PV‐BES) are typically designed to increase household self‐consumption, neglecting their potential for voltage regulation in low voltage distribution networks (LVDNs). This work proposes an enhanced sensitivity‐based combined (ESC) control method for voltage regulation, using BES control as level 1 and reactive power compensation as level 2. A centralized controller manages charging/discharging intervals, while local inverters handle real‐time power rates and reactive power, ensuring effective LVDN voltage regulation. The BES set points are obtained concerning the measured local bus voltage and according to enhanced sensitivity coefficients. The enhancement algorithm ensures that the full capacity of BES is utilized and that there is adequate capacity during charging and discharging time intervals. The proposed method, tested on 8‐bus and 116‐bus LV test feeders, outperforms OTS and an adaptive decentralized (AD) control method by completely preventing overvoltage issues, minimizing various changes in the direction of BES power, and reducing voltage deviation without significantly affecting consumers' grid dependency.

Modular Microgrid Technology with a Single Development Environment Per Life Cycle

The life cycle of a microgrid covers all the stages from idea to implementation, through exploitation until the end of its life, with a lifespan of around 25 years. Covering them usually requires several software tools, which can make the integration of results from different stages difficult and may imply costs being hard to estimate from the beginning of a project. This paper proposes a unified platform composed of four modules developed in MATLAB 2022b, designed to assist all the processes a microgrid passes through during its lifetime. This entire platform can be used by a user with low IT knowledge, because it is completed with fill-in-the-blank alone, as a major advantage. The authors detail the architecture, functions and development of the platform, either by highlighting the novel integration of existing MATLAB tools or by developing new ones and designing new user interfaces linked with scripts based on its complex mathematical libraries. By consolidating processes into a single platform, the proposed solution enhances integration, reduces complexity and provides better cost predictability throughout the project’s duration. A proof-of-concept for this platform was presented by applying the life-cycle assessment process on a real-case study, a microgrid consisting of a photovoltaic plant, and an office building as the consumer and energy storage units. This platform has also been developed by involving students within summer internships, as a process strengthening the cooperation between industry and academia. Being an open-source application, the platform will be used within the educational process, where the students will have the possibility to add functionalities, improve the graphical representation, create new reports, etc.

Heat transfer enhancement of PCM in the triple-pipe helical-coiled latent heat thermal energy storage unit and complete melting time correlation

Secondary flows induced in helical-coiled pipes significantly enhance the thermal storage performance of latent heat thermal energy storage units. This paper presents a three-dimensional model of a triple-pipe helical-coiled system to investigate the melting characteristics of phase change material within it. A correlation for the complete melting time was developed based on the simulation results. The findings indicate that the thermal-hydraulic fields of the heat transfer fluids and phase change material deflect from the vertical central axis at cross-sections. The secondary flows within the inner pipe are more effective in enhancing melting than those in the outer pipe. Melting performance improves with increasing inner pipe diameter, coil diameter (from 100 mm to 160 mm), inclination angle, or heat transfer fluid temperature, or decreasing helical pitch. The inner pipe diameter, helical pitch and heat transfer fluid temperature exhibit more pronounced influences. An inner pipe diameter of 30 mm, a coil diameter of 160 mm, a helical pitch of 80 mm, an inclination angle of 90°, a heat transfer fluid temperature of 360 K, and a heat transfer fluid Reynolds number of 2000, respectively produce a faster melting process. The developed correlation for the triple-pipe helical-coiled pipe thermal storage unit accurately predicts 96 % of the 45 data within ±11 %.

Techno-economic analysis and optimization of a hybrid solar-wind-biomass-battery framework for the electrification of a remote area: A case study

An off-grid hybrid energy framework on the basis of wind turbines and photovoltaic panels as the primary source of energy and a biogas generator and energy storage unit as a back-up system, was considered for clean energy generation in a rural area in Semnan, Iran. This study was aimed at designing an optimized hybrid renewable framework with minimal costs and CO2 emissions and highest reliability, utilizing comprehensive modeling based on two energy management strategies. The decision-making variables in this work were the type and number of wind turbines, number of storage units, capacity of solar panels, and the capacity of biogas generator. Then variations in turbine model, inflation rate and biofuel prices and their effect on the optimal design of the hybrid framework was investigated in a range of uncertainties (0, 1, and 2.5 %). Additionally, the powerplant emissions penalty cost rate was also considered. Eventually, the optimal hybrid frameworks were economically and environmentally compared with a stand-alone diesel generator. Optimization results confirmed the superiority of the proposed hybrid wind-solar-biomass-battery system in comparison with other investigated systems. The cost of energy for the optimal design including biogas generator (22 kW), photovoltaic panels (30.7 kW), a 10 kW wind turbine, 11 batteries and an inverter (15.1 kW), while considering the inflation rate of 10 % and the uncertainty rate of 0 %, is equal to 0.201 $/kWh. Additionally, the selected optimal design emitted 97 % less CO2 annually, in comparison with the similarly-sized diesel-based energy system.

Improving a shell-tube latent heat thermal energy storage unit for building hot water demand using metal foam inserts at a constant pumping power

The phase transition heat transfer during the melting and solidification processes of phase change materials (PCMs) was modeled in a shell-tube thermal energy storage unit. For the first time, special attention was dedicated to the heat transfer enhancement on the heat transfer fluid (HTF) side by placing metal foam (MF) inserts in the HTF tube. The MF inserts on the HTF side were placed next to the fin bases to produce the maximum heat transfer enhancement. A two-temperature local thermal non-equilibrium model was applied to accurately model the transient heat transfer in the MF domains. To perform a fair heat transfer analysis and consider the hydrodynamic aspects of heat transfer, the pumping power for driving the HTF fluid was kept fixed. The finite element method with automatic time-step control was used to integrate the model equations. Results show that the insertion of the MF in the HTF tube enhances conduction heat transfer but reduces flow for a constant pump power. Using a small amount of MF provides a good flow rate and a convective heat transfer while using a large amount of MF provides good conduction heat transfer but a poor flow rate and convection. A moderate amount of MF inserts results in poor conduction and a poor flow rate, notably increasing the phase transition time. A 5 % MF insert could provide about a 13 % shorter solidification time compared to a 25 % MF insert. Thus, a well-designed and engineered MF insert configuration on the HTF side can reduce the phase transition time and improve the energy storage power.

Voltage stability control strategy for DC microgrid based on adaptive virtual DC motor

The large-scale integration of distributed energy sources and power electronic devices results in the DC microgrid exhibiting significant low inertia and weak damping characteristics. This, in turn, leads to inevitable fluctuations in the DC bus voltage, which endanger the stable operation of the DC system. Energy storage devices can provide equivalent inertia. To enhance the inertia and response speed of the DC bus interface converter, this paper proposes a power allocation parameter adaptive virtual DC motor control strategy based on a hybrid energy storage unit. The strategy introduces power allocation control to regulate the energy storage converter on the basis of virtual inertia parameter adaptive control, thereby enabling the energy storage converter to simulate the inertia and damping characteristics of a DC generator. The small-signal stability of the system is analyzed by establishing a small-signal model of the photovoltaic energy storage system and utilizing the impedance ratio criterion. Finally, the proposed control strategy is validated through simulation. The results demonstrate that the strategy effectively mitigates the fluctuations in bus voltage under varying photovoltaic power and sudden load changes, ensures the power distribution in the hybrid energy storage system, and enhances the dynamic response of the system.

A low voltage load balancing distribution method considering street information and V2G technology application

The low-voltage distribution network (LVDN) is the final stage in delivering electric energy from power plants to consumers, and its operational condition greatly impacts many power users. While medium-voltage and high-voltage distribution networks can be managed through intelligent digital systems, load imbalance issues in LVDNs often rely on planners’ experience, leading to significant limitations. With advancements in electric vehicle (EV) charging technology and vehicle-to-grid (V2G) technology, where EVs act as distributed energy storage units, bidirectional energy exchange between vehicles and the grid can now contribute to LVDN operation. This paper proposes a low-voltage load distribution planning method that integrates street information and V2G technology. A two-stage stochastic programming mixed-integer model is developed to tackle load imbalance in LVDNs, with the planning scheme derived from solving this model. A case study is presented to verify the effectiveness of the method, demonstrating that incorporating V2G technology enhances load distribution accuracy and reduces reliance on manual planning, improving network stability and operational efficiency.

Exergo and enviro-economic analysis of thermal energy storage assisted finned solar still

The current investigation focuses on improving the performance of a single slope solar still integrated with Phase Change Material as energy storage media. The problem of low thermal conductivity of PCM which hinders the energy storage capability has been addressed by incorporating fins with different profiles into the energy storage unit. Initially, an experimental investigation was conducted and analyzed to assess the effective performance of a Conventional Single Slope Solar Still (CSS) using various water depth levels: 1–4 cm. The optimal basin water depth for testing solar still with energy storage material along with fins was identified as 2 cm. Subsequently, the CSS was subjected to performance enhancement investigation under three different conditions: Case 1 – Solar Still (SS) with PCM storage unit, Case 2 – SS with fins at the PCM storage unit, and Case 3 – SS with fins at the storage unit and a parallel plate attached to the other end of the fins. The experimental results demonstrated the production of fresh water and efficiency improvements are as follows 26.95%, 55.86%, 69.14% and 24.34%, 52.83%, 68.83% for cases I, II, and III, respectively. Further, it was observed that Case III exhibited a lower cost of water production and a shorter payback period compared to CSS. The enviro-economic analysis revealed that the net CO2 emissions (NCEM) and Carbon Credits Earned (CCE) for Case III were 15.60 tons and 312.07 USD respectively against 9.22 tons and 184.31 USD for CSS.

Enhancing the melting rate of RT42 paraffin wax in a square cell with varied copper fin lengths and orientations: A numerical simulation

Latent thermal energy storage units are especially preferred in renewable thermal energy systems for their significant capacity to store heat. Nevertheless, the phase change materials in these units have low thermal conductivity, prompting researchers to tackle this problem using several methods, such as incorporating fins. This numerical study contributes to improving the charging rate of a square cell (50 × 50 mm) used paraffin wax RT42 as phase change material by adding 4 copper fins inside, 1 mm thick and of different lengths. The fins were positioned on the left wall, where a constant-temperature heat flux was applied, while the other walls were thermally insulated. Four configurations of the cell were examined: without fins, with 10 mm length fins, with 20 mm length fins, and with 30 mm length fins, respectively. The results demonstrated that the presence of fins significantly improved the charging rate of the square cell. Compared to the baseline configuration without fins, the time required for the paraffin wax RT42 to completely melt was reduced by 22.22 %, 33.33 %, and 55.56 % with fins of 10 mm, 20 mm, and 30 mm lengths, respectively. Configuration four was also compared with a setup where similar fins were positioned on the bottom wall while maintaining the heat flux on the left wall. It was observed that the total melting time doubled compared to configuration four, suggesting that the optimal placement for the heat flux is on the wall where the fins are located. The study contributes to enhancing and developing the charge rates of square and rectangular PCM cells such as these used for cooling PV panels.

Optimal scheduling of a multi-energy complementary system simultaneously considering the trading of carbon emission and green certificate

This paper uses a multi-energy complementary system composed of thermal, wind, photovoltaic power generation, and electric energy storage units to participate in four market mechanisms and construct the optimal scheduling model of these trading mechanisms. These four mechanisms are carbon emission trading, green certificate trading, these two trading that are not joint, and joint. Under the latter two mechanisms, the excess carbon emissions of the system can be reduced to 9258t, and the utilization rate of renewable energy can reach 100 %. However, the operating costs under the fourth mechanism are 9695.80 $ lower than the third one because 5947 pieces of green certificates are converted into carbon emission rights. When the carbon price rises, the cost of the fourth mechanism increases slower than that of the third mechanism. The conversion volume of green certificates increases from 5947 to 10947, and the cost difference between the two increases to 67558.33 $. When green certificate prices rise, the cost under the fourth trading mechanism decreases faster. As that cost steadily declines, the carbon emission rights are converted into 907 green certificates, and the cost difference between this and the third mechanism increases to 4695.52 $.

Comparison of Configurable Modular Two-Level and Three-Level Isolated Bidirectional DC–DC Converters for Super-Capacitor Charging in DC Shore Power Systems

Compared to the AC counterpart, the DC shore power system provides a significant advantage of efficient power supply from renewable sources to ships and onshore loads. Super-capacitors serve as key energy storage units in such a system to buffer the power fluctuations and collect the regenerative energy. However, the ultra-wide voltage range of super-capacitors imposes a significant challenge in the topology selection and efficiency optimization of the interfacing isolated bidirectional DC–DC converter. To tackle this challenge, this paper analyzes and compares two promising converter topologies, which are a configurable modular two-level dual-active bridge (CM-2L-DAB) and a three-level dual-active bridge (3L-DAB). To facilitate an ultra-wide voltage range, extended phase-shift (EPS) modulation in conjunction with the topology reconfiguration is analyzed for the CM-2L-DAB, while a hybrid modulation scheme is proposed for the 3L-DAB. A unified design approach is provided for both topologies, which also yields to the power loss modeling. On this basis, the CM-2L-DAB and 3L-DAB are thoroughly compared in terms of the modulation schemes, current stress, soft-switching operation, power conversion efficiency, material usage, closed-loop control scheme, and reliability. A prominent conclusion can be drawn that the CM-2L-DAB provides a higher efficiency than the 3L-DAB over the whole voltage range, but it relies on additional relays to reconfigure its topology which results in lower reliability and dynamic performance than the 3L-DAB.